← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/985/2015dismissed

Shri Ram General Insurance Company Ltd v. Rahul Singh And ORS

2018-09-24Mr. Justice Satpal5 pages

      



!" #"$%&%'( ) 

  *+,% -"'", .'&/, '$"-0 '12!# 00".. '! 3",&/&  +/.*%'4+ '#!+",& "&0'#"'!&  

 

,"&"'!( , 56%,*%'4+7#8$ !" ,!+" 00".. '! ,-%'#",*%'4+7#8$ !" ,,"&0'#"'!& '#  *",8%$" ,"&0'#"'!&9 '#)&! '#&#%&0"'&"#:%!+ 3%#",#",# !"#

;



 +%& 00" . + & 6""' %."# 61 !+" '&/, '$" -0 '1 $+ .."'4%'4 !+" : ,# # !"#

) 0 &&"# 61 !, $$%#"'! . %-& ,%6/' .72/#+% ' <,%6/' .= ,&+,! 00" .,$,&&65"$!%'&+ 8" 6""' %."#61!+"$. %- '!&

,%"

$!& '"$"&& ,1 , #5/#%$ !%'   !+" $ &" ," !+ ! $. %- '!&>,"&0'#"'!& '# %."# 0"!%!%'/'#",*"$!%';; !, 3"+%$."& $! &""?%'4 $-0"'& !%' ' $$/'!   #" !+   !+"%, -!+", ""!  '%%' -!,8"+%$." $$%#"'!:+%$+!?0. $"' ;

! : & 0." #"# !+ ! ""!   '% #"$" &"# .'4 :%!+ +", &'  +/. *%'4+7 $. %- '!>,"&0'#"'!: &4%'4! 50/, # ,-%66  #'!+" -!,$1$."6" ,%'4 @

@A;

#,%8"'61$. %- '!>,"&0'#"'! ""!  '%7+%&-!+",: &,%#%'40%..%'B+"'!+"1," $+"# 50/, #7 00&%!" :  %,1 ! 6/! ;9  0-7 !+" 

"'#%'4 !, $!, 6" ,%'4 

  @ @  $ -" ,- 6"+%'#7 #,%8"' %'  , &+ '# '"4.%4"'! - ''", 61 ,"&0'#"'!>- '#""0*%'4+ '#&!,/$? 4 %'&!!+"-!,$1$.""&/.! '!.17 ,"&0'#"'! > +/. *%'4+ '# +%& -!+",@""!   '% ".. #:' ' !+" , #,'!!1," !+"

"'#%'4!, $!,, '8",!+"&!- $+ ""!  '% '# ' !+" ."

! ."4   ,"&0'#"'!  ""!   '% #%"# ! !+" &0! . %- '!>,"&0'#"'!  : & ,/&+"# !  &0%! .7 2/#+% '  '# !+","

!",,"

",,"#!7+ '#%4 ,++" $$%#"'!: &:%!'"&&"#61*":  *%'4+&' /,- %.*%'4+7 :+ : &$-%'46"+%'#!+"-!,$1$." 

: &,"4%&!","#/'#",*"$!%'& A79 )@799A '#99  !.%$" *! !%' %8%&%'A3 ,#+- '' ;

&!@-,!"- !+"#" # 6#1 !+"#"$" &"#: &$'#/$!"#!: &$. %-"#!+ !""!  '%: &) 1" ,&.# !!+"!%-"  $$%#"'!*+": &,/''%'4 6/!%C/" '#" ,'%'4 &

>@ 0", -'!+ . %- '!&>,"&0'#"'!  '#  %" &' '# # /4+!", !+"#"$" &"#$. %-"#!6"#"0"'#"'!/0'""!  '%+"%,

!+",+ # .," #10 &&"# : 1" ,.%",-0"'& !%': &!+/&0, 1"# , 2" ,'"# ,%6/' . +".# !+ ! !+" $$%#"'! %' C/"&!%' !? 0. $" #/" ! !+" , &+ '# '"4.%4"'! #,%8%'4   !, $!, 61 ,"&0'#"'!@- '#""0 *%'4+  &/-   &)7

