Mange Ram And Another v. State Of Haryana And Others



  

  
  




  ! "
  #$#%&#' ()

 %(*(+#' ()  

 









 !"!

 
 



  

 ,,!  ! "
   




 

 

 




 !"!

 
 



  



-  ! "
   















 !"!

 
 





") ./ " 0 1 0" 
 

 



!

"
# $  



%&'()*+,
-
(../+'(,+/


 
0 
 "
# $  


 

#$ "
# $  



%&'*,*(1'(,+/


 
#2 
"
3 
# $  
! "
 
4444



1 0" 2




 
 




2 $' 


6
 



 

6
 
$ $



  
7
6


6
 "
  
2
 


 



2 


 





 
2

82
 
%


 

2


 
 
(1'#


9
#: 
# "
+1/;




<+1/;
# =
>

 $"
 
 
2
?
 
%&'()*+,'(,+/



  "








6
: 
2

 
$ 
@

 
 
(),+(,,1
   
;

+1/;
# 
5 
9
#: 
% 

 

2





<9#%="
$ 
#6
@ 
A)
 
(*+((,,/

 ? $



A,",,",,,B'

 
5  "

 
   
+1

+1/;
#

2


 
#  
3


 "
!  



< 
%

=

 
  



$ 
#6
 
(/,+(,+;"
 
6
 




+",(",,",,,B'

 
 

A,",,",,,B'

 


& 


2


 






6

>#')),.'(,+*
6

2


%

$ 

 *,,1(,+*
#C 
'+"

 "


2
 6 6
 6
$ 
 
 
(,,)(,+A
#C 
'*

>#
@ ;;.)

(,+(



%

 






+"/("*,";,,B'

 
 
+",(",,",,,B'

 
5

 "

D2
 
%



9$
 
%$
@ 1,(;'1,.;
(,+.
$ 

 
,),/(,+.
 

 





+)E



2


%




$ 
 




"


 
6

 


+"A*";)"1;,B'
  
 

6 "

 
%

8
#6
 
(/,+(,+;"
"
6







  
 
 


#6
 
(*+((,,/

2
9#%"

 
 
 
(1'#


+1/;
#
6




  2
 
 "
2


9#%

'  


6 



2


#6 
(/,+(,+;

2
 
%



5 
9#%"
$ 

 *++((,+;
#C 
'("
 





 
 
(1'#

+1/;
#

 







+",(",,",,,B'

 

6 
2
 
%





 
 
 $

 




 $

 
2


9#%


2 


6


 
2

82
#C
%

"


$

$


 
 

6 
2

82
#C
%

$ 

 
,),/(,+.






: 




"

 
$
2



  


9#%'

 @ 
(




 
  
 

3
9
   
2


  
$
2


 
2


%




 
  

2 
#$%

"


&'(
) *!+,,  - ,) !&
 

(.,.(,(*
5

 "



?

2 $ "
  



2
 
"
2
 '+*
6 




 

 
 

 
 

3

<

   

             



    ! " #$  %      &  '(!   !

               )*

  %   " + & 
(!

,.#/!012)0

! +,,   3"4 ,5    '*
(-. %"% -".

/0     $     

  & '(!!



    

   %  "  



 1     1 

  & '(!!

 

           1  



       $     ,2+  3   4

 5

2  -
))6.'&""78       

    %   "         

    

   

      "  ,.60   7 0 * "!)0#/' 2-8#!,) !5   

'**8-/.&""6(0  3   "    & "  9!"   



     

      

    "   & "         :   

; ,.92" #/   ,) ! * +,,  6 ,) 5:   -
))6.'&""8()0  3  9!"         



 & '(!!





   

     

   "  

    

       !  "  ,.9) ,!01   ,) ! * ;) +,,   ) !),    ,) !5   

'*
(-
.%"%-"./)70; 


"

$6


2 $



   "

6

2







9#%

 


 
 

 
  
2


 82
#C
%

2

6
2
 
%


2
 



  
 2

 


2

%


5 D2
#C
%



<9) ,!01   ,) !  !"! ;) +,,   ) !),    ,) !5  ( ,  ! 

  #
# 
0*0< 
$
 


9#%

 

 
 
 
(1'#


+1/;
#
  "
 ?


 


6
 
2



%


$
 
 
45%56$7(89$

 
  
2 6
:
8  <

      

          

    "   1

      

      &  '(!



              

      

 3    1     &  '(!    
7  &  '(! 

   

'
))'  

9!%=
' 
')
)(  '6
*'***          "      1  

     

:

  '*'**)>    "  

  1       

  

 

 & '(! 4

5

-

.? 

  

   =      

 '7*6'**) $                 "   

   

      

    

 

    

  



 

'
))'  

  !

          9 !

<"         &  '(! 

  

'
))'    

    "    '*'**)  @ ! =68) 67*
))7 " ?

? !

  @  "            '6
*'***      

  ;
:







2


%

 
7


%



&)0   !  !"! +,,   - !&"




 #
#
0*0< "
$
 

  
  '
:
 3             3

9 A 9 !

<"  A   '*
6 -'. %"% -". /7  B

 & - . 9%

& A  '*
6-'.%"%-".6*7 & 

 &  

'*
6-'.%"%-".//
! "

,

 

        

 1  

      

<                   &    

<             
/ 3   

    "                

                             C % 7( /87D$ 

     

 

           





   
)

'**(-4. 

            

 
)

'**(     

'*7
))(;
,
9 
 



 


 



3$ 
7


%



+,+,(,+.

%&'(*A11'

(,+A"
$ 
6 
6
 

2

' 



6
 
9 
 


6



%

6





3$ 
7
6

 
2

82
#C
%



9$
 
%$
@
A+1

(,+1"


;"<$ "'#= +(>7+ ?($47@ /6' &$ /5(' +A*7$767( ==#+6%B
#



 82
#C
%

$

6 


 


3$ 
7 "

 
6 ?


   
2

82
#C
%

"
6 
 

  '

-


 



2


 6 
6







? 6 

9#%
6


 







 
2


 
%





 

% 
2

 
 



$



  
 


 






"
C  
2

' 

 
"
6

 
2


%



-








&




 
   "
 
2


2
 
 


9#%
6

 






@
("


>
#

>#')AA)'(,+*
-
>#'

;;.)'(,+(

2


%

"
6 "
 
6
  
F

  "
6 
9#%
6
 






@
(

6




 
% "



2



6


6 2


 



  "

 

 (,,)(,+A


>#';;.)'(,+(




6


 
6
 

2


%

"



"



 

  

"



2


  
 


6




? 6 


9#%
#  "




"

9$

#



%





> #
6 

2


 "





2


9#%
6

6 
2




  
2

82
#C
%


F


 C 
 
 
   "







 "
 
 
 $ 
 6 "
6



2
?


6

!


 
 




"


   
6 



2
2



 

  





!
F
$6


 
 
2 $"



6 
 
5==?#'

9#%'


@
(

 

 







  
2

82
#C
%

" 2 





2 

 

 




6

 
*;


+1/;
# 
 6$ "
F

 

?






 



 


%

 

6


 

 
2 





 "
 
6 


2
 


 


 

 


 

  
2


 82
#C
%




 


%





 
 
 "

"
 

 
 


 #+#>C#% 2

   1 0" 
E11 

E




























 F & 1D  GD= F %  GD=