← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/871/2022dismissed

Child In Conflict With Law A v. State Of Punjab

2023-05-02Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari14 pages

  

                



  !"       # $ % &'&'

(         )# % '*'

(   

       

!%+,-./!'0123 /21/24351 +,-./!'0123 /51.//34 

  ! !"#    $% "&'"  (((( 21/2435160' ) *+ ! , )-." /    01 23"

/ !        4" & 

 !"

5!   "/ 

6-7"6-72"6-72 "-83   +""

9  

  /1 :  

".8).;  <::

".8).=>;  

6?32  +" "  

 

 3    :: 

" .8). 

 >@  *+ ;> #

    @"   /.8).8.."     !  "%#%  "!"  //"

 # 

  "         " "

A       "   "  /      !5 //

@   "/5 /  !!  5 " " /   5    #

 @" !  /  A5 ;>" " /   !  " %# %  " !"      ;>" !   5 /"  .8).8.. @ "  

   %!"* @ $ %!"!" "  = " 

)B  %#% ; 

 >

".8)-;  < 

 .8)->"" )6   %#% ;

 > ".8)3 ;    <    .8)3=>" /  "  / ! 

 /  5   ;> ::

".8)."   5 /  "    A/  /!   ! #

A  ;>"       "   /    #       / * /" #

 /

5 / )35 !" / !5 //

!

    ;>    5" #  /  .6.8.."   %!"* @ $ %!" !" /!   !" ""#

"   /  #  "  5   //

        ::

" /

# "     

. @!   //  *+ 013!@  013 " )8)).8.)"+'#4! % 4     "  /  #4"/  #

/ !2  ' ! / ""!    / #! ! C! D#

/  ! C! D#

/"!#5 5!.

   '#/  /5  "  C ! D#

/ 

$   // 4!   !" !



! :.)).8.)   -88"  

 ! ! D#

/  !!  ! !""!   / 4@ "

       $         ! D#

/: $!"! D#

/ "  !    /

EE

 $   "" $  /   $ 

EE   $  $! ""         5" $@ 

EE   !:! "! 1$54" / ' 4  

 EE /   / /" 5   ! ! / $ + ! "

    F #   

EE ! / " /5//        5    #"   # @ " /  /

 

!"##

$!!

# " 6 :   # / "+' 4/    !"     " *+   

6-7"6-72 6-72 "-83+9 ::

".8). ! :)8)).8.)   ..8/"! + !##  ""  !           /      / 

/"!?5"    !  "  ! / 

)37 :)))).8.)" 

EE  

%

     #

/"         .?83.8)7 "   

     

EE"    )-86.887  

   EE       '!"  !  "%#%  "!:  /$ !# 5 & 

 

5   "     

6?32  +   

 3   :: 

  + '  4 !



 /  1/    #

/ / # C " !" /     #

/    !#! #!    &, 5 :5 /  

EE  &,5"

    /  /" 2 /   $  *     5    :

 # ! "  

)?6!



EE      !  " %# %         A5 

  !  "%#%  "   



GE#!

.8? &!!

# "

'!(!

)!

&# #$ #"!* + !

#!

+"#!

 *  7 @    !  " #   .8).8.."  

! /5 / "   %!"! A 

    

)9;6>  

 .8)- @    %!" !     %!  ,# &!!

# " - +       "    1/ )) " "         "   #    # 

-

%! "  !"

6)6  "

"

  "" / /  C         #      5  

  1 3  "  /     !  # 

       %!" *  @ $   "!"#

#

/  689.8.."A # !    

-83  +""

3  ::

".8).C #"   /  #

#

" !/" # 

"689.8.."  ! .)5""  

 ! .)5"  /  )6;9>;> 

 .8)3"       5 *$ "   6)9.8.."  !  ""  ! ! #  ? :  

    # 

  "  6)9.8.."      %! "       /"  5      ! ! //   5"" 5 " /   /    )"888D2"        5/    "    !!//     5" 

    

-83  +#"

  !!  / .85"" 5      -8"888D2"        5/    "    !//   5"

     

3  ::

".8).+ "      5#"  

.    5 !  # 

  " 

/   

 7.9    "        " "     # / /;>      #   ;>   //    * /"    / "  /   

 )8"888D2     #

  1" 

/   +  "   

  !   .) 5"         5 9 +      "  #

   " /  ! 5" "   1   )9 5   /  

 !#$! # 

66 2

9  ::

".8). B  

  / 1 :   " .8)."  /  7"88"888D2 / " / "  #

/     /  /  "" /

 

& 

!   5"!  5/ #

/  / , = /   /  F/ #

/D## 1 D  /".8)9 B   #

"



! .)5"  ""  "  ! #/   #  ;> //       /"#"

( )!

"!0!

( )!

##0* 1) "!$$!

#  )!

1# !""

'2 "

&34 )8 @#

/ 1   1F2) @#

/"# 5     01.!"

/"   !    ;> /!  "  "     !       1

 @ " ! /  / 5# 

#

 

 1  " 5 #"      %! " ! A5! "

  !  !!!     !   /    / 5  A"" !!#! !    # A"   /  " "  /

"   5



+  "    # #"  !    !    /   1"  #"    %!

"   /!  !  5  ! /     "  "  /"  /$ A C #" / !    / A " "  %! "/"   5"" /  " +A"

/

  5



 )) +  1/ 22  "     !  

