Commissioner Of Income Tax-Ii v. Ravinder Singhania




    
 
















  
  



 
 
!

"



##""


$ %
& '
() 

&#
   

 

  
      
 
   * 

+ 
$',
(
' 



+ 
* , -
!


(
' 

.
+ 
'/
(% 
' 


+ 
# %
!


' 



#

0
0
0
0

 






"
%
(
 


 
 

1 2
 

3





 "

#


 
/

11 115


"




"".)
%4  "
6%

"

.

 

                        

 

 



 !   " 

               "  

#  "       !$   %     &&' ( ((&'(&('))*+ 





/




6%

"

.





"

 7 '%
8

 

)
8



 

%

23



9


)
 
%
(
 :




 
4%




(%# 

,-. ,!/ ( &&' 0. &)1,
 "
 
 









#
"

"
4 


2## "3



2## "3
 
 

4


)


%

4"/

'.


-%) 


(%# 


:/

; 


(
 :
.




.

 #'

   151
:/


 
 



 

% "
'

"/



 
 
4
%#"
4/
'
:




.23 1 -4 

 5 && 6 77.78'9:;

'
:





9 <

 

 -=$(, 

  > &&)

'8.')9:;
 


6%




#



.


"
 

'.



 
4/

; 



 




 





6%

.

"
 
4

%
  
4








/

)


6%


.



2## "3
 

#.

/


 
 

 

#. 
% 




'.


%46%
# )

'.


%46%
# )
 
%
 
4 




)


"".
8
 

)
8 ##"
 




 



 
 

'.


; 

 
8
 

#


"

  




2## "3
 
  
8
 


2## "3



 
 
4/
"'/)
 








#7 
 "
"

"




 
  


 "
4/


 
 5 
#


"
"
4/
4

#


 "
4/

)








2## "3


2## "3
%"

"/
4/


 
  "
 
 
.%"
4


4"








 

.








4

# )


"/


"
 
 
4
"
4/


4 


2## "3

.

 ) "

 
 
.


# 



 
)
 
% 






'.


-%) 



.
 '





6%

"

.
%
4





#







/


.

# )
% 



.

  4"




 #"

 



%


"/
.
 







 
 

4

4/


2## "3


%46%
# )
.
"%

"
"
4/



 
4
#%
 



2## "3
 

"/

-% 
4%

4") 



%


<
"



 "
.'



 
2## "3
4/

 #%)

 
1 5 
=


4%
4/







*

, 
) 
% 
$
/



 
 
2%#

3
.
 


6%

 5
+ 
!


"



%"

)

4 "



#
%4 
 

-%) 

*

, 
) 
% 
$
/



 
 
2%#

3


##" 4"


# 
 
=


% 4"


>%
2 3

2 3



 
 

% 

'(    ##   "  # > #$! #



"  ! $



  

"      ?(3(1$ / (-(,@5'))6)

1,

 1,   !  <  

 

# ! * (  "     



  ##    !

  #    1  

'

'    

 !    "

 !     A># 

  # $       >  >

  

  !B  

'  1  

'

   *+ 
#

#


'
:



 

& -
?%

() "
$
@


2%#

3
%#"

' 


; 

 


'
:

%


 
 %
4/


























; 

 

'
:
# %

4 '







& -
?%

() "<
 
2%#

3



 
4/



'

 
"' 4"


 



4/


)
% /
%

 

.

 
 
4
# 
 %

 


 
.


"/
 "%"



"

/


4)%/
 
.


"


 ) "
# '

.




4

/
 %  4"


4'
6%
. 
  

4/

'
:




#







-%) 


##" 4"


# 
 
1

"

  
"".

 #%)



 "




6%

"

.







 
 

  
     
    
! "# $% &'()