Commissioner Of Income Tax Faridabad v. M/S Motorola Solutions India Pvt Ltd
































 





 



 

  

















































   !

#$
# 
% "

 
&'
(



) 

   
 !"
#

 
    
  $
 & #* 
+, - ' 

-
   #.



-"
%

-
'  
#

- 
//0 
' 

-
    %&'(%)%*+% -
 
 

2
-
)' "
- 
"

% 
3

-
 


3
4
-
-
5 56
/


-
 
3


2
-
 

 


 
7 /  7 -
5 5
7 / 

4&6
89:$7 8;$<

3

-


2
=: -
)' "
-
 
-
 0

/
>"

0
 

 2
-

"
         

              

 !    !"

#         ! !  "         !          !     #          ! !  "       $    "$$ 

%! #  !"   !"

   " &'

"



-
 =


-0'
-



 

2
 * 

-
*"


-

"

-
/"


-
-


-


2
-




7 / 
 
-
-



 0- -
0



93
0
# 
 
?  

&'
(

-  2
-
-

@ 0
# 
% "

 
&'
( 0- -
-



-



 

4 6=! 7 / 
0- -
-

 2
 0

-


-


-




7 / 

-
 2

-
 
/
0 - # 
 
&'
(
 
-

- /

# 
% "

 
&'
(
-
 
-



-



-



-



3
0- -


* 


-  /



/ 2

0

 
-
-

"
0" 
-'

*"



) 
0
  
"


 '

7 -
*"/ 

-

"

 

       



  
-
-

"


-

/
A 
4
-
-
5 A56
-



-
.

/-
"
0- - 




" -

A 
0" 

-
*"

.

/-
"
-
 2
"



-
)' "
-
  
 
"  '

7 -
*"/ 

-
 -
.

/-
"

 



   ! "  

$

0- -
 
-
*"/ 

,-*%
&'+%,'
4 "6
0 
@




 







 

/ 2

-

"
0" 
-'
*"


-

 2
-
/
0 -
# 
% "

 
&'
(
0- -
-



;"/ 



  
-
 2
 "



-
 
-
-


-



7 / 
0" 



 ' 
 


-

A
- 0

- /
 
-
-

"


-



0" 




/
 


-

/
"



-
 
0


-
'

0
-
- /" 


2
-
)' "





 
-
 * 



.

-
 =






"- 

 '

-
 


,-*%
&'+%,'
4 "6
-
0








"


% 
9 
-

0- 2
-
 
0




7 / 

;"/ -
*"


-
 =


0




-

"


0

- 
-
-



" 

@
' /

-





"


-

A
0" 
/ '
-
.

/-
"
-




A-0



0"  




'

'


0
 
0 2
-
.

/-
"  

-
 ' 


'



"

"  ( #   "

     "           !  "       "   #   $ !    )  " 

  "



 "$ "    !)  "  *

""   ( #  

 #"  

( #      !  "    !

)  "  *"

  "  " !  # $

! ! ""

$( #      !)  "   +   !   "     " "$( #       !)  " 

    #,  "      

!" !  

!  "$

 "- $$

.)  "  /! ( #  ."

 #  !"  . $ *    $

"!  

!

! ""

$)  "  !( #  - $*,  

  "

#/  -   "

) )  "    !  " 0    " 1 2  " ( #   - $

/! *  !#

      "  

#      /!  ( #   *

 "

#!$     !"      !  $  )   "  $ ! "

! 0 "    !*   

  )

  "

#        "  

   .   "       /    3 !                 

"   $        #,  "

   $   , *    !  "!       "         

 "    #,  "

 /  3 !           ,   

 "

 /  3 !         *  "   "  %% ! )  "  

 #,  +  " "!  #

#    !)  "   ! ( #  !$ 1 4 "!

   " * #   "  !!$"

    

 

)*  

! "  "$ 

# !  $ )   

   !)  " 

   "  "  $     #  ,     - #!

*

 "

#!$!  "  !!       !

#                )  " 

 "  ! *'

-

'

0
0
 0

   /    


  
 

  
     

  


0-


-


5
 
-



 
80
 -

 
  
- /-
"


% 
9

-


- 

 5

0 "/-


-  /

-


 
-

" " 
-





-
 
"

*"


@

'

0
-
 



-

"


/
  

-  '

7 -

-

"
  '

-
/"


0- -



/


-
)' "

-
- /
0 -
-
 =  2



-'
@
  

: A5

0


93


% 
9

-

-  







  

-



-
'

"

2
 2

0- -
-
" 

@
  
"
-


" 

" 







  

-



-
'

"

2

-



" 



) ' 


"

1      "*

45*   $ $    

       #"  "   "" $ $ 

         "             $      6 
" !!"   

$   

.!  "

    !!"    

$"   *'


-




7 / 
0

# 
 
?  

(

93

-



2
=:
-

>" 
/ 0" 

/ '
 /-

-


/
"-
0-
-
*"

'
-

" 


 2
 
 2
-
A

-
 


 2
0" 
-' *"


0- -
0 
  2

7 / 

-

-
-


-


"

-
 

>" 
 2
- )' "
0" 
/ '
-
A

-
" 


 2
*"





-"




 

'

0

-
'


% 
9

-

 



/ 2
-
 
 










2
- 

/
-
-

"
- 



*" 
"
-

'




2
-
A

7 / 



>"  2
-


" 

-
)' "




-
 
"

*"

  
0 -
0

1 !%2+ '%-3 1  %&'(%)%*+%3  4,+&5(+6 78,+46 7'56 









 8%+*68(