← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3547/2011dismissed

Arjan Singh v. Jit Kaur And ORS

2017-03-16Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik14 pages

   !   

"#$  $%&'&()*

 

 





   



 

  



   



 







   ) +, -,.



   ! "





#  ! "

  $%"&''

(    ! )

(

* !  $%+"&''

,,,, -,. , -

 !  !

#  

$% $%+"&''%$&"&'$ )

! " ! "

   #   ! 

 !..  



  "."! /)

 "

"!0 " !

"! #  ! ". $%+"&''

  

 

.

   .

"

  2  &''  #0

3! )

#0 .

 !

 '

' &&2"

! . 

" !)   ) "

"

""    %4 



  

!

 (#0 )0"

 !



1! !

0" "



 !

#0 "

 ! ".

   .

    4  %) .

 564'7   

 "

 '& '

'2+5

) "

  . ! 0!

  ''

'25   ) ! '+ ''

'25 8"

   %

.

 %6   

 "

  

 2 ''

'25%$ ' '227

""

 "

.

)   .

.

0 * "  !



""   

 ! )

 



) )#

) "

  " .6 !.

90

"" !

 

"# ! ) 0 !

-

) !

! 0!



 !  

   :)"



 

!

"  %   . " "!.

( " (..    "!!

"

.



.

).  '7 $ &&& 

  

.

)!!

#0

(..  3       '

&&

.

 ""  %!!

 

) # .

"" .

     

 )  .   #0  

 1!  (..   

 # (      + $ && -

 )      -

) #

! 0!



.

     % !   "

"&0  :)"

! "

"" "

.

 54'7  4  %    

 "56")

""

;

   %"  < !



""

"" 

" ! "

!"!

".!

"

 



.

) !

 ''

'25#0

!"

  #   

-

 )    

!"!  "  "  

 !  !        ) !.

  

  0! #   -

)

!"!" "

!! 

) #"&0 

 -

 

 #" 

 ) 0 6 "!#  "

  ".

"")

0   : #!6  

""" " !

""

! 

))   "%6"

#"

 

 2 ''

'22%$ ' '227"

       

    "  

    

       #0 (..   3     '

&&#0 1!  (..   

 #  (       + $ && !!

 

.

"  ! 0!

 '& '

'2+5 "" 4  % ) )    : )"

. !  

".

 "

 

 "

"" 

 

)  

 8""!  '



 " 

)    . 

.0  # !        %  "     

  )     """ 

! 8!.

"  "

   !".



")  '=;



"")   "

 >8

=;



!!

. + $ &&"

.

.  '& '

'2+5  ) !>8

=;



""  ! 0 ">8

%=;



.#  ".

>8 $=;

 !

?@5&( ()  

# " " 

>



7=;

! "!!! 

"" "

>8 +=;



"" !.



!)

!   " ""

!>8 5=;



"" ""< !"



4 . >8 2=;



) .>8 '&=  ;  )#



!  !  #

  !



!.

0)   !

 "

  ! "

    

 !

#  !  !!.



!!  ""

 "       

!

 !! 0   )  .     .

 !

 '

' &&2 3"   """ 

"

 ) !.

# ) #0

3!  .

   .

 !

 2  &''

 :"! ) !

) ! #0

3! 

.

 ##0 ""

 .

 :

! "

"") !

#0 #  

    !  # ) 

  "   #0  

     )       %  )  .   

    !..   .

   % &'$  #0

3!    / !

 !



"  %

/  ! "

 1! 0 

:. " !   56'7.) #0

!.

 0"

 4 

4    '& '

'2+5

AB< 3= 

.

 ! 0!

  ''

'25AB<

(=!.

 # < ! #0

!.

  0" " 



4

        

     2 ''

'25%  AB<

=  )

< !   #0        "  "    4        '76  -

"  

4      

          & ''

'252  )  

   4  "    56  """    "  #0)0"

!"!

".!

) ) !

#0

!  .

 !

 5 ''

'22AB<

:= 1

"

). #0

"

 !  .

 $ ' '227AB<

*=

.0  $%"&''  < ! 

".

 %6'

''

'25""

""

 

: %$&"&'$  4

  $6. 

 ""4   

 + ''

'25

"  < ! 

# 



  " "  #0)0"

!"!

".!

" 

    ''

'25 

.  4

 " !.

#0

)!

