← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8881/2018dismissed

Ram Singh v. Financial Commissioner Pun And ORS

2018-04-16Mr. Justice Gurmit Ram6 pages

 

   

  

 

!"

$!#%&% 

(

!#)& *+ ," !#% !%- "% 

      #!%!

".

/#(#),0'"!

!#     !-#!%!

(!,& ,!##"

'(!%

2

3

" ! %"

"&"

  # 4#

"&#! '!#"

## 5&%

-& !,#,!#,"!,36

 

!7&#!.%4!((%#,!# ,"!,  8

3  

!7&#!  .3  -%%!,  +9  #!%- "%     ,  ) #!%-!'"

0!(9)4 !#!+9)" !'(

#'  ! : %# ;

! %+!!

#!*!'"!, <# (9)" ! '"% " !'%!% ,!&"

-#!%!

#!

" "#

((9" !(

%-&"!4%4 !,+9 ! "* !#:&# !

%%%!#"

!7!'&"

 ((

0&#+9% ,* !#:&#  !

* !#:&#4%% !,

;&#,!0:&#+!

 !#% %"!# !#! "!#)" !( ,4%!7'  !,4 " " !

, ;&#-#!!"

  "!#" !,!"  * !#:&#)" !-!"

!#'



%-&"!)9!" !

(!,'

(%& #,!'(#"

" " !!

!'"" " ! %4

%-&"!  (( ," !!7'  !,!!, %  ((!( ,  "+

&- " !

!# =4!0!#)" !%&

(!,+9" !-!"

!#4%,

%%!,0 *&, ","!,  

" !#& ," "" !-#9!# #-%%!%%  %

,!%-!#'%! !#) !4%

" !

," !#!4%  !'!%% "9"%!!>-%%!%%  # !0!,+9% ,#,!#)" !-!"

(!, --!()4 4%(%,

%%!,0 ,!#,!#,"!, 

6 !#! "!#)" !-!"

--#' !,"

%&#"+949

 8 

6)4 '  -!

"!#  !-!"

!#+!

'"&( - 9% '(-%%!%%

%-&"!

(!, --(

 : %#  ;

)  4 '  4%  ,

%%!,  +9   

, ;#,!  + ! % (,#0 ,! "%#,!#,"!, 3

" !#& ," "'

('%!4% -!

# !0!,+9% ,#,!#)" !-!"

(!, --!(+!

#!" !

((!'"#)4 ' 4%((4!,0 ,!#,!#,"!,8 

8 ," !'%!4% #!

,!,"%% %" "((!'"#

,;#,! +! % (,#4 " , #!'"

" "-!"

!#+! !#, 0!

%&

"--#"&

"9"-#,&'!" !

!0 '!

0&# ," !--( +!,!'

,!, "!#0

" !%-")  #,!#,"!,8 

84%' ((!

!,+9 #!%- "8+949

--!(+!

#!" !

!#)4 4%  ((4!,  0 ,!  #,!#  ,"!,  36

    !#! "!#)  " !  -!"

' ((!

!,#,!#,"!,36

+949

#!0 -!"

+!

#!" !



(

!#))4 ' 4%,

%%!,0 ,!#,!#,"!,8

3 #,!#%  ,"!,  36

   ,  8

3  #!  %&+*!'"  ""!#  

' ((!

!

8 ?!# !,'& %!( !#' "!

,%" "--( '##!'"

: %#;

#!*!'"!, (9 " !#& ," "

" !'

(&#" ,,!'

,!,

%"" !-!"

!#)4 !#!%)" !-!"

(

," !% !' +!0!#

!,+9--

?'(

!# ?!# !,'& %!( &#" !#' "!

,%" "* !#:&# 4%(

4 " " !-!"

" !#  ," !-!"

!#4%

-%%!%% 0!#" !(

%-&"!  ((!

" !#;&#,!0 :&# #;&#-#!!"

 4!#!#!% "% 0 ((!< #:( ,!#( * !#:&# !#%!( 4%#!'#,!,%4 ,> &,> %"

&!

#!'#, ! 4% !' 

'((9% !,+9" !#!0!

&!

(%

! ;&#,!0:&# ?!# !,'& %!((%' "!

,%" "" !

-%%!%% !# % ">!

"' ,!#"

," !

#!'#,!,+9" ! (&#"#!+%!, * + !

#!% ," !

%!

"(!,"!"" !: %#;

'##!'"!, =!#,  " !  #& "%  ,0 '!,  +9  (!# !,  '& %!(  #  " !

, 0!(% !" #& " !

-& !,#,!#%%4!((%" !# ,'& "%0 (+(!

(!  "'%!)" ! %%&! #' ,!#"

 +!

#!"

&#" %%"4 !" !#-!#% )4 

'"&(-%%!%%

%-&"!) %!

