Commissioner Of Income Tax Faridabad v. M/S Carrier Air-Conditioning And Refrigeration




  
   



           
 !"

# $ # %%&& ' ( ) *+

  , #'  - # 

- ' .

  &/0 1    2'#3  % ' 4        
 !"

# $ # %%&& ' ( ) *+

  , #'  - # 

- ' .

  &/0 1    2'#3  % '

  !

"#$% &'( %(&)*+
, - !%+&'( % !

"#$% &'( %-((
!.$ 5' % '  & &% %  /$ &&1#''6)#- '7
45' '$  

#'' % '  '7
85' '6)#- ')&#$ % '# '-'7

 '9 *  6 :"#( '"  ' %%&& ' * % 0% "#( '1' *  /); -"#( '"  ' % ' <<<< (&)*+
 &.

&3    1&& #%  
  ! %% &  =8= # =8> 4?= & @)'  & 1  (&(# $'' 

' ($ ' 0


=8= 4?= 4 ' ' %% &  -  ' '     '
  ! %%&& ' $) &# -' %%&& 'A %% & -  ''  '    
 !.%% &3
.%% &3#&'#'

# &&1  1

'/% (  '' % '  ''  ' / >>B,>> #4??,?4 8  %%&& '  ' # ' ' ' &&1 - )$'

' & @)'  & 1 9, C3
  

          

    

                   





             

      

 

   

   

  

    

  

          



      

          ! "    #  $

 " %&''( )*+   ,& %-"  .

/  $

*0,+,'     

1 5  ( 1 # ' @)'   ()    '

% ',  # -  '' %%&& ', ( ) = ) (1 )$'

' &@)'  & 1# ' 
/ ( '" ' @)'   1 #  ()    ' % ',   (1 '6)#- '  (   ') ' #$/ 6)#- ' ';)% ) ' D  % ' &#  ')

     "E4"??">B?+,  (# ')

 #& # '       ' 1  %&'#) ' =8.83 '
 !'">F.

  'G' 'A3 '  '' &    "F="?="4??+,    # #$'# 














 

















 






! 
 




 






"



#


$%&

$%'


(

 
(#
)
*









"


!



+


,

-



!


(#
)






!!

 





!




.


!
!!



+#

 




+

.



!






 







+

 .


#





!




 


,
!





+#


 

!
!


!
 &


(#
)
!







!!!




!!

#


  
(#
)
!






 
 


+
!!








!

/
!


 




!#





!!





!




!!

#

) #




!!





 


#

(#
)





"


+


,




!
#


&$0$101


( 
2 -

0(1
!!

,
!


-

(!!
!



!!,
!
!#


!!,
!#


! '



!!

!


#






!



3

 -








#

 








3






#




!!










 
(#
),






!!





,






#

#
!!


!!
 


##






!



(



-

0(1


#









# 





!












!











3







 






!



 !

-


##



!#

+




!!





#

!#

!!!#




 



 

!


 
-








#

!#



!




!


#

 



!#












#
 +

!5
 





 








 








*!!
 
 


!!


,

 $


*



 





6#


7 
8


2





   

!" #!!

$%&'(


!
!



!


7 
8
!

9



     

   

  !"

       "  

       ! #   !     # #     $  %     !   %  

 

       #   

     

  "     !     #    "    &

   " '  

(  ) *+,-,. /0 )1 + 

 "     

         #      !  

     # "        #  "   

         #       # "      !   %    ) 

#     %%  #   



 %  " 

      #       2  "  " #    3  

  



     

 %     #   !

!

 

     %

  4445 $$




!
 


,
 


6#


:
2

)* +
 %  

 


," 
)!

$-(-



!


7


 





!!





!








!
#
-



#
#


01


 !! 
:
2
6


;

#
<
$%

:
2
!
!




 





!
01



+#




*

 !


*




!







#
 $ -




!










.;HI
 3 

  ;
 .;;52
3   

  ( A