High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/65/2014dismissed

Rishi Sagar v. Commissioner Of Income Tax Ludhiana & ANR

2016-03-28Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan5 pages

!"#$$!"%

&'()

"*! +!,-, . /0

(. 12(33 2 12(3 33 4!-!

*. (4%5(,**"%6+7"*! 4*8!"$$!%%"

* (494"3, :8;%"46+7"*! 4*8!4!-$ +!

*- "<!-8, +"% 8!"--!--!!,-, "$$!"%= +!43!*, *8! !

"#*6 > & 4-84*61*8!*1)":", -**8!4+!4 0

06$"--!+?@ *8! !"#$$!%%"*!4,?= "%68"

+,:"48!

8A168"

+,:"48& 4 -84*6 1*8! 4,?= "%1) 4 *8! "--!-- !

* @!"4

C8+C

064",-, :*8! %%D, :-=?-*"

*,"%E=!-*, %"D.

F&,) G8!*8!4, "*-"

+,4= -*"

!- *8!$4!-!

* "-!6*8!"*, *8!2+=*84,*,!-?!%D, ,:

4, :

*8!$47,-,

&) *8!*,-%!:"%%@ = -=-*", "?%!, *8!!@!- %"DH &,,) G8!*8!4, "*-"

+,4= -*"

!- *8!"-!6*8!%+ =*84,*,!- ?!%D =:8* * 8"7! !,*8!4 *"5! , * -,+!4"*, *8!"++,*, !=$ 4!!,7, 4! "

+4!$4* 4 *8!4:*"

E=,4@E="*8!

$"@ !

*?!, : "+! 4 *8!"-84!+,*"= "--!--!!"- , !8"-"4=!+**8!"--!--!!D8,8

=%+?!8"4:!"?%!**"#= +!4*8!*H &,,,) G8!*8!4, "*-"

+,4= -*"

!- *8!"-!6*8!

"*, *8!"=*84,*,!- !!--,*"*!*8"**8! "**!4?!

4! -,+!4!+?@*8!%+=*84,*,!-?!%D* +*8!

7!4",*@ *8!"7!4 !

*- *8!"--!--!!H &,7) G8!*8!4 , "*- "

+ ,4= -*"

!- *8! "-!6 *8!

"*, *8!"=*84,*,!-?!%D6*8!, $=:

!+4+!4-"4!

%!:"%%@ -=-*", "?%! , *8! !@!- %"D "- *8! %+ =*84,*,!- ?!%D ",%!+ * !#!4,-! *8! +,-4!*,

<=+,,=-%@HI 2!"4 !+= -!% 4*8!"--!--!!-=? ,**!+*8"* +=?*"**8!

*, ! *6*8!"--!--!!=%+ * =4 ,-8*8!4!E=,-,*!+!*",%-"

+ *8!"=+,*!+ "= *- * "=%* *8!8"4*!4!+ = *"

*6 8D!7!46"**8!*, ! 8!"4, : *8!"$$!"%?!

4!*8! ,--, !4

!"#&$$!"%-)B62=+8,"

" 4-84*61&)16?"%"

!-8!!*D"-

=4 ,-8!+*D"- 4 *8! "*!4,"%$4+=!+"**8"* -*":!*8"*,*D"- %"4, ,!+ *8"* !4*", " = *-6 D8,8 D!4! -8D , *8! 4!+,* *8!

4!+,*4-"= *-8"+6, "*6?!!

%!"4!+8!*4"

-D!4!*84=:8 ?"

5"= *-++,*, -D!4! "+!-*"*, :*8"**?!= !+, ! !*8!" = *-8"+?!!

$",+*84=:8?"

5*4"

+*8!4!D"-

+,-$=*!"?=**8"*6"++,*, !$4+=!+?@*8!"--!--!!?!

*8!&)-8=%+8"7!?!!

-,+!4!+8!"=*84,*,!-8"7, : ",%!+* "$$4!,"*!*8!-" !, 7,%"*, *8!$47,-,

&) *6*8,- ?!, : "-=?-*"

*,"% E=!-*, %"D6*8!4+!4$"--!+ ?@*8!

4,?= "%+!-!47!-*?!-!*"-,+! *8!*8!48"

+6%!"4 !+= -!% 4*8!!7!

