High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1322/2012allowed

Mukand Singh Gill And Another v. Gurbachan Singh Alias Bachan Singh Etc.

2016-09-09Mr. Justice Arun Monga6 pages

!!"#$#%&!' !()!*+,-

./%0#%12#33 % 2!* ''!33% $ 4!*$.$ .*)"2%#%123#$"2%#%12$#%"!0!"!$!0 2*.125 $

2!*$ !$'%0!% $

!"#$%& '( $(')#*%&+,$

*!$!% &

**.%#%,!%#*06" !7# 2

*(# #%,06" !, * 2!''!33% $

* #2 ,!%#*06" !7# 2

* %,06" !, **!$'%0!% $ 8 9 +

*:%73;# #%12,!%#*06" !7# 2

*(*;# #%12,06" !, **!$'%0!% - <<<<< (')#*% ''!33% ='3#% # ./%0#%12#33$%.*)"2% #%12*( 2!#*$ 7#!%0''!33% ='3#% #37% #%12$% .*)"2%#%12*( 2!$!"%07#!*!11*#!6!0%%=1*% #%1 2! 0!"3* #% 2!337#%1*!3#!$&= #

0!"3* #% 2 2!'3#% #$%00!!%0% $$ > *! 2!7%!*$ 2!3%0(!$.*#%18=-?

=9'./2 "('*#$!0#%:2!7 @>A,:2 .%#,:2$* +A == , +@A> == , A =@= , A== ,A=@= ,+>>A=>=@ , 33%0 8=@=@ ./2 $# . !0 6#331!#33,0)$ -(

!2$#3%0#$ *#" 5.02#%$27%#% 2!;()%0#* 2! B!* +@8=@- %0 3%0 (!$.*#%1 =8=9 "('*#$!0 #% /2!7 >+A,/2 .%#-9-A,:2$*++A= 8= %03$3%0%! 2#*0$2*!#%3%0. 3 3%0 (!$.*#%1 =+=> "('*#$!0 #% /2!7 @, :2 .%#@,:2$*++=9=8 ,+8== , +-==+ ,+>==@ $# . !0 6#331!#33,!2$#3 %0#$*#" 5.02#%%0 2!'3#% #$%00!!%0% $ >*!!% # 3!0 %!# 2$2*!!"2%'* # #% 2!)6! $#03%0 !* 2!0! 2.*)"2%#%12,0!!%0% %0 #6

*'!*(%!% #%;.%" #%**!$ *#%#%1 2!0!!%0% *(3#!% #%1 2!)6!$#0$.# 3%0#%%B(%%!* %00!!%0% -*(.* 2!*3#!% #%1 2!3%033!1!0 26!)!!%$30 2#()B 2!0!!%0%

**.% #%, 3!*%!0!%#*.%$!3$$#$ !0)B *(# #%,*!'*!$!% #%1 2!''!33% ='3#% #$$.)(# $ 2 .*)"2%#%12 7$7%!*)#1"2.%/3%0$0!$"*#)!0#% 2!$.# %8-+9, "('*(#$!7$**#6!0 #%#6#3.# )!*#%18+9 # 3!0$ ./%0#%12#334!*$.$.*)"2%#%123#$"2%#%12D0!"#0!0 %-+9%0$'!* 2!$#0"('*(#$!,3%0(!$.*#%1=8=+

./2 . /2!7 A/2 .%#88A99. :2$*@@>,3%0 (!$.*#%1== ./2 . /2!7 A/2 .%#88A99. :2$*+>,3%0(!$.*#%1=>=, ./2 . /2!7 A/2 .%# 88A99. :2$*+>>0!$"*#)!0#%;()%0#* 2!B!* +9=9$# . !0#%4#331!#33,!2$#3%0#$ *#" 5.02#%2$)!!%

1#6!% 2!(

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

0%++%0, 2!*!*!,$.""$$#%'!%!02! $.""$$*$='3#% #$,)!#%1 2!$%$,*!3$!% # 3!0 2!$2*!)B7B % .*3$.""$$#%,$2!0(# !0 26!0#!0#% !$ !,B! ) 2 2!.* $ )!3726!% /!%#% "%$#0!* #% 2#$$'!" %0"((# !0#33!13# B %0'!*6!*$# B%0, 2.$,.*1!$ 2#$.* *$! #%1=$#0! 2!"%".**!

