Bimla Devi And ORS. v. Santosh Ram And ANR.
!
" #$% &'()&*+ ,, -- !
.&*+/+ !(+)0$()&* 0 !, !
0"
12#- 034!
. !131 5 ,*&+&("
++#+%6'7(&6
*()&88%7(+ 88&%%(+ 999 *%
)&88&%)+:&& %&;+(()&<*(& 8++&:=()&(*77&(%$+ *:/%61+)*8/* *+)*(6>()& *:/%2 )&88&%+77$8&:=88%7(
/&*!&7( ()&-$((7( *7;()&&%= ?=+ %;()&88&%
$(*'&)7/%*77&(6()(77/**& 6 @+),%!;)%+()+% & 7%$8&(( %&:=()&%&;%)&*+ ()&&7&+&/&*!&7( ()&(*.&)7%&+7(6? *+)*(6 >()& 7(2 6 ()& *:/% '& (+ <* (& <*& 7$8&+( 6 6 %;<()(&*&+((()&*(& A8&* /$
;+( ()& + <*6 ()& 88&% )+ :&& %& * &)7&$&( 7$8&+(6%;<()88%7( *7( &%= ?=+ )& 88%7( 7(+ &B8%( ()( ()& 88%7(+ <&*&(<*& 8++; ()&<*(<+%=7(:&*6 6 <)& ()&= '&* & :/( ()& 8&; 7%$ *$ ()&* 7/+&% ( 1+)*8/*6()&=7$&(C<()(()&*7%$8&(()+:&&&7& ( )+ /*()&*:&&'&**&()(()&88%7(+&'&*C&<()&&B7(*&++&+ ()&*&+8&(+ * %;()&&B&7/( ()&<*()&=<&*&
7%%='&*=8*6:&7/+& <)7)()&=7/%(8/*+/&()&88&% *&$&=:& *&()+7/*( *&)7&$&( 7$8&+( )& *&+&B8%(8/( *()()&88%7(+( +(+ 7(*=6+&(%+*&;'&()&88%7( )&88%7(7$& /8 *)&*;-&*&7/+&%<++C&(;'&&(%+ &B&7/(()&(&+<)&()&7$8&+($/(<+8!)& +/;)(($& )&7+&<++$8%=D/*&(()&+ (&6;%&*&7/+&%+/;)($*&($&(;'&()&&(%+ )&7+& <+ D/*& ( =6 %&*& 7/+&% '&*= *%= 7%=+((&()(+8(& )&*:&+(&
*(+6()&88%7(+*&(<%%;
(;'&()&&(%+ &B&7/(8*7&&;+()&(&<)&()&=*&7&'& ()&7$8&+($/( +/7)7*7/$+(7&+6(+&'&(()(()&&(*& +(*=$&+(7'&*/8()&&%=(+(: &+( )&*&+E/**&%()&8*8+(()(%:&*%88*7)
+)/% :& 8(& <)%& 7; ()& &%= %; <() ()& + 8*8+(6(+(:&7+&*&6 *+(%=()(+/
7&(7/+&++)<6 +&7%=()(()&88%7(+8/((; *()()&*&%&'(&(%+()& *&+;'&+: &
()&8*&+&(7+&6()&88%7(+6+8(& )';*&+:%& 88*(/(=6)'&+(*/7(&()&*7/+&%((;'&()&(& *&7&';
()&7$8&+($/(<*&:=()& *:/% )&&(*&:++ ()& &B8%( *7( &%=</%)'&&8&&()&+(& )&*&+;'&()((%%7(:&*6 6()&=<&*&(<*& ()&<* (&8++&()&* '/*6+(+/88*(&:==&'&7& )&*&+
'( ()&7/+&%:& *&()& *:/%(+((&()(()& <*8++&/;/+(66<+(7'&=&(()&88%7(+(%% 7(:&*6 8*( *$()&:'&+*&+6&'& (&*7$;(C< :/(()&<*7(:&*6 6()&88&%<+ %&+%(&+3/*=6 )&*&+$&(& *()+&%=+()(()&88%7(+7/%(
%&()&&B&7/(8*7&&;+6+()&&B7(*&++&+ ()&*&+8&(+ <&*&(C< )+8%&*+&+ 7(/%%=<*; )& *:/%(+ <*)&%()(()&7%$(+</%:&&((%&(*&7&'&()&$/( *$ ()&*&+8&(+ )&*&<&*&(<*&+8&(+:& *&()& *:/%*+(<+ ()&*'&* ()&()*&& <)&&%&*()&+&7<+()&<&* ()&()*&&
<)&&%&*6&)* )*-(6()*/;)*&;&*6! 6!&7(*
6);*) )&7$8%&(&*&++ *&+8&(<+
()&*&()&<*(+&% '&()&*<+&6(+/:&%&':%&()(*&++ )* )*-(6<+('%:%&<()()&88%7(+ )&()*%$: ()&&B8%(+()(:&7/+& ()&8*
7%7(6()&88%7(+7/%(8/*+/&()&*&$&= 88&% )&++(7(:&77&8(&6+ *()&*&++:&+(C<(()& 88%7(+6()&=)'&<())&%()& *$(+(<)&()&=*&7&'&()& 7$8&+($/( )&%<+<&%%+&((%&()(&<)88*7)&+()& 7/*( *&E/(=+)/%7$&<()7%&)+ )& *$(*&%&'( * ()&&7+ ()&++/&+)/%:&+7%+&:=()&88%7(+0&%7& ()+ *&;* + 8%7& /8 &7+
00'% 6<)&*& ()&12:%&8&B/*(%<'*/+8*78%&+(&*%"
! "
?
