← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/111/2012allowed

Suresh Kumar And ORS v. Luv Kumar And ORS

2018-12-21Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal19 pages



   

 

  !"#"$%& '( #)*'+ ( $,) (# -- ..

$# /# 0'1*'+ ( $,) (#  #-$, $#  %

   

  

        



  

    

 

 !

    "

    #

$ % & # '

$  ( "

    & ) *  %+'',* +&-

....

 

23345  /



    

 

  & 0 



 



1  , 2     

/   &  

   4 

 

56    %

#

$  

2(  

 (

(2 

  *( 31

(  1 

 ( 56 7  

  

(  1 

 ( 1

  (

1   2 / 1



,,     &



 $ % 8 

 8(

/

 

:(

 



 $ %

 

 *

(

/ ;$ 1 1 

5%6  

(





 /



/  2 ( 2 2

2

/ (

 8(

/

8( <

/

 3 2 (

32   

   / =  32  

 (  1 2 =   ( (

/ 1

 



= 

 

(2 :(   32  

2 &=  1

  ?(/ 32  @/   = 322

  3   2 

  1

 (

 (

5&6  

 (

 4 (  

(  $+   12/  & + ;#'



( (

 

( (2 :(   ? 2

=$   A 

 (   ;=&+  

(2  =&+   3 ( (2 ( ( / ? =  322

   (  $+    2  (

    & 

 

/  (

/   A (   ( 12 2

(    & 4 2 3

 =$  ( ( ? =&+  ( 

'

    2   1 ?( +&  ;;'

+  ;;'

(  1

 

2/      &  '

  ( 

'

1    2  (

 (   

;

/2

/ =  32 / 

 (  $+ & + ;#'

   2 * 

 8(

/  

(/ 

/ 1 2 (

/ 1

 (

  C(2

(

/

 

 :(     

 

  2

(    

  2

11 :(     / 

#

  (  (

/  1

 4 5#6 7  1  12 (,  

         

       

 

 !

   "   

#  #     !  !$ % &  '

         '

 (     !  !$ % )   

   '

   



 #

  '  $ %*

  '

   "          ' 

$ %*  ' 

    # $ %* +  

  #   % & ,  & --$ %* , .

5'6 7          5$6  *(  1 (  

/   (  ? 

/ $''

++,+% )D? =- ?  E, 1    1  ( ? 1( 1

 ( 

, 

 

(

32

 

 (



2(  3  *( A    *(   (



2(   

2( 



 8(

/  *(  

,?2 2 (  /

 / ;#'

 8( ( )  -  ++

(2

 



  

/ 2 3

 8(

/=  /    8(

8( ( 

=  /



2 1

  32  ? =   (2

/   !

/

  / = 

32  

2 1 ( 3





  ;=&+ )=

=&+-   1 (2  =&+   (

5;6  *( 

(  $+ & + ;#'

 

 

(  & + ;#'

(2  

(3    $    2

(   2

/  (2  

 2 

 +; ;;#

 (



3( ;

/ 

 2

(

(  / %+ +$ ;;;

 *( (  ( ( 3  1

  / 

 2

( > *(   ( / 2(   5+6 1  *(

  2   *( >  1 



 3  *( 56 (  1( 1 

 ( +; + + >      

  / 2

 (

  3    

;



  

 

  3    

    "

     '=  >   +% +; +   *(     ;

 /

?

1 

( 

  + % 1

  1 

  ;

% 1 

 / '

 0  1 (   # $ + % &

# $  

 @ + +& +%     + (  

?



 



 ?

 >  ( 

 ( @

( + ** (3( 

1

(  1  (2 (3 H> A D?H 1    

  3   ?    

1

 (

 56  

 12 (3  :(

  2(

 ,  '

 0 1    2

0 ''0

  # ""

!  "

"

! '

   3

  $

 !

       !   $

  4 -  # 

  ''

  ' !  "

   ! '' "$

"  

           /     !

   $ 5%6 @ ( 

 :( 3/   12 (3  :( 1 

  *(,    

 ''0  '"  #

 5(  1  

0 ''0         $

&   5(  1  

0 ''0   "" '   "

"

! '

 0 #0  "

" ' '

 0   

    '       1 

  78   8 & $ )  

        '

    ! 

   0   '        

    

  $ 5&6 A 

1

 :( / 

 

 *( 

(2 

 +# +% ++  2 1 

 

   (   (



2( 



 / /=  8(

/ 

 

 

 / ;#'

:(  ( / ( 

( 1 4 (  # 8( (   *(

 

(  $+ & + ;#'



  1

 2 1 

  / 2

/ ,3 



   3 1  *(  (2



2(  2(

 D? )D? ,-

 (  @ *

(

=&    ,   *

(

(

 11 3

  1  (

2  3  

/ 





  (

=%  

2 1 3

/

 :(  

 ( 





     1



,   1

? (  (  

 

  1(   2 

, 

 



 0

 

( 5 (  1( 1 D? D? , ( E, 1   1   (

 /

 

 E,     ;

,?

1 (

(

 /

   ;

D   ;



*

 (  $++=;'=;;

D? E,=;

D? E,= (  1   ;

32   (

 (  / 8( (

/ A (    

 1  

  3 *(  /     



 ?(    D? E,=% (   ;

   / @ 

 

(/  A  

    ( E,%

3 2

,( ,

2 *4 (4   1

  





 

(/  3 (  

 4 

:

1 

 3  

:

1 

 2   

5#6 @ 

   *(



    /=  8(

/

(  $+ D? E,= 12

2

 2

(    & !

