High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/29/2015dismissed

Ashok Kumar v. Anupama Sharma

2015-01-2116 pages

! "#$"%& '

((( ) * ! +* ) *! !! !

%,-,#. % /"&00"%1"2'345"., %.6,"77,22"#.

((( ! !'

! "#$"

%!&'(() "&*!"

'((+,-. -"/ 0!% %1 %0!2 # #23& -.

" ! "4"

%!&'(( -. "5

0 0 - "

0 %- - "6-.!"

6"!

6 ! !-" " 75 0 % - "0 8 "

2 #22!!" %" !0" 0 %&. 6"% -

0 %

.!" 00 %0.6 . -"" "

"!/"2'

2( #229

65 - - . /"0" "0 -6

-"& "/ 0" .!!" %.&

/ "

!0-& #22& .

" !!"00" " :/;"".& & % "- % %

< ."

. ! 0 %& " % 0" 2 ! " 0 % " !"0"0 % !"

< " " % 6- %

" ..0"" 0".

""" / 6 - 0"6 "0 1"- 0-&#224-! "

0 -6 "

=0""

>- .&#223&1"

! ?! 6 :/"

1-& 1 "& "&0 -6

"% !"

< "& " ! " % :!"

:/- 1"- ""6!" " !"! 6 "4@4A. 0 %-! "

0. ! " "

""/0 "0 :

" &

- -6

"!""

" " "

8 0 0" "0 % %6 %" ! " " %" % =.#223&0"5 5

- 6! "0- % ! -6 " "

- 2'

2( #229&%6- " 0! %0" -"!0"6 0&

.- 0?"/

" "2B 2$ #22& " "

0 0" "0 - %% 66- % !0 " "0

2$ #22& !0"" /!" "%6

.- " "" 0& "

" ""

/ 0" 0 .00- > = "0 " ""

9(( 2'

2$ #22 ! "4#4&3(#(29"

= ;" ) "&*=

;

+, % " ! ";

&& !"

!"0 ! "#"

"! C"0 "0"0 ! "!!&#22() "&* "0 ! "! !+,& 0 !"0"0 " 2$ 2 #2 ";"!

";& "

!0" "

#4! % 6" "-0 " %6 .-.!!"0 0"

0 0" "0"2$ 2 #2 = -. "

9 !""

!> ;

.&D %" "

! #! "- !" " 0" "

(&B4&222@5 -." " !"

6&" "-. " 0"

2! 0". / -. 2$ 2 #2& " % -. % % - % -. % " - % %

.60/"!! 24 2$ #2& ""

-."1"

- .!0"."

! "! "!"00 !

! " -."!/ % 0 " "4 2$ #22

" 0 " " <

! & :

";"" /

6 &; %&:/"

1-&&" %;"0.& = :/& %&&"/ :/&" 6 " " "0 0" 0- -! "

0 -6 "

"!"% !"

< "& 6 ! 0 6. 0 0".! . %

- !!""&"#$ 2'

#2!0 !"

< ""!"" %

.- " ""

!""!

%6 ! " " ! " !"59& !

!"""" !

"" !" ! %"0 !"5%.?0 ! ! "2B@(;""

; "! ) "& *;

;

+, -. " ! 0 .

" #$ 2'

#2 "

! " " % % " " . ;"00 "& "

" !& " 0 %;"00 " "C"0;"00 "&

.&" -0 !"6 !."2# 2 #2 "!"0"0 - !" "- "& -

! #$ 2'

#2 % "&"

" %!"

6"!"%" -

! .-.

5 - !" " -.

0 ."-1! " -. 0 " "0 -"! "

! "

6" "

-! 0 0" "0

" ..0"" 0 & "5

"1"

!"1 %!"0. " % 0-6 " &!" "1

0 0" "0 = " 0 0" "0

%"& 6 0""0

! .

" ! "'"

'((

" !"1 % %

-. 0"

" "% "-0"

0 "! ""6

!.''# "% " "

'.& 0 % "0 8"#'

2 #22 !!" %" !0" = "65! 05

: % 0 % "

. 0 % 0 %& ""6"-"0< "0. ! %0 1"

0 . -" "

% =

!0-&#22&.

"!!"00" " :/;"".& " ."

0 %&" !"! 6- %"%!.-"

" 0 "

-!/%"-.!" " !"< !"

& -" "/ "& -/1"- ""

?0"& !0" "

"" !" % " -. 0 .& . % . " 2'

2( #229&"%6- " 0!

5 - % "

0 % . "

%0 % " "0 0&" "% 6 "

&? " 0"

% 600". " 0 ! """&" 0 0" "0" "

"!/

>;:/""/ .%"& 6

0""0 /-"

"0 "1"

!"1 %!"0.- / 0"!"0 " "" .&0

5 / 5-""

"!/ 0%6 0!

- % : % !"

&" %" > = "0 " "2'

2$ #22 ! "4#4&

; 3(# (29 "

;

% % 0

" ! ( 2'

#22"

!"0 "0 ! "!!& #22( !"0"0 - " " ;"!

" ;& " 2$ 2 #2 -. 6 "

!"0"0 &0" "

4&B#&222@5-. .!< -.

0""0" "

(&(2&222@5 !

> 0" % " 4&2&$#(@5 B2&222@5 % 6 " " " !"

" : &0" "

$&22&222@5

-. "0" &"

-"/ "" " 2! ""

-. = % 5 - 0- #2& " ! "

8 0" 0 0" " "0% ! ". 0 C """&"" #$ 2'

#2& "1"

%1"-. % - !!"" " "0 0 0" "0

" ..0 "" "1"

!"1 %!"0.