" //  *+ ;>!   1/ 22  " !"      /   

  

" 013"5  "! 1/ 22  " /   / /"    " ""   !  #"



@ "  / #

 " / 21/  ). !  21/   1#"

   /$!!! 1" 

 $!   / $ 4   

 5"    /$!!! "  # /" #



#    $4"

 /H!5  ;>   1 /  / #   +  "  !!   /     F2)"

/    

$  "    /   /     $!   /  $ 4"

     / #  "  /  /   1 #"" 21/ " !!  5/

"      )6  /""  !     ;>   1" 

#51/ 22  ""  21/ ;>" 5 1/ 22

 "  

   

  / 5   

"         #  / #  "  /  1"   # !! "  /       @ "  5   /  "   1       !#"



 27 4 67   8

#) 9 )7 @/   1   1 F2."" ##5/ / 01)"!""  *+ ;>" /!!     )-  /5" !1/ 22  " " /! # 

" .)).8.)"     -88 "  A    !" 

!"  ! ! $   / $ 4 @   "        1" 

5

   5 "# / 01) )3 @!" 1""/ /$# ! "     / 5       

   

 @"  5 // # 5  "  !       #  "  /  

  ::

   ;## ) )? , "   

 

  .)).8.)"  $4"   1"

/  )8)).8.)@ "        !"    5  / 1 "  #     !     

  " 5 F ;>"       #    / ""

""  /  @

   /$! # /"$ /   

/" ! 1# " 

 #5/5"  

$  /

   1    

    #  5"  /    

/"  $5"     #

 "" /   #

"#! 

 $4""   A! @ # A !  F2. $!! ""

!  " ! /"# 

  ' !+ " ! "   A  " !   #

/$! /  " 5    #

"  A!  "  !

  F2. ' ! ! /

 5 "   5   ! /"  

" "  /5 //  / ! #" ! "     72- 5"  /5 //     # 

  ! /  $@!  5 / 

 /$  /   !          C #"     ! #1  !



 5 !     "  1  1  C     # !/    !"

!   21/ "F2.    #  /  01 )"  !     

"  / $! 1/ 22  "   #  5"  /5    # 

  "   F2.   ! /" 5    !     

!

"  5  $! 

! "  /5  

 !  /5  1#"   

" 51/ 22  " 1   # 5"/ "$! "  1 5"  #  

 /$! /   "  

  

" "   /5 //     # 

  "    A!    "  "F2. /!   012)" 

  #"   !     2 1/ "   ! / 5 F2.  1/ 22  "

  /$! /  !      / F2." "    # !   5 " "  5   / ! /"  /5 //     # 



/ ! "5 F2. /!  

F2)"  ! 

! @ "!

 #51"D"1 "  

 5  !         "      # !    #    / " "

 !"

( !6!#  )!

' !

"'0#""# )9 @   

!   #  /"  /5 !#   

/" !  /5      1  1 "/ ! /F2./$!/  !     , "  

  " / / 5  / / " ! 1 / 5  ! "   1/ 22  " "  21/ "   !  " 013#"  " # " 1"1/ 22

  /$!  $!"   !   / 5    

 /

"5 $! /!

    5"#!  !    !! 21/   5"       2 1/ "/!!    5  5/

" 

 ;>"   

/  1 $!  

# 5"  $4" /

/  /" #

 

  $4* /" / 

/  $4"  " ! 2 1/ "   1  /   !! "  

/     /  $4

 

!  @ "   #5     / "  

/ ! / " 5 

 $  A 5   5 5  

"  !#   2 1/ "    # /"          $4" ! ! $4" 

1"       @ "   $   5 1  5 1 /! #5  

"      !! 21/ "  / 1"

 # 

    #   /   @ "         !" #  5  #

 / "" #  5! 1"  $4"

 A !   /  /   )B

  5"    "  #     / 15"   !  

"   /   !     

  ! 5"  5 !"5  "  "

/ 5 ! /5     /5   5

/ @ ! " /        1"  !"  /!   ## 5     / 5       " /

 .8 @ !/     "    1"  #   !        F2)8"    !/ 1/ "   5 # ! !  "#! &,/   #

  /

!  " ! /  1  @ "

/  5  #  C #"     !  " !/ 

 .) @/ 

! #!/ " "   /"       ! !# # 5 /    !         1 @ "   /  #      # "  5

  #    !    ""A

/ 5"  1@" #5   # / #   # "#   #"   1    "       #!     !    "" 1"

/ #  @ "   !     1  ! /  1/ "D 5#! &,/"   1/ ;>  " ! /" !  &, /  

"  / / 5 A  .. @   /$! #   /" /

 

/"  F2?"      /   1" 

/ 

)37  " ! 

1"    1/ 22  " #    / " "

 01 7  !    "   1/ 22  " A# 5   " 5 !#  /

#

/""  /

   " 

!   <=  <0=  ""         01?"   !;>

"  / # 5/C #"   !1 !1/ 22  " / 2

% 1/@ "   /"    /  1"  /   017"  

  !  @ "       #  /   # !



# ! !  "  / /!   #   ! .6 @ # "   5/  ""   / A 5"

   / @ /! #

#

"  

A     "  / /  #

  #

! "/ "" /+ 

#

   " "    ;>  / 

#

2     1   %! " !      ! //

   @

  "

  15 

 /    !  .7

       .- @/  ;>" 5"D    21/24351"        01</          51.//34"       01</ ! 6

(       <

=:#  4 #8> = #  % ?#=+ 4  8

:  % ?#=+