Commissioner Of Income Tax Faridabad v. M/S Ram Gopal And Sons




   
 


 !"!#$%$&'() *!++$%%$&!,
&#+!-. ,$"/"

0011!22&

3% +12 4&% 0 !%1&"!&  ' 56

 4
7


6  56

 4
   

 



      

   

  

  

     !"  #$

 %&'





 "$ ( %&'





  897:+, $ 2.
  

 



    '  



)

*+&

,  -&%
.*
/  %0&12   3*+
%&-&,,,

,  -&

    (  454%  6    /    %  0  12    , & +7897++. 

    

    ++:;+*%    

 

  <

!;

2      

 % = 4, &      



%+>%:37;&

  

 



  



4     

  ++
;+%      

      

   &



2      

 % = 4, &      


+%.@%:@7;  

  

' 

   

  

 

2      

 % = 4, &      


3%:.%>3
7;        &

  ?

      



  

>+/2/ 2

,  -&%
.*
  

- <     


3%:.%>3
7; 


.>A 

4  

- 

5  
:;,   '

1

 &     ' 

    

 

     ' 

'

'  

 &

  &

  


*%
:%*.% ++7;)


>

/ 2

&'

 *
++@%&-&
  

 

!;

2 &



%+>%:37;  

 

2&

 


+%.@%:@7;      

  



B

 


3%:.%>3
7; 

>+/2/ 2B



  


 %@
%+37;
@%*.%
+37;

 

C    



 

  &

  ?

  

  

    

 5 '

D"7 # "E) %5 "7 , 



& A%5    

F
:F 

 ' &









     -   &

 ?

     

 

       




 




:F  



 %  -  

 %&



  



%+>%:37;C 




:F



 '



 

  -  



%>+%
*7;    ?

% A, /&2 



  

4  



++
;+  



 '





 

 



%+>%:37;  ' 

 

         

     

    

4  

 %





' 

&

   

    


+%.@%:@7;  



 &

    

3+%..:C      

    @
.F 

   

  ,  '

 

  

  



%&

   



C'



  '



'




>:/ 2

&

 



@F

 %&



  

 
+%.@%:@7;  

 @
.F6  

%

 



 A, /&2G  >

++3%&-&,,%A, /&2 

   



 








..:;.*  

A, /&2

 

   


3%:.%>3
7; 

>+ /2/ 2

& 

  


.%>
%.37;   4     4  ? 

    -  %    

    

 -


:+%+++7;  
3%:.%>3
7; 

 

&







  

-

 


.>A

& 

    )     

    '5 6 
:;,  &

  ' 5   

         

       %

'



'




.>A

&

  '





'

)

>+/2/ 2

& A, /&2


3%:.%>3
7;     

  < 

-

 '



A 6 @
:33
..:  







'= 

 ' > 9  

  <

6 /

 '



A .@+
: , &6 
:

+
> 
 

      

 '





 '%  

  !;



<



  

    <

 

 





        :+       &

 ?

 

 '

   

 



   '







 '

  C           - 

       

          

    <

-     

      

 ,

  ;

 



 

  



 <



 

   





 

A, /&2



 '   1       ! "#  #   $    $%&  '() !
   

 

      

 



* +"

0:   <





  

 <

 

       , 

    <

 

   &



 

4   '



4     



 A, /&2

% 

%

      

  C%  % 

% 

  %     '

   &

 ?

 

 



  

 

    



               

 

    '  *   <



  

  '





1

 ,    
-( - ."

#%& /

 

*0

     1*% 0 ( '   '
      !* &!2 34%# ! $    1 


." *1 #  !&#4 *!

5' ) -- ((
 *  +"

6  #!&#  ! # #   ! 1%& #   ! * &!  34%#!  $   1
 

." *1  # !&#  %%&  5' ) -- ((*  

* *+ 7(+
  !&#! 34%%!$  !&#  $ 34#%

*+#

& 34%%!   !#5   ! &! 

 !  !  &  34*

  %  !      

 34          !   &*

%  !!  90
   /

  34 %$
 

."  * 1   *  %:! &! # !!!!   /

 % &

) # *   * & ! ;% !&#1 
 

."     *    #!

              !&#*#!<   

* 
 $ 

& %#    4*  #    

 &  %    %&       4    %$     5=' )  -- ((  #  !!

;    

*#%& /!# * &  $4     $  !!

> 

* 
-( - ." ?

)  % *  !    %& '


  +"

6 /# 

*90*#! !$  ( ' # !&#*  * 1   
 

."    !      

*    !+"

 0 5%@ .:#; 
 )--."

 0 !4;.0 5 @ 
(- ."

 0 4#@ .0 :#4#
  )."


-( - ."

 /1#A# "
  !   1*%  !&# 
-( - ." ( '*               >    #     %$ 

*

 5        '
    *  %#           #  !&#          ! # #   ! 1%& #   ! * &!  34%#!

-  $   1
 

." *1  # !&#
*  %#    %%& 5' )  -- ((*  

**+"

7(+
  !&#!   34  %      %  !    $    !&# $ 34#%

*+#

& 34%%!   !#5   ! &! 

! !& 34*

% !      

 34          !   &*

%  !!  90
   /  34%$
 

."

  * 1    *  %:!& !# !!

!
*  %#  / %  &# *    *  & !       ;  %     !&# 1
 

." *#!

     !&#*#! )' %$  '
     

#  *;      5' ) -- ((>     

*#%& /!# *   &         $  >    

* 
-( - ."  - %$ 4$!! %   (, $  $       #  !    !     !  ,   %   &      %#        A # 5' )  #

(    B #*  & #&    '
   &*!   #?

- @        !!

"$  *    %    #  !!   %& '
  *

 % *   

 !$ &#* %& '' &$*

 %$ !! #