High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23800/2021dismissed

Manoj Kumar v. Haryana Staff Selection Commission And ORS

2021-12-03Mr. Justice B.S. Walia8 pages

!"#"$%&& '

$()*+ -

,#*#

0 ++"##"$ ,#& -& #

+% $451 ',&*# "!

&0& , % ',&0 !6"$) *#6"7829!

,& ',& $)*+ ,8 :::

, / , "$

"$ *$2 , , "!1 # <=>

$# * "$ $2"

"# , "##* "$ $

", ," ,?* #6"$@ "$ 1, #*1 8$$ =2

2&&"##* 5/ #$ @,*$2

#*1 =+ ,7#

$ 2 ,# "$@6"+ , 3# 0*5$#3 ,"$

@,/ "# $8 2 #3"

6"# 6 9"$@ # !*, 2 +, ,7#

"2!

@,/2* 6"#6 9"$@

2 , # "$ "$

@,/ / 5 /$2 CDE

@,/"$#

2 "# $!

@,/&

,$ 2!*$# 1!$

$2#

,"# 2"# A $ ;"

6 2"# / +, $ CD $2 "$ , #3$#

"# &=B$$ =E8

2 , 3# 0*5$#3 6*@66 1"@"51 ,!$#"2

"$ ,

"$#

@,/ "# $8"$

1/8

@,/8

1 A $B7"11 /5 /$2CDE $2;

!!,2"$@1/8 "##* 2+"

,28$$ =C&6

+"$

"$ ;6"!6 ;

# 6 12 $ <&G& 11;

2 5/ 6/#"!

10!,

$"$@ $26/#"!

1 $B7"11 "$=2"# /5 /$2CDE

@,/& !!,2"$@1/8

#!,* "$/ 2!*+ #8

#!$#"2 2 ,# "$"$

1 "$ = 2"# /$2 CDE $2 $ "# $& 6

, "1 &> ;6"!6 ;

# 3 ,+"

5 ;"

62, ;$ ;"

6 1"5

#*5+"

!+3, $#"9

, ;"

6"$ 6,

/# ,+

"3 !

" "

2 !3/ ,2 , "&

0 ++"##"$;

#2",

$22 !"2 "$ !!,2 ;"

61 ;

7"$@"$ 11 #3 # +

6"$ $

,& 6

, !1 "+# 6 "1

"$5* !$

$2#

#$ !"2 28 86 #"$97 (*,"#2"!

5/;

/ "$#

"$&

,$ 2!*$# 16 #, 2*3$ !"#"$ "9"#"$ $!6 "$

2 !"#"$ ,2"$

#$%

& '()* % 1# !"#"$ $451 "9"#"$ $!6"$(!+"

% & "$#

!"#"$"$0 ,1 4#!

B0*3, !$

"$9"

; !,,

9"$@5

2;"

"$ ,+8

!*12 $ 5 3,"9 2 # "$& ;

,8 #*5+"##"$ 6 5 !$#"2 5 !7@,*$2

2 !

/ 5 /$2 CDE 5

,"$@ &CG8 2

&G&G8;"

"$8 #"# 9"2 ,+

"$ ,+8 $$ =85* $;8"$

2"# / !

8 $$ = 2

2 H&& #6;"$@ 6"# 2"# #CD1"

1$@"& &,*$2 2 >CD;& & & 5G& H 2+"

21/8

2 *$2

@,/ $B7"11 /5 /$2CDE5/

!6"$@!

&CG82

2&G&G $2$ "$#

@,/ "# $ 5/

!6"$@ !

$$ =;6"!66 #5

$31 2$, !,2 , ",# ;,"

"$&2+"

,28$$ =C"##*

,!1

,1/ "$#

@,/"$;6"!6

,6 2"&

1 / 5 /$2 CDE& 6

11;

2 5/ 6/#"!

1 0!,

$"$@ $2 6/#"!

1 '

11 *$2

@,/& "#$1/

#!,* "$/ 2!*+ $C&&;6

1"I

2*$2 2"

@,/ "& &

/ 5 /$2 CDE "$#

2 !