   . "# "

( " (..  !'&"

# !6 3  

 A3 =! '2+7 AC

!D "   =  )  )  .           '7 $ &&& AB<

E= /)

 

" #0

!.

) 

)) #0

(..   3         '

&&  AB<

1=   

  "     "   

   

# "

1!(..   !'$A'="

!

-  

). #0

1!(..     + $ &&AB< =  / #

 ") 

 



" 

!" !

""

! 

) )   

#"

# 



 "(.. ) 1!(.. #  

-) $%$%+"&'') .

/)

 "

"

"") ) #0

3!   ) !.

   .

"

 

2  &''

!

" #0. 

)

 ) !

#0

!  .

 !

 7 '& &' 1

" #0

""! ) #0  %) . 

 !.. .

 7 % &'$ %$& "&'$

#  "

.

   .

 !

  #0

3! ).6 !0!  

!

!



0 

!"

.  # "  

.

   .

 1  ! #0

3! #

" 0

 #0  "

!!

  

  0  " !

..



< ! # 





 

 ) ) # < ! #0)0"

!! !

 5 ''

'22 8!



" "

""

!  

""   "  !

 

."!  

) 0 

 "!) /    ("



!!

 "

 ! $%$%+"&'' #

!# ) %$&"&'$ !..   ") )   



! .

   .

 !

  

.

# 



: )")  #

! 

# 

  #

"# #"   / #

. 

!

 ")"..

.

!!  . ")  !

   

 )#0 !

   "06"  ".

!") ? 

!!.!

  !'7"

!  

#"!"!!)# !  8



  !



4  0

""

"".!

# " '22' 

! )# !   '&4"

! -  '&4"

!!.

#    "!  '22'). 

!# )

' '22'

 ? 

!!.!

 )



! "

)!"  ) 1* !

 .

" ( /#  &0"(1"(  ."20  "(3  #4$0'  5'  4$  &("(%&"6  //&''&($07 $8$(2$$%0$#"09#8$0(/$(#7 2(1":"(3#4$0'7

  %&8&6* 7)# 

!# 

"!"

!   

 )  0 #  . " ! :  )"

. !# "

0!!  

"

 !))  "  )   

.

   .

 !



.

# 

 "   

 #

6 

!

 00 ."

-

..





 

!! 

 !."

""  / !.



!) ! 

 / #

" 0   

6)

  "

  .

) )

! :

    "

) !#

. .

!

") :

. 

)0 #!6.

"" )  ) <!. . 0".

/! )# "  ".0

""  !

 

" !   ? 

  "!!!.!

 

 0

 

"

 !)) ) !  

.

   .

 !



.

# 

 "    8!!"

  # . #0/D#

 ( '$" .



  

   

) !#  "0") 

! 

   !  "#

 # $ 

   %$#  &$'   !   $    (" '!$    '$   (   $ 

  &$ !)"*# # +  (  '      " 

(("  $    "  ($    ""    $       $  (!

* !,$! $ 

( !

!"' (* $ ""!

-$    ("#   $ ( !    . .(  !"



  !

 . . . "  $   

"'

"$ # .( (  

/ !

*"     (!'     ! 

  $   .!     $

  

%$ !-  $ 

$" !   " ( !$  ($$- !

  !* #

$ "#



' $   !

!

*  /    $   -   "    !$     .

   $%$  ! ./' .$"' 

 "  !

  "/  (%$#  (* !

    *

 " $   (((

"# . -(  $

 . $!  !

$ "

"  0  



$!  " # ($ .

 " 0 ''

!"



 " '

 $ (( ! $ . !"   

 $$ # $ $ 

 #  #

( $(  "'

"(! $  !

*"#!$ 

    $ $  $  

      .'$" $ $ $%$ '

  #  $"

 $

(! $ 1.

# !$   !#  ( " !($ *!    -  ( #   (( !'    $  .   !"   .$" " "  2$  $!( #.

"$!!(""$ '  

%$ ! #

/'

(

 "# "

 !

 !"

 "(! ""#$ 3 !"4   $ +" (( !' !$ 

" '

 $ 

!!

 !

 ! . !"   +$!

  !

  



$!$!

 $ " !"-

""#

!!*(  

$   $ (!  !$ $! " '

  ,$   . "' "#

 (  !

' " '  !!$



  "  !* $"

($(

$   $  (! !$ 3" '

  $ 

/ $""  $ !"$ !

567 





   





 !"