*:%73;# #%12, 3!*%!0 !%#* .%$!3 $$#$ !0 )B

*(*;# #%12, *!'*!$!% #%1 *!$'%0!% -, 72 #$ $.)$!F.!% 6!%0!!,#!, 2!)!%!#"#*B3%0(!$.*#%1=8=)B6#* .!$3! 0!!00 !098+@@,$.)(# $ 2 2!''!33% ='3#% #$26!% )!!% )3! '*6! 2!"2*" !*%0% .*! 2!3%0)!#%1%"!$ *3$!E"!*' E GA0!$% *!3!" 2 2!'*'!* B 2!2%0$.*)"2% #%127$#%2!*# !0*(*01!%!* #%#%3#%!1!). %3B*!3!" !0 2 2!

20#%2!*# !0 2!'*'!* B*(:2.$2# (,72#"2#$% $'!*$ 0# #% .33H$#%0.57, *, 2!*!*!, 2!$3!0!!0#% 2!$.# #3!0 %@"%% )!"233!%1!0%0, 2.$,.*1!$ 2#$.* *0#$(#$$3 2!$.# ,'* #".3*3BF.*!3#!$## %0###

* #2 , 3!*%!0 !%#* .%$!3 $$#$ !0 )B

* %,*!'*!$!% #%1*!$'%0!% $ 8%09 +$.)(# $ 2 2!G#330 !0-8+@@2$)!!%'*6!0 2*.12 2! !$ #(%BG=

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

$"'!0 2!% #"! 2! .* $,#$ 2 2!"% !% $ 2!G#33*!6!3(#%0 2! !$ *,%(!3B, .*)"2%#%12,7220 0#$ *#). 02#$!% #*!!$ !#%!F.3$2*!$ (%1$ 2#$$#)3#%1$,#!,$%$*( 2!#*$ (**#1!%0$%$*( 2! $!"%0(**#1! 2!"('*(#$!0 !08-+96#$==6#$ 2!3%00!$"*#)!0 2!*!#%,3$#%0#" !0 2 !* 2!0! 2.*)"2%#%12,''!

,#!,'3#% #7#33"F.#*!$2*! 2!!E !% A8 2$2*! #$ 2!"%"!0!0'$# #%%*!"*0 2 37% #%122$)*%*( 2! $!"%0(**#1! (% )3! $"*#)! 2!$.)(#$$#%6#$==6#$ 2!'*'!* B 2!2%0$.*)"2%#%12)!#%1%"!$ *3,*, 2!!E"!*' E GA '*6!0% *!"*0$27!0#%2!*# %"!.*)"2%#%12*(:2.$2#

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

7.30)!26#%1*#12 ""*0#%1 2!#**!$'!" #6!$2*!$#% 2!!$ ! .*)"2%#%12 0.) , 2#$.* %!*3#!*""$#%$20)!!%*(#%1 2! $.)$ % #3F.!$ #%$3772#3!0!"#0#%1 2!''!3). #%6#!7 2! ".33!0. )B#6!3!*%!0.01!$ 2!%H)3!.'*!(! .* #%

72!*!#% 2!'*'$# #%*$!$ 72! 2!*#% 6#!7 2!'*6#$#%$!" #%+9 ,72! 2!*'*6#$#%$!" #% > 2! .%;).* $" ,+@7.30''3B* 2!''!3#!

7.30 )! #3!0 .%0!* !" #% 0! #6#3 *"!0.*! 2!

%$ # . #%3!%"2%H)3!.'*!(!.* 2!30 2 2!0!"#$#%#% !" # !

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

B*!;!" 0%0, 2!*!*!, 2! ''!33% ='3#% #$*!0!"3*!07%!* 2!!E !% A8 2 $2*!!"2, 3!6#%1 2!'* #!$ /!''*'*# !(!$.*!$A*!(!0#!$* 2!'.*'$! !# 2!*1! #%1 2!'*'!* B;#% *$!'* !#%""*0%"!7# 2372! F.!$ #%6#$==6#$ 2!'*'!* B3! )B.*)"2%#%12,720#!0#% !$ !, #$ 3$ %$7!*!0 #% 6.* 2! ''!33% ='3#% #$ 2! F.!$ #% *!1*0#%1#%2!*# %"!#$0!"#0!01#%$ 2!''!33% ='3#% #$ ''!3$ %0$337!

948

)505 02 948