M/S Gagan Trading Co. And ANR v. State Of Punjab
!"
#$ %"&'('#)
*+*
+,
- .
* / / /
!"
# $$$$$ / /
0
* 1 2
%%
&
' (( )*+,,(-.-, % /
0/ 1#
((3,,4)(-.-, % /
1#% 2
- 5 6"! " " 6 0
(()*+,,(-.-, % %
0/
7
/ 8
"
%"0% ' 9 (7+4-.-, -).3-.-, " 71621 2 ,: ,4 77 ;" "
" ,*+4 %,.1)21
2 ;" "
% ,*:, % " -* ;" "
" ,*+41 < ()2 00
-7.4-.-,1 < ( 32 /
=
"
% 0
%%"8 "
0 )
" " .4.4-.-. ;" "
;" >%"6 6 #
" 0
%& >%& #912 #
"? 8 0
" % (
0
1 (( 3,,4)(-.-,2
&0% " "
( ?/
"
%
)@
!
>"
'-..:.,. 0"
=%/-.-. <
/ =-.-. 0" / 0 %
"! A >%
0%&
& 0% "636"6 3 9 &0% 0%& %/ ;" "
A / A
%/ ,7.4-.-. 0& "% 0 (
,).4-.-. " " %/ -3,@ " !
)..@ "/ %/ %& &" " -+.4-.-.& ! % (
/0
%/ ""/ ! "'-4*
-3.:-.-. !
&
"
" "
& & ! "
0
0/1#
(()*+,,(-.-,2 +
&" " .4.*-.-.%& %/ &
0/ % %/ &" "&0 %& "/ ! "
--.:-.-.!
&
"
" "
8 & "
0 0 %
"!A >% :
&" " ,,.*-.-.%& "/ %/ & 0"
"0/ 0 %
"!A >%
0"
"0/0 %/ 0 8 "
"% 9 " 0
(%/ "0%/ % ;" "
A / 5
!
" -)172
" -)1)2 ;" "
" ,*+4 ?&! 8 ( %/ & "% /
"% 9 " 0
4 9,4.*-.-. % (
% % " =
"
% ; % 0
6 ( %/ "0% 0 %;" "
A / 5
% " &%%& ,4,,-.-. " 0% ?/
"
%
1)..@ 2 & % ;" "
A / 5
!
% -),,-.-. % ;" "
A / 5
"% 0%0 ( ?&! & 0%" 73)@" !
)..@
*
" (%/ %;" "
A / 5
& %% "" "%
%& &" " &
% % ""
% (
&""%% 0 (
?&!
% = #
"
"% 12("0( %%
/ % % ""& / %
0% 6 0
%"6 % 0 & ?&! % & 0 %%
0 6 " "
0" / 0 %
"! A ,.
-).3-.-, ("0% % "0% " 71621 2 ,: ,4 77 ;" "
" ,*+4 % ,.1)21
2 ;" "
% ,*:, %
" -* ;" "
" ,*+4 % (
1 ((3,,4)(-.-,2
(
0/1 (()*+,,(-.-,2&%% 0"
"0/( 0 %
"!A ;& %% "0% %
"00
" ;" "
"/%% "6
" "
8 0" "00 " /0"
0 "/ "0% -).3-.-, "
< () ,, 9-7.4-.-, %&
"("" "0 00 "
% " 8 "/
0 00
-7.4-.-, "
< (3 ,-
0 "0% 1 < ()2 00
-7.4-.-, 1 < (32 %%8 "
0 8 /&/ 8 ,7
% "% " %/ %
" "
" "
0 0" /
& ! "
%% "6 36 0& % /
%
% "% % % % % % / / %/& 0" 0 %
"!A ;" 5 0(1#2 1 < (-2&% "% %/% %0%& 6/ "0% 0% "6 ? " !
& 0B
!
"# $# %&' # #( ) * '
% + )%, -' . ' / % + )%/$&
' $/% + )%" $&'0 + 1 2! !
23!' 3 )'
% + )% '4151 + !) '
% + )%$ ,'+ + ' % + )% $'
) 3 '
% + )%$$&6
' % + )%$ "&' & %
" " 7.172 ;" "
" ,*+4
/"% % % 0"
" / &
"
% % / %/ %/ & 0"
"0/
%%/
%% 0 %
"!A 0" "% !% " "
8
"%/
(
0/ %
0 "0/ &
',*4, '+ ' > % >
" 0 % ""
(
0/1 < (,2
"% "
" "
"%/ 0 0 %
"!A
0/
"% "
" "
"%/ 0/ 0 0" 8%
%
"% % % /
!
