High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/271/2014allowed

M/S Punjab Institute Of Medical Sciences, Garha Road , Jalandhar v. Commissioner Of Income Tax Jalandhar And ANR

2024-12-04Mr. Justice Sanjeev Prakash Sharma,Mr. Justice Sanjay Vashisth32 pages

I TA No. 271 of 2014 -1-

#. /00) 1 /0)0)

!"" -

$ #"

(

" ' !"" -

) #"

(

" ' !"" -

* #" !

(

" ' !"" -

+ #"

(

" ' !"" -

, #" ""

!"" -

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -22 # "

%& " ' ( !"" -

#" 3 #"

%& " ' ( !"" -

#" 0 ##"

$%$&'$()

%& " ' ( !"" -

#" "

$%$&'$()

%& " ' ( !"" -

#" * +,

--.

/--

--.-- / !4 !. 5 !. ! - ( #.

!""

!7*+) 0,8)2+0083+3,338 000$ . 9 #. 6

!7,,)0)$$0 . 9 ! :

% ; <9' !"" 9!

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -3- 0)( . 9

( $0$"

!"" !

5 !

% ;

' "" (

!7*0)!003

!7 **!003 9 00+<00, 9! #. ".9 . 6 6 6 (

!3+%;!=' "" 9 ( 0"

(

!7)+02 9 0*<0+ " (

%!' ( " ! 11$02%32$(4567$ $'$)8$ ! #. 0+03 "

( "" (

!7)+$!0) 9 00+<00, " " 9 "

9 " 9. 9!> 0+03"

!7)+$!0, 9#. ( 0+03"

6 (

!7)+*!0, 9

9 00+<00,.6" 9.

9!> 9

%!'6 # "9#"9##"0)( " (

$00$"

9 00<003<000,<002 002< 003".9.6 6 ( ( !

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -4-

#. 3030* "

! 7 ,)0!0$ . 6 "6 ( 9 00)<00*6 6

#. 20$0+ "

!7)2*!0) 9 0< 0.6 6 ( " ! 5 ( 4

!7*0, ""

='. )00$ "6 !! %$'

! 3+ % ; !=' ( ( <9 ! ! ( 6 64 (

66 ( 6 6 00)<00* $

<9 "" ( ( ( ( !! . 00*33)6 0+0)33)

96/ % '

(

8 % ' "

( 6 9

. ( .

64 (

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -5-

4 6( ( ? 9"

%! > 003' )

"" " 9 <

9 33$ 9 @. A 6 ( 9 @.

9 ( +*

!( B .9 A

<9 @. ( 6 9 ! 1 6 "" 9 @. 9 6 ( 33) @. ( $ 9 33)<3* 33+ !6

"" ""

" 33, C =

* 00D 9 " E. F "

6 . $0332,* 6 . 0*0*000 ,*

0$$6 . 00$00+ 33,+,,, 6 " 9 9 $

( C" " 6 ""

9 ( ( 6 333

" 20 6 "". ! 000 " 6 " "

" 6 ( ( > 0 .

((."

66 " 9 9 *

!(B .9 *

9 00AH 6

( 6 E 900 ". " 6

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -6- " @. & " 9 9! "

( 6 6 @. B1! 9 1 (00$<00). 646 4 " 00*<00+ 9 " @. ( 59 " ".

" " (

( (

6 9 . !(003

$0$00+ 26. 9 9$0$00+6. " "$0$00+6 *66. 00+< 00,2*0,0 . I ( +

0)0+0$ 9 4 ."@. C" B . ( "

( " 6 6 0)0+00 #E 6 ""

90026 ." 0

7# ! 6

" 6 9

9 . (" $00

*D 2 9 ""

" ( 6 ( 9 "

202003 , !"

(

? ( ("6 ( 6

6 6 00+006 9 < %$'6 !!! ".

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -7- 4 9 "". C . (

!7*0, (

!7,)0!0$6 6" 6

9 "

-84:3%%3)%67$ $'$)8$ 2 A "" (#.

(. 9 ( 9

"( )00$ ( ( ""

6 00)<00* ( ".9 C

( 1 C( " 9

! " #$% $ &!%0'$$3

#+%1'6 6 "

"6 !!%$'!

6 " $00+003 6

6 " 6 00+00

( . " 6"

)00$

(

6 00+00 "66 .

