Balbir Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS













 




  



 !"# $%%!$ &$ '('

% %$ (!)

!*%#$ '

+$',!*$!%'




 
 
 

    $'$!%- . /&$ 0 1*23 %$

 %#$,$%%!$  
  
 #$, 5$ !%#$, $'$!%,$%%!'  ''( 6 %!%#$ !

%( $    3$ %   '$%%!"  '*$  0,("!$*   *$  * %$*  

 !!$7( $-, ''$* 5


2'!1(*

1'% 3%.

6#$ $ 51 $!% '#,

%%$*%%#$,$%%!$ # $$! ''$''$* '6$

 *$ * %$*

!!$7( $- , ''$* 5 $',!*$!%16#$ $ )$3%!'

5%#$,$%%!$ !%#$$7$3(%!, 3$$*!"'# 2$ $$!

$)$3%$* !*6

!%  ,''$''!# $$! *$ $* ( %#$ , 5$ #

' $$!0 *$  8( '#!"  *$ 



!!$7( $-9, ''$* $,(%5
00''!$ 1.

16#$ $ 51%#$

5%#$,$%%!$

!'% *$  *'0''

)$3%!'1#

' $$!*'0''$*  $

51%#$

3%' %#$3 '$ '0 *$(%!%#$, $'$!%,$%%!

$%# %.(!3,

1(*

3!'% (3%$*'0$'#,'!%#$

   !%#$5$ 

:#$,$%%!$ 6

%%$*'#, !"

'#,  !'%3$ % !%$ 0' !*3!*%!' !*'!3$%#$!%#$,$%%!$ '!,''$''! %# %'#,',$ %$ 0' !*3!*%!' %#$

%0$!%1

! 0(!% 
;1

<-6 '% $, * 5%#$

%%$$!%6!'%

0$!%'

!*  %#$ $

%$  %#$  ,''$''!  6 '  %  $  # !*$*  2$  %  '(33$''

(

**$ <

%%$$ #$!  %#$  $!%  6 '  !%  , *1  !  ,, %!  6 ' 

$*  $',!*$!%;(!*$ $3%!'1; !*: (

3 $0'$'3%1 :; , 50$!%

!3$ $!% %2 %$%#$'#,#$


2'!1 (*#

2*$%' *$ *

 *$ $*%#$,$%%!$ %*$,'%%#$ $!%    %#$  '#,  !  *',(%$  %  %#$  %$   
91

<-  ,$  0!%#  6$  9 

:1

!"6#3#1.(!3,

1(*#

6( * $$!%% $* %% =$2$ %#$,''$''! 0%#$,$%%!$ #$! *$ *

 '!%30, $*6%#1 !$7$3(%! ,, %!6

5%#$.(!3,

(!3 1(*#

(!*$  *$  +( $

  30,

 *$

!*   $32$ 5 ! 0(!% 
91:1

<-16#3#6

6$*#$$7$3(%!"
( % *$ $*%% =$6

!% ,''$''! %#$ '#,!*',(%$  30,

 *$ *

"" $2$* 5'

 *$ 1%#$,$%%!$ , $ $ $* !

 $%#$$,(%5
00''!$ 1 .

16#3#6

'*'0''$*  *$ '*

1

 !*



 $'( )$3%0 %%$  3#

$!"$!%#$, $'$!%,$%%! >$  %#$,$%%!$ '( 0%'%# %%#$,$%%!$ '

!,''$''! %#$'#,!*',(%$'!3$9 

: !*#

'!2$'%$* #("$ 0(!%#$,$%%!$ # $$!* $3%$*%2 %$%#$'#,!*',(%$

"

,  5$ '>$ ( %#$ 3!%$!*'%# %%#$,$%%!$ '  $ *5  %  *$,'%  %#$  0(!%  3

0$*  5  %#$  $',!*$!%-.(!3,

9
(!3 1(*#

!3 '$

$ %5'"2$!%#0%*$,'%%#$ 0(!% ?$ *%#$ "(0$!%'  %#$,$%%!$  !* # 2$

'"!$%# ("#%#$0,("!$* *$ ' !*%#$ *3(0$!%'

!

$ *0%%$* 51%#$'#,!*',(%$6

%%$*%%#$,$%%!$  .(!3,

1(*#

!'%3$ % !%$ 0' !*3!*%!' #$ ,$%%!$  $0 !$*  !  ,''$''!    '

*  '#,  '!3$  9 

: +$',!*$!%;

! ,, %!  $%#$


2'!1 (*#

 (!*$  $3%!'  1;  !*  :   (

3  $0'$'  3%1   :;  , 50$!%

!3$ 0(!%  $!% 2 %! '#, 0%#$,$%%!$  #$


$3% 

6$*%#$ ,, %!2*$%' *$ *

!* * $3%$* %#$  ,$%%!$  %  *$,'%  %  %#$ %$  
9

<-  ,$  0!%#  % .(!3,

'  $!%  0%#$* %$ ,''$''!$9 

:

!"6#3#%#$,''$''!2$ %#$'#,!*',(%$6 '% $% =$!2$

5%#$.(!3,

#$ $

!$7$3(%! ,, %!6

$',!*$!%;(!*$  *$  +( $

  30,

 *$ * %$* 

!*   $32$ 5 0(!% 
91:1

<-16#3#6

6$* !*

!% ,''$''! '#,!*',(%$6 '''($* "" $2$* 5'

 *$ 1%#$,$%%!$ 

!

 $$,(%5
00''!$ 1.

6#3#6

'*'0''$*#$0,("!$* *$ '# 2$ $$!3#

$!"$*!

!%#$" (!*%# %%#$,$%%!$ '!,''$''! %#$'#,!*',(%$'!3$ 9 

:  !*  '  $ *5  %  *$,'%  %#$  0(!%  '  3

0$*  5  %#$ $',!*$!%'   *0%%$* 51  %#$  ,$%%!$  # '  !%  , *  !5  $!%  6$  9 

:  #$  ,$%%!$  #0'$

 # '  *0%%$*   $  %#$  $,(%5
00''!$ 1.

%# %#$' (!!!" '#,'!3$

%0$!% !*!

0(!%# $$!*$,'%$* )$3%!'

5%#$,$%%!$ !$7$3(%!

 ,$%%!6$ $*'0''$*2*$ *$ * %$*



%$ #$ !"3(!'$ %#$, %$'( '$8($!% 51%#$

5%#$,$%%!$  !'% *$ 

*'0''

)$3%!'6$ $

'*'0''$**0%%$* 51%#$,$%%!$ # !$%#$ 3#

$!"$* *$ *

56 5

!"

< $2'!

 $%#$ (%# %$' 6 !*# ,,  3#$** $3% 5%%#'
( %#$

0(!% ' *$ $* 5%#$


$3% #

'!% $$!*$,'%$* 5#0 2$!%#$ *$   $)$3%! )$3%!6 '!%3#

$!"$*#$3!*(3%

%#$,$%%!$ %'$

'#6'%# %#$6 '!%!%$ $'%$*!0 =!"%#$, 50$!%  $!%!',%$  *$ , ''$*!#'

2( $2$!

!" $7$3(%!

,$%%! 33 *!"

51%#$ $'!0$ %!%#$ "(0$!%' *2 !3$*

!*%#$, $'$!%,$%%! $!"*$2* !50$ %'#$ $ *'0''$* ,  1


  

,)

  #$%#$ ',$ =!"< $ '!$* @$'

#$%#$  $, %

@$'