Naren Pratap Singh v. Kurukshetra University And ANR

  
  
  
  
 





  !"#"$%   !"#"$%   !"#"$%   !"#"$%

 & $&

'("$)* + ""$ & ,# ,# ,# ,# -.&./#* & $"0 &#"1 $* & + #'$2 $#

3%453(
-(-3
3%453(
-(-3
3%453(
-(-3
3%453(
-(-3

& # $% 3&("$)*620!

 6

&* ' ""$ & 3&*.7 $, #620!

 6

&& #'$2 $# 

-(-36 -(-36 -(-36 -(-36 * ' ""$ &'

## 2.*"#553 1 &#4!.&#  &8*  -.&./#* & $"0 &#"16-.&./#* & 9 &#*&:* $"0 &#"1;"$* 1

<    ''=" 2  *  $"0 &#"1 /"$) "8'&0 8 $ > 7*"!** #? $8 2  ''="!

&8( ##"$

@ & && 2
= &?.* * #? $"$ &8 2 ?1* $"0 &#"1* #"$! * * 2!8'=  2*"#553"$* 1

<

$2* 2 !"#"$7"*& ) &2"8'&0 8 $"$* 8 &/# 553* #? $

/ $"$* 1

7 

@6* & & 6* 7.=2$?  =")"?=   *  ' ""$ & * # *.# ''& !* 2 *"#
.& & # /"$) 2"& !"$  *  $"0 &#"1  !$#"2 & *"# ''="!

& ' &8"##"$ 

&"$* "8'&0 8 $ > "$ '& 0".# =1 & 553

    & $"! 6 *  $"0 &#"1 * # "= 2 "# & '=1 "$ 7*"!* " "#

0 && 2* * ,"! 
* $! ==& * $"0 &#"1!$#". 2 !88"  !$#"2 & *  & A. #   *  #.2 $#  &2 )& !  8 &/#  *  553 #.2 $# $28 / '&0"#"$# &"8'&0 8 $"$* 553!.&# *  8 "$)   *  # "2 !88"  7 # * =2 $ B

C

0.& & !88 $2 "$# 7 &  '= ! 2 ?

&  *  !

2 8"!
.$!"=   *  $"0 &#"1 7*"!* 7 &  !$#"2 & 2 ''&0 2 "$ *  8 "$) * =2 $

C

* 2 !"#"$ / $?1* !

2 8"!
.$!"=7 #* $'= ! 2 ?

&  *  > !."0 
.$!"=   *  $"0 &#"1  $ "# 8 "$) * =2 $

CB

6 *  > !."0 
.$!"=   *  $"0 &#"1 ''&0 2 *  & !88 $2 "$# * !

2 8"!
.$!"= $2' &8" 2"8'&0 8 $ $!  7*"!*7 # "$!=.2 2 "$ * .= # 8.!* = ##
=

"$* $"0 &#"1
&7 0 &6* # $2 * $"0 &#"1"#* *  ' ""$ & !

$$ ?  ' &8" 2  # / "8'&0 8 $ "$ *"# 8 &/#  553 !.&#  ? !

.#  *  * 2 '

## 2 . "$ *  1

< 7* & # *  '&0"#"$# "8'&0 8 $* 0 ? $8 2 7 

@ $ &2 &  ''& !"

  *  & #' !"0  !$ $"$#   = &$ 2 !.$# = &* '

&" #6"7.=2? & = 0 $& &
= &67*"!*& #.$2 &%

  ' &#$ 7* * # '

## 2 *  553 > "$   *"# $"0 &#"1 $2 "# 2 #"&.# "8'&0"$)*"#' & $! 67"== ?  ==7 2 # $ >#.2 $"$*  553 > "$ *&"!  "$ $  & 8&  * &1 '

' &E#F   & 0".#

< "$7"*"$ "0 1 &# *"#'

##"$)* 553 > "$(.!* !

$2"2   "$ *  "&# "$# $!  6 #* == ?  & A."& 2"$"8 ==* '

' &E#F"$7*"!* *  7.=2 ="/   "8'&0  *"#G* & $!    7"== * $ & "$ *  & #' !"0  '

' &E#F  *  & 0".#

#"8.= $ .#=1 "$ '&"=G3 1

"$ #.''= 8 $ &1 "$   *  2 # $ "8'&0  *"# $! * #* ==?  =")"?= 2#"$ *  ==7"$)1 &E#F7*"!*7.=2? &

# # !$2 !* $!  $ !

#  *  2 # $ "8'&0  *"# ' & $!  0 $ "$ # !$2 !* $! 6 *  7"== ?  )"0 $ *"&2 !* $!   "8'&0 *"#' & $! 

* & #.= #.!* !