6 (9 "6 3 A .6 " 9 5

9 C( $'% $" %& ( ! #!!) #"%0'$)$

#$%5

9 !!%$'! E !00 "

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -8- !! 4 ( 9 . ( ".9

( ". "6 (

( 6 6 ( "6 6

9 !A (

" 6 . ( -84:3%%3)67$%%$%%$$3) 0 "" ( !< 9

"6 !!%$'! " 9 6 00+00

".9 00)<00* C

9 00)<00* "6 ( .

. .

6 ( C

9 @. 96

.9". (( I 6 6 ;

64=

!7, ,)0) A

(9 0033)$0$00+ ? 9 (

"< (

6 9( ! ! 9 4 ( " 6 ? (. #.

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -9- 6 . 9 .9 ""

" 0033)$0$00+

(6 ( "" ( 9

.9 ". "C

$0002 "

9 ! ( > 6 ( " !6 69 C

#. 4 " "

( 6 @. B1!! 9 9@. "

. ( 4 ""( ( " 6 (9 6 " $ A

$0$6 9 "" 6

"" #. 6 ". ? 8 "" !. 6 #. .

) A ! 4

. 966

> 003

6 ( ! 6 " * G .

3%;8%%3) + %*'!

"" 6 ;

""= ;( . (= . (

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -10-

9A (5 " !!!#!! ! ! $%*% +* " &$( 0 %,' !A& +)2 69 6 " 9( ".

. % (6 6' ".

( " 9 ". ( ". 6 00)0+ 9 6 . /< ! ,

! %%

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -11- !!!%$' !!%)'! ? 9 /< &!!!&!*&! &' (

)

' & *

)

' +$

' ,

)

)' ) -

./0

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -12-

2" 0

./0 3

4 5-

6 , ) 4

7-#%!

"*"(!!..%.,/ ., *

3 1

8 9:) $

&((!

3 1

$ # ;

( <9 99 ;

''''/'99'

( &: 999 ;

. ''' '='999'

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -13- 1

( <9 99 ;

''' '/'99' 3

8&//:#

8&//:

3 1

&((#

&((

, -'&( 99= )) 99= 2

3 1

&((#

, -'&( 99=)) 99=

&((

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -14-

@ 6 $

( 1 3

( &/&/ ). &/&/

(

&/&#

&(A

$ $ $ #

&(A

$ $

(

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -15- A

&)1

;

&(A

(

& $ $

&..

<<(A

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -16- & B

8&//:

!% J< &;$(8&$&&$=3%6&063)>

)' B

, -'&( 99=))99= 2

3 1

' < B

)

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -17-

, -' & ( 99= )) 99= 2

& $

3 1

! %%

' -

(

&/&'% ,

9 @.

9 6 6 "" . 9

"" . ( ( " 9

4 ( 9 ( ( !E " ""

6 69

""4 96

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -18- ( ! ! " !!%$' ! 6 6 . E ! 00) 6 0000) 6 ( ( !!

E ! 33+ ? 9 "6

( "

. ( ( 6

( ""6 ". 9 E ! 00 6 00+00

6 "6 6 000) ( 2 C = " 0! 1 *" %&" ( ! $ #$ #!! . % $0 %*' $06

( "". 0%$' %.' ! 6 9 6 ;9= 6 " /< 7:=' *

! ' 2

' E F

' B

;

/&)1 D *$( ' (

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -19-

' *

;

/&)1

;

' D

' * E F E

;

/&)1;

G$ ''

$ "

' * ( H IF+

;

$ E F '* $ '

' B

;

/&)1 1

' *

( H 1

' B

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -20-

;

/&)1

' * 1

' "

;

/&)1

' *

;

/&)1

(

&/&'% 3

$%*% +* " &$(= %" ' "

" ;

""=

( "

9 !"