% %,.1)21
2 ;" "
% ,*:, %
" -* ;" "
" ,*+4 %% " "
0 %" "0/ &
',*4, '+ ' > % >
& 0" ( 00 %
"!A % ,)
% "%
! 0%/" "
"(
"" &%%(% /& % / %%
%'" 8
"0% 1 < ()2 00
-7.4-.-, 1 < (32&0 ? &! "" %
" ! % ,+.*-.-- % /
!
;" "
;" >%"6 6 #
" 0
! 0 0 0% / "0% &
0 % (
& 0 %
% "6 " ! 0
(
0/ & " ! 0 0 0" ( 0 %
"!A ,3 ; !
% "% % ,+ > "
&% !
" 7. ;" "
" ,*+4 0
" %& ( $ # 7!
!
+8 +8 )) 3!
5!#9
!
" # $
%
& &
'
$
%
%
( ,:
0 !
/
0 0 ;
!
"# $# %&' & %
( ) * *+ ,- ./". ,- !,
0 *,
/ , &
* 1 2 + * 345 67 - 899:
8;-/28<;2=*;79">27*?0@?20 <""7*92 "92<A9,?2-/-<@;923 BBC + ** * 1!' ++ .D @; * +
'C, 3 + '
+ '
E + '
7
? + + + '
7 3 + '
E ; * .
9
# @&* 8*3:"F*+ = ,G3!C 2 * 2 *
D1%45
"F= ,G3!C #
!
2 * 2 * )B%345 68*=
,G3*24+4+)H!)+!C #%345A6 = ,G3!C
2 * 2 * !HH 3> = ,G3 !C '
2 * 2 * ')1 H 7 + / + B 0 * + 'C '
7 ,
7 +
% % +
2 *3 68 = ,G3
BBD
2 * 2 * 'DB
C + + @ + , #I H *+ + .
# @ + * 7 0 "
' C !C 1 * < 0
45,6 *4 0 <0- !'H+ !'B5,,!
!C 1& '
# H!BI'' 7 B1H + @ &&2+ H @ * <0 45 *7, 0 4 '
# H!BI'' 7 B1H<0- !D +!DH5,, !
!C 1& + @ & & 2+ B
H @45, 6 *4 0 C) C! !C 1 @ J
!)K 9* 8 - 7= *60LCC' 45
*7, 0 3 * !H H5C 8 2 @ - 0 7 - *,/85 50?5#C)
C1 !C ) @ &&2+ C @ 45, 6 *4 0 & & 2+!C @ 45 *7 , 0 = / = >G C! C! !C 1C) C! !C 1 !
!C @ C! C! !C 1 C) C! !C 1&&2+!
&2+ !!&2+!' .
9
7 2+ 5, H * ,7+ + *45 *7, 0
- '* + *
9
7
7, 7- *,/85 50?5#C)
C1 !C ) F 7+
, @ , .. /,+ @ + *34568G 8 3 : 8*+ * **+ , @+ + < ,( ; ": # #( ) * '
% + )%, & & %
( C# 0 'C '
7
+ @ @ - D 'C '
7 H @ ''7 - 7 ,- - !
7 '' 7
- 7 ;3&* ,0 - 8!CC) 2*2 * @ - 7 B 7- 7* ;
, !C !
2*2 * !! M !C !
2&: 2 :
!!M!C '
**''C & * & /7 * 7
C !C !
2*2 * BD), / >
,G* '' /
7 7
* * - 1#C!
!D CB !C
'6
# H!B''7 B1H 2!# ) 7 2 B# 778 45
"F **:
4 7 * 0
( ; . '
/ % + )%/$&' & %
( D 0 - - !-
+- '- D - ' 7 &
7
!H ! !CC1 'C C !CC# C C) !C C @ & + D1H* , * ) @ G ;3 *4568G8+ * <"F BBC ** *+ 1!' @G M .@; * +
'C, 3 + '
+ '
E
+ '
7
? + + + '
7 3 + '
E ; * @ - .