@,/ "# A

,8"$97 (*,"#2"!

5/ / &> B$$ =>E 1

2"$@ @, 1"5 "1 !+3, $#"9

2",

!"2 !!,2 ;"

61 ;&

H C $ #6 6"11$4# !

B0*3, E8

, ;6 ;

2$1"$ $G&G&H5* ;6 #6 7* 3,"$

"$ ,+8#6

1"I

"$# ;6"!6#6 2;

##6;$ #J03 !"

1 !7;

##4 $2 "$ !",!*+#

# $ / "& & G&G&H8 #6

33, ++"##"$ 33,"# + 3,51 +8 ;6 *3$ #6 12

#6 + / #*5+"

6,*@66 ,2!3/;6"!6#6 #*5+"

2$&&H;"

++"##"$ ,6 ,!

*$2

$"$#

2 03 !"

1 !7;

,2 ## 5* #, (

25/ ++"##"$$&&H& $451

"9"#"$

"$5/

7"$@"$

, "1"$@

"$;

#&&H $2",, #3 "9 ;6

,$G&G&H #,;

#$ !+3*

,@1"

!68

,$&&H"& &+*!65 1

;6"!6

"$ !*12 5 #*5+"

28 33, ++"##"$ +9

"$, ?* ++"##"$ ,6 ,*$2

#$3,9"#"$$ 5#"

++"##"$ 11;"$@ !,, "$ "$

"$ ,+

,6 25

$, (

9 ,/ 6, #612;6 ,"@6 # $

2(*2@ 28 8,"@6 # $ ,!

;*125

,+"

!$#"2 28 #3, / 2 ,&!!,2"$@1/8"$ 1"@6 3#"

"$$

"$;

"& &#6 6"11$;

@,/3, / 2 , 5/6 ,&

C < ,8 "$ "$#

, #*5+"

"$# "# 8$$ =;

#&>&5* #5

$5,*@6 $ "!

5/1

,$ 20

!*$# 1

, 331/"$@ ;

#*5+"

,+ $ &&& 6

, ;

# "##*

2+"

,28$$ =C"$

@,/"$;6"!66

+"$

# ;

11 # "$ 6/#"!

1 0!,

$26/#"!

@,/;"

6* $/

, 2 +*, $2 + $

+3 ;6

!,,

2 5/ #*5+"

"$ 3,", 1

, #*5+"##"$

"$ ,+, ,

26"#@,"

, ",# 5/ "1"$@ &> *$1"7 "$ #6 6"11$4# !

;6 +

, ;

,1"

&6*#8 "

!"#"$ "$ #6 6"11$4# !

B0*3, E"#2"# "$@*"#6 $2"# $ "1

,& >

,$ 2!*$# 16 1#, 2*3$ !"#"$ ,2"$

$!6 &H< >"$!

,1 9#0

,#"$;6"!6

,6 *$2 !$+"!

11/ !7;

,2 ,#$ "$

# B

@,/5* ,!

2$ @,*$2

#6 "11 ,+2 !1 ,"$@6 ,!

# ;6

1$@;"

"$ ,+8#6 1$@

@,/& 6

, "$97 (*,"#2"!

"$ 2*,"$@ $!/ "$ 3,!

## $2 ;

# 3,9"#"$ 11/

"!"3

"$ "$ 3,!

## , #*1 3,2*!

,6 2# !*, 2+, + ,7#

@,/& F

,$ 2 !,2"$

< ;6"1 5# ,9"$@

, 11"$

$23*,3# #;

!1 ,"!

1 +"#

$2"

, ;

# $ 9 1"2 ;6"1 , 1/"$@ $ !"#"$ "$ #6 6"11$4# !

B0*3,

$2 2",

,*$2

@,/"$#

2 !