I /< 79/'D ! *

;

/&/(

'''/'/<'&//)

03J

;

& ( '

;

A (

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -21-

03J '

;

03J

! K

' 03J

3K;

'# B

03J

'# 6

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -22- $

' ' C 7

# K

" #

-K41#

'# (

03J

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -23-

&/M

;

& G

C03J

;

/&)1 ;

' ( 2

&/&

' '' /'/<'&//9 ;

/&)1

03J

;

D*( '%

" 6 ! 96 " 6 ( "

! "

16 /< JDN';

&)' D

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -24- % ''' /'/<'&//9

D*( ' 2"!&%, .3 ('' D

%# ('&' H

7 O% '''/'/<'&/=

03J#

$ 2

/ " '''/'/<'&//9# &

" '''/'/<'&/&# &/M

'''/'/<'&/=# (')' 0

% 7

%' D 1

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -25- ('<';

;

' 1

03J

' * 2 ;

<( "

;

& ' ;

;

/&)1

;

<))

' ''' /'/<'&//9

' $$$ $$$ $$$ K' *

(+31

' H

;

& D*( '% 0

! 7 0 $ #!! )

" ! 4&' $"5! %&" ( 6" 020*0)% 9 ' ( " (

"" 9#.

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -26-

! 7 *) 00 #!!

#$%'$ ! 0!+7&%&"( ,030) 6 ( "

0! 1 *" %&"(= %" ' ( "

9 K C( #!!

( ! 0! %&!%02'*2

*)%K ' /< 7<'D

; 1 2

P H 1

' B

' N

-1N*

!!%$'!6 ( 6

6 0000 $

"6 9 00)<00* (( 6 00)< 00* 9 00)<00* 6

6 "6 9

( ( 00)<00* 9

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -27- )00$ (

!7,,)0, $$0 ) G "

. I

" .

( ( 9 ""

9 ( 9 " 6G ( "

6". %' ! E 6 @. ( I .

" $%*% +* " &$(= %" '6 . "" " ( !!6 9 ( *

#. 6 ( 5

9 C( $'% $" %& ( %" ' 6

.6 ? " " 5

9C( ( 6 . "" " "

6 9 !!%$'!6 6

( .

9 !! %$' ! ( 6 ..

" +

" "

!7*0, 4 6

9 4 "6". %'! "

; =

6 "

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -28- " "

!! %$' !

6 ". 00)< 00*

66 (. 9 9

E !00 "6 9 00)<00* #". (. 6 ( 9.6 9" ! 9 00)<00*

6 .

( ( !!G ( "

. 6 @. ( I ( ( .9 ,

" ( .

9 #. ( "

( C"

.9 . .

.9 . 6 9 . "" "" ( ( ( ! 6 6 ( 6

" ". . "".9 2 G

)00$ ( "66 .

".9 . (

.6 . )00$ "".9( . 3

! . 9

" .

"" I

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -29-

9 ( ( 9 $0

9 ( 9 "". ". 5

9 C( "

E ! 00 " 6

!!! 9

(6 "E9 6 9 8 9 6 " 6 6 G ( "

5 ( 5 ;= %(( '$ !#!!)

&*"%0+' ,

* %5 ( < ' 6 " 6 ( " 5

9 C( ( %" ' " ( ( 6".C6."6

( .

( " $ G #. 9 "

( )00$ 4

66 9 ! > 003 "

6 9

!7*0, 9#.

!7)2 +00 $ 6 .

. ". ,%'! ( " " 9 6 . ""

!7)2 +00 9.

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -30-

!7, ,)0) $$

(. "

69 4 9"(9 0033) 00 .

9 (. 9 "

( ( 9

.9 9 ( " " " ( ( C

" !6 (9 6 $) G ! :

9 "

9 6 "" ."

. ! 9 6 6 .6 (I

(

( C"

! 7 , ,) 0)

9 00+<00, 9!. 6

(9 6

!7$$0 $* !(

!7$$0 6

"" 9 0*< 0+

>B )0*0 6 5

E B .9 C 4G >B 6 6 ( I

. (I"" " ( . ! " %*' !

"" /<

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -31J* $*" & !

! 3

#% K" ( .6

. "" 9 9

6 . 6 ( "" * 0,%" '6 .9

( . 6

""". 9 . 9 4 ( >B 6 B .9."

". ( " (6 . .

9 <96 " !

ITA No. 271 of 2014 -32- 0"

!7$$0 6

!7+)0, $+ "" (

!7*0," 9

%&' ( ( ( ( . )00$ 9 " ( "

! 7 +) 0, (

6 ( ( ( )00$ $, ! (9

!7,,)0)$$0 9 <9 6

!7*+)0,)2+ 003+3,33 000$ 9#. ? 6 $2 !" ( "" " $3 7 -.

/--

-.-- .- G" 4 ( F G"