>@ : & : ,#"# & $-0"'& !%' ! !+" $. %- '!&'$-"! D,"!/,' %."#61!+"$. %- '!: &%4',"#61!+"." ,'"# ,%6/' . '#%'$-" !+"#"$" &"#: & &&"&&"# !& A

>@/.!%0.%",  ) : & 00.%"# 44,%"8"# ,- !+" : ,# # !"#

)7 0,"&"'! 00" .+ &6""' %."#61!+"'&/, '$"-0 '1 ! %& $'!"'#"# !+ ! !+" '&/, '$" -0 '1 %& '! .% 6." ! & !%& 1 !+" "'!%," $. %- & %! %&  $ &"   $'!,%6/!,1 '"4.%4"'$" 2" ,'"# $/'&". , !+" 00".. '! &/6-%!& !+ ! %! %&  $ &"    +" # ' $..%&%'7 !+","

,"7 !+" "'!%," ,"&0'&%6%.%!1 $ ''! 6"   !+" !, $!, %'&/,"# :%!+ !+"

9 00".. '!!%& /,!+",$'!"'#"#!+ !C/ '!/- $-0"'& !%'%&"D$"&&%8" '# %'$-"   !+" #"$" &"# + & :,'4.1 6""' &&"&&"# & & A

>@ 61 ! ?%'4 !+" %'$-"   !+" #"$" &"# & &

>@ 0", -'!+ '# ##%'4 &9A

>@ ! %& $'!"'#"# !+ ! %'$-" ! D ,"!/,'& , !+" 1" ,

@



%."# 61 !+" #"$" &"# :"," ,%4+!.1 '! ,".%"# /0' 61 !+" ." ,'"# ,%6/' . :"8",7 %'$-"   !+" #"$" &"# + & 6""' &&"&&"# %' ' %'$,,"$! - ''",!%&7!+/&70, 1"#!+ !!+"& -"6","#/$"# 2" ,'"#$/'&". ,!+"$. %- '!&>,"&0'#"'!& '# + & ,"

/!"#!+" 8",-"'!&- #"'6"+ .

!+" 00".. '!!%&&/6-%!!"#!+ !%' $ &" ' 00" . , $,&& 65"$!%'& + # 6""' %."# 61 !+" $. %- '!&7 !+"1 :/.#+ 8"6""'"'!%!."#!-/$++%4+",$-0"'& !%'"&0"$% ..1?""0%'4%' 8%":   !+" 5/#4-"'!   !+" '=6." */0,"-" /,! %'  !%' . '&/, '$" -0 '12!#3&, ' 1*"!+% '#!+",&7

A)%8%.

!%& #"'%"# !+ ! !+"," %& '1 $'!,%6/!,1 '"4.%4"'$" :+%$+ :/.# 5/&!% 1 '1 #"#/$!%'%'!+" -/'! $-0"'& !%' : ,#"#!!+"$. %- '!&'!+"&" $%,$/-&! '$"&7%!%&0, 1"#!+ !!+"0,"&"'! 00" .6"#%&-%&&"# '# : ,# # !"#

)6"/0+".#  + 8" +" ,# ." ,'"# $/'&". , !+" 0 ,!%"& '# + 8" 4'" !+,/4+!+","$,#:%!+!+"%, 6." &&%&! '$" 0",/& . !+","$,#,"8" .&!+ ! &0",!+"7:+%$+: & ,"$,#"#'!+"&! !"-"'! *": *%'4+7%!: &&! !"#!+ !!+"#"$" &"# ""!  '% .'4:%!++",&' +/.*%'4+7B: &0,$""#%'4 ,-%66   #! 50/, #' -!,$1$."6" ,%'4 @

@A;

! 6/!

;9  0-7 :+"' !+"1 ," $+"#  50/,  #7 00&%!" :  %,17 !+"

"'#%'4 !, $!, 6" ,%'4  @ @  $ -" ,- 6"+%'# %'  , &+ '# '"4.%4"'! - ''", :%!+/! 6.:%'4 '1 +,' '# &!,/$? 4 %'&! !+" -!,

) $1$."7 &  ,"&/.!   :+%$+ ,"&0'#"'!   +/. *%'4+ '# +%& -!+", ""!  '% "..'!+", # '#!+" ,'!!1," !+"

"'#%'4!, $!,, '8", !+" &!- $+   ""!   '% '# ' !+" ."