=!-=? ,**!+ *8"* %"4:!-"%!+,-4!$"

,!- = +, $4+=!+?@*8!"--!--!!"**8!*, ! *"

+ 8,- ",%=4!* "

-D!4*8!E=!4,!-4",-!+68,-?5- *-D!4!4!<!*!+"

+*8!

"--!-- !

*D"- 4" !+= +!43!*, 0&0) *8!*8!+,-4!$"

,!- *8!!

*4,!-, 4!+,*4-1"= *-8"7! *?!!

+,-$=*!+?@*8!"--!--!! 7!

"**8!"$$!%%"*!-*":!6*8=:8*8!"--!--!! ,%!+ 4!-8$47,-, "% ! -8!!* *4@, : * !#$%", *8! !

*4,!-6 D8,8 D!4! = + * ?!

0 "

,$=%"*!+ D,*8!"4%,!4?"%"

!-8!!* ,%!+6?=* !7!

*8"* D"- *"

"=+,*!+ ?"%"

! -8!!* 8! "--!--!! ,- *4@, : * %", ,-%"*!+ 4!%,!

: !*4"

*8!"?-!

"=+,*!+?"%"

!-8!!*"

+ !#$%"

"*, 4*8!4+,-4!$"

,!- = +, *-6D8,8 "4!%"4:!, = ?!46-=8"%", ?@*8!"--!--!!"

*?!"!$*!+8!4!

,- !444, *8!4+!4$"--!+?@*8!"=*84,*,!-?!%D-=?-*" *,"% E=!-*, %"D"4,-!-8!"$$!"%+!-!47!-*?!+,- ,--!+ !"4+%!"4 !+= -!% 4*8!$"4*,!-"

+$!4=-!+*8!$"$!4 ?5 8!"--!--!!, *8!$4!-!

*"-! ,%!+!B4!*=4 +!%"4, :8,- !"* 606>/ CB8!"-!D"--!%!*!+ 4-4=*, @*,!D"- -!47!+ =$ *8! "--!--!! E=!-*,

",4! D"- -!

* !-$,*! 4!$!"*!+

*,!--!!5, :,

4 "*, 6*8!"--!--!! ",%!+* $%@D,*8*8!-" !"

=4 ,-84!E=,-,*!,

4 "*, !4*", +"*!-6!7!

!"$$!"4!+ 4*8!

"--!--!! 8! "--!--!! 8"+ =4 ,-8!+ *8! " !- "

+ "++4!--!- *8!

$!4- -6D88"+?!!

-8D *?!-= +4@4!+,*4-"- 0 0

6 +=4, : *8! =4-! "--!-- !

* $4!!+, :-6 *8! "--!--!!

-=? ,**!++= !

,4 "*, 4!+,*, *8!"= *- 4!+,*4- !+,+ *$4+=!"

@?5- *-67=8!4-!*8!?5-

"= *-68!

!6D!4!4!<!*!+"

+*8!"--!-- !

*D"- "+!, 75, $47,-, 0&0) *8!*!-,+!-*8!4+,-4!$"

,!-"

+ "

"%,!- = + , *8! ?5- "= *- , *8! %,-* 4!+,*4-6*8!

"--!--!!8"+-8D "4!+,*" = *, :* 6>>6>/ CB, *8!"=

!D"

3*!!% +=-*4,!-*D"- = +*8"*, 8,-?5- *-6*8!

!D"-J!43, ,%"4D"-*8!$-,*, , *8!"= !:!

*3*!!% +=-*4,!-6"

*8!44!+,*46D8!4!4!+,*?"%"

CBD"- -8D 6D8,8D"-"%- = +*?! ,%, *- 4!+,*48,-,-+!-$,*!*8! "**8"**8!"$$!%%"

*8"+$4+=!+?"%"

,4 "*, !4*, ,"*!- 3=?-*"

*,"% +,

!4!

! D"- = + *8!

$!4!

*":! :4--$4 ,*4"*!-6"- $"4!+**8!$4!7,=-@!"4!4*",

!#$!

-!- %", !+ D,*8=* *8!4! ?!, : "

@ -=$$4*, : 7=8!4- D!4!

