← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3517/2011dismissed

Haryana Warehousing Corporation And ORS v. M/S Haryana Enterprises And ANR

2016-07-22Mr. Justice Arun Monga7 pages

 

       

 ! "#$ #%

%&%%%'(#) "##* +,- ./.0 1.2.! 03

+0. %%%22

 4. ,5..2.! 03 6!

!.6+0.

%%% 26 %

%&%%%78)$ "##* +,- ,5..2.! 03 6!

!.6+0.

%%%22

 4. ./.0 1.2.! 03

+0. %%% 26  !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.& #% /00. 2..  22.9:

;60< 619= % :...60 2...= '% /00.0< 6190

6:.2.601=

.

,.%>%>% 2!6?!

.022

 &%'(#) "##+ .0.26 &%78)$ "##% ,.%,%>%.1!6?!

.022

 &%78)$ "##+ .0.26 &%'(#) "##% @@@@@

  *)+%,' 0.6.90

62; 1

.&6 22 %'(#)678)$ "##099A  ;6 .? ?6:0022 %

&%'(#) "## 6:0./.0 1 .2.! 03

*0..

6B066C-1 0< 61966.:00 .: ;!;0.:0 .

.?.9 8!)"!8##5D 126 6  .. E# F2. 9!;6.6:0.  .!;0.0G;.

22

   .  966  0  < 619  6  6.  :  0 61  0  6.?.09 ;%%%# %7% ""'10 ?6'#%)% "" 0 6:0.  .%

&%78)$ "## 6:,5..2. *0.....6B02 C-.1D6061 0G;.22

.A 9610< 61966. 0.  .% ,.%>%>% 2! .6  .022

 & %'(#) "## :900 31.?.09  96:?;.. :6 2 910.0 2.9 .6 022

 . .1;0%0 2.9;.3..1:6  :%0

 ..; % "2.9. ""'%02 06 .6

6 02 0  !;00?6.9H% )

.66 %(% ""'66.6:06602 6 ;

 .H%# 

16 ;.:02 0 . .6.60 .%0.  .06 .6.60.?.09 ;%%%'#%)% "" (%(% ""(:

1  0  .  E  '% (   2.  9.  ! ;0. 0  0  G;. 22

..6 6.9# %7% ""'(%(% ""( 910 9 ;002.60..%!2.H% # !%%!0< 619 66.66 I%8% ""(26? & %##I66'"%)% "" !

9 . 002  910.E'% (2.

9.    .  0  2.6  (%(% ""#    '"%)% "" !  0 10  06  : 6.6!:

0.9002 0 62.? ..6002 0;.3 ..1 .:. 2.6 ..6!0 !0 ; :

:6966!

0 ! :900A  ;..6.9% .0.

:900.1.

1 62.?.0< 6196 6.:00 .: ;6.61 0A  ;

.9

6099.6 922 . :

:.96.

06< 60 % 00.06!,.%,%>%.1! .6  .0

/ 22

 &%78)$ "## :90 0< 6196 6.    0  G;.  22

   .   .  .9  

1   6 2.?.!.!2.0< 61966.H% # !0.. 0 .6:0 6:'% (2.9.602 610 .96 A 3102 0 ..1 ..

2.6 ..0?:920

666!0 !0 .96< 61966.69:

0?62.

02.?06?6% .0. :900 6606302.9;%%% %(% ""#0.96 ...18"""9.;0%?0 .9   "!"""5D ;626:02 ?6.266 %(% ""#% &0.;

.290.50.0.1.02.6 .9'#%)% "" (%(% ""(!0.96 ; 6%;?.!

0G;.22

.0.. 0 600. :  96.9.00..6..60 9;0 0..!:

0.9;0.20....;%%% (%(% ""#'"%)% "" 609  9602. ; ;%%%'#%)% "" (%(% ""(0 ; 6# %7% ""$%0 9  962.60..6!0..!

6 0?:..6.0..:3106 10  6!0 ! .10 ..1D60< 61966.

 0G;.22

.A ..1 9;%%%# %7% ""' 0

;1 : A  ;;

6? ?.6< 6  &%78)$ "## B/00.  0  &  ?.9  .  9D1?.9 2.9.

.01  929 9  1:

2.:312  9=C 0?0.60 .6  .02.!22.6 022.:360?;00.9.6 :0 :9,.% 2!;0.0..0 :9 ,.%.1;0.1.60 9;%%%'#%)% "" (%(% ""(% 0662..602.0< 619 66.66 I%8% ""(*H% # -!0 93102 0  . . 1 .: . 2.6  . .0 : 660;.960 .....E'% (2.

9.;%%%(%(% ""#'"%)% "" 06:6.6;0006 6 %22.00662.2  6

.6 06..6 1 2.61. 910.%H%# . 6 2:,.% 2606690.;00 0  2     

16    0?  ;.    0   . .6  .

60 .!;0.H% )2 .2.6 

.;.:066022

;0.1.60.1

0  02.9  % .?16 9;006 ..2. 92.

0%

066; .:  ?1  0  2.9  3    .!  0  

6  0?   996  0 ;.90.662.9.9;0902.906 

16 :.6 %0?66 9902  0.?6

1 2092.6 09  .1.610.2..900.62.%0:0 9!9 0 ?;0< 61966. .6.6.6! ..:



660066;.2.2  6

. 931029% .1.6061.6.6:0G;.22

  .;0.1.6 910 902 .9'#%)% ""  # %7% ""'!696 02.? . 6 1!06.;

202.6'"%)% "" 6066 620

9 !0:96

.;%%%'#%)% "" (%(% ""(.

0H2.2.6 ..%0 .

60  0609  96.2.6 0..6:6::60 9%

 .61 !  0  61    0  G;.  22

   .

910.?.09 .9# %7% ""'0.:D6 600.  ...6%0A  ;!6 :?!;.6? .02 61066%

&  %'(#)    "##   6  :  .  /.0 1 .2.+0.696!;0. &%78)$ "## 6 :,5..2.+0.

;60.96 .9% '1,0    *)+%

234 '(-.& +454367 83

 938

+454 5:!

938