$2"2  #* ==?  2 != & 2 $=1 "

*  "8'&0 # *"# $!  "$ *  ))& )     *  7*=  "$ ?1 /"$) "$ !!.$ *  &/# ?

"$ 2 ?1 *"8 "$ *  '

' &E#F "$ 7*"!* *  &  & 2 $2 *  8 &/# ?

"$ 2 ?1 *"8 &=" & "$ *  & 8 "$"$) '

' &E#F !7*"!* 0 & & *")* &* 

! *  *  !

$2"2   * # "8'&0 2 * 

C $!  #* == ?  8 $"$ 2 "$ *   "= 28 &/#
&2H &0"2 2 *  *  !

$2"2   7"== /  *  !!&2"$)  *  (1== ?.# "$

&!  & *  & ).= & #.2 $# "$ *

!

2 8"! # ##"$ "$ 7*"!* *  '&'# # 

/  *  > & *  '.&'#   "8'&0"$)*"#' & $!  5 &$ 2!.$# = &* ' ""$ &* ##.?8" 2* 
=

''=" #* ' ""$ &? !

.# "$=1 =/#  ' &"2    1 &#   *  '

##"$)   *  553 > "8'&0 8 $"$* 8 &/#"##.?8" 2* ""#$=1 2 !"#"$7*"!* * #? $ / $"$* 1

?.* .= 2 #$# 1 $17* & * " 7.=2 $ ''=1  *  #.2 $#6 7* * 2 '

## 2 *  553 > ?

& * .= !

8 "$? "$) $ *  * & * $26 = &$ 2 !.$# =

*  & #'$2 $#G$"0 &#"1* ##.?8" 2* * .= "#'&#' !"0 "$$ .& 

$2* #? $8 2  ''=17 

@"##.?8" 2* " 7.=2$ ''=1* !

#  * ' ""$ &7** =& 21'

## 2.*"# 553!.&# "$* 1

<  * 0  * &2 = &$ 2 !.$# = & *  '

&" # $2 ' &.# 2 * 

"= ?=  & !&2 7"* * "& ##"# $!  
= *  $"0 &#"1
&7*"!*& A."& #"$ &'& "$6$2"## !"$67.=2& #.$2 &%

  E"F
 ' &#$6 7** #'

## 2 553 > "$ *"# $"0 &#"1 "# 2 #"&.# & "8'&0"$) *"#G* & $! I E""F
"==?  ==7 2 # $ >#.2 $"$*  553 > "$I E"""F
*&"! "$$ &8& * &1'

' &E#F '& 0".#

= > "$#I E"0F
"*"$ "0  1 &#   *"# '

##"$)   *  553 "$ !!&2"$)* 

& # "2'&0"#"$6"7.=2 ''=1 ==#.!* >#.2 $# * 55367* & 2 #"&.# "8'&0"$)* "&' & $!   *  553 > "$ '

## 2 ?1 * 8 ?. 7.=2 ?  ==7 2 *&  !* $! # "$ $  & 8&  * &1 '

' &E#F   *  '& 0".# "$ 7*"!* * #  ?  7"*"$ "0  1 &#   *"#G* & '

##"$)   *  553 > "$   8 $# *  "

 #.2 $ * # '

## 2 *"#G* & 553 "$"$* 1

* $* G#* 7.=2$?  $"= 2G =")"?=  # / & $!  "$ *  "8'&0 8 $ > # $ >#.2 $ "$ * 

6

 & *  >'"&1  "0  1 &#   *"#G* & '

##"$)   *  553 "$   "# $7* &  8 $"$ 2 "$
=    *  $"0 &#"1
&* "7.=2 ''=1 #.2 $7** #'

## 2.*"#G* &553 "$* 1

?."7.=2$2 ?

$1 >#.2 $ 55367*# !

#  7.=2

==7"*"$ "0 1 &# *"#G* &'

##"$) * 553 * '.&'#  &"$)"$* "8'&0 8 $ > "$ * '& # $' ""$"#* & ?1 ==7 2 2"& !"$"#"##. 2  & #'$2 $    !$#"2 & *  & A. #   *  ' ""$ & & *"#

& $! "$* "8'&0 8 $ > "$ 553"$!

# * 7 $ 2

&"$'& 0".# =1 &  > "$ 553* $ ! ## &1

@ 2 !"#"$#* ==?  / $?1* $"0 &#"1"$*"#& ) &27"*"$ # 0 $2 1# &8* 2 & ! "' ! &"

" 2!'1 *"#&2 &  E-(-3F E-(-3F E-(-3F E-(-3F

    
 * * &#'

/"$)G& #$ 2 %

#G * * & '& ?=   %

#G