← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/396/2015allowed

Amandeep Kaur v. Sukhram Singh

2017-10-27Mr. Justice Krishna Murari,Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh6 pages

  

    

 

 ! "#$$%&'&() %#*$+,-

, ."(/$$01"2+ 300$44"(# 5' 6278+".6&(98 3 $'0(/$(#  )  :;  66  :;  6  6 6  

+$'$(#) +68"4&<"4-/=%"#$+#8$"00$44"(#

$'0(/$(#6278+".&(0$+'(     >&$8"'0+$$++$/#8&'"00$"4"9"&('##8$?2/9.$(#"(//$%+$$ /"#$/292'# -

/&''4=&(9#8$."++&"9$#8$0"+#&$'2(/$+6$%#&(

#8$&(/2"++&"9$%#8$+$'0(/$(#@82'*"(/8"/&4$/"0$#&#&( 2(/$+ 6$%#&(   #8$ &(/2 ."++&"9$ %# + /&''42#&(  ."++&"9$ "44$9&(9#8"##8$."++&"9$<"''4$.(&A$/( $*+2"+B

-

<&#82#"(B /<+B   $."4$ %8&4/ "=($$# 1"2+ <"' *+( 2#  #8$ <$/4%7 &( 6$0#$.*$+

>8&4$4$=$44&(9"44$9"#&('%+2$4#B&#8"'*$$("=$++$/ &(#8$0$#&#&(#8"##8$"00$44"(#<&$&'"("*(+."44"/B(#'&(%$+$##8$ ."#+&.(&"44&$#$+2+.(#8'."++&"9$'8$8"/4$#8$+."#+&.(&"4 8.$ <&#82# "(B %"2'$  68$ 8"/ +$2'$/ # "%%$0# #8$ $+  #8$ +$'0(/$(##'#"B#9$#8$+ "(%8"B"#'<$+$"++"(9$/"'"+$'24#<8&%8

   '8$ ?&($/ #8$ ."#+&.(&"4 8.$ *2# 2'$/ # &44#+$"# "(/ ."4#+$"# #8$ 82'*"(/ "' '8$ ($=$+ 0+=&/$/ #$"- %$$- $#% # 8&. "(/ +$2'$/ # 47"#$+#8$92$'#'"(/".&4B.$.*$+'"(/2'$/&4#8B"(/2(84B<+/' #<"+/'#8$+$'0(/$(#"(/8&'0"+$(#'<&#82#"(B+$"'("(/$C%2'$68$ 2'$/##8+<2#$('&4'"(/<"'&(#8$8"*&#4$"=&(9#8$."#+&.(&"48.$ <&#82#&(+."#&("(/&(#&."#&($+'#"B&(#8$."#+&.(&"48.$<"' (4B

.(#8'"#$+."++&"9$8$"00$44"(#."/$@D"##$.0#'#4$"=$#8$ ."#+&.(&"48.$(#8$*"'&'0$##B/&'02#$'(#8$.(#86$0#$.*$+ 

- " $."4$ %8&4/ <"' *+( "(/ <8$( #8$ +$'0(/$(# "(/ 8&' ".&4B .$.*$+'8"/9($#'$$#8$%8&4/#8$*$8"=&2+#8$"00$44"(#"(/8&' ".&4B.$.*$+'<"'(#9/#&'%4"&.$/#8"##8$"00$44"(#8"/.$(#"44B #+#2+$/ #8$ +$'0(/$(# "(/ &# <"' &.0''&*4$+ 8&. #4&=$ "(/ %8"*&# <&#8 8$+    %.0+.&'$ <"' $$%#$/ *$#<$$( #8$ 0"+#&$' *B =&+#2$  <8&%8#8$B8"/.2#2"44B/$%&/$/#/&''4=$#8$&+."++&"9$"(/#4$"/"( &(/$0$(/$(#4&$"(/'8$8"/+$%$&=$/ 4"%'"'4&$#&.$."&(#$("(%$"(/ $C0$('$' ( %#*$+ D- 