"(!,"!": %#;

'##!'"!,

!)4 !

(( "

%-!

%-!#'%! !#) !

(!, --( : %#;

)4 4%  #!*!'"!,  +9   

, ;#,!  +  ! % (,#  0 ,!  "%  #,!#  ,"!, 3

" !#& ," "'

('%!4%-!

# !0!,+9% #,!#) " !  -!"

!# 

(!,    --!( +!

#! " !   ((!'"#)  4 '  4%

 ((4!,0 ,!#,!#,"!,8 

8 ," !'%!4%#!

,!,"%% %" ((!'"#

, ;#,! +! % (,#4 " , #!'"

" "-!"

!#+!

!#, 0!

%&

"--#"&

"9"-#,&'!" !!0 '!

0&# , " !--( +!,!'

,!, "!#0

" !%-") % 

-%%!%% #,!#,"!,8 

84%' ((!

!,+9#!%- "8+9 49

--!(+!

#!" !

!#)4 ' 4%((4!,0 #,!#,"!,36

  !#! "!#)" !-!"

!#' ((!

!,#,!#,"!, 36

  +9  49  

  #!0  -!"

 +!

#!  " !  

( 

!#) 4 ' 4%  ,

%%!,  0 ,!#,!#,"!,  8

3   " !

#& ," "" !'

(&#" %'(!#(9!%"+( % !," "" !-!"

(

%-&"!#" !#" !!7'  !,!!,!7!'&"!,+9 ;&#,!0:&#

;&#-!!"

,&(9-#0!, #!'#, ,;&#-#!!"

 4% !(,

(

%-&"!+9" !'

&#"  -!#&%( " !,'& "%0 (+(!

(!) %'(!#" "

((9* !#:&#4%4

 @6#!#,

 !#

'!4%% !,

;&#,!0:&# !#! "!#;&#,!0:&#!7'  !," !(

%-&"!4 ;&#-#!!"

& +!#

84%(%% !,

"

#!#, !#! "!#" !!

"# !%4!#!

'#-#"!,

&!#!'#,+9 % 4

;&#-#!!"

 %4

%-&"! !

(!,'

(%& "+!

#!,, ( (A&,!)!

# )  #&#)4 !#!

) ! ,' ((!

!," !

* !#:&#%4!(( %!7'  !,!!,!7!'&"!,+9;&#,!0:&#

;&-#!!"

 !'

(&#",

%%!," !%& " !#+9 (,

" "" !

!#4% "

(

,#" !#" !!7' 

6 ,!!,!7!'&"!,+9;&#,!0:&#

;&#-!!"

,&(9 -#0!, #!'#, ! &%4%&- !#"-#0! %-%%!%%

+&"  !  (!,  "  ,,&'!   9  !0 '!   # !0!,  +9 % ,  #,!#)  " !

!# 

(!,    --!()  4 '  4%  (%  ,

%%!,  0 ,!  #,!#  ,"!, 

6+9 (,

" "" !-!"

(!,"-#0! %-%%!%% 0!# " !(

%-&"!  !%& "4%

(!, #,!'(#"

4 " &"%!!>

&#" !##!( ," !#  "% " !-#"

!% 0!(#!,9+!!

,!"!#

!,+9" !'

(&#" " %%!""(!,-#

-(! (4" " '!" !%""&% " !-#"

!%

((9,!"!#

!,+9" !'

(&#") "4 ((+!+

, %" !0!#.

#

!

!'"&- &!&" # !%  "'%!)" !'

&#" %(#!,9,

%%!," !%&

(!,+9" !-!"

," !#! "!#" !

--!( %(%+!!

%%!, !

(!,

%"+" " !*&, "%

%-!

"!#   !--(

(!,+9" !

: %#;

 %#  "(9+!!

%%!,  !-!"

%'(

%#  " (9 0!#" !

%-&"!+&"" ! '"" " !

) % -#0!,+9

  !5&!%"

%"4 

" !%& "-#-!#"9) % 5&!%"

'" !#! !0 #!'#,"-#0!" "-%%!%% " " !-!"

!# !#  "% " !-#-!#"9 0!(#!,9+!!

,!"!#

!, +9" !'

(&#" ," !#! 

"!#

#,!#

" !)4 '  %%""!, "+!-!

 !-#!%!

"

+(!% (&#"

,!'

%+

&- &!&" # !%<9#!'#,

" ! #!%

%)" !--( !# %#  "(9+!!

%%!, " !#! "!#--!(%4!((%#!0  0!(%+!!

%%!,  0 !4 '"% ,(4-% %!7-(

!,+0!)



" !' "!

%# %!,+9(!# !,'& %!( ," !

+!

,!0 , 9 % !#!+9,

%%!, -# ( )

  

-*    !" !#%-!>

2#!% !, B!%  !" !##!-#"+(!

B!%