! ."4   ,"&0'#"'!  ""!   '%#%"#'!+"&0!"&0'#"'! +/.*%'4+7:+ 00" ,"#6" ," !+" ." ,'"# ,%6/' . & B7 !"&!% %"# ,"4 ,#%'4 !+" - ''", %' :+%$+ !+" $$%#"'! !? 0. $"  8% E/- ,7 '!+", "1" :%!'"&&7 .& #"0&"# ' &%-%. ,.%'"& !%&6,'"/! ,-!+","$,#!+ !!+"

"'#%'4!, $!,+%!!+" -!,$1$." ,-6"+%'#,4/-"'!!+ !!+",": & +" #'$..%&%'%&'! &/6&! '!% !"#61!+""8%#"'$"',"$,#+","%&'! '%!  "8%#"'$"! %'#%$ !" '1$'!,%6/!,1'"4.%4"'$"'!+"0 ,! ,"&0'#"'!%'#%'4 !+"." ,'"#,%6/' .'%&&/"%& $$,#%'4.1/0+".# ',"&0"$!!!+"%'$-" !+"#"$" &"#:+%$+: & &&"&&"#61 !+"." ,'"#,%6/' .7%!%&'!"#!+ !%'$-"! D,"!/,' !+"1" ,

@

 D; : & ,".%"# /0' 61 !+" $. %- '!& :%!+ !+" 8",-"'!& !+ ! !+" #"$" &"#: &" ,'%'4&79 7)

>@0", ''/-2" ,'"#,%6/' .7+:"8",7 %4',"#!+%&%'$-"! D,"!/,''!+"4,/'#!+ !'%'$-"! D,"!/,'0,%, !!+ !+ &6""'0. $"#',"$,#7!+/4+!+","%&'#"'% . !+" $!!+ ! !+%&%'$-"! D,"!/,': & %."#0,%,!!+"#" !+ ""!  '%!%& /,!+", 6&",8"#61." ,'"#,%6/' .!+ !!+"& %#%'$-"! D,"!/,'+ &'!6""' 0,8"#',"$,# &0",. : &'

%$% . ,-'$-" D "0 ,!-"'!+ # 6""'"D -%'"#!0,8"!+" /!+"'!%$%!1,4"'/%'"'"&& !+"& %#%'$-" ! D ,"!/,' 2" ,'"# ,%6/' . + & ! !+" & -" !%-" 6&",8"# !+ ! &%'$" !+" #"$" &"#: & 1/'4:%#:+ 8%'4! "'# ,+",&".

 '#+",!:$+%.#,"'7 &+" -/&! '"$"&& ,%.1 + 8" $ ,,%"# ' &-" 8$ !%' & & ! 4"'", !" %'$-"

 '!+" $!/ .- !,%D !+"$ &"7#'! %'# '15/&!% %$ !%'%' ,"#/$%'4!+"%'$-" !+"#"$" &"# ,-& A

>@"8"'% %!%& 4,""#!+ ! !+"-"!+#  &&"&&%'4!+"%'$-"- 1'!6"$,,"$!'-1$'&%#","# 0%'%'7'4,/'#%&- #"/! ,,"#/$!%' !+"$-0"'& !%' : ,#"#! !+"$. %- '!& E""0%'4%'8%":!+" $!& '#$%,$/-&! '$"& !+"$ &"7#'!

%'# '1 4,/'# :+ !&"8", ! %'!", "," %' !+" %-0/4'"# : ,# # !"#

)%'!+%& 00" . %."#61!+"'&/, '$"-0 '1 +%& 00" .%& $$,#%'4.1#%&-%&&"#:%!+',#", &!$&!&  

   *"0!"-6", )7

  &+: , B+"!+",&0" ?%'4>," &'"#(@"&> B+"!+",,"0,! 6."(@"&>