← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/226/2014disposed of

Commissioner Of Income Tax Sec-14 Hisar v. Dhbvnl Hisar

2018-10-09Mr. Justice Ajay Kumar Mittal,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan7 pages

    

  !"  "#$%$&' (



)       *"+%,%       !   "! #"$% # & '$"()*

'(+,)$"$

 ()-'

# & '$"()*

'

''*(

- ()-'

. % $ +./* *! /

  $ , -* !0 1 $ )-!0 

  ! *- ./

 0/ ! /! * 345

  67468  9 0& &:  ! !!

65533563            9/       &&

18   & 9/&:!

;4548:3566   00!355<=57 3 >1/9?/ 109 !  % +,&0

$@  ! /  

&9

1 1/!  !  !

8:"1 9!! !9# /  

/!!/    /  "6AB7C<55A;D=    

/  

!!    99 /     !  9  !!         !



/          /!             9  1       

/E $$ @  ! !9&9

 /9 1   ! !

9&9

      3554=355C !9 !

99 

9  &9./ 9 ! / E +,&0 $ @  ! / 

 &9

1 1/!    !      !  

8:  "  1 9   !1 /D;58:8:!9#

/

=!!/             

1D    "3;6AAB3<BAD= $D .

 !9!!E $$   @     !  9/     !  !

  /!/  0   1 3 786:

80:    ! &&   0 &&9 /    1 !  &&/&&    0        

   /E $$$  @  ! /  

 !

1 1!     !  9           

 D1F*   1 9

 !!/  / /!  67;( 

 E #5465356;  1/!?/?/  8:8:/! - /! 3G/ 8:!8:/! - /! 6 1 1 ! 0/01 !  / 

3A< 356;! !!3A57356;G/ 8:!8:/!

1 - /! 61 !0    !!9 0 !9

3A<

356;   !/ !9 /   !

?/1  0 !9!  / 

357 356;

!       

   ! ! !!665356; B

/?/ 8:8:/! - /! 39 

    !

/!    0 00!9 !

 !=$D      !  /!  67A4!! 9/ 1  *   /     $D .1 -    !. /8.- :!! 9/  /      /    /  ! / 1   

!/.    !8 .

:   / !/

      !  9   '    "/  8'": /   / ! .-  ! /   ! 9/       .

  "!            .

  !9'"  !/ ! &&   0 &&!   1 * 786:80:  !/ !/9/! !!/ /   .



/     !&1  &!* !     8* :

 !

  /!0!!/ ! *1  !* !9 .

* !!!/ ! * ! 9 .

#

 ! ! !!3B633565H!= 1 !9 !  1!*   

!     .

        355<=57   0!      !  ! !9   

8:I

8:J ! ! !!665<3566 11! ;

 0/! !  

8:9   9/ 

9/0! ! !!65533563 1   !       3554=5C355<=57 !  /!  (/    9/  

           

  63C    6B6D(.D3557 !!

B55;3557!! 1! 19

 !!!/ /  D1  !

*   /! * 67;=(    9  0/ A  !  /      0/  /9!    !  ?/9! !!9/ 

4A3 3565! !! 5<5A356;  !

 !  1 / 1  !  !     1  !!  9         #

  !   9 0 */ / 

 / "23$*% 3 +!$"22,2 +.$4$!"083566:BB5

"3B7  0   !   !91%    

      



    

 

             

      

       

 



     !





     " !

  

  #



$  % #"   

  

 

   

5 &           



  

 

  &  '

   

    (         )*'+   

 

'

   

& ( 

   ,- ) !+      )*'+

'

  

  

 



&

            

  





 

    

*   

  # $ 



 

( 

        

  .  /        

      

 

  

# $

       # $                   

        

 

0#  $     

    #

 $.

1 





     

  



1

   

     

   



     

  2"

   



( 



3

'

4 

( 

     ,-) !+   )*'+

 

 

  

 

  # 

$ 

 3

'

4*

4567 



 #   

 

$   

  3

'

4









     

   

 

  

  #$    *

4567 "  

 & 1     



  

  "  

  5(  

 



 

 1  89



    

     

  



   &  !("(

    "  :     

     

   

   ;

   

 

     

  

  

            

  

    (   !



   ,



!

 

 

 

    

 8"&*9 4< 

  



 8"&*9

   

 

    &     



   

  *   89        





  

9 



          !

+  

 3

'

4  

              



$ 2  "              !

  



 

 4567  









 

 

  



 "   !



            



 

 





   







 

    







" !



   

   



   

    (           



      



    





  5   

      

                 

   



    

6   !





       

  

  /    

    

=



*

><4849 ><4849 /

 ><4>   

       *

"       7 )  

   

      

   

        

  



       

  

    

 

    

       

 

    ?  !



 

    

                       1

 *+&!  "        

   

("'

?@> ><4<  " 

  

 "     







  7.     *- 

(



)     @ D !

+D @ " 9% +D