Satpal Garg Etc. v. Mohit Etc.
!
"#$ $%&'&()
"#*"+",-"(.#/$,'
**$++"(#'
0'
/&#"(.#/$,'
$'*(.$(#'
)
! "#
$% &'%(!)* + # % )* ,
&'%(!) '
%#%-).-( *
/
!
"# $ % & '
( ) (*
+ ,- .,
/ (
"
) (*
.& . ., ,
0 / ( 2
03")
*
) (*
.!
* (
% ..,
&
5"
6
(* +!
0** (
% ..,
& 5"
6
* ( +.7 8 '
#
*
% +
9 :, ,,,,$3
9 .8 &',,,$3 6 4 ;5
* (
6 4 ;5 *
( &!
4 + ,- .,,+ % +
(*
* 9 +
*
%
.
(* = % " % +
= = " 7 , .,,+ = "
7 , .,,& ")
* > -?
"
*
% + -!
(
(*
% ( *
( "
(*
(
( * < " * (
( * *
(
(* ( % +
= .- ,8 .,,+ .8 ,+ .,,+
,8 , .,,+ " % + 6 4 ;5
+, ,8 .,,+ ( *
( *
* *
(
# * ) '!
% + *
* =
(* + ,- .,,+
(* " "#
,8 , .,,+ % + = * =
7 , .,,& * % +
# *
*
(*
#
=
(
( *
( * "(
(
#
(* + ,- .,,+ 4 " * 7!
% +
) *
*
(* + ,- .,,+
#
@ ( A
9 .8&',,,$ % +
( "
*
(* .& ,' .,,+
*
(* % % + *(
(*
( *
:!
3(
@ ( * ( .,,+ B
( ( & ,: .,,+
@ (
%
% * * (
* %
( ,- ,8 .,,+
= <
@ ( A
(* .- ,8 .,,+ % +
(* .- ,8 .,,+ =
(
8!
% +
(
(
@ ( A
*
% .7 , .,,& 6 4 ;5
@ (
( % +
(
@ ( A
)
" * % + ,!
% +
(
@ (
(* .- ,8 .,,+ * (
@ (
% +
* % +
(
@ (
= *
* * 4 *
( !
4 ( *
,. .,,& .!
C
+!
= * *
@
* ,: ,: .,,-
* &!
B % +
4
, 00
,: ,& .,,'
% & '
* -!
% & '
*
4 .
.
00 " *( "
% + 4 *
% +
* % & '
* ( 3 *
6 4 ;5 - , .,,+ '!
"*
* % +
(
% & '
*
% :8& .,,+ * * )
# *
. , .,,'
%
( ) (*
7!
"# $ % & '
4 .
.
00
% :8& .,,+ * ) ( ( * ")
*
*
( "* . , .,,'
*
(
" % +
(
% & '
- , .,,+
* .+ ,7 .,,& "
% +
(
% & '
* * :!
D 3 * ,8 ,' .,,'
<
% 12 * .. ,: .,,7
% 3 3 * + ,8 .,,:
4 3 *(
" ( 3
!
# $% &
' $ ('
)
&( * + '
, -
.
/ % % , %
&
, ,
% + '
,
0
'
, &( *
$ ( 1 # , &( * ( /
2 8!
C
.,!
< * ) (*
.& . ., , . !
E(
((
(
) (*
"
) (*
+ ,- .,
/ (
..!
* ( ( " # % +- (
3 / % %
. 0
3 #
% . .
.
0
."
3 #
%
.
$ *!" # .
."
4
3 #
%
.
0 . 3 #
%
.
3 #
% .
4 . 1
%
. . 1
%
.
% . 56 .
.
% 0
.
.
0
6"
4
3 #
% .
0
.+!
"
( ( .&!
*
% + 9 :- ,,,,$3
9 .8&',,,$3 % + =
(* + ,- .,,+ 9 -,,,,,$3
* ( = ( 7 , .,,+ = "
7 , .,,& ") -?
*
* 9 +,,,,,$3
*
(* 6= 3
*
% +
( * *
*
.-!
(
B3-
3= * % &
@ (
# *
@ ( * ( .,,+ .'!
. ,: .,,+ 16= 3.2 % &
(
(* + ,- .,,+
#
( ( *
(*
.. ,8 .,,+ 16= 372 6 4 ;5 5"
6
# *
% ..,
&
(* + ,- .,,+ *
,- ,8 .,,+ % % &
( * (
* * * .7!
% +
$ * % & '
.& ,8 .,,+ *(
< $*
(
( .- ,8 .,,+ 4 .- ,8 .,,+ % & '
6 4 ;5
"*
* ( $*
* < "
*
@ (
(
B3.
3= *
.:!
;5
.- ,. 8:7 $ * #
(
*
(
(* ( 6 4
%
& 6= 3& .8 ,8 .,,+ ;5 +, ,8 .,,+ 16= 3:2
.8!
