Commissioner Of Income Tax Faridabad v. M/S Mercer Consulting India Pvt Ltd
!
"# $% & '('!)&*+,+(&-!
.
!"#$
% $/ 01$
22 34 - 2 01$
2 521- "
& '(
)*
)* +
,&
" -
% $ .... 34 - 2
+ - /
) % "
- 0112341 0 - 5 / # "
/ #"!
+
6 + 7
+3
!
" # #
$%
# & ' & () #
# * #
#$ # *
+'
# % +! +"
8
+-+
-
#
9 /!
7 -
+
+ +
:
-
69,
;
"
;
";! /
-+-
+ -"; / ";-
20 ! 6! &
<4<
;
&
) % " )%"!
;
+
-) % " )%"!
488 ! 42<4
5 /!
+
/ -
<
-
";/ *
+3
+ ,
#$## # * # $ * #
# ,
$ - * $
# . ,
$ *
# / ,
- # ## #
%
# $
0
$ * * & 1 # *
,
* # 23 1 # %
& 1 %
!'1 2# +''1 # ,
24 1 $
# & ,
$
# ,
% 2 #
# =
-
";/
+3
+
5 6 $7
7 8 # % * & 1 # *
. , 9):
; #$ < =% 7 # #
# #$ *
# 5>? @
- $
/ ,
>*7
#
# =)> * =) > *
,
$-
#
0
A67 *
*
* # - 0 B ## # #
#
# =
# *
, 7
9 , 7
& # 7
@ 7
6 @ # $
* #+
! : #
7 2$-$, C7
>
-
7 -";
7
?
@ 4 6 8 = + ?
@ 0:<> 2A+ ++ 2 ?
@ 0 6 : 2 +
-
-
?
@ 4 8 +
";
-
-
- +
- "; + -B
+ C+ "; - +
+ A+ ++
41 @:+ ";/ 7 + =:D
/
+ 21D
411D! 7
"; -
+
44
(
3
- "; - +
=:D
- &
"; & -
+ =88:D =:D + + - "; A - +
& -
+ 1::D
( /
- +
40
=:D
46
( /
- +
+
-
C
- +
- C
+
"; C
+
-
48
&
+
- 7 +
- -
-
-
";
*
+
7 4:
- ";
- - + +
";+
+
+ - -";)%" ! -
+ - - + @ ";
4< / ?
@0
&
4= +
-
-
+ -
"; +
-
4>
:=64D
$ #
% =6= + 221 +
- <22 + +
-0==< +
,";
/
:=D
+ - $# B,"; + -0==< +
42
-
$ #
,";
? -
+
;
- +
+ -
- 01 , +
$#
$3E'? + F9 #
$3 E'? + F9 #
-
-
$ #
A + $3E'? + F9 #
,";
+ $3E'? + F9 # + -><41
/
:2 A - +
- & ) , ) C
!
" # $ % & ' ( !
+ ";
?- ? # #F
#
- # + * #"
/
)%"
-
+
+ +
-
-
* C
04
*
$ #
$ # =6= + - 0==<
,";+ - +
-
+
+ 221* <22 -
-
$#
+
,"; + -0==< +
:2 00
- $ #
06 + -
-
+ "; +
-
08
9
+ - $ -
#
$
/
6)
+ -
#" 0: "; ,) 0<120111+
-
- 9 "
? 9?!
413 413, 42<4
- -
+ -
-
7
7
-
$
?- ?
/
+ - 9? +-
#"
/
-
B
-
-
#"
0<
- &
!
0= "; %?-
#
"; %?-
#
+ - (
-64 )
+
-
4 "; +
-
,
)
$ * + ,- "$ %..'/. .
0.# + -+
-
0> A
+ "; )%"
+* -
- 9
-
+ *
+ +
-
- ";
+ +
#" 02 -
% ?-
# - 6440011>
7 64160112 6416011> ! +
--
- - 6440011>
7 6416011>
7 64160112
- 1418011>64160112 61 + - % 41 ,! 8! +
3 D+'52/
#
$
# $ E 64 %
- -
-
-
A% 7
-B
+
- +
-
-
+
- %?-
# 60 A - +
- +
-
3
8!
41,
" 66 C # + * + E
-# +
A +
3 C # 68 C # + -
"; 7
C #
-
7 ";
";
+ - C #
6:
(
-
*
7 -
6<
+ +
#" 7
-
-
";
-
+-";
";
& -
A
6= 7 + C #
+
C #
+
C #
+ *
21D -
+
-
+
+
+
-
+ * 7
+
-
- 9
7
-
-
7
+ +
- 7
6>
+
7
7
- +
+
*
-
+
+
+ 7
- +
+
+
+
62 A
+ +
) , ) C
1
-,
"# $ ""
- %331%%4. *$ * :
$
## : F %
*
$
# #
# # $- $ *(* * 8@> * ## * $
$ * # >
$ *
$
F $ # $ * ##
$ * $ # # * : $ * # #E 81
/
84
-
41
+
A
+
- >>8 -
-
-
80
;
+ C+ +
+
+ + & ) , ) C
+ -
&
C
! ""
- * % '% ( !
) C
+& ,-C
* # 2"56
- $ %%13 '
*C
7 "
$ %8&1&/9 - : + +& ,-C
) '
* C
+ & ,- C
*# 2"56
- $ "2 - ++
& ,-C
,-C
3 D& % * * % * $ # * *## % G% *G =%
2 +'
$ % #
# % - #
#$ * * # % #
* # #$ #
%
* #% # # $ # # @* $ # %
% * % * * # @* $*
% G *G #
> # #+'
C$* % G% *G # # # G% *G % # % * # > # % ## % G% *G*## $# # *# #
# # H $ > - * C$* * *
$ * # $ # #@*$ % *I F% *F $ * ##
# # # @* $ $ # #
% # G% *G #
# $ # G% *G $ # # * # # *$$ *E 86 A
+ & ,- C
&
41 7 -
41 ! ? 41 4! 8! 9 0 !
3
! "# $%&2+0 *# # # *- # % #
#$# #* $ * *$ - #
#$
$# #J 2/K #)2+2+ # * # % #
#$
$ # # #- % * #
#$ *# -
K # L 22 %%%%%% 2 G% *G # % - #
#$* * # % $ ) 2. #
* #
#$ % # # % * * M N
E
'
(
) $%&&2+ 0 * #
# # 2 # # = O ''
# H $ #
** * *
# + # *
+LNNNNNN 2& K # ) 2+ # * # % # * 2
#$
$
# # # - H % * # * * #- J LK # L 2 G% *G # % - H # * * #
*# % # # % # * 2
#$ ME 88
41 41
41 =! -3
41 41
- +
-
8: 7
+
7 @4
+
7 @0
+ 8< -
(S.J.VAZIFDAR) CHIEF JUSTICE (DEEPAK SIBAL)
JUDGE 'ravinder'
Whether speaking/reasoned √Yes/No Whether reportable √Yes/No