Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd v. Ankur Saluja & ORS





   
  

      !

"#$%&'( ((($$

'

) *  +#' ((( '



 

   *  +#' ((($$

'

)  $ ,#' ((( '

 !"#$"%&'&#()* *

 )  +,

* -
*-*  -

'.

(+

/#% 0/#!'

1#'

'

  1#' '2#(  

*

(3*0/#!'

1#'

'  

 1# '2#(04  *

(#$ '' 0/#!'

1# '2#(    1# '2#(5  

* *-* .* ( 3%'# 0 

$# #1'7#
( (   1

#8  1#1  !

"#$%&'(



 

1

#8  1#1' '07!/  # '#1 '  7( ( 3 %''

01!'#1' !  ''# ((0 '*  +, 8# '%  #,7'# ,'

2/ +, 8# '% 0'(9 +071 2  +

02   /'

7 '/

, !!8 , ,''#  2#(-3:55  !#,  1#  :      ,#, '#7& /(;(#<' !78 ,/ 8%!

'

*   +< 7  '   !  !   1#' #1 "/ =#$' :    '  '  7  8# '  5.  $((0  '     ' !*  8 , ,''#2#(-3>:5,#,1#'#1' !  % #7<!

'*  + #$$ 8*  ' $

#1 ' !<'  7

0' !*8 , ,''#2#(= "4 ! 1#8 8 ,/ 8% '2#(/,' %,$

 ' 7'# '$$ %, 8* '' !1#8 <

''

%' ! ,'' !* , ,''#2#(-3>:5,#, <''

#11!'

' !77! 8 '7

'7#' !*<

' #!! $'#1'

! 11 , /# +  <2  +71 #1!

'*  + #' #1!

'2/ + '' $#'07 ' #' +  7 '* '##$' <' !! '77'

8%# +  : (
2#(#11#' #11    !'# 0 0 0  -"7' ,'#' !! '7 ,'

'

-# !

''#"'%0:(

 ( - ''# ?!

'*  +2/ + 8# ,'!

$ ''#   !'#55#1' #'#) !

!'0 ,' '( (  $ ,@#7 0/,@ /   !

"#$%&'(  #1' !* ,   ,''#  2#(= "4    7

   &   3#''

, "#$%0& @#7 0',@/ 9'

 

 !

"#$%&'(  #1' !*8 , ,''#2#(-3 >:58 1# #'#!! '"

;8  0&   1'

 '#'

0!

,!#$ '#'#' '  #1(54

* #,7''

'!#'( (   , '',  #'!

0  

 '  A   '  $$  (  '2#(1

+#'7''

''

 ',/#

, #8+ !'## ' %,'' '2#(7,  '%#1 % '/,#1' ' !*0' !!#,'#'  #' !*8 , ,''#2#(-3>:57,#,#(;( # "/ =#$' 0:'#7& 1#

8% ! !   8 ,   ,''#  2#(-3:55 <  '  /   #1  ''  ' !*   %$$ 8*  !!'' ' !*<' $ $$ #1 ' !*8 , ,''#2#(= "48 '8* 1



' '   ' !* ' !*  ,' ' !  !    ' !*  8 , ,''#2#(-3>:5( '7!'#1#' 7 , '!# #'8  8

'#$%!#$ '#(

7''

''

 '1

8% '2#(0' #  /# 

, #8+ !'#0# ' %,''%!! ' '* $ !

7'' !*8 , ,''#2#(= "4'',''

 ' !! ','/ 8

! 8%# #' / !

0#7  ! ' !! '$#/ '   '/ '* $ !

 '##

#!#'8 '#% #1' / #1' / !

7! ' +  7'',#' / !

/# ' !! '<'

8 '%#17 , '!# #'8 1A  

'7$#/ ''  /   #1  '  / !

     !

 7  # ,    /   

!'/ /, !

'' ' #1

!! ' #,7'/  "0# '

$ '1' '1!'

'!(  ' 2#(   4  1

  $'

 7''

  ''

 '

'*,$

%#8+ !'#'' '2#(4',/, ' !*   8 ,   ,''#  2#(-3>:5  7   '     # '' ' !*8

/# # %'#, '!#$ '#( ! ' #!/ 1# #1' $ ''#(  '  2#(5   !

 !#$%  #1   ' !*   8 , ,''#2#(-3>:5' $'

7''

''

 '1

8% ' #  ' 8 '%'#$%!#$ '#0$%,1# #1 ' $ ''#( 4(

# '7 1 ' $' 7 11#  B '

#$$#' ' '#

 /  $$#'#1'  $ !'/

( 5( 1'

   ,  ,  '0  '  ;8   /  7  '

4((  

  '  !

  $ ''#  $'

%    !#$ '#  #1 (0504?7''

'C D$  1#' '

#1'  $ ''#'

!'  E'#77 '#' '0$%8

8% '2#('#+#'

%

%(F # 8 '%'#$%

4 !#$ '#71'

 $#' #'  '( ( ; '?$ ''# ' $ ''#8 ,'1 7'  '  B '   #1  !#$ '#  7   '#  '      !

!#$%8 , #,, 8%' 7/ 1

 $'

1# '"# '( ( 2#'!

 #1  '  $$   7     '#  '   $ !'/

'07#$ '$$ !

'# ,!# 

( (

/  

 !# 

1#' $' 8  ,#, '# ,' !#( ( &  !# 

1#'

'@ !

!#$% !#'

 '''7! #1!#'8 '#%  !/ #1

' '

/ !

