High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3588/2011dismissed

Mukhtiari v. Om Kumar And ORS.

2016-11-08Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages

!" !"#!!"$ !" %%&& '" ()(" !" %

!" !"#!!"$ !" %%&& '" + ,! !" % *

!" !"#!!"$ !" %%&& '" ( #! !" %

" &)!"%&."/0! "-1!##"0&./ "%%&& "/ !&./ ""%

!"#"$% &'()*+, "*-. &'())"#"/% &'()*+,

"*.( &'()) ,0"##*% &'()*+, "*-- &'()) 3" ! " ! %%& . 0!! " &1 %%"41

/.$ 5 #!( !%%& """44"#! "". "!%"% %" #! %" %%& %%& &&0.46&&67% +,1 !2!

8! "" ( !&& % !" "#&" %%& 8!%%&&

##"/ !6#( " " "41!&0"%%&&,".0!"41! #&"

! " *:** :0 "& " ("%" .!4 (41!&0"

%%&& ,". . 6#( " ! "& ," " #!.!4 "/" " &)!"%&.&"

", &41" -1!##"0&.&"

&%%" 4!& %%&&

4(.!!"0% /"( !%& ! !" %%&&

0 !," "!%"% 7 #! +- !"4"!"( #!%"%"1 !4"!"9 9&0" " #"#! !%"%"1.(!&. "

" 8!& %(" # & ("&; ! "& "0 !1"**

** ** 0! !%"%"10&41! !4; / " #&1.! ** 0

&0!%"(%,"4&0 #&&! ."! 4!&0"%%&&,"!"" &1"/"! # 0! #! ! #" "" &<,-,!4

%"/!!&8!/"( !%"/=%& .0!!!4

7-9." &! " !%"%"14 6 !

(&1%"%"10!" &&10 ""!%"%"10 !" 41 !" "( !" !4 . !" ". 0& !/ !"" 4/.(!&.; " # ! (&1 &( 0 ! #4 (%0"##& !%"/ ! #" 4!%"%"1!! #! 4! "( !

444& 00! ! %"/ "& * !$( 8!" # 41! &0"%%&&,"&&1& !"& ( "1/ .

(!&. %& #.!. !" #" &&#&1 %"/"1 6#( "";"4 "/ !&.&"

&%%" 4!&

"% 0 !4; / 4(!/&4&"#!

!" !& .0!" &4!4 %"!" "&& " &%"" (%"" ! & !-"%"10%"!41/" 1 #!& .

!" ".&& !/4 "#!&1.!&0"

%%&& ," ! "/" ! # > #" " ("%" !/ 4 %"/ "#!," "

"( # ! # "!&& # >!/!"&"

& "%" %%"!%%"

4 !/0!!" (" " !4(

" &)!"%&. ".%%&&

!("4&1 &%"/ ! #" "!"!&01" ## !%"/" &# " 1 "/ 7%" " (%" ! !(4 (%" =# " !/ & ( 0" ( !4

.!0 &";"( &0 > (1/0.

!" &" !"# #! ?/ "!".!%

0& ! : ! 0 ! 0&#

!%&

1 &! ** 4.!(

"!& 44"#!0! %" !" 1" "( ! ; ! 0&#& 4/0

!1"** @!(1.!,"! " !%%&4&1 !$( >(& ! /04!/ # &%"/!( #" .!. & ! ! #4 ##" A( 3"!" .>

"0!

! #" "41!&0"%%&&,"

#" " "

" ( . (! &. 4 &; &0" " #&1.&&!%%&"( (-))'()$ 32432 !52 6+,78 ! ,20% 2!8 32432 2% 2!8