High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/807/2016disposed of

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nasreen And ORS.

2019-02-21Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan6 pages

!"# !$% "!&'()"!*+,- ---))##"! . $%$ (- "$ !"!,' $ ---$)'!,!$

!$% "!&'-+,- ---))##"! . $%$ "!/%0"(1'/"!,' $ ---$)'!,!$ 2"'32&$'!4 -- 5 6 $!4

-"/0%(" "$"(1''7,8'&" 3' "))##"!9 !$% "!&'()"!*! -

-%8 2"!7,8'&" 3' "))##"!! "!, 3' $)'!,! '-! -

- "$:%)"7,8'&" 3' $)'!,! ! "!, 3' $)'!,!$ '- "!,! -

$-("!,)0"% 7,8'&"3'

-$"! ' "7,8'&" 3' $)'!,! '$- "!,! -

;;;;

*$' , 7 $"##,$)'$'3'$--

3#,'!1"#3'3"))##"!9 !"# !$% "!&'()"!*+,-"!, 3#,'!1"#3'3"))##"!9 !$% "!&'()"!* +,-"!,& '$$'1/&'!$

'3 3#,'!1"#3'3&#"("!$ ! 7&"8" $!'%'3$"("&&,!- 3#*$",73"&$'3&"$" "'! <- - <7 ,&"$,-:"="!0"(1'/"$, 8!=('' &*&#1" != =$ "'!

='!=3 '("!,=" '(#"@"*$"0"! A$"0"!"$)##'! ,!='!"('' &*&#@"""1'% 4 )-(-!('' &*&# "&,'! BB % !70"!,"="7" %&B "8!= =$ "'! '->6 5 , 8! 1* $)'!,! '- 9 0" "(/"##=,#*!" "$"!,!=#=!("!! 1*='!='! '!=$, ('' &*&# $%#1' , $"$##"$('' &*&# 3##'! '",@" , $$%33 ,$ '%$!/% $@* "B!' '$)"#7'8 71'!/% ,$%&&%(1,'!/% $$%33 ,1* (!($")-

$- "$ !9(' "!,- %$B(93" '3,&"$, *$" 0"! A $" 0"! ", 1 '%= " &#"( )'! 1" !=

,",-- <%!, &'!

'3 '' .&#$ & "="!$ $)'!,!$ -- $)'!,! '- 0" "(/ 9 , 8 7 $)'!,! '-9%B,8!=9'! 7 $)'!,! '- "'!"#

!$% "!&'()"!*+,-7"!,=" 9!$% '3 %&B '->6 5

"$##"$ $)'!,! '-<9" 8$0"(1'/#="# '3-:"="!

0"(1'/9,&"$,7'"$, 8 "!,'! '3('' &*&# '-> ?5< "!,$!$% &'()"!*9 $)'!,! '-9 !"# !$% "!& '()"!*+,- +="# ) $!"8$'3-:"="!0"(1'/!"(#*(' 9 "!/%0"(1'/"!,3" 9" 8$0"(1'/","#$'1 '%="&#"( )'!1" != <,", -- <"="!$ $)'!,!$-- $)'!,! '- 90" "(/!=9, 8 7 $)'!,! '-%B,8 !=9'! "!, $)'!,! '- !$% "!&'()"!*9 !$% '3 %&B '->6 5 - '&#"()'! ",/%,&",1*,33 ! ''

&&,!#"($ 1%!"#""!,=" - &#"()'! 1" !=

,", -- < "$ ,&,, '! -5- 1* ''

&&,!$ #"($ 1%!"#7 "!,=" 7 6 $,, '8 1* -%# 0"$"!"7&&"('&'!&#%$'!""&&,!''B)#"&,%' "$"!,!=#=!"&'3, 8 '3('' &*&# "$ ##"$ "$"!,!=#=!, 8!=1*, 8 '3 %&B '->6 5 7 $%#!=!',"'3*$"0"!A$"0"!"!,"$" &"$ '3 &'()'$ !=#=!& '3 , 8 '3 ##3", ('' &*&# "!, '33!,!= %&B7!""*"& '!=,' "$/'!#*"!,$8 "##* #"1# 3' )"*(! '3 &'()!$"'!- '' &&,!$ #"($

1%!"#7"!,=" #,('' &*&#, 8 "!, %&B, 8 '1 !=#=!'C!'3D"&7"$$%&#"" ,!=&'()!$"'! '3$- 757E"))' '!,#"1#*"&&' ,!=#*-

< F "$ 6'! '- < ,", -- < "$ ,&,,1*",33 ! '' "&&,!$#"($ 1%!"#7"!,=" 7 6 $,,'8 1*-"!/0%(" "!8,"" ,,",- - ! &"3!,!="$ % !,",&"$,-:"="!0"(1'/",,,'! "&&'%!'3!/% $$%33 ,!('' 8&%#" "&&,!&"%$,,%' "$"!,!=#=!, 8!='3 %&B '->6 5 1* $)'!,! 90" "(/!=- 3' 7&'()!$"'!'3$- 757E! $ "!,&'$"$"" ,,'&#"("!$)"*"1#1* !$% "!& '()"!*+,-76" "!'7>("&"#6 ",$9!$% '3 %&B '->6 5 - == 8,1*"" ,,", -5- )"$$,!