! !"0 % 0C"0; " !&" < .&"

" "/0". "0 0"!!" "

!"0"0 " "

% " " 0 0" "0 """- %-!/- "!!"0. .&!0"/"

" " 6"!%

-" % & -0 " "!"00" "

0 .&! % -"%"". 0 .

00 0" "0& 6 /""" "

" . " /"%%6 ""

% "/

-0 % 6-"/0" " / %"

"!."0 0" " 0- " !"0 !"

--6 % / & - " % 0 "

& ""

% -. !" 75 C"! ! ." "%E

C " "0 -E

C ""! "

! ""

(

:" ! 6 ! " - ! 6!" "

" "

-"? C % "% "?0

: 1& C40 & C3D 0& & C( 1;/ C9 0&;

"&5 -?0 C 0 & %&>;:/ C# 1.D"&:! %&= :/&

! %6 ! !-. -0 " 0 " - & ;" !0 " !"! "

"6"!" ! ! .""%" "! "

6"! "0 "

& " "

> % %% 6 -. 0 % 1 %0 ! 2 # #23-. !" &"/ 0 $

-0 " 0 -. 1. %% & !" %6-!"

00" % "

0 %

) -"/ 0,"%" -

! .-. !-"6& !"

%% ""6"

" %

!" &!" "% "0 %6 ! !-. " " #22 "5

" % 6! % 6

.!"0 % 0

" !" ." " .% % - %0-. = !& -! "

% 0-6 " &"

!" "1 0 0" "0 "%"? " ."

0 %!"! 6 - %"%!.0

" 0 ""0 :! "

! !" ! " "0 !"6 1"- C 0 &%& >;:/&!"5$&" ! 00"!" % ""!/"

34#1"

.-. "6!

!"."

"!/" " ?

3!!" %" !"!/ " "

0"23 #22'""6."!! " "".-." 00 ?

-". % .& "6-. C# 1.D"& :! % "

= :/& !"5#& !!" "

22B45 (324222 1"

0 "

"/ 0 00) ,0"

!!" ?

!!" 6 !< 2$ 2# #22 ?

90" %" ( ! " !!" & 0"

!" "0-" !

6 !" !"

" ! "

-! "

! "-!0

"&0 .!"0"0 /!- F .& #2 ! "

! " "0 0" "0 ;"< "!"0"0 ! "

! . !"" "% "

-6 " "

! "

& ""

!"" " % !

F .&#2 ! !" !"0

0- "

G! .G ""5

" "!"

6"!

*; .+ %" " 6"! ! "4),) ,"

'(( "*! .+ "6 "&" %"

&- "0 . !! . "" " = "-/-6 " -."" "

" !! "- " 0 "

" " 0""!" 0 0" "

" ;" %"6 ! "4),) ,"

'((.

"--" 0 %

" " 6"!"%" "

! .."

! . ?;" = 6"0".4- %- 6"0".

9!; ' "-6 75 *

" #

" %

0*! .+-? -.?;" 75 '# '

( %

" )

)

& #

6 %" !& ""- 0-"

!"-." ""

% " -

! . -. !

% ! % ! !

"6 " % "! "! 0.

8 6 !-."& !" !"

% 75 *#

./.0!

1 " !

./2.0!

3 ,

4 !

)

, , 56!

0-7 * ,*!

5,8

3 *

4 !

, !

4 !

: *

+ % *

+ 3

2/.00 !

; :

+677 2/.00

<7.

, *

, * 8!

4 !

5,= (

2.0!

/.0

/.00 .0.0!

9 :

,%< >

3:15

5( *

> -?"

4 !

- 0-7 * ,* @ (

( !

9+/-2!

A?!

4 !

+6 7.0 , * 8!

4 (

(

4 8

?",%<-( ,%7 3 :$ *

3* 1 !

(

9+/!

52!

A?!

4 !

- 0-7 * ,* , * 8!

4 .0.

0.0.

* 33:

+7 .0.!

- 0-7 * ,* ?",%7-( ,%6

* (

*=!

@ (

; :

+./6 <.0!

- 7< ,* , * 8!

(

9+/!

52!

A?!

(

; :

+72 .6..0

5B!

; :

+60 .6..0

; : (

& 4

" - 6 ! "

"& ?0 ". "

0. C 0 & %& >;:/ C# 1.D"&:!%&= :/& %.& 0 "!" "

-"?"0/ 6 %0!""6 % ""

" !6 !"

" 0 0!& !" %. "

"" !" ! 0 %

"!"0"0 - #2 ! .&

.&""!""&

;" 75 *+

5 !

!"#"$% 1 !

& 3

"6 ."6 .!" -0"-. !" "

!" 0% %

"0 0 % " 0 !

" "

6 ! 6 - " !"

""& !!" % " & " "0 " #$ 2'

#2 "1"

%1"- . % - !!"" "

" ..0"" 6 "

-."! 0/5 !!" %" !"#$ 2'

#2 !0". % - !!""&& " 0".& !"

< " %

.- " !"

!""! !""

"" !" ! ! ! " 2B@(;

;

%-."#$ 2'

#2"

: - !. & 0- 0 "5

-< " !

& "6 -. C9 0& ; 0 " ;" "

; F !

% & &!- %> = "0 " ""

#$9 #24 ! "4(3(29=

;

% %

" ! ";

&"!"0 "

;"."

> = "0 " " /5 ! -< " !"0"0 "-6 " "

!" "--& 6 " !"

! .""6 6 = -! "

! -6 " "

""%" - ""

0""

= "

!& %"/ " 0 %-.!"

6"!

% "

!" "

6 "- %"0 & -. 0

+* ! !

"#$"%& '

&$'($$)$$*$$ $$%$ +,$"-&