 &( 0+%$$/&(9' 2(/$+ 6$%#&(    #8$ &(/2"++&"9$%#*2#"##8$#&.$'$%(/'#"#$.$(#'8$8"/<&#8/+"<( 8$+%('$(#"(//&/(#+$#2+(#8$".2(#"''2%8'8$8"/%..&##$/*+$"%8 #8$#$+.'#8$%.0+.&'$ 8$"00$44"(#%(#$'#$/#8$/&=+%$0$#&#&(*B&4&(9+$04B( #8$+$04B'8$%4"&.$/#8"#"'2.  4"%'<"''0$(#*B8$+0"+$(#' *2#'8$<"'."4#+$"#$/(#8$0+$#$C#/$."(//<+B8$+$'0(/$(# 9"=$ *+2#"4 *$"#&(9' # #8$ "00$44"(# 2(/$+ #8$ &(42$(%$  4&E2+ "(/ &(#C&%"(# "(/ "#$+ #8$ *&+#8  $."4$ %8&4/- 8&' *$8"=&2+ #<"+/' 8$+ *$%.$ .+$%+2$4($%$.*$+

-#8$+$'0(/$(#82'*"(/"(/8&'

  0"+$(#'9"=$*$"#&(9'#8$+"(/#2+($/8$+2##8$."#+&.(&"48.$( +/$+ # '"=$ 8&' ".&4B .$.*$+' +. #8$ %+&.&("4 0+%$$/&(9' 8$ 8"/ $(#$+$/ &(# %.0+.&'$ # &4$ "( "004&%"#&( 2(/$+ 6$%#&(    #8$ &(/2"++&"9$%#"(/"9+$$/#0"B"'2.

4"%'$8"/0"&/

4"%'"##8$#&.$+$%+/&(9&+'#'#"#$.$(#*2#/&/(#8"=$ ' 4"%'"##8$#&.$&("4'$##4$.$(# ( #8$ 04$"/&(9'  #8$ 0"+#&$'- #8$ 44<&(9 &''2$' <$+$ +".$/)  >8$#8$+ 0$#&#&($+ &' '2*?$%#$/ # %+2$4#B *B #8$ +$'0(/$(#G   >8$#8$+ +$'0(/$(# /$'$+#$/ 0$#&#&($+ <&#82# "(B+$"'("*4$%"2'$G

  >8$#8$+0$#&#&(&'."&(#"&("*4$G

 D >8$#8$+ 0$#&#&($+8"'( 4%2' '#"(/&"(/ %"2'$ "%#&(#&4$#8$0+$'$(#0$#&#&(G





$4&$H ''2$   <"' /$%&/$/ &( "=2+  #8$ +$'0(/$(# "(/ #8$ ."++&"9$ <"' /&''4=$/ *B " /$%+$$  /&=+%$ ( "00+$%&"#&(  #8$ $=&/$(%$0+/2%$/*$+$#8$2+# 2+&(9 #8$ 0$(/$(%B  "00$"4- #8$ +$'0(/$(#82'*"(/ <"' +$E2&+$/ #0"B "'2.  '

@ "'&(#$+&. 4&#&9"#&( $C0$('$'   $ "00$"+$/ #8+298 8&' %2('$4 ( 0+&4 I- 

, *2# #8$+$"#$+ ( ($ "00$"+$/+8&."(/8$<"'0+%$$/$/"9"&('#$C0"+#$(24B -

, ( "%%2(#  8$ 8"=&(9  +$."++&$/ /2+&(9 #8$ 0$(/$(%B  #8$ "00$"4- %(#$.0# 0+%$$/&(9' 8"=$ *$$( &(&#&"#$/ "9"&('# 8&.  $'0(/$(# <"'

   '2..($/*B *"&4"*4$ <"++"(#' &(     $ "00$"+$/*$+$ #8$2+# "(/9"=$"(2(/$+#"7&(9#0"B#8$4&#&9"#&($C0$('$' '

@&(#8$ '8"0$  *"(7 /+"# *2# 8$ "&4$/ # 24&44 #8$ 2(/$+#"7&(9  C0"+#$ 0+%$$/&(9'<$+$'$#"'&/$"9"&('#8&.'2*?$%##0"B.$(#

@&( "//&#&(#'2. '

