High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1029/2012dismissed

Harjinder Kaur And ORS v. Swarnjit Singh And ORS

2018-03-12Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages

!!"#$#%& '"()* '+#%,!'-.' (!'$ //!00% $ 1!'$.$ 2'%+# #%3( (!'$ !$/%,!% $

!"#$%& '( $(')#

'!$!% &

'+4 0#%3(),5" !) ' (!//!00% $

'#,(.),5" !) ' (!'!$/%,!% $ 66666 (')#*% //!00% 7/0#% #$'!#% !3.0'!"%,//!03#%$ (!

+.,38!% %,,!"'!!, !,99)2(!'!:4 (!$.# ',!"0' #%2# ( "%$!;.!% #0'!0#!/!'8%!% #%+.%" #% "0#8#%3 (!8$!05!$ :! 2%!' #% /$$!$$#% (! $.# /'/!' 4 :!#%3 %"!$ '0) +#% #%,. "/'"!%'4/'/!' 4 :4"(00!%3#%3 (! '%$!' ,!!, , !, *< '!3#$ !'!, % < :!#%3 '3!, %, :'#" !, ,".8!% %, "%$!;.!% #0 8. #% :!'#%3 , !, =><) (, :!!% ,#$8#$$!,:4 (! '#0.' %, (!//!0/'!!''!,:!'! (!?2!' //!00 !.' 2$0$,#$8#$$!, (!//!00% 7/0#% #$#%$ # . !, (!$.# "0#8#%32%!'$(#/ %,/$$!$$#%*@A=$('!0%,8!$.'#%39<B%0$8'0$) ,!$"'#:!,#% (!(!,% ! (!/0#% % (!/'!8#$! ( (!/' #!$2!'! #%,.%,2!'!35!'%!,:4#%,.?2(5#%3C$('!*@A=$('!

%,'"(00!%3#%3 (!'!8!% #%!, '%$!',!!,% (!/'!8#$! ( .' !+#%3($%?:(#%3()2(,#!,%>9@)2$"/'"!%!' C $('! *@A= $('! !' (#$ ,! () (! /0#% #$ :!"8! "/'"!%!'$.'+% #%3(0$,#!,%,,!!%,% $))<)= @'!

(#$ 0!30 (!#'$ "((/0 #%3( ,#!, .%8''#!, %, #$$.!0!$$) 2(!'!$ ,!!%,% 9)#%"%%#5%"!2# (,!!%,% $%,) '%$!''!, (! $#,$('!*@A=0%,8!$.'#%39<B%0$8'0$5#,! '%$!' ,!!,, !,*<)'!3#$ !'!,%<%,8. #%, !, =><$%" #%!,% (!:$#$ (!'!

!$/%,!% 7,!!%,% $ ) ) 9 %, < //!'!, %, "% !$ !, (!$.# :4 B#%3/'!0#8#%'4:+!" #%$;.0".$7$ %,#)".$! " #%%,"%"!08!% 2$$ !, ( (!/0#% #$"(00!%3!, (! '%$!',!!,:. (!$8!2$% /'/!'0450.!, 2$0$,!%#!, ( (!/'/!' 42$+#% #%,. 8#04' (!/' #!$2!'!"/'"!%!'$%" ) # 2$% !8/ ('$$ (!,!!%,% $ %8!'# $)# 2$00!3!, ( ,!!%,% 9.+%-.'2#,2?:(#%3($%%3#'#%3( !D!". !, (! '%$!',!!,, !,*<'!3#$ !'!,%<#%$.%, ,#$/$#%38#%,#%5.',!!%,% $%,)%8!04)2'%+# #%3(%,8'+# #%3($%$.'+% #%3($%?:(#%3()#!) (! 3'%,"(#0,'!%

!/0#" #%2$#0!,:4"% '5!' #%3 (!5!'8!% $8,!#% (!2'# !%$ !8!% %,'!# !' !, (!$8!8,!#% (!/0#% (! '#0 .' )% (!:$#$ (!/0!,#%3$ (!/' #!$)'8!, (!002#%3 #$$.!$&7 E

! "

# # ! $

! %

& &

''! (

! ) *

0#% #$!D8#%!,'+#%,!'-.' F7%, 0B# #%3(

F7 %, !%,!'!, #% !5#,!%"! "!' #% ,".8!% $) 2(!'!$ (! ,!!%,% $!D8#%!,F78'+# #%3(%,F7 %+# #%3((!

'#0.' )% (!:$#$ (!!5#,!%"!),#$8#$$!, (!$.# %, (!?2!' //!00 !.' 0$,#$8#$$!, (!//!0

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

/0#% #$A//!00% $ %, (! '!$/%,!% $ (, :!!% #3%'!,) 8."( 0!$$ /!,#3'!! :0!(!#%,#%3$% (!'#$$.!$2!'!"%+!" .'0%,) (.$) .'3!, (#$.' '$! #%37$#,! (!#%,#%3$.%,!'"(00!%3!

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

% $ $(2 ( (!/'/!' 4 (!(%,$?:(#%3() (! (.$:%,,!!%,% 9.+%-.')2$%"!$ '0 (!'# ($"8!% '!"', ( ?:(#%3((,#%(!'# !, (!/'/!' 4'8(#$8 (!'%,) (!''!)2$% %"!$ '0/'/!' 4!#%3$!07";.#'!,/'/!' 4).+% -.'(,'#3( ,!02# ( (!$8!#%%48%%!')$(!2% !, , %845#!2) (!/0#% #$(5!%'#3( #% (!/'/!' 4$ (!4 #0!, /'5! (!$8! :!+#% #%,. 8#04'"/'"!%'4/'/!' 4 (!/0#% #$2!'%%!!0$!:. '+#%,!'-.'2#,2.' +#%3($% ?:(#%3(%,"(#0,'!%%" ) (!,#$/. #$:! 2!!% (!,.3( !'7#%7 02%, (!8 (!'

' (!'!$%$$ !,:5!) (!"%".''!% #%,#%3$''#5!, :4 (!.' $:!02,% 2''% #%!'!%"! '8,#!'!% /#%#% (% (! %! ''#5!, (! //!0 #$ ,!5#, 8!'# ) 8."( 0!$$ %4 $.:$ % #0;.!$ #%02'#$!$ !$.0 % 04) (!$8!#$,#$8#$$!, .*/ (')# 01.

%&23$ ).4.156 71

817

).4. 49 817