High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/16/2015dismissed

Shera @ Shamsher v. Sukhdevi @ Neelam

2015-01-13Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri10 pages

!!"#$#%&'(( )*!+,#$)*-$*!+ ((((..!,,% ( /!+$0$ )01*2!3#,#$!!,- ((( !$.%2!% (

)& +( 45.+,#1623" !+ *!..!,,% ( (

!!,#%7 77+#!3!2 89 *! 4027-!% %2 2!"+!! 2 !2 ((:.$$!289 *!#$ +#" 027!65# *,6;*!+!89 *!.! # #% #,!289 *!+!$.%2!% ;#!0%2!+)!" #%' *!#%20++#7!" 6 < #%$*+ = *!" > +2#$$,0 #%-++#7!892!"+!!2#3+"! ;$,,;!26 *!..!,,% *0$8%2*$..+"*!2 *#$0+ 89;9 #%$ % ..!,( ( !;" $%!"!$$+9+2402#" #% *!.+!$!% ..!, $%++ !2 *!+!#%-98!% #"!2(*!+!$.%2!% ;#!#,!22#3+"! .! # #%6 .,!2#%7 * *!+-++#7!;$$,!-%#?!2;# * *! ..!,,% 80 9!+$7""+2#%7 #%20+# !$%2"!+!-%#!$ 3#,,7!)0, %#6!*$#,0*,6#$ +#" 5# *,( !+ *!-++#7!6 *!9 ,#3!2 7! *!+$*0$8%2%2;#!%2"*8# !2$$0"*%2+- *!#+ ;!2,"16 *+!!!-,!"*#,2+!%6%-!,96-%6!*%2#;!+!

8+%( ,, *!"*#,2+!%+!,#3#%7;# * *!+!$.%2!% *!+.+!% , *0$! 3#,,7!)0, %#%2+!$ 029#%7#% *",$$6%2",$$%2#% 0+$+9",$$6+!$.!" #3!,9( *!..!,,% ;$22#" !2 ,#@0+%2 0$!2 8! *!+!$.%2!% 0%2!+ *!#%,0!%"!,#@0+()*! ,!+ !2 ,, *!"+0!, 9"0$!2 *!+;# * *!*.! * 20! .$$7! #-! *!8!*3#0+ *!..!,,% ;0,2"*%7!80 *#$8!*3#0+8!"-! -+!"+0!, ;+2$*!+(3!% *! *!+ *!..!,,% $0..+ !2*#- #%2+#%1#%7%28! #%7 *!+!$.%2!% ( *! *!+ *!+!$.%2!% +!@0!$ !2 *!..!,,% % "%$0-!,#@0+%2% 8! %2 *+$$*!+0.%;*#"* *! *!+ *!..!,,% $$0+!2 1!!. *! +!$.%2!% ;# *0,,+!7+2%2% * $$0+%"!6$*!;$$!% *!+ - +#-%#,*-!( !+ *!8#+ * *#+2!-,!"*#,26 *!8!

*3#0+ *!..!,,% %2*#$-#,9-!-8!+$8!"-!-+!"+0!, ;+2$*!+ %2 *!90$!2 0% *!+ * $*!"0,2% 7#3!8#+ * -,!"*#,2 %2*2.0 80+2!% *+!!!-,!"*#,2+!%% *!-(% *!-% * .+#,6 *!..!,,% 73!$!3!+!8! #%7$ *!+%2$*!;$ 0+%!20 *!+- +#-%#,*-!,%7;# * *! *#+2207* !+%2 $#%"! *!%$*!;$,#3#%7 *!+.+!% ,*0$!( *!.+!% $ *! +!$.%2!% "%3!%!2-%9.%"*9 $ *!*0$!+!, #3!$ *! ..!,,% +1!!.#%7 *!+!$.%2!% %2*!+207* !+$;# *,3!%2 !" #%80 %0$!(""+2#%7,96 *!+!$.%2!% #,!2.! # #%0%2!+ )!" #%' *!" +2#$$,0 #%-++#7!892!"+!!2#3+"!( *!$#2.! # #%;$"% !$ !289 *!..!,,% 89#,#%7;+# !% $ !-!% ( !$#2!$ +#$#%7 3+#0$ .+!,#-#%+9 84!"