!?6()&12:%&!/8*&$&/*( )&%+/&*"
! " # $ # % ! & &
!
' (&& ! & &
&# $ &)*
&+&$ &
&!
& &&& ,-.
& / ( & & &
) 0.10
&# && )/ &
&
& $ &
0.20 20--13&& !& && &&$ !& & 3& !&&
& & # $ %&+&$ &$
&
& &(24 4
&$
&
& & & & 4 &
! &# $ % & !
& && 5 .2
0 &%&+&$
& &$ !
& 2 &&&& + !%
% & &+&$
&$
&
&$ &
&
&
0.20 0--1% & &
%&&!
&
&+&$ &$ &! &
! & !&
& &
% ( &!%
& 6 !& &&
&4
&& &!
%& ! &
&
6
!&& ! !& && & !
&
&
4 %& && & &
&
0 7&
&
4 &
& %!& & &
&$
!& &&
1 08& !& &
4
()&:'&7+&6()&&%=<+(7&:=()&12:%& 8&B/*(6*&%=;/8(+&*%&*&7+# $ !
% & ' ! (<+)&%()(()&8&*+<) 88*7)&+()&7/*( *;*( *&%& +/&*:%;((7%= +7%+& %% ()& $(&*%$8*(( 7(+ <)7) )'& :&*; ()& D/7( ()&++/&+*+&()&7+& /*()&*6 ( ) % % &*'! + ! !6()+:&&)&%+/&*"
& &%& !0, , #& & ) $
&#%& 9 & & 00 1
: &9 ;
,5 &+&$
&<&& ! = -
,& &! 00 1
:%! (&&
&
& &
#%
: 3& %
!& !
&9 ! #
:>
%&
& 9 & & <&!
& &
& #% ! & & !
& ! & 9 ! & &9 &!&3&9
& ! & & !& !
)
,#
& )
& #%&! !& !!&!&
&& !
&& 4
&$ #
&! !&
$ 3&
&
& #&&!
& 9 ? &&! &&4
& $ & 2
<
& ! & 9 ;
0 !& &
&
% !& & !
& ! % & & !& !
& $
&
!2 & ! & +& $ & &@ ;
?
*) !& !& & !& && & & 3&9 & !&
& !& ! &
&
0, , & &
&! - &
0
5 <&!& &
&%& &&
& 9 & !
&& & % &
%
&
&9 "&%!&& 9 &
!!& &!&&!
% & 2 &
& &$ &
&
= -
,% & !& & & 9
&$ !&& & & & !& ! & !& ! !&&
&
% &&!
&
( && &% & !& & !& &
0, , %
& !& #& ! &$ %$ ( !&&
4
&& &
& 3&
&
0, , &
!& % & & 9 & $ &
3&9 & &
!&& $
& &
&!
&
&9 ! &
&%&& && !
! !&4 !&
!
()&:'&7+&6()&12:%&8&B/*(*& /+&(7& ()&&%=*&
%;+()&*&<++8&7 7&B8%(7$; *() ()&:%$&<++$8%=8/(()&8*&'/+7/+&%6:/(&(%+<&*& ;'&
'&< ()& *&+ D/;$&(+ * ()& *&++ $&(& :'&6 ()& &B8%( /*+)& := ()& 88%7(+ + ( +(+ 7(*= )&<())%; &(%+ ()&&B&7/(8*7&&;+()& (& *&7&8( 7$8&+($/(:=()&88%7(+ /*()&**+&+ /:(:/(()&&B8%( ()&*++/&)+:&&*+&*8*&++& )& 88%7( * 7( &%= + +$++& +&E/&(%=6()&88&%+%++$++&:&;($&:**&
!
D