High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1319/2012disposed of

Arjun Lal And ORS v. Dakshin Haryana Vidyut Parsaran Nigam Ltd And ORS

2024-12-12Mr. Justice Pankaj Jain23 pages

"# $!%&'&"( ) ** + *

,-.( /0 ($ " 1!,'

****** 22!00( '

3!,'.'

4'1&( ,5( 6&$5.

,',( &78 / $* ($ " 1!,'

**9 !'2"($!( '

,-.( /0 ($ " 1!,'

****** 22!00( '

3!,'.'

4'1&( ,5( 6&$5.

,',( &78 / $* ($ " 1!,'

**9 !'2"($!( '

)

/ * ;

; < *

" " !

"#$ #" % & '(

)

" " * + , " -* , . ",

*, !, " " 0 *, ,*$ , 12342 " $

44 , **, " * 5 *, , 6 " "

" *, "

7 8 " *, 9: ) 8 . " 9: 9: / 8 *, 5 5 9:6 8 *, " 9:6 ;

8 * +9 :6 8 "*9:6 < 8 9:6

8 . , 9:6

= >

*. , " *$ !, $. 6 ) ! " 0 /

! " " ;

! * "."

. *, " " ,* * $ ! " " *, , . !

* , *,

, " *, 0 " "$"*" 5 ) 3< 12 "

5 ,12

! @ )) 3# )31

7! " ,* #A #

, 46$ B,C, "? * , , @ = 6$D

* " " E" , ,12/

@ " *" ,)33; * ! * $

. )2 )31

, * > <

6 *. !, ." *,?

"." *, ?

* , , /334 0 ! 4

,," ! ! * " 0 ""

$ $ % & "'())

# %

$ * $ + , ,, ! #--%.)&/0&

$ & $ & '!$ 2, #-3%.& !

& 45 0&, 6&! -#-% .-.

*" * " 44 5

B ); 2; ?" * !* , "

* , " " *

""$"*

5 0 " ,

*" 4 " 4

, ! "." *, " 3

* ,

! "#$" ! %&&' ! ( %%)&*)%&"# %&%+ ))

), )

@, 4

, *,

0 " 6 * " , $ /4 0 /334 , 5 , !" =* 3&(7 "# 0>'

2,"3&$&(7 #", %?.&'& &"( "# !' !'< ! %*

* %+ "" ( 1;G %( , /

4F %(

** %+ "" ( 1;;G %( 5 *, , , E " " , %*( $ "" , ,*, " * "" , %( " " " * "" ,

%( E " " , " " " , %( E " " , *, ,"

, " " " "

, "

*" * $ ,*, *, 1

"*, ?

, *

, "$, 5 *, , , " *,

* 5, " * ", "* , *

5 * ," "

* "$

%)( 0 4

%( EH H

, "" E 5 E

4 %( , . " " " !"

A ,."" I %( , , " I %( ,

* *,

I %*( E H H

, *4 4 4 , 4, ", ,

* !,'"('

$!2,&3!$ "# 2,"2!, 5 '3!

@5 . 1",& 5 "# 0>

* , *, ,

> /

/4 * " , * 5 *, , " "$ /334 , " / /334 06 2 2 "

( 6 ,-#%.-#%.

7+ J" " * $" *, " , * K * " E *, , "

* * " 4 , " , ! , " " $ " , E , $ , * " "

* E, *

+ * ,E " " , = 5 , "

E +* A$) , + %",,!% !$ 3&$!

##&%&0 ",,&7!($.8 "**B$* **B+CB $ !$ D *E ! 5

H " " H , " " " , % ? J" 6"/J 131( 5 " * * % = J" 6" L %@ #1 8=G( "" * " " +* !, % C

1;/( $" " "" , * "*

= " " " " E " ,* ", * " E

= * * " H* ++* !* * , " " /%)( /3% ( ) / E "

/334

+C* : "$ , *, 8 " " , 0 , +" = 1%(%( " * " /%)( :

" 6 , , *

, +D*

/4 * 5 " $ , " 7* > 7 "" ,> " " E ", " " $

* , 1 CC* ! )- . / F 0=12;

3< %12;( =2GE" ?

5 % "" ( 12*,

5 * "

/ ! " E

, * , * "5 * ? "" 5

/334 E" "

= 5 , *" 0

) ? , ,*, ,

/ = 5 , * * ,

= ,"" . " /) *

,$ B ))2

" ** " " $," * /33 , K , 5 " * *

1) * + *, /%(%)(." * E" " /33

/334 " * ,*, , " *, * , " , *, E ,

, "*,"

! E 7 ,> /33 * $ ,

,"*, * *,

F *

/334 , E @ 5 " E

* , *

, +

5" 7* >7" > ,

" H* " H " " ,)? 000

, , 5 FD* ! " "

/33 /3% (

) / %(

/33

! ," " *

, /3% (

/ %(*.

! %+ ,4 "" ( 1<# " /* * % ( /3 = , * ". ,"" ,

, " " " , 5 , *, * " ,"" ,

" "" " ,5 , , * " *," ,"" , + / %( * ? "

"$ ," " "$

* 5 * F* ?$ ,

"" . " " *. + ,4 "" @

+ ,4 "" * " , " 5 , @ 5 " "" ,* ,*, , /33 .@0&% 2.,2"'!

D * 6 , " /33

,$" $ * * ! " " , " *" ,* " , " ,

, *

* , ,

* " **. .