$2"##* 33"$ 1

,&6 "2 2 !"#"$ ;

# !

,,"

1 B"& & F & GE 5/

0 ++"##"$ 5*

1 ;

# 2"#+"## 2 5/ $451 "9"#"$ $!6 5/

7"$@ "$

# 3 3

##$ ##6

1"I +"#

!++"

"11"$@ *3 $1"$

"$ ,+8 #6 "++ 2"

1/ +

"$ 2

2 >&H&> 5 !+3

* 6,"

?* "$@ , $ ## ,/ !,, "$ "$

"$ ,+ $2 ;

##*,

9 ," "!

2!*+ #8#6 ;*125

,,/* $ ## ,/!,, "$# $2;

,+"

,"$

5* #*5# ?* 1/;6 $#6

2 ,9 ," "!

2!*+ # $ &>&>8 #6 # $ "!"3

,9"

; $2 6 , !

# !

2& $451 "9"#"$ 1# 7 "$

"$ 9"

; 3, "1"$@ #!"

!$+"!!$2"

"$"$ !*$ ,/ 1#

"I $#;

$ ,$

99/ $, 6 !+3*

, , 1 3 ,

2"1/ "1 , *#

$2*3$ !/5 ,!

#3,9"2"$@$

"11"$$1"$ ,+ $2"$#*!6!",!*+#

#8" +"#

!!*,, 28"

;*12 5 ;611/ *$,

1"# "! ,5"

,/ + #*!6

#* ,85 #"2 #8 #$3,9"#"$$ 5#"

++"##"$

11;"$@ !,, "$ "$

"$ ,+8 1#

3,;"2;1 2/

> 6 !"#"$"$0 ,1 #4#!

B0*3, 1#"# $ "1

# "$ "2 !

1# $ $1/ 6

, $

1"I"$@ +"#

!++"

2"$ "11"$@*3

"$ ,+8

* 6,"

33, 2 "@6 2*,"$@ $!/ "$3,!

## $2;

#@,

,"+, ,5 "$@3,9"#"$ 11/"$

,9"

28;6

#"$ "$#

,;6"# 2 , 3# 0*5 $#3 ,81"!

8"$

@,/

!"#!$%$#$ " % #!%&+

"!#"1 #3"

9"$@5

$"##*

2+"

,28 $$ =C !1

,1/ "$2"!

"!"3

+"$

"$ 11;

25/6/#"!

10!,

$"$@ $26/#"!

6* 3,

,2 +*,& "# $1/

"$3,!

##;

,;7 *3 "$97 (*,"#2"!

5/, 1/"$@$ 2"

G 2*5

, 6

2 2"# / !

$$ =2

2H&&"$2"!

"$@6"#2"# +, CD5* "22"# /!

25/

1$@ ;"

"$ ,+8 $$ = $2 "

/$2 CDE5

,"$@ &CG8 ##*"$@ * 6,"

/% 0 $26/ ("

#*+

,/8 2

2 &G&G8 ##* 2 "# ,"!

% , "11 ,/8 #"7 ;6"!6

1$@;"

"$ ,+8$$ =&

8 $$ =8

, "# $ 5 !$#"2 2 ,# "$*$2

@,/ "# 6"# 2"# / 5 "$@ +, $ CD 5* ;*12 $1/ 5

!$#"2

"$ *$2

@,/

"1#@"9 $"$$$ = ,;6"!6 ,9

"$ , 0'"#

+ 11;"$@,2 ,% '

()( # * ( + ,)

- #*1 "$ ;

# 2 !1 2 $ &&& !!

3, / ,

, ;*12 , #*1 "$ *$#

1"$@ "$3,!

##;6"!66

2 "$ /&6

,$ 9"$@

$2"1"@ "$ "11"$@*3

"$ ,+;"

62* 85/

!6"$@ !,, 2"# /!

1#"$$ @"

"$@6"# @,"

,#*5+"

"$@ $1"$

"$ ,+,

$/3"$ 3,", "$9!

&> #*1 9"$@5

$2 !1 +

6"#;$+"#

$ 1"@6 3#"

"$$

59 8 "$2"$@$+ ,"

"$#

"$8 "#2"#+"## 2"$1"+"$

./0 1)) 2 3 1)) 2 3