@"'&(#$+&.4&#&9"#&($C0$('$'8$+$'0(/$(# 8"/2(/$+#"7$(#0"B#8$%'#(6$0#$.*$+I-

, ( %#*$+ - 

, 8$ <"' 0+$'$(# &( #8$ 2+# *2# /&/ (# *+&(9 '2.  '

@ /$'0&#$#8$/$."(/0"B.$(#%'#*B%2('$4+#8$"00$44"(#(=&$< '"&/%&+%2.'#"(%$'#8&'2+#8"/("4#$+("#&=$$C%$0##'#+&7$8&' /$$(%$&(#8$"00$"48$"00$"4<"'+/$+$/#*$#"7$(20( %#*$+,- 

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

  >$8"=$%('&/$+$/#8$?2/9.$(##8$4<$+2+#&(%(#$C# # #8$ '#"#$.$(#  "00$44"(# "' >  +. <8$+$ &# &' "00"+$(# #8"# '8$ "/.&##$/ #8"# '8$ 9# 8$+ '#"#$.$(# +$%+/$/ ( 0+&4

- 

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

#8$+$'0(/$(#"'<$44"'8&'0"+$(#' 8"/9&=$(*+2#"4*$"#&(9'"(/8"/#2+($/8$+2##8$."#+&.(&"48.$# <"'2(/$+#8'$%.0$44&(9%&+%2.'#"(%$'#8"##8$"00$44"(#<"'0+$''2+&A$/ #&4$"004&%"#&(2(/$+6$%#&( #8$&(/2"++&"9$%#"(/"9+$$ #+$%$&=$"'2.

4"%'#0"+#%.0"(B/2*#-'2. 4"%' 8"/ *$$( +$%$&=$/ *B 8$+  # 8"' "4' %.$ ( #8$ +$%+/ #8"# " '2. 

 4"%'8"/*$$('0$(#(#8$."++&"9$"'0+=$/*B#8$"00$44"(#"(/ 8$+"#8$+&#826&(98*B"00$"+&(9"' >#<"'"4<"B'0$(##8$ "00$44"(# # <&#8/+"< 8$+ %('$(# "#$+ '&C .(#8' &( 0+%$$/&(9' 2(/$+ 6$%#&( #8$&(/2"++&"9$%#8$'"&/+&98#8"'*$$(9&=$(2(/$+ 4$9&'4"#&( ( %"'$'8$8"/ +$%$&=$/ " '2.  4"%'#8$'"&/".2(# %24/$&#8$+8"=$*$$(/$."(/$/*"%7*B#8$82'*"(/+&#%24/8"=$*$$( "/?2'#$/&(#8$"%%2(#."&(#$("(%$#<8&%8"<&$8"'9#"'#"#2#+B +&98#$+$4B*$%"2'$#8$"00$44"(#8"/"#'$%(/.#&(-(((+$%$&0#

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

4&#&9"#&($C0$('$'+/$+$/*B#8&'2+#"(/(9+2(/ <+(9 &(/&(9' "++&=$/ "# *B #8$ 4<$+ 2+# +$9"+/&(9 "00$44"(# 8"=&(9 /$'$+#$/#8$+$'0(/$(# 8$"00$"4&'"44<$/8$?2/9.$(#"(//$%+$$0"''$/*B#8$ 4<$+2+#&''$#"'&/$<&#82#0+$?2/&%$##8$+&98#'#8$"00$44"(## 4$9"44B 0+%$$/ "9"&('# #8$ +$'0(/$(# + 8"=&(9 +$."++&$/ /2+&(9 #8$ 0$(/$(%B  #8$ "00$"4 &( %(#$.0# 0+%$$/&(9' "(/ #8$+ 0+%$$/&(9' "="&4"*4$##8$"00$44"(# 6!

,    6 6! '"(?"B   >8$#8$+'0$"7&(9@+$"'($/) $'@ >8$#8$++$0+#"*4$) $'@