Commissioner Of Income Tax-3 Ludhiana v. M/S Venus Woollen Mills 424 Industrial Area-A Ludhiana

GURBAX SINGH 2018.12.03 12:13



    
 
 

         ! "#$#%&'() *  +#%"#, -..#$$#% +
%".  /0123!*# %             44,, -- %     5$

6$5 %3$7-- % #--$123!*# %            4 $,%! %
  &  82

 9
:

 
2   82

 9
59
 






 

 



  
 
 


 


 ;

<:3.

+ # -1   ')(=

=)

 

 





!

 



 
"


 
 
#$
%
&&&

&'&

()&*

 +


 


 &





$
 
 
"

"




(,)


#-
$ .

&/,&
0

1
23
 


 
&4 / ()&'
.563
 
"

#-
$ .
 
$" 
  

8
  
0 



1
$" 23

#$ % ')49:;9()&6


-
 
())<5)/ 

-
"




 
(< ()&,

- 


 
"  !



5
1=


 



- 


 
:8"
#$ $
  



! 

 




(,6

- 
"

#$56
>  

 

 
 


- 


- 
"





-
"





 +
-
"+




-

"


-


 ?2
(


 
 

  


 
   

-
"

$


 


"

-  9 



"






&66








"
-




(< ( ())<


 

-


 (&*)))))95



 -

$





-


-
 
())<5)/

(4 / ())<
 

-


 &6*6,6))95
$
 













$
-


-


&'6063



"


@


 
< &( ()&)
0 .5#3
"
- +



 &*4*(95


')0 30 3



"! 

--

#-
$ .56
>  0

1
#$23


 
(< ()&6
 


(,6






 





@





 



  






#


"
 


@
 
 

- +

 


-



 


 
   

#$


 
(< ()&6
.5(3
 

-



"

 &<6<)()<95
A


"


.5(



 
"

$" 
$
$" 


 
&4 / ()&'
0 .563
! 


 
(< ()&6
0 .
5(3
 





-





  

  

0()))3
('6
#$
<6
:


 
"

 =
 
 
 



 





'

B.

-




(,60&3





"
.



 



 


5


 

   



          

     

                 

          

    

    

               

        







   

    



         ! "

 !#$
*

"


 


(,6



- +

 
 
"

#$
 





 

!

"





 
-
 


 


- 
"



@




 



  






 


(,6



 
"
.

 






@
 
 



  






$


 
-

 


-




(,6


5
3



"

C
0"3



"
  





 #


 
- 
-
.

 "

--

.
 




(,6
D 
0 3



C
0"3
"




"

 
 
"
 






=


-

"
5









"


  












"

  






5
-

 


(,6





"


,



$
"




 -


 







  






$

"
 




 



 





  
"



 
"


@


; -
 




  





@
#



 

"


 



@

- +
-
 

 
 


(,6




 

 "






@


  






$


 

+
-

 D



"


  






"



 

 
  
(,6



 
"
- 

 
 

-
 .





   

 8
 
0 3
"

5
E4
$
 
"

"
 


 
"
+


 


 

- +


--
"



@C








 



"
  

-

 


 




 

!-



"

#

 -
 
 

 


 



  


 

- 2
<




  
- .



 






"
-




(< ( ())<


 




(&*)))))95


- 
"

 
-

 






 

-5
3

4))))))95



. 
-

+C
0"3

')))))95



.
 


 C

03

&6&)))))95
 
-
- 



"

'('
#

 
>  C
03

&))))))95
 
-




 




- +9-9 


"+


 / $

@

-

 
)< &( ()&)
 


&'6063





 



(&*)))))95


- 




&66





(< ( ())<


 .

"
-


 &6**()*)95

- +




 &*4*(95


')0 30 3






-



&6*6,6))95  


-




 


@


-





"+



"

.


 

"+






+ 
@


!

 
 
 



 
 





(&*)))))95




&66



 


(< ( ())<


-


 &6&)))))95






-



"

'('
#  
>  

4))))))95



. 
-

+
A-

  

 

 "


 
 

 -





- 
"
-
"
 -




"
 

 .

"
-


 
"

&6**()*)95
 




(&*)))))95
- 
"

$
$" 
 
- 

 
" 

 
" 
"


 

 

 
"
#$


(,6



$
 
" 
 
5

1(, 
 


+

"
 

@
-
 
 

 
 

 
"

"




 
"
- 


-







@

 

"
-
 

 







 

 
"


"


-

......2
&) $
#$


 


(,6



 
-

 -


&<6<)()<95

5

1&'

@
 

 +






:8"
F
:



F
$" 
 


- 

D 
 
"
 +


"+



"



-
 
"
 

"
-


"



$
"+





 




 





:8"
F
:



:8"
F
$" 

G
 

-
 
())45)<





-

 

 
.