C 6 4 ;5 % & '
,+ , .,,+ 16= 3.&2
"*
"
( <
* ) ,: , .,,+ 16= 382
( % &
6 4 ;5
'
+,!
% :
#
3 7 1
.
&( &
. ) .
. &* '
6
'
8
) . &* &* 1
'
. #6 0 &(
8
.
&*
2 + !
%
- , .,,+
( ,8 , .,,+ 16= 3'2 6 4 ;5 "
1 % + = * =
7 , .,,& ,8 , .,,+ 16= 3'2 4 - , .,,+
" % :8& .,,+ 6= 3 , - , .,,+ "
6= 3 , +.!
% '
* (
* & , .,,+$ - , .,,+ " 6= 38$C ++!
D
- , .,,+ ( * ) ( % - * (
# % '
3 *$ % & '
* (
+&!
3 * % & '
3 * - , .,,+ 16= 3.$'2 +-!
% + *
6= 38$ . , .,,+ 0* % ',:
.,,+ 6 4 $ - , .,,+ + . .,,+ 16= 3 2 ( *
(
2 "3) "
* 3 *
3 *
040 " * .. ,+ .,,& 16= 3 .2
"
( *
+'!
4 . ,& .,,& % :8& .,,+
) .: ,7 .,,&
* ,& ,- .,,& ( 16= 3 &2 4 ,& ,- .,,&
) . ,- .,,&
* )
0
( ( (
*
. ,- .,,& 4 + ,- .,,& (
3 * - , .,,+ ( % :8& .,,+ " * . ,- .,,& 93 *
+ ,- .,,& 16= 3.$:2 +7!
(
= " % '
6 4 ;5
**
< +, ,' .,,& % & '
$* *
( 3 * D
3 * 6= 3.-
,. ,7 .,,&
% & '
(
+:!
4 .+ ,7 .,,& * * 4 .: ,7 .,,& % :8& .,,+
4 ( # * *
, ,: .,,& 16= 3 +2
(
0 9 % & -& .,,&
% & '
( 6= 3 + *
,- , .,,& +8!
4 .. . .,,& % & '
6= 3 '
*
( "* ( * % & '
* ) ( 6 4 ( - , .,,+
) ( 6 4 ;5
* : ,7 .,,- 16= 3 82 % ) (
*
( *
% & '
8 , .,,:
16= 3 82 &,!
% &8& .,,+
,: ,: .,,- F
% & '
*
*
* ) "
*
"( ( ( **
* = E
8 , .,,- 16= 3 &2 (
3 9 $
4 . : (
: (
4 . ' ;
4 ' (' . .
4
: (
3
4 1 '
4 . '
4 . %
. * 7 .
'
1
6 (
. * 7 ;.' . : (
3 % .
< !$ , .
"
)
; . .
+
4
4
' 5.
.
(
3 % .
< !$ , .
"
)
: ( 1'
.
.
. * 7'
;'
. * 7 1
* 7 .
6 '
.'
.
6 2 & !
D
6 4 ;5
3 * (
*
,- . .,,- 16= 3. 2 % & '
;5 ( 3 * - , .,,+
* % ,,8 .,,'
, ,: .,,'
16= 3 :2
"( * ( *
4 +8 .3 00 5*
(* *
0
*
( 9 - ,$3 ., . ., , &.!
*
(
4 .
.
00
(
"# (
*
&+!
D
'( &-)( )% )0
#-)( )% /12234+, ;F" =
( *
"
( "# ;F" =
!$ %1% %4#"
)%
-# .'#" )%)/ +555143,3 (
'
9 1
F F2 "( *
'
( *
* # *
2 1"2
12
(
*
"
( *
(* * < #
"(
"
D
"
# *
'12 " *
* " *
(
)0 !) / %' - )% 0
6 6 ) )% /1+55742885
) (* ( "
" (
#
(
#
#
) "# G &&!
9 '
) 0
& ! )- )%
/ +5521+48++ "#
( D ) (*
)0 !) / %' - )% 1
"( "#
( *
&-!
(
" -)1% %4 '(
)% 0
)- !% '
%-1% %4
'(
)% /1+5,4:,
( *
(* =
=
*( =
&'!
D ;
< = 0
! ;'! /1+534 327 ;F" = ( *
F
"
=
) *
*
# " * ( ( * =
)
=
( ( * *
(
.,
( * *
%
(* (
# * (( " = ( ( *
"#
( * 9
* (( *
( * D "
;F" = ;
< =
" -) 1% %4 '(
)% 1
= (
&7!
( ** ) (
(
(( ( 5 4 & + 00 "(
) "
(
-%%->'- 1% %4 #"
0
!
-)( !/ +51+4 '!?+7 "* * 4 & + 00 (
# *
&:!