#%$6 # ;$ .,!2!2 * *!+!$.%2!% ;$3!+9",!3!+%2@0++!,$-!,29( )*!0$!2 .#"1@0++!,$;# **#-%2*#$-#,9-!-8!+$%.! 9 - !+$%280$!2*#-#%%0%.+,#-!% +9,%707!( A*!% *!

! ..!,,% +#!2 0%2!+$ %2 *!+!$.%2!% 6$*!0$!2 80$!*#-%2 ,$ *+! !%!2 "--# $0#"#2! %2 #%3,3! *#- %2 *#$ -#,9 -!-8!+$#%,$!"$!$()*!%!3!+.+!.+!2-!,$+*#-%2*!+ "*#,2+!%%2+!0$!2 2 *!*0$!*,2;+1%22#2% "+!+ *! "*#,2+!%( ;$0+ *!+.,!2!2 * *!+!$.%2!% *2.!++-!2 $!"%2-++#7!;# *%!)*+8)#%7*%(('%2$#%"! *!% $*!;$+!$#2#%7;# **#-(""+2#%7 *!..!,,% 6 *!+!$.%2!% *2,! *!- +#-%#,*-!;# *0 %9+*9-!%2+!$%%2;# *0 *#$"%$!% (*! *!+3!+-!% $-2!#% *!.! # #%;!+!2!%#!2%2 .+9!++2#$-#$$, *!$-!;$-2!( +- *!.,!2#%7$ *!

.+ #!$6 *! +#,"0+ +-!2 *!,,;#%7#$$0!$& ( A*! *!+ *!.! # #%!+#$!% # ,!2+2!"+!! 2#3+"!% *!7+0%2"+0!, 96$,,!7!2#% *!.! # #%B

( A*! *!+ *! .! # #%!+ *$ % "-! *! "0+ ;# *",!%*%2$$,,!7!2%2$$0"*6 *!.! # #%#$% -#% #%8,!#% *!!9!$ ,;B

!,#!( '( %$0..+ *!+"$!6 *!+!$.%2!% 8!$#2!$!C-#%#%7 *!+$!,$ A6,$!C-#%!2*!+ *!+,-#+$ A%2,1+ )#%7* $ A'( % *! *!+ *%26 +!80 *! !3#2!%"! *! +!$.%2!% 6 *!..!,,% !C-#%!2*#-$!,$ A%2,$ !%2!+!2 "!+ ##!2".9"-.,#% (DE'$C( ( :( *! +#, "0+ 1 #$$0!$ ( %2 7! *!+ 8!#%7 #% !+"%%!" !2 %2 % ..+!"# #% !3#2!%"! ,!2 89 *! .+ #!$6 2!"#2!2 *! $-! #% 30+ *! +!$.%2!% *,2#%7 * *!

" +!$.%2!% ;$!% # ,!2 2!"+!!2#3+"!% *!7+0%2"+0!, 9(

0+ *!+6# ;$*!,2 * *!..!,,% *2#,!2 .+3!%+!"+2 * *! +!$.%2!% *2 % "-! *! "0+ ;# * ",!% *%2$( ""+2#%7,96 *! +#,"0+ 3#2!4027-!% %22!"+!!2 !2((: ,,;!2 *!.! # #%%22#$$,3!2 *!-++#7!8! ;!!% *!.+ #!$89 2!"+!!2#3+"!(!%"!6 *!.+!$!% ..!,( ( F!+%!2 "0%$!, + *! ..!,,% $08-# !2 * *! +!$.%2!% *2"% +" !2$!"%2-++#7!%2 *!"-.,#% 6C( ;$#,!2#% *#$+!7+2( F!+%!2"0%$!,0+ *!+"% !%2!2 * *! ..!,,% *2% "--# !2%9"+0!, 90.% *!+!$.%2!% %2$*! *2,! *!- +#-%#,*-!*!+;%;#,,(""+2#%7 *!,!+%!2 "0%$!,6 *!,,!7 #%$,!3!,,!2 89 *! +!$.%2!% ;!+! 7!%!+, #% % 0+!%2;# *0 %9$.!"##"#%$ %"!$( ( !+*!+#%7,!+%!2"0%$!,+ *!..!,,% 6;!2% #%2%9-!+# #% *!"% !% #%$,!+%!2"0%$!,+ *!..!,,% ( D( )!" #%'

# *!" !-.;!+$ *!0+ 2#$$,3!

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

2+;#%7"%",0$#% *!+!%( E( *!.!C0+ #%#$%&&'&()#% '*&$+,)&()#

-!. -,%,/.