/# ' !! '7 $#8

1# $$ ,#1' !! '8 ! 1/ #1' !*8 , ,''# 2#(-3>:5,#, #1' 

1'

!#'$$ '

8*   %0' !! ','/ 8

/# <  %1 '*  +/,' 

1'

 !!* $'1

'!

1#' ' !*,#, 1 ' # 1' / #1' !* ,   ,''#  2#(= "4     #  '     1

'!

8 '7

' !* !!,#, 0' !! ','

#'/  '*  $ !

0' 1# 0 

 ' / #1' '

/ !

/#  ' !! '  '   ' 8  1#$$ ,#1'

!! ''#'$#$ '#1'' ' 8  #/ #1' !* , ,''#2#(= "48

# 8%'

' $#!

# %' / 0#7  !

!#$%#1'

  ' !*  /  8

  

  '#  8 8

 '#  $%  !#$ '#  '#  '

5 '( ( F 0

 !# 

,1#' '/

!#'

'

'

!#'

'#'',''' ,'

%,/

!'  ''   '  2#(  /  ,  7   $#8

 1#  '

!! '1#7'#1! ! '##$'( ( 1'

  !# ,  '  /  !#'

'#    $  ,  '

!#0 1''' 71

%+ '1  !, 2#( 1/# #1' ',' '2#('#(3#'' %  7'

#1' !! '0

%0 -F+ : !

'

*  +$$ ,-F' 11/'/  $# $ '

! #1' '' $ ''#("# $

7'''' 1!'

''
GA(-F?7' ,'#' !! '8

 #, ,'

' 2#((  ; 1# 0   ' 2#(  7  ,'

% 

  '# 8

$#8

 1#   $$ ,  #1  '  !! '(  ;  / #  '  $  8% '2#(''' !! ''* $ !

#!!# '#1   $$ %,#18* 8%' / #1' !* 8 , ,''# 2#(-3>:57#'1# '#8 8

/8

7 + !'

(
#' 1!'!! '!

#1' !  / / 8

# !#0#1 !8 7'''7! #1!#'8 '#% #''*  +/ #1

1'

!#', / #1' !*8 , ,''#2#(-3>:57  #'1 '

$$ ,#1' !! '(; 1# 0',  '#1

 !# 

1#'

'@ !

!#$% + !'

( ( F' ,'#' #'  8# 8%

 !# 

1#'

'@ !

!#$%''!# ,' , #1'

  '#8 % 0' 1

 #,4D'#7 1 '  $#$ !'1'

 ,' !# #1 (04?$ #'( ( ;' 8# 8%

 !# 

1#'

'@  !

!#$%

'#/  '( / 7#1+ , '
 



 

   

 !"

## $"

%7  78

#7, #1% 0D#1 '  # ' '#8   '#7 1 '   $#$ !'( >#, '' '

#' %  !#  #1  '       '*     (  4  H  44  I (0 4?( 4( ;  ;8   ,'

%   !'

 ?  #1 '  #' %

,#1'  '#7 $ #  /, A$ (>#, '''  $  !%#1!

'!# # ''#(4 0 454 ? $   #'0      $  !%  !#   # '  '#  (  4  A    I (0 0?( 5( ;   '$ #1 07!*

$, / 7' , #1'  8

$#$ % (>#,'''

!#$ '#$%8

!# # ''#(0 0A I00?(  ( ; 7    #1(40?'#7 1  A$ 0( *'#7!##' #1 80(40? '#7 #/ 11 !'#'#!

'2#((0'#7 # #1 ''

( ( =#7 0'

, $#'#'' ,8

!

1 + , '8%' $ A"# '( (&'( 





 


 # 

#) 

* !"## $"+++0

 7 '7#8 / ''# '#1(0? !'#8 7 '# %!

'1#1  !##' / 7#1+ , '
 



     

           "0 7!$#/ ''7

7#*,# '' !#$ '#$%8

  ' !#/ '#  0

%0 ##1 ''

0 ##1!##'  1  A$ 0  # '  #1  (400  (0?    (40?0 $ !'/

%# 8 7 ( >#,  ''  '  !#$ '#  !#   # '  '#  8

(500 00HHH4H4 ( ( ;  ;8     7#, %  7   !#$ '#  #1 (0504?(;    !

'#(500?( ; '

7# 8 ''

'#, ''

'C (4D$  1#' '

#11 , #1' $ ''#'

!'  E'#( ' '

!#'# ,,$$#'# '' #, 7

'  (;

 #1' '

8  !

$#$#'#'

%( ( F' !#1!'#0
 1

#8  1#1

 !

"#$%

$'

%7'!#'( (

1' # '#1!#$ '# %8

$8%'

 !

!#$%0' '

1 ' A!

# ' / '#'  !

"#$%#' 7 '  !

"#$%

8

''

'# !#/ ' 11 # '1#' '$  7 8%7%#11 , ! '#$$ !'#8 1# ' ( (  ,' 
 1

#8  1' '

*,  !

 '  #1  !#$ '#0   1  ''  '  !#$ '# 7 # #'!

1#%! 0' ' 8

 # 7' 8 7'' ',',!#$ '#/ #1! #8#/ 0'  8

  !

("# '

%0
  1

#8  1#1'

'?!

'' ( !

 ' 
  '  

  $'

%  7' #1!'# 
 ' 0' !

 # $$ !'#

0  1  %0  $ ,    '  $$   '  $#   #1 !!#, %( (( *-*  3+   /0"!0"11" '#("23'4" 5&(6 ) "'3# /0"!0"11"4#1! 78"

) "'3#