1 D1H** F & & 7 !H ! !CC1
'C C !CC# C C) !C C !B7+ & # 7 +
+ (
; ' $/% + )%" $&' & %
( H ;+
@ + @ + @
B - 'H5C# !) D !CC# '
# H!B''7+ B1H 2!# ) 72
B# &,+
( ; ":0 + 1 2! !
23!' 3 )'
% + )% &
& %
( CB 0 8*2 6 ,G !C !
2*2
* !#' M *24 4+ '##D !CCB
) C !C CM+ .# " LL &,+' ; 7 7454 6 2G 2 @,/@@ 7 5
'C '
5 7
&,+' )CC @ )CK9*,8- @2 CCCC! 7 @
5 .
C 0 G 5*263
7 * - #B C! C' !CC# '
# H!B''7 B1H !# ) 7 2 B# 45 ,G6 **:4 6
( ; " :4151 + !)
'
% + )%$ ,& & %
( C:; " %5 0DD1 < (-2
"0%>"
% & 0%& "
& 0
%"6
%"6 & 6/ %
0 E 0%&
& & "%0'3
5 0FA 0% 0 0/"6 F % %/ 0% G % 6 / ;" "
;" 5 0(DD 1 < (72 &"% %/0 %0%
6 0 "0/"6 ;!
&
"0 &
"
"
"% 0% 8 & 6 / ;" "
;" 0
%"6 !/ 0" ;
>> H"1 2 <" &
%%%& % % !
( .D @; * +
'C, 3 + '
+ '
E + '
7
? + + + '
7 3 + '
E ; * @ - .
H 7 'C '
;
8 9 7 7 B1H ( ; ":+ + '
% + )% $& & %
( C) @ )CC - ! @
F & ,+' 77H)CC @ @ M45 :2 8 ,G
77!CCB 2* 2 * H'
@ # "LL&,+' ; 7745 4 6 2G 2 @,/ @@ 7
5 'C '
5 7 &,+' )CC @ , )CK9*,8- @2+CCCC! 7 @
5 H 7 @ .
,G 45 4 6 < &,+
/:4 , #
!CCH&,+! ( ; ) 3 ' % + )%$$' & %
( 1 @ @+ @ @
@ 7 &456 8G8 * <"F
BBC ** * 1!'45=* > 4 4 ,G !CC!
!
2*2
* )1 ,I;
/ I< ,G!CCH !
2*2 * !D 45,G8G 88I ,G 7 72!CCH
2*2 * BBH * ( ;B6 '
% + )%$ "&' & %
( ' 0&,+) "2''72 B# 323 - )
2&,+1 " 2!D2 7,1 +
D 0 + * < ; :/
,G @ <!' ) !CC) ) ; + 1 0 4568G 8 * <"F BBC
% **
E ,DM+ . 7
? + + + '
7 3 + + '
+ .
# @G *F 45
8 ,G!CCD !
2*2 *+ '11 ,I;
+ 'C '
7 B1H 5 H 245 ,I "F ,G!CC) !
2*2 * BDCM !CC)* 0 : !HD'
'C '
@454 ,+ "F ,G!CC1
2*2 * D11 ,I;
>G ,G!CCH !
2*2 * !D ,I;
/ I < ,G !CCH !
2*2 * !D
,I;
246I< ,+ G!CCH !
2*2 * B'C ,I;
B 0 ( ,4 % 0 0&% & & ;" "
;"
& 0% " "
0
%"6 % / 0"
& % % 0& 0 0% 6
% "% % % % /"%
%/ !6&!&
% " " "
&0 ( 0 " ! /
% "
( & % % 0"
% &% %% 0
% "
,* ;!
& 0
" 0% "
& 0
%"6 %
% /
& " ! % "
0 0" !% "" % (
0% 6 0%
" " " "
"0% 1 < ()2 00
-7.4-.-,1 ( < (32&%
" -. ;0/% %! %% %% !
% %,.1)21
2 ;" "
% ,*:,(
% " -* ;" "
" ,*+4" " 0 % ""
0/1
2 " "
"% "
"%/ &
" % "(
"
0 "% 0 0&% %/ 0"
%
% -,
; 0
"0% 1 < ()2 00
-7.4-.-, 1 < (32 %%8 "
0
8 8 %/ --
""
%/ / /
0
6 6
I' %
I'