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

# #$ 8! 1!%$8!*3#+89%!$.0$! ;+2$ *! *!+;*#"*"0$!$+!$%8,!..+!*!%$#%#% *! -#%2 *!, !+ * # #$% $!+*#-+*!+ "% #%0! *!- +#-%#,+!, #%$*#.;# * *! *!+( !% ,"+0!, 9#$$ !-#%2%2!!,#%7;# *%!

*! $.0$!$ 20! *! 8!*3#+ + 8!*3#+, . !+% 89 *! *!+( %,#1! *! "$! .*9$#", "+0!, 9 *!-!% ,"+0!, 9#$2##"0, !$ 8,#$*89 2#+!" !3#2!%"!( #$%!"$$+#,9- !+#%!+!%"! 8!2+;%+- *!" $%2"#+"0-$ %"!$ *! "$!( !!,#%7 %70#$*6 2#$..#% -!% %2 +0$ + #%#%%!$.0$!"0$!289 *!"%20" *! *!+ "% %,9 8! ..+!"# !2 % $$!$$#%7 *! !%2#%7" $%2"#+"0-$ %"!$#%;*#"* *! ; .+ %!+$ - +#-%#, ,#! *3! 8!!% ,#3#%7( *! #%!+!%"!*$ 8!2+;%+- *! !%2#%7" $ %2 "#+"0-$ %"!$ 1!% "0-0, #3!,9( % "$! -!% ,"+0!, 9# ;#,,% 8!"++!" ..+"* 1! %#%$ %"!-#$8!*3#+#%#$, #%%2 *!%.$! *!@0!$ #%;*! *!+$0"*8!*3#0+#$$0#"#!

% 89 # $!, "0$!-!% ,"+0!, 9(*!..+"*$*0,28! 1! *! "0-0, #3! !!" *! " $ %2 "#+"0-$ %"!$!-!+7#%7+- *!!3#2!%"!%+!"+2 %2 *!%2+;#+#%!+!%"!;*! *!+ *!.! # #%!+ #% *!2#3+"!.! # #%*$8!!%$084!" 2 -!% , "+0!, 920! "%20" *! *!+(> <( C-#%#%7 *!" 0,- +#C*!+!#%6# -98!% #"!2 * %;-%;0,2 ,!+ !,!3!,,#%7,$!,,!7 #%$20, !+9%*!+ "*+" !+( % *! .+!$!% "$!6 *! ..!,,% *2 ,,!7!2 * *! +!$.%2!% *2.!++-!2%2-++#7!;# *)*+8)#%7*80 *2% ,!2%9!3#2!%"!#%$0..+ *!+!( *!..!,,% ,,!7!2 * #$, )#%7*%2*0,, ,2*#-80 .!++-#%7$!"%2-++#7!89 *!

1 +!$.%2!% ;# *)*+8)#%7*80 *!2#2% !C-#%! *!-(-.,#% 6 C( 89# $!,;$% $0#"#!% !$ 8,#$* *!,$!%28$!,!$$ ,,!7 #%$ ,!3!,,!2 89 *! *0$8%2( *! .9-!% -#% !%%"! "*+7!$20+#%7 *! +#,;0,2% 8!!%07* $*; * *!..!,,% *2% "--# !2%9"+0!, 9(!#%7*0$8%26# ;$*#$20 9 .9 *! -#% !%%"!"*+7!$(*!*0$8%2*2#,!2 .+20"!%9- !+#, !3#2!%"! !$ 8,#$* *! ,,!7 #%$ ,!3!,,!2 89 *#- 7#%$ *! +!$.%2!% ;#! !C"!. *#$ 8,2 $ !-!% ( *! +!$.%2!% ,$ !$ 8,#$*!2 * *!..!,,% *2 *+;%*!+0 +- *!- +#-%#, *0$!897#3#%7$!3!+!8! #%7$%2;# *0 %90, *!+( ;$% !$#8,!$!%22#7%##!2+ *!+!$.%2!% ,#3!;# * *!..!,,% ( *! +#,"0+ "%",02!