@ 5 " , * * *,

*"$ D* ! * * , E" *. *. , * $

/33

D* 8 5" * * , , "* .

E" 5" ," " /%)(

D* ," " "

5" /3% ( / %( $ /33

+ ,4 "" 1<#

* ," ," , " , /33 * ," . " ,* 5 " " *, " , D* =5" * , /33 * " "

* . *, .

, . * . ",

" " *,

"$ , 0 "" * , E ,

/33 *

. , . * ",

,*. *

/334 * 5

, K , *" 8 /334 " ,* /%( % H= H ( /%)(% "* J" 6"( /33 * ,*,

! * * 0 " " , ! " * * ,E *, 5 * ! " " * E * ! , /33 " *H. * H " 1%(%()2%*(/3

E" " " *. 5

," " "

" "$ " . * " * *

", , * HH" H H"

$ 5 ,* , H"

*H B * H H" $ * ,5 " * ,

0 E.

$ " *" * = , " "

/33 "" "

* ) = ? *

/33 $ /3% ( /

+* A$*) ,'

+ ($ C %",,!% !$ 3&$!

",,&7!($.8 "**B$* **B+CB $ !$ D *E

/4 *, + "" 1; * " * ? , , , !

*. " " / %( %( %(

F* A$*) , F %",,!% !$ 3&$!

",,&7!($.8 "**B$* **B+CB $ !$ D *E ! E * " $" "* ", C . ", " " * , * * ", "

C " * " , * " @ " $ * * * , . * $ *

,**.

, " , D* ! ",*" * " 5 ," . "",

= * *,

, * " .

* : " " ,

, .," *

* 6 , ", "

, E 0 ? " " 8 , , *. ,

" J " "$ ,

"* ."

!$2 ( #--% 38-- 14 " * H) !

* ,E , 12< , " *, / 000

/ ,F

9)&:+) #34%;;8 '3.

G *

. "

) ) ! , *" *, %+ ,4+ ( "" 1<# *" F &,!6 < 0 #-4%434#-4%# %.= /33 /334

* ,*, ,

! K , E * *,

!* ," E , /334 * >6 2 #2%" 6 ,#-%8 #-%.# %..= ) / !* , ,

* " /33 = ."

& 2 &! " & &

& 2 &! " &&

#--3%55= % 2/2( M B /33 E H" "", , *,5 "* "" * * * " " * %" ( ) 0 1 2!!! '!, '

#1 2!!!'!, '

#--;%335( & % ;)2)( H) 0 , " " * $ ,E

/33 ! $ $ /33

" * , %" ( ) ;

0 $ $ #2%" ?2 > $ $ #2%" ?2#-% 43.8#-%.# %54= ,*"

% /<1/3( H/3 0 ,.*, $ "" , * ,, " D"

* , * ,

H ," * * , * " 0 , 4* " *

%" ( ) 0 < &: 1 : 6$ +&@ >< &: 1 : 6$ +&@ 3& #%3( &

% 2)< #( H# 0 /334 , "

* , *, ,

! * ,

6 *,, " 5 $ /334

%" ( ) < 0

** , , ,

," . " *" * 12<

) # !

, 5 " ,* 8" $ ,

" ,

,*,

) 0" ,*,

K ,

= ." & &,!6 < 0 > &,!6 < 0 #-4%4348#-4% # %.= " " , 5 5 , "* ," ! *

*, *, *,

) 3 ! & 0&, 6&! > 0&, 6&!#-%-.-.8 #-%4# %5( ,

* , , * " B" * "

" ," B"

" ," B" " 4 "

) / 0 " . "

$& E . " .

>2 /! 1#53%38 53#"%=A

" ? B

$ !

" 0 '! ( -. (

3;8-. 15-

" * * "0!

"# 1!

.($!, , &%0!

"# 1!

"(' & . &"( / ! = , , *E *, & 6, 0&

$ ) !6&!-.

(

;

* 4E *4

5 - , ! * & ." *

*4 * * 4 E ! ( , " 5 ,4 ( , *. 5 *( , " 54 ( , " 5 * , 5 ,* ( , * " ( , 5 , * " E ( 4 MH FJ" G

;

0 *, " " , !" *,

2; )<""

@, " ," " " = 4 " *, ?

**, ." *,

0 "

*, " ) '!

2#--4%- , , *. , *

*,?

$:N?0= // 2

" *, " " ,*$12 "** 0 !

"#&% "

5 * K * " " ! "

" , ))

#&% * K" 0)&/0&

$ & #&%

* " , ! * " E "* <

0 *

0 "

4 "$ ,12 * ,. +, , * " , " B , * " 12 ,"," ! " E

, , D " ,12 ,* , !" * * " 1

+ " ,)33;

,* ? 5 #1 + "

* " *

2 3) )33;

" " 5 5 " " 12 *

*, 5 ," , " , = 333-4, """12 3O" ,3,

5 P2O"

)

0 *

" %( ! " ." 3< ) )3 *, 6 B 5 "

%( ! " E " ,* " ? 5 #1 * 2 3) )33;

%( ! = 333-4" 3O" ,3, "" " , 12

5 2 3) )33;

%( ! "" B

5 " 5 2 3) )33; 3/" " , , ."

))

: ,

, *

)

" * "

; ** + 6 8 $-

Q 8 = * Q