/ 4   ?  (  =&+  ( 

'

 

 +&  ;;'

)D? E,=%-

+  ;;'

)D? E, =& D? E,= - @   

(  # '

# ;

)D? E,=# D? E,=$- 1   ?

1  (   & 5'6 F  (

 (3  (  *

(





 32

 



)

 (- *

(

(  ;

 +& $;+   ( 

 *

(

 *

(

(  +$ % +# ;&$ )D? E,=-  (

3 11   



:(   !

(  '

+ +' ;%

 11  

/ 3  1  *

(

/ 



(  '

+ +' ;%

  2 3  

(  ;  1 

1  (

 / 1 *

(

 



( 32  /   2

/   

 F  ( /2 (  

   !""#$!% 

 $ &%  '()  1

 

? 1 

:(



  1( 

 5$6  (3 

  ( 



  5;6 0

D? D? , 1  E, 1   1 



E,

  ;

(



3 (3, 2

 :(   (  

  /=( 8(



/ 2   *( 1 

  ( 1 (  1

  2 1 (2 ( / /

2(  3 1  *( 1( 2

/ ,3   ,

 5+6  *

(

 

  1

 ( *

(



9 (

  *

(

   32 





 

 

(

   ( 

 2

(2  1   2  



3 1  *(

/    (

 

 =  8(

/ 

A 1

 ( (3  :(     (

 56  2  :(    (  

 

!

1

( 

(2  8H3 ?

*( * +

 ,-.

*&

. ,-. !"/) $#% 

 $ &%  ()!

/

  3 

(2 12



 '$ %

&



(2 ,  : /  

    0 '"

     !   ;

!  '

;

;    

   1      8 & ; 6  +7)  <     

    '' # 0 = "

  '

 !

!         '  

'        !! #0  /  

 8

   #  " '"



 0 '' "    /'0  #0  0

    ' " 0  ,  1

2 !""/$3%

$ &%')#4$!""/%5!#

 * 

!!.-!' =  '       0 /' '"

  !

"

! ' "   

 '"

   0       ,3

   '

   # ! !

    " 

''      0    '

    ' !     ' 

 '"

 "

! !

        '

      #0 '      :

     8     #  

   %     !

 "

   1 ! -    #  

  -    '        #   ' " # !

'

  

 !

     # ' >" 

!

     # !

" ' "    '"

     #0  !

   =  '    !

     /'0

    '' #   

 

   0      '

  3       :   '    ' #  "

  /'  !

!      : '"

 <'

!  '        '

   '   & * # &

         

    

!   # '

 '    

    8 : '"

 0          " #0      /  '

 0 ''0  

0 # "

#  

 '"

 '' # 6

0

>/'       #     0    #  " '"

  6  +7  #0 # ! 

 

     '

     & * # &     '

   #0  "0   

  "  

 '"

    #?    

 >/'    &) 8 !0       !  

   '' #   "

! 

!   "

!

'

    6' # & ' "     

!  # * '      

 ! '

    

0  "  < '  # & * # &

 '   '' # '    

   

   80      '

        # !" #0  >/'    &  % #" '   - "

 8''  &  &)  :    1 ! -     :

  

   1 ! -             8 



0 #    ! '

0       &  " # & .

56 2  # 8( (  1

 8( 

 

  8( (  ;

# 2





 4

 / /     ( ( (2

3  /



  1    

      

(2



      ( 

      1   (2 ( 

       4

 /    

 /   (



/ 3 ( 



 ( 

8(  4

      1( 3

 



 4   

 / 3   1    

  

 ?  ( 1    8(  4

 3  1(  (

 32

 1    

 / 3   

/   

 /

 

5%6   8( ( )  -  ++ 1

8( 

 

   

 8(

/    

 /   (

 (

 /     3 



 4  

5&6  * +

 ,-.  )( - 1( 1

  :(   (

2 2 (2

 /

  8( ( )  -  ++

  

 2 +; +; ++

 /

 / ;#'

   

/ 

 1

1 4 



H  )( -

 3  8H3 ?

*(

(3:(

(2   

6  7  , -.

  , -. !"/5$/%

$ &%583 A 1

 2   3 8( ( )  -  ++

1( 

/ :(

(2

 

<  # 8( (  ;

#

 2 = 1(  =  

  ? =  1( 2

1

 

1( (   $ 8( (  :(     %;

++

       

2  A   2 ( ( 2

  

 =  / 1  D? )D? ,-



?3  1 

  *( /2 ( (

 0    3 





1 (3  :(  (



5#6  2  :(  %   1

 .9 ,-.

:

,-. !"/'$#%

$ &%#5/

 /

( 1(  2  (

 2

( F  1(    

1

(    1(   1      





A 1 1  7  *( 9   &

  1

 ;

 &

 ./('(* #8(  /  (



( (   1    

 

1   1 ?(

( 1  (

 

    < , -.

=.2  ,-. !"")$3%

$ &%8!5 0  

3 





1 :(  % (

 5'6 0  

3  (2

(2 

  *( 31

3/ 

  

1 2 (   1  (2(  3  +$

  

8 <  E  42=  "= E  3 "=