-


5

3
$ 




 



6()&)&4/*95

3
G

6,44666&95

3



G
 && '<H

3



G


I
())45)<

&4 (6H

3
G
+


G
 
J
&4 (6H

**&*6*6/95

3
;

G

&<6<)()<95
#-

"
 
"

&<6<)()<95




"

#
-

 
 

 
-


  
  

- 2
&& #

- 

 
"

 

-

 
)< &( ()&)
 


&'6063









  





  



 

$" 





 
(< ()&6
 
"
#$



(,6




&(



 





 

 



 
"

#$
 
(< ()&6

-


-


&'6063
 


(,6




(< ()&6
-

 .

"
-
 


-
"

&<6<)()<95
$



 





 

" 

 
 

"+






-  
 






 (&*)))))95
 
"
- 




&66




(< ( ())< &6



$
 

#$


(,6





 
- 


 

 

-
 
-
-  

 "
-

-

-
 

 


 
"






 



  






@




"




-  
 





@



  







#$

- 

 




- 


 
-

 
:
-
 



 


-


-
-

-
:


- 

 

-




-
$
#$


-







 
 
"

 
 &'

$
#$

-



 
 
-


"

 
"

 &<6<)()<95
 
 


- 

 
"


#

"
.






#$


!
" 5

1*
#
 
 


"-



$


 
+




"+


"

 


"+




 "





- 
"




  








-
 
 

@









"+


= 
 


!
 

 -



 


 


"+






-


( &*

 
"


%
 


 

"+



 " @
 

 

"+


 

- +


!


"+




 ,
#



 


 
-



-

- +



( &*
  +


 



 


- + 
 




 



 


- +
$
 9 
"
 
"
"




 
 

"+



 "

"
 
 -


 

G
 

9
K
=





(< ( ())<
$
 -


5
L &
;






+


-
K
=

 
"
  



+

 "
  
-


,'),*6/)95  

+

"+
 
"
 

 *4''(4(495
$





,,((,,*95
"
.
+



- :


. 

 -?


#
 
. 




--
: 

"
 

-



 
#

 
-


<)
 
0
 3



. 
-

+
"




 


(4&0&303 L (
;






 

 "


"
-
 
"
 




 
  

 "


',6*4)95
: 
 



"+


-


4*<)(95
 

. 



.
 



6<44,<95


#
 
. 


--
: 

"
 
#

-


'
 
"
 
-



"




 


(4&0&303 L
;






 
"
 




-


&6&)))))95
 
"

"





"

'('
#

 



 -

 

-







"+?
#

 



?


#
 



#
 


-
 


"+

 


 



&6&)))))95
 
"




 
"

K
=


'('
#  
> 


  
 
())45)<

"

-



 
"+

 $
-
 
"





-


-


#
-


 .
"




 


(4&0&303 L '

;





 
-

 

 

"?


#


 

-


&)
 


"
 



"
- +9-9 


"+





  
 
())45)<
$


-


 (&*)))))95
0  $ 



 3



 .


"

- 
-





  
 
())45)< < $
"
 -

 
 

8
"+



 
"






 

 









-

 
#
.
+9.
 




 "
 

"+



 " 

 


- 
 

@
 




# 

@
 



-
 


- 

"+


 
"



/ $
@



"
 
!



 









 

.
# &) $
@


! 


 
(( && ()&)


 
.
## 




 
(/ && ()&)


 
.
### && 





 
6 &( ()&)
#
 
&&



 
6 &( ()&)


"-

5

1 
 
 


G
 
- 


 
 



 
 

 
"-


 

A

 

 



 

 



 




 
 

G
-

&& &6H




" 


 
,/ 
 


 



 

 

 
 

 

- 


 
 

 
 

 

- 


 
 

- 


 -
 
 

 

"

 

 
4)5/<
 
"

 
 
 



G
 
 

 
- 


 
  2
&(
$
@
 



-

-


.  



@


 


"+





- 

@


-


 

 


"+




 "
 
"





.  



#
 



 
&* ()&6

"-
 



-



G
 

"





 8
 

 +



 
"
 



 







 
 


G
 


- 

 
 
 
 -
 


 


 


 "


"+







 "

&6
@
-



  
 

 

!

"

$

-

-



-

@ 

-


 
-
"

-

"




- 
-
 


 
 
#


-


 






-
 




B



 
 
"
"
 
-
/ 6(H

'

6(H
$

 
 



-



-
 2
&* %
 



"





 
"

#$

-

 

"

  

 


 



 
&4 / ()&'
0 .563
 
"

$" 




$
"  
!




 

 


 &,


 



 


















  

;
$ .
0 ;$3


 





@
 

 

 

D



 
 
"
 

"

; -


- 

 
-







 


 

 



"+








-





- 
 
7
"+





+8


"


@



          ;

<:3.

+ # -          3!>   9 , .? +'1)    @% $**#%> %   A>$8       3!>   %   &      

%