'- ,", -- < #, G(- "$ ! "!, "!' . $%$ -0" "(/"!,' $G7 !"# !$% "!&'()"!*+,-!$% '3 ('' &*&# " "*,"$ $)'!,! '-!&#"( )'!"$3#,"!"))"#13' $'% -- -F "$

"'!"# !$% "!& '- +,- $ ,$$"$3, "" , ,", - - )"$$, 1* 1%!"# ! 6'! '- < '3

-- <#,G"!/%0"(1'/"!,"!' . $%$0" "(/!="!, ' $G"!,"$3#, - &#"("!$E $)'!,!$"8 "#$'3#,& '$$'1/&'!$& "8!=3' !"!&(!'3&'()!$"'! "" ,,'(1* 1%!"#-

'&$ "8 1! $$%, "!, )" $ "8 "))" , '%=&'%!$#-

"8" ,#" !,&'%!$#3' )" $1$,$='!=

'%= &' ,-

!$&"$,%'',33 ! 1%!"#$ *!=&#"( )'!$ #"!=''!"&&,!7"8 *"!'("#'%$$%"'!"$" $!- !

'3-- <7 1%!"#"$&'('&'!&#%$'!" "&&,!","B!)#"&'!"&&'%!'3!=#=!&'3, 8 '3 ('' &*&#--:"="!0"(1'/,&"$,"$##"$ "$"!,!=#=! , 8!='3'33!,!= %&B1*0" "(/9 $)'!,! '- 3!,!=( $)'!$1#'C!'3D"&&'(!='&'!&#%$'!""$ "&"$'3&'()'$E&'! 1%' *!=#=!&7!""*"))' '!!= #"1#*1!'! 7, 8 "!,!$% "!&&'()"!*'3 %&B"$ ##"$#="# '3:"="!0"(1'/9,&"$,7, 8 '! "!, !$% "!&&'()"!*'3##3",('' &*&#- F "$' 1%!"# *!= 6'! '- < ,", -- <"$ % !,"&#" 3!,!=""&&,!","B!)#"& '! "&&'%! '3 "$ "!, !=#=! , 8!= '3 '33!,!= %&B 1* 0" "(/!=9 $)'!,! '- -

$8 *$% ) $!="'' 1%!"#$'!1"$$ '3$"(3"&$"!,& &%($"!&$"!,"#('$$(#" 8,!&"8" 8, "',33 !&'!&#%$'!$- 3' 7'3!,$'#%'!'$"(1=%*7 '"" ,$" H% ,'1$"$,"!, ("!,,''! 1%!"# 3' )% )'$ '3 =8!= 3!,!= "$ " &"$ '3 &'()'$E&'! 1%' *!=#=!&' "&&,!"8!="B!)#"&'! "&&'%!'3 "$"!,!=#=!, 8!='3'33!,!= %&B1* $)'!,!

'- 90" "(/!='!#*-

3' 7"" ,$%!, "))"#$" $"$,"!, &"$$" ("!,,'#" !,2$ &%,=9&%( '' &&,!$ #"($ 1%!"#7"!,=" ')"$$3 $"" ,"3 " !=#" !, &'%!$#3' )" $=8!=$$%$3!,!=$8,"&'!$'#,", " ,E/%,=(!- )" $ '%= &'%!$# " , &, ' "))" 13' #" !,2$ &%,=9&%( '' &&,!$#"($ 1%!"#7 "!,=" '! -- 5- '$"$##"$& '$$'1/&'!$" ,$)'$,'3 "&&' ,!=#*- =$ * $ , &, ' $!, #' '% $ &' , ' #" !, 2$ & %,= 9 &%( '' &&,!$ #"($ 1%!"#7 "!,=" "'!&- +" !,2$ &%,=9&%( '' &&,!$#"($

1%!"#7"!,=" $"##3C","3' " =%(!$"!, "3 )"$$"! "" ,C),'%$#*) 3 "1#*!") ','3'('!$3 '( ,"'3 &)'3&')*'3$' , - -- 5 /

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#