Makhan Singh v. Punjab State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd. And O
!" #!$
% $"#!#& '( ')* %
+* ,,-- ./
0 12% .
-%0,,- /,/ 3 */
,
% $4#!#& '( %5/ %
+* ,,-- ./
0 12% .
-%0,,- /,/ 3 */
,
"
% 6#!#& '( ')* %
+* ,,-- ./
0 12% .
-%0,,- /,/ 3 */
,
' 73'% %
"
##$% & ##$'
()#( *+ "
!##,# ()#(
9 - ./ "
!##$% ##$'
##,# ()#( /
0 1
2
"
!##$% ()#(
"
!##$% ()#( / ./ #4#)()## 6/
3
7 / ./ )'#(())'
* 6/ 13+ 7 ( + / ( 8)9 / !% #$9 + 4$9 "$4$:#');7 / 1< "$(8#:,;7 =
" :)%)#4%;7 . 1
> #(9
./
/ !8
!#7.3
*
* ? * /
+ / * #4$,
/7 !#
3 @ * #()8#44%
7 !( @/ #()8#44%
!
/7 !% A )'#)#44) 1 *17 !8
3 )#)%#44$
( B + #44%748 3
%
3
"
/
( +
/1 + 0 . + 1 +
1
/ ;
/ + / A + /+ + /7 + /
A / 0 + + / +
+ 3
2 + #44%748 (:$%$48) 0 !#
/1 A + 317 ,*:
- ./ ;*0 */
,/ <- 5* - .-0 * 5* %#)%#44:
%)%')8))) ,$%8( #4:'$4:
8;4:
(4%$))) ,'8:# ())4, %;4'
##,#7,47))) :$($'
':8(,$ ,;4'
%4447'(7))) ::#)4 %)'8((( - '(#'4)))) $4 $:#') + 3 +
/ /
-+ 0 +
0 + 1 /1 2 * @ 2*@ 1 (('#:
3/ 1 / 3 #8$#:
C ')
/ . 0 + 0 "+ + 1 @
= 2*@ 1
"#)':$%4%;7 1
+
"%'8$());7
@
":)%)#4%;7
( 0 3
1
+
1/ 2*@
A
2*@
D + 0
5 / /
2*@
+ / +
@
"(#:4),;7 + +
@ / /
7 /
-
% /
- + 3 (
/
1
!#
+ 3. /
3 + 7. +
/ "
/ /
@
=
@ 1
/ / / =
$ !# 3
/ / = /
3
+ 1 / / /
= (9 @ 3
!# 3+ * @/
+ + 1 / + /+ + . +
+ !( * @/
/ !#
+ #44%748 @
!# = (:$% C + #44%748 / !( D / & - A ;@;5+ / C + * * / /
/ / = / $ , + D+
" ()# .3 E F "
!#
3 /
!( 1
3. !#
1
3 !# + 1
@
)#):#448 ##;#448
)####448
-
!#7
/ ! + )####448
!#
/+ 3/ !# -
+ 3 + 1 3
@ !%
!#
+ /
@ 13
/ )()%#44$
/
@ !( 3 0 2*@ !% 3
F !8
/
2
/ 1
*7 # F + "#:,(,8,#;7G A ( F
G A % F
3 7. + G A5 8 F +
G A57# $ F G A5 , F
3
A5
> : F G A5 ' "
+ 3
(')(#44'
H=( %))8#44:
H=%
%)),#44'
H=8
())# )4)(())) 1
=
E+
F7# 1 3/ +
+ @ + %)('7)8 C
/1 + H=#
/ * + /
/7 !#
- 0
-+ %))8#44:
H=% (')(#44'
H=(
%)),#44'
H=8
($,88'
3/ 1 / (8%,($7,) C + %%$$8 3/ 1 / %#':,7%) C
/ ($%( 3/ 1 / #,''):
C 1+ = /
@
(4($%8 3/ 1 / (::#'474:
C A (,4,$:
3/ 1 / ($8,'(7)% C 2*@ (('':
3/ 1 / #8('47)8 C . 2*@ 0 +
@
/ '(#'4) C
=
1.
/ 6 F7( 1 (
+ #44%748
/ 6 3/ )()8#44:
H=, 1
// ;5 8$::) 3/
+ 1 ((:$$ 3/
=
? (')8#44:
H=:
= = 3/ // ##)$#44:
-+ / + = #,)$#44:
H='
1
-
#(),#44:
& ##):#44:
H= /
/ ##)'#44:
H=##
*1 / + = + 4#, 3/ F7(
1.
/
D (#'%4 = 3/
. 3/ "(8;7 3/
/+ = 3/ "$(8#%,;7
/ . 1 + + =
6 *
2 F7%
!( @/ + #44%748 * ( 3
0 %
+
; / 5 + #44%748 ( (:$%$478) C 1 A 1 / ($8,'()% C
#448 6+ #44:
6 * F7%
+
/;
?
/ /; 1 / 3 #8(':)% C /
. 2*@
@ + H=#8 H=#$ 3 /
/
.
- .
H=() H=('
/ /
( 0 3
+ 2 * @ 2*@
+ H=%( H=$:
2*@ 3
+ 3
- 3
2*@
"(#:4),;7
- 3 / 0 +
2*@ / 31 )%###44, (8)##44: 1 / / "($::);7 "#):')$;7
2*@
"%%:)';7
/7 5F7#
7=
+ #44%748 1 / (:$%$48) C
+ !
/ 5F7(
+ + 1
!
( * / /
+ . ":)%)#4%;7 %
/ /
- + 3
/
/ + + 3 / -
+ 7 +
A / * 1 *
?
/
1 ./ I3
*
! ! "#$ %#! &'( ()), (
*- (,
+ / /
+ /
? 7 !
./ / * D *
) &'$
! ! "#'!( *"
!,($% ()## ),#(()#(
@ + / . /
+ /
F
/ ./
%#!
&'* * 3 * + +
3 "
./
'% +)! $
! ! #'! ( ())4 8
?"
%:$ 13+ * =
./ /
%#! &'* @ ./
./
%#! &'* I3
*
3 / 31 !#
/ 3 + +
I3
* + /
3 I3
*
1 + 3 1
1 + / /
+ /
/ + /
/ +
+ 2
./ *
,' &'$
! ! "#'!( * " !8,#8 ()#( #:)'()#(
. * 3 =+
+ = + /+
+
?
3 +
# ./ + ./ /
) &' '% +)!
,' &'* 13+
/ + /
/ /; 0 + *
3
/ /
/ ./
/ +
+ 1
*
! 3 0 1
"+ /
"
##$% ##$'
##,# ()#(
( ##)%()#$ .