Balwinder Singh v. Punjab State Cooperative Agricultural Development Bank Ltd And ORS
! "
#
"#
$
%!
"#
$
-. % / 0
& '
' (
'
)
(
*
+, '
(
*
)- )
) '
(
*
).
0"% / / *
*
012* *3
(
"
*!
!
)-4 "
!*
*
*
/'
/
** * !!
" $
!*
!
!
/
*
)-4 "
.
*5 /(-66
)
.
"
)
.
" 7
!
'
(
)
.5 *
*
/'
(
)
.
!
2*8/(9-2
:
4-
!
$
!!
!
2 * 8/( 9-2
:
40;
/
$* / 9-049-2 !!
- *
!
(9-2 ! < = /*
! +
,
:
46
:
4-.
/ . *
!
!!
"
"
$
#
/
*>12 1% 33 !-)
&+&/4 ,
/4
* $ %
5',
(
> 63!027!1% 268/9!1:!2;2!;
1;97<.3%-(
-.*'/(9-0 *
/
* # )-0* 9-0
-9*)
!
(9-0
('
(
)-
/
/! /*
/ /
*>/%/% 1% :!!9!1/3 !-"
)
'+((/'#5 3
*
* 0 *
+,
/
/ $ % 4, 4
(4
>0! 01% 268 / 9!1 :!2;2!; 1;97 < .73 3 !-( .
*5 /(9.(
&4 "7.
The issues involved in the present writ petition are : a) whether Cooperative Society falls within the ambit of 'State' as enumerated under Article 12 of the Constitution of India?'. b) 'whether the writ petition would be maintainable against a Cooperative Society despite the fact that it does not fall
5
within the ambit of 'State'?.
2
&4 <:::::
-9
/ * 5
!7/: - +
,(3
4
/ > >
!
/
*
(( * ! *
-* *3
$ /( ? !
2
*
:::::
-. @(
*
!
> >
*
-*
*3
( !
!
/
6=>+
,
* !39 027! ? +
,3 !
!
*
* ! *
-
> >(
!
;
(
* !
/ *
* *> >@ &
3 *
/ > >
* / $
!
:::::
<-
/* *
!
* *
@
"
!
!
,
/ /
! ?/
*
7 *
( *
/ 5
* !7/: - )29!+ */ 4
:
/%/% - +
,) ? &
!"#$% -0 3
"*
/5
* 8!/: 1%77!
)99;+" ;3 ! 1 3 !"
(()5+
)1;+((
&4 <.2@
*
$ !
*
/
* /3
* /(
/
!
$
* /
@ $ !/
/
/
@
/* $
!
A+, +:::
,(
B
* !
$ * /4
/ *
? * * /
* / * /
*
!/ /
/ $ * !
*
* (
/ /*$ * !
/ $ !
/
!
(
* /@ /
* * !
/
!
@ /!/
**
/ !(
*
/*$ /$
/
! /(
/*$ "
!!
$ @
!
A4 *
: /!/!
?
/ $ !!
*(
*
* /
* /
!
!
*
:
/
/
!
!
*
: /4 +,*
!!
'
* /
4 +-,( $
/
/* !
/
(
/
! /
: / !"
*
*
!
*
* /
* $ @
*
!!
$ * !
4 +,/ $
/
* * /$ = -2 @5
*
/
!!
$
!
(( *!
!
*
!
*
-A
!
/(
* /
* "
"
!!
$ (-62A
@
!
*
$ @(
! @
!
/
4 !!
$
/ !
7 !
4 "
$
!!
*
!
?
/
/ * / * 63! 027! 1% 268 / :!2;2!;1;97<.73@$ %
5',
( (
-.*'/(9-0
& <@
"
"(
3
!
$(
(
!!
/
!
*
@
** @
*
/
48
*
!" #!$@
4
&4 <A3
"
$ *
! !!
!1
/
*
5 ( !! *
$
!1
"
!
! !
"
?/ (
!
$(
!/*
*
!!
/
!1
!"
"
$@
( !! *
$
"
/ ! !
!
*
* C (
/(
$D (* (
(
/ D! !!
!1
6@
* /)
" E *3
-9
%''
"*3
--
* "
/ = ! /( %
&'( ) (*
!" ! #+ $ $(
/
!!
/
! "@
&4 <-5 !
(
/ 99490 /
** *
*
*
'
7**
(
?
/
!
/( $* / 99490
!!
! " -. @ ( 3 *
4
/
$*
/ 99249A@ * /
*
!
-0* *3
3 *
( * (
/
**
*
/
!*
*
3
!
>
/ >* / 99249A
/
!
*
*
!
*
!
!!
@
*
/
!*
!
* >
/ >
* / 99249A-#
*
&
!/
69-(
*
-
/( 3
! *
4
!*
*
'
7**
!*
! "
*
/
$* / 99490
!*"
$ * / 99A496(9924 9A(990492(9949
99.493 *
*
:
(
/
! * ! *
*
*
/*
**
?
! "(
!
*
'
7**
@
/
/* : *
'
7**
*
/1
*
/=
/("
*(
= -6 @
&4 <-- ;
( *
4 "
* > >*
! ** (
*
/4 !4!
3
"
!
* >!
4 !4
/> > > @ *
:
* (
*
*
(
!
/4 !4!
*
* !
/
*
-F-0*
;
*
!
/
8 */ *
= 9 @(
* *
/
*
*
"# !
/
4 !!
$
*
-
-0* *3
* /
*12%1% 33 !+
,
/@
48
* /2< 31/: 1% 33 ! +
,( !*
!
=
A
A
*
*
/ '
!
!
2 *8/( 9-2
!* !
0! 0- +
, $
*
)
*
! * !
*
*
*
/*
6
( * /(
** -9
/*
"
* *
!
"
# ) 0+ 9!
C
"
1
& 1) C
& 1)