2 * +- *!!3#2!%"!6# ;$-2!0 * *!+!$.%2!% *2% "%2%!2 *!" $"+0!, 9%26 *!+!+!6$*! ;$!% # ,!2 2!"+!!2#3+"!% *!7+0%2"+0!, 9(*!+!,!3% #%2#%7$+!"+2!289 *! +#,"0+ +!2 *0$& =:( ;-%;0,2 ,!+ !%9$.!+$#%%*!+ "*+" !+(F!3!,,#%7"*+7!$%"*+" !+;#!#(!( 20, !+9 ! "( #% *!-$!,3!$ -0% "+0!, 9( % .+!$!% "$!6 *!+!$.%2!% *$,,!7!2 * *! # #%!+*$.!++-!2%2-++#7!;# *)*+8 )#%7*$%F!!,0 -+!$#2!% 5+!

50+01$*! +6 80 ,!2 % !3#2!%"! $0..+ *#$ 3!+$#%(!$ !2 * #$,)#%7*%2*0,, ,2 *#- 80 .!++-#%7 $!"%2 -++#7! 89 *! .! # #%!+ ;# * )*+8 )#%7*6 80 2#2 % !C-#%! *!-(!,$$ !2 * *!*$% $!!%$#2-%

)*+8 )#%7* ( *! +!$#2 $ !-!% *!

2 +!$.%2!% $*;$ * *!,!3!,,!2,$!%28$!,!$$ ,,!7 #%$(!+!#,#%7"-.,#% C( 2!$% .+3! ,,!7 #%$( *#$ "%20" +!$.%2!% -0% !2 "+0!, 9(!2-# !2 * *!%!3!+ +#!2 -!! *#$"*#,2+!%%+73!%9 *#%7 *!-( $*;$ * *! #$ ,$ % 8 *!+!2 80 *!-6 *07**!",#-$ *3!#,!2.! # #%+"0$ 29 "*#,2+!%( ..!+$ * *!40$ ;% $*; * *! ,3!$ *#$ "*#,2+!%( *! .9-!% -#% !%%"! "*+7!$20+#%7 *! +#,2!$% $*; * *!2#2% "--# "+0!, 9$,,!7!2(!#%7*0$8%26*!;$ +!@0#+!2 .9 *!-#% !%%"!"*+7!$0%2!+ *! ,;(*0$6 *!"% !% #%,!+%!2"0%$!,+ *! +!$.%2!% * *! *$ 8!!% +!70,+,9 .9#%7 *! -#% !%%"!$*;$ * *!#$"+#%7*0$8%26#$% !%8,! #% 3#!; *!

"%20" *! +!$.%2!% !C*#8# #%7+- *!!3#2!%"! *!.! # #%!+( ( *!,,!7 #%$6-2!89 *!+!$.%2!% * *!.! # #%!+%!3!+"+!2+"*#,2+!%%+"1!22 + *!-6*3!,$% +!"#3!2%9$0..+ +-%9 @0+ !+6!C"!. *#$8,2$ !-!% (3!% *!+;#$!6 +- *!0%+!80 !2$ !-!% *!.! # #%!+%2 *!+ ;# %!$$!$6 # #$ -2! 0 * ,, *! *+!! 207* !+$+!#%*!+"+!%2"0$ 29(*#$8!,#!$ *! ,,!7 #% *!+!$.%2!% * $*!#$% 72 - *!+( *! +!$.%2!% ,,!7!2 * *! .! # #%!+ +!0$!2 "12%2-#$8!*3!

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

.! # #%!+*$% "%2%!2 *!" $"+0!, 9( E(

!+2#$"0$$#%6 *!.! # #%!+*$8!!%8,! !$ 8,#$*%+!"+2 * $*!#$!% # ,!2+2!"+!! 2#3+"!% *!7+0%2"+0!, 9(*!+!$.%2!% *$ #,!2 .+3!%+!"+2 * *!.! # #%!+*$% "-! *!"0+ ;# *",!%*%2$(> ( %3#!; *!83!6,!+%!2"0%$!,+ *!..!,,% ;$

0%8,! 2!-%$ + ! * *!+!;$%9!++++.!+3!+$# 9#% *! #%2#%7$ +!"+2!2 89 *! +#, "0+ 8$!2 % -#$..+!"# #% + -#$+!2#%7!3#2!%"!;*#"*-9;++% #% !+!+!%"!89 *#$0+ ( ""+2#%7,96 #%2#%7 % -!+# #% *! ..!,6 *! $-! #$ *!+!89 2#$-#$$!2( - .

34 #'5#$6!

-. 78$ 34