Gurmeet Kaur v. Shiv Kumar Bansal & ORS

  
    
 %&'  %&'  

'

'()' - !

- '*+ +,  .

-  //'00%,&"

$



  '

/,1',&"

$

 

  
 

 
  


  
 



'(
6
 





  


*
7
 

 %0 *
'( ( 8888




!



 





!
 
"# "$ %"

&
 




 
'(
)*

 
+ ,
+ 




9
) )*:,
!

(* 


./"""01
 
(
!
!
 

0(

!

!

2
&3
 
*(

%

 


 #

/

(
((

 
(



)*
 


(
 

*

- .""""""01
+- -*

54
 ,
 
!

2

%3

*(

*
 


4



( 

*
 
!
4


%.

".

%"

/
!


 

  




0  #

5 
)*



 



 

* 
*











0 
 



 

!

 
!
!*

 

;
* **

!*


 




*

 

(
!*
  
*
!
( 





!
( 
1
.No Heads of Clai im Amount (in Rs s) S.

1.

Loss of Consortium Rs.1,00,000/- 2.

Loss of Estate Rs.50,000/- 3.

Funeral Expenses Rs.25,000/- Total Rs.1,75,000/-

<

 
 


! 

"# "$ %"

&

 


 



 0(

(
(
= =




( (



*
 


 
 




)* *


 *

 


 
4

  



 



/

5 
*


 0(


!

*(



!
!
 
(


=

= =
6(
* >

!


 **



( (

*
! 

- ?""""01

( 
! 

)* *
(4
 




!*

 




**
 
!*




 


*



 (
!
*


(
@
*
 



)*
 
!

  
(*


(

 


!


 !

@
 
* 
*(

(
!
*
 
 
!



!


&

A




 *

- 
 %0 *
'(
*(


) )*



 
!*


 

(



 
@
*


0( 

B*
( 




!
 *



( (

.

  


*




*

 
4







*( 
 



* 


 0( Question of In ncome

?


 




 
(


=

!

!

=
6( (
*>

!
*
  

@
!

!4 4


** 

!


( (

*

4
( (
+CD '

,
! 


 
 


*

-

?$//01 
(
+-

"

"?#01
F
- .?.%01,


( 

7* %"

/
=*
* 
D(
CD '

'%

'/

71=(
*

0
-*
6

5 5
'((
 
@*( **
)( 
5 5*

*>

*( 

**
*
4
'((
5 5*

*>

( (


 

**
(
 
-

<<%<<01



%"

"

)

!

!*



*(


!


 

**
  


**
 (



%"

/
*

  
 
2
- %"""""01

 *(
+-

&&&&01

(,

?

) 
@E
*(
'*

 

-. //01 /

2  

  !

"


#$%&'( '( &)  *+,


 
 

 


D*
! 
(*

(
-




* 
*
1

      



   

 

  

  

  

 

      

  

  

              

      

    

      

 

 

   

   

   

   

 

         

 

        

      

       !

 

  

"

  #  $ %   

           

   

          

                  

 

         

    



       

 



  

    

   &  )* *

(


 


(



( 

*
 

- #/&% 01

( 
+-

?$//01
(
 
F

&&&&01
( (
**
 , Question of M Multiplier and Compensation n under Conventional Heads s

$

!

>*(


@ E
D
'*

-

  2 3  ! 4 3  524/ 

   

 /  !  4"
 

$%%'#6(  # #/1/2())
- / 2 

 !

3 :  4/ ! 4"
 

$%&)#*(  #/1/2(& &%%'
9 / !!/  

 !

1  / /!7 8/!9 9


#$%$&(&&) );%

 



!
./





 
 (
(*

< <
*




 (
!
(*


' (
!
*
 



B* 




'

'(




-

?"""01

(
* 



* 
D

-

?"""01
 !




 

"3

* 

 

5 

*(



! 


*

- < <?"""01
D
<
+-

$%"""01,

 


 #
 
/

!!
 








*

 
*(;
*
(** 



 

(

 *



 
 


"

!

!


* 
 


 

  #

/








(

!
( 1
Sr.N No.

Nature Amount Rupees in 1.

Annual Income o of deceased Rs.4,27,452 2/- (Rs.35,621X12) 2.

Deduction (1/4) Rs.1,06,863 3/- Net Income after Deduct tion Rs.3,20,589 9/- 4.

Income after applying m multiplier of 4 as Rs.12,82,35 56/- per age of 75 years (Rs.

3,20,589/- X 4) 5.

Funeral Expenses Rs.18,000/- 6.

Loss of Consortium (Rs.

48000x4) Rs.1,92,000 0/- 7.

Loss of Estate Rs.18,000/- Total Compensation Rs.15,10,35 56/- Amount Awarded by th he Tribunal Rs.1,75,000 0/- Enhanced Amount Rs.13,35,35 56/-

) 



2
&3

 *(

>*

!



 
*(
 






 
 
(


@E E

*(
'*



 5/! 4 3  / 2

  / / !! 4#$%%'(#*(,&6





*B*
>*(
 

: 

 ! 43  

!!! 4$%&*#&(

 #/1/2( **6
 




$3 3

*(


(*
(
 !


(
( (



*

 (


 
G


( 



(*
(
 



(
 

*
(

 
(

!


(




 



( *
+,

  




  $  232 & 4

% "

-  H H 
40

I 


I 0 0