(
"(
*
(
* =
( * 6= 3
* B (( ( (
* 9 :-,,,,,$3
* + ,- .,,+ ,: ,+ .,,: ((
* = 3 = * * % + (
* 9 :-,,,,,$3
( (
*
*
;5 " ( *
(
"
( &8!
* (
( "
( D 3 ( " (
4 .
.
00
-,!
9 (
:
* ) 6= 38 "* (
" =
(* + ,- .,,+ ( * ) "
( *
(
( - !
! % ##%'
'
1+41% %4'(
0
-#-& ) )% /1+55243?8+
D , .,,-
0 / ( 2 * )
( **
* * )
* = .+ ,7 .,,& * " * ( *
"
(* -.!
.
.
00 "
) (* (
( <
E
* *
"
!
- )% 0
! -)%&-; '/22:14< 888 -+!
(
% & '
;5
(
* )
*
(
"#
* )
* *
'12
( * G *
(
% + 4 *
) (*
-&!
"* 6 4
(( ( * .: ,7 .,,& ,& ,- .,,&
(
) . ,- .,,&
(( )
0
" ( (
4 . ,- .,,& 3
( *
( 3 * - , .,,+
*
**(
( (
--!
(
( * "*
(
(* + ,- .,,+
* " "
% +
*
*
"
% &
# * % + * ( .,,+
*
( % & . ,: .,,+ 16= 3.2 " ( *
#
( %
6 4 ( *
.. ,8 .,,+ 16= 372 6 % +
( **
,- ,8 .,,+ % & ( * (
* -'!
"
6 4 ( * ( .- ,8 .,,+ *
% '
" 6 4 ( *
( ;5
(
(
** *
(*
(
6 4 % +
% & '
% % & '
( ")
)0 !) / %' - )% 1 #
= % & ' #
(
( % & '
" G
-7!
(
) (*
=
% & '
"
!$ %1% %4 #"
)% (
* B (
)0 !) / %' - )%
!$ %1% %4#"
)% 1 %' ! 0
=$-)%-)( )% /+55:1,4 1-04?37 "#
(
( *
) (*
"
(
= % & '
D (
** "
"
6 4 ;5
** ( =
(* + ,- .,,+
* % &
#
* * *
=" -:!
D
# ( #
"# " (( *
( (
" =(
(* + ,- .,,+ D
"
;F" =
! $ % 1% %4 #"
)%
)0 !) / %' - )% 1
= * H
% & '
G -8!
D "
# ( 4
) .
)% ) 0
- -)( )% / +557134
1-04:55
;
!!% # -%'
)%
& #%'
#1.4#"
)% /1+55548 ?5+
"#
81"2
= ( < ( (
@
#
',!
D ( *
( % & '
% & '
( 8
81"2 ( * ) " = *
4 .
.
00 ( * ) ( * . '
!0
- ! )% )/+55,1+4 1-0- +8:
) )-0
& -#-)(/+55,1,4 1-03?3 ' !
D ! ($ ); '0
-)%<
-)(/22+14
32 * *
"# *
* )
* 4 .
.
00
"
* ")
(
"# ;F" = '#'@-)(0
/ 28?14:5 * 4 .
.
00 (
"
* *
( D * * *
* (
I
(*
#
D *
" C
-)( )% 0
0-)%-)( )% /+5531,4 1-0- '.!
D
( *
(*
( *
D -)%&- -)(0
<! % / 1+5+43 7+ ;F" = (
#
( * #
( (
" (
(
(3 ) *
(
*
( '+!
% & '
( (
( (
"
(*
* (
*
*
# D
% & '
(
"* " 6 4
= (
"
(
'&!
D "
)0 !) / %' - )% 1
=
" "# D "
).
)% )/
;
!!% # -%'
)%
%' !F 1 2 % & '
*
1 * 4 .
.
00 . '
!4 ) )-
! ($ ); 'F 1 2
% & '
'-!
( % :8& .,,+ ( ( ( ( * .: ,7 .,,& ,& ,- .,,&
( * *
( )
0
"
(
% & '
(( *
*
(
( 3
* * < (
="
''!
* ( :
* )
*
* )
( % + (
% & '
(
( * )
2
% + * ( ( "
(* (
( *
* " , .,,- (( **
*
=
< ( *
*
* *
* = *
*
( -&
*
* ) (* 6= 3 & '7!
" #
*
*
* 4 .
.
00
( " ( % & '
(* D % & '
* (
*
"
(
% & '
*
(
( % & '
"
* 4 '12 *
( " ( # % 12 12 *
/ (*
) (*
':!
"
"# ( * "# *
*
" "( '8!
(
(* 6= 3
(*
*
(* D
" ( *
*
(* ( , .,,-
(
(
(
(
* ) (*
"
* ( ) (*
(
7,!
D (H
*
*
(
* /
., '
# )