 #$# % &% '( )#  % *   +, 

 $#  

 - -



./ !"

 



  &# )0#  1

 .-!"

2% %



 

3  4  

 - 



.1!"

0 4  % + 0

*#     

 - 

/!"

&% 07

3  4   

 - 

/

-86 8 9-(/',$ # $ ,$ # 

%$ !"   $ "!"  !"  !"   %!

* 

 ,$2$



"%$!$" '

 -  "'

" 

0  %$  

$   ,$$       !$

$    %$ "!$("  .! 



  "

.

$ 

$"  ! #  "    %$#           (!(    $   + %$!

 !$ $"  !  $! $

(!"

. # '$ "" '

  $"0!  "! # $ 

" '

'$

*

  #  0 $  !

     (    "'

  $(    " '

   !"    $   !

  

(( ! !$ . !"   :;" '

 !

("

#< /=.  !$  (

<(!/ !=-$ !

$'  !"  $

/."

. $   !

1. ! . !

 !

 !"   !

 " .  !$ .  "  $((!!  

 " !

  (  "  " '

 *  !,$ *!

!# $!!

 $ $ # $ ! '$"

$! (("!

 ,$   . ! (  !$  $' (! !$  9& :

#

00 % 4  ;



 - 8

-

.8!5 * "         !!     3!    0 <.  ! 

!  "!"

! ) 

 !

#  ! 

! !



!

( "  ! #0

3!  '&".

   .





) # !





 *'* $' $"!



$ 

 #!$"   ( 

 !

    

$

.

 ""

 #  ;   ;9

 (! "'  !$"  -

.

 ""

  $ $%

!/ ') "( )( "3!

 >4 

! .

"

.  ""

 !*# !  

!$" "" 

  #2!$" !

( (# 3("   " 

/ #  ;9 

 

/ "   /  ("

   ' ( #

 " 

$ "$  $ "

   "     $'  .     "   3!

$ ""# "(!.

*'* #("

     /  $   "!

 



#"

. ?.* *!" #    (* ""  !

6

 ("

   

/ ' (" 

  ($! .  !

. $  ! .

( $ 9  (!!6"3!

?

   ,$ ($!  $ "

  '

$'   $

 %

!*# !

 ""

 "

  "" !$  $



 .

  ;9..

.(  $ "

 " 

$ "

  ("

 

$'  . "-*!" #  ("

 $ . 

  ;19$ ""

/  ""

 (  '  0!$   .

(    ("

   " $  (!!(

! '

   ;9 !*"

!$     

  .

  !  *  %$'

 



!

 

   (( "(  

 #  ;9   3!" !$

'  '* # !*"!$ %$'

  ! 

  ;9.

.(

$ "

 .

 $ 0!$   "  $ "

 *$ ("

 +$

0!$  !  

.

' 0!$ 

$' !$ "

. -*$!$   

&  )*&     @ ! "  

  $%    '

  !



  ''* # !*"!$   #  * *" # %$!

."!

!""'

 ""

  *$  ;9- (" 

/ #  ;9   ;   * " # 

/ !

 # !*"

!$  !$ * $  (" .

!!(  # !*"!$  ;. 

("  *  '

 #     $. #

"!

  

/ !

  ("

  ( $ !

9  (!!6"3!

 - *!$!" "#. 

 ("

       (      $  "

     !

!""

>:  ""



 3%   '     >    ""'

"  $""  *   . $  %$!

      ("

       "  !"

 %$!

( # $;

    !   *$    ("

     ''* #   "!$ . (!

  $ '

 ("

  5 3 

! "

  ! "



 "         0      0   

0   

 #  "  ! #0

3!

/ ! 



09 ").!

#9 ") )  9 "     !



" ( ) 

< ! 

 !  !'&&"

( "(

!



:    !

!# !



 .

"

/D#    (   "09"("(  "1$(30"(  "(3  "(#4$0  5' ,$;'4/9"01&(&"(3#4$0'7

< %&8&6 =*  "(#'4 ">"0&5' 20'4##"/&?"0&7

< 

 .

) (  

!"!!!.!

"

!  # ! )

"    ("

!  ) 



 .!!

 # "".

 ) 0#!

-  

." ! " "

!

#

. 

 0 )

# # .  

 !

.   )

 )  !

 -,. 

  '7  &'+ 3/ 

+ ( /'A BA; + (

"7 BA;