+,-"%%D!+8!*"#"?%!, !D"-"--!--!+"*6

60KCB"-":", -*

606>/ CB6+!%"4!+?@*8!"--!--!!

"$$!"%?!

4!*8!&)6$4"@!4D"- "+! 4$!4 ,**, :

*8!"--!--!!*%!"+"++,*, !, *!4 - =%! *8! !

"#=%!-6 > 68D!7!46 +, :*8"* *8!, :4!+,!

*-!

= !4"*!+ *8!"

4!-",+=%! 4$!4 ,**, :*8!"--!--!!*%!"+"++,*, !

?!, :"7",%"?%!6*8!-" !D"-+!%, !+8!4+!4$"--!+?@*8!--!--, :

,!4D"-

,4 !+7!

4!*8!4,?= "%6*8!"--!--!! !**8!-" !

"*!8!?-!47"*, - "+!?@*8!4,?= "%, *8!4+!4$!4*", :* +=* *8!"--!--!!"4!!#*4"*!+?!%D.

K 4+!4*"7",%*8!?!

,* =%! *8!=%!- 4!%"*, *"+ ,--, "++,*, !6*8!"--!--!!,- *-8D"-*8D,*-"-! "+ ,--, "++,*, !

,-7!4!+?@*8! +,*, -$47,+!+= +!4-=?B4=%!& )*4=%!

*8!=%!--4!

!44!+*?@=-, *8!$"4"-8!4!,

"?7!6,*,- *""-! *8!"$$%,"*, %"=-!&")= +!4 D8,8-=8!7,+!

!=%+?!"+ ,**!+?@D"@ "++,*, "% !7,+!

!D8!4!*8!8"+4!

=-!+*"+ ,**8!!7,+!

!8!

"-! *8!"--!--!!D"-*8"*"-*8!!

*4,!- *8!"-84!+,* %, ,*"

+,*-"$$%,"*, D!4! *"7",%"?%!D,*8,*+=4, =4-! *$4!!+, :-6*8!-" !D"- D?!, :

$4+=!+ ?@ D"@ "++,*, "% !7,+!

!6 +!- * !4,* "+ ,--, "- *8! "--!--!! 8"- ",%!+ * !-*"?%,-8 *8!

4!"- "?%!

!-- *8!!7,+!

! *?!, :"7",%"?%!+=4, =4-! *$4!!+, :- ######I =4$, , 6 -=?-*"

*,"%E=!-*, %"D"4,-!-, $4!-!

*"$$!"%8! +=* *8!"--!--!!"

+*8!?5- $4+=!+?@8, +,+ *, -$,4!

,+!

+D!4!4,:8*%@4!<!*!+?@*8!

--!--, :

,!47!

"* *8!"$$!%%"*! -*":!68!$4+=!+ "++,*, "% !7,+!

!, 4 = "=+,*!+$47,-, "%?"%"

!-8!!*"

+*4,!+* *"5!?!

,* !4!%@*D!

*4,!-D8,86, 8,-?5- *"

+*8!

!-8!!*!"4%,!4$4+=!+68!8"+-8D +,

!4!

*%@*"

*?!-",+ *?!" !4!!44464"*8!46,*D"-"+!%,?!4"*!"**! $**+! 4"=+*8!4!7!

=! 8!4!%,!

6D8,8*8!"--!--!!,-%", , :"**8,--*":!!#$%", :*D

*4"

-$!4*", :**8!4!+,*4-6"

*?!!#" , !+, ,-%"*, ,

*8!"?-!

*8!4!

*4,!-, *-6D8,8=%+ *?!

!+?@8, "**8!*, ! *"-*8!E=!4,!-4",-!+?@*8!

--!--, :

,!4D!4! *4!-$ +!+*"

+ $%!*!?5- D!4! *$4+=!+ 4*8!4!"- - !

*, !+"?7!6D!+ * +*8"*"

@ -=?-*"

*,"% E=!-*, %"D "4,-!- , *8! $4!-!

* "$$!"% 8! -" ! ,-6 "4+, :%@6+,- ,--!+ &"<!-8, +"%) =+:! &"4, +!43, :83,+8=) =+:!

!4*!$4*!4)