Dr. Chahat Bhatia v. Government Medical College & Hospital, Sector-32, Chandigarh And Others.

 
 

  !

 
   








 







 












 
  




!"
   

 










# 

"



 "



 







  $













 
  




!"
   

 










# 

!



#

%$

 













 
  




!"
   

 










# 

&



##




 

 













 
  




!"
   

 










# 

'



 #"

(  













 
  



  
!"
   

 










# 

)



 "

 
( * 













 
  




!"
   

 










# 

+



 $

,  
 













 
  




!"
   

 










# 
-





"

. 













 
  




!"
   

 










# 
/





"

,0

% * 













 
  




!"
   

 










#  1





"#

$
, 













 
  



# 
!"
   

 










# 











 

 







%  * .












 
  




!"
   

 










#  "





%$


%
3 

 













 
  





!"
   

 










# 


!















$ 













 
  





!"
   

 










#  &





$$


3  .
3 













 
  





!"
   

 










# 


&'(  ()*+*,-% %

 4#%
5


78
#,9 (:8
%
#48#





78
#,9 (:8
#%, :#
8 #%;%(

 5






 
%  

% 
*


% 
 
%

"





<



= 
;

>-/)"
"+->"1-
,
 
?  
% <



= 
;

>/&)>"1-









  .


 
%





<



= 
;

>")&-!"
-!!>"1-
# 
  >:
%





<



= 
;

>"!&

""'+>"1-
, 


%





<



= 
;

>""++>"1-

  
 
% 







<



= 
;

>"")">"1-












 

  
% <

=
= 
;

>""&""&"
-"

""&!>"1-
  
 
 
 

*


  
, 
% 

% 
# * % <
9(
    
 

% 
*









 0
3 $ 
%





./0 

=4 
$ "$


*,




  
*
%

<



$
 
$ "


*,




 
 
*
 
<<  


$


&*,)&+(+  2


<




;

>""'+
"")"

""++
< "1-
7 


  
<

9(
   

% 




 0


*
* 
 
<
;

2-/)"
/&) -!"
-!!
"!&
")&
"+-
""&
""&"
""&!
-" ""'+
"")"
""++
<
"1- (
<  
*

 

<
;

>-/)">"1- :
<  
 0

@



0


<
<  




<< 


 0




@<

 

  



  
<
   


   (0
 
@
 
<
 




   




 
!"
   


<



 @

 

* 
*
 
<






* 
 
 


1+1'"1-
A

 
<
<

 

B   
@*
5> C


    
             ! "#     !   $ 

" %%%$&'

 %( #)#* + " #



#%%,

 " --


! "# -   


(  

 "

$ "#   " %%%$

 "$ (# .

" % "%$%       "  # !  " % %%$ "$   # (/#

  "   

  .    "  "

    %$

% ,(01 

  %%"#  2%%3" /#

"  $01   

 %%"

"  .    %$

#

 

#", 

 !    $ "

 
 %# 

 "

 ,   

0.   ""#

$012%%3" /# (.#%"

%  

  "$  %4  #   (% # 53  



#  6 

"%.75 8!537! %3  "# 

!

 " %%%$&'

 %( 

9( "$    

%

 "

  , 

$ "#  :$#  ) :;

+ , 5 
 %# 

 "

 ,   

0.  " "" 2%%3" <# )23<+ "=
 "$ % %.75 32%%3" <# )23<+79 

3  %    # # "  (01 %# 

  "2%%3" <# 33=
 "$ %7 


01 %#



     "   

#"

 .    

"  

 6   " %3

 #  =
 ,( "$ >#   ( 01 

   "

 "#%"

 ) +
%%.$ % .

 " %""

#  

?

  "

# %    "

# "
3 % # $  

 %%.

75 8!5@72"



<# )=
 "$ %+ 

) 

+7

=" 

$,(%,   ""

  %$%



%,. 

"   6  

" %  3

 #   %

"  .       % #" ,=
 , "$ 

$ '. ( 2 ,( ""

 . 

"      6      " % 3

 #   %

"  #

"      %  #" ,  = 
 ,     "$   #     ." 

:

       :      2 ,(  !

" %%%$&'

 %( 

9( "$ (   ,     (    %  %$%   

%,  

2 ,    =
  "$   %  

 ! % $,"   % ""

 '. ( , #%"

 

 "--
5!  "#%%% %%

% % %$%    9 01 

   " "#%"

 ) +

""

 A2"

.%% "



%,    

 #"--
5! ?

  "      01 

   "

 "#%"

 ""

  "  $.#%"$

 . 

"   6    " %

 #  %

".     %#" , =
 "$ 
$ 

  

  %, " %

 # %

".     %#" ,  "$   .   .#%"   %,    %%    

   ""#

$        "    "#%"  

  .#%"

 

%,%%"#   #

. 

"

  6   " %

 # 

 "$ "  $ %%  #

 $   

 # ,   "

     

$ "#   #  

  "$     ""     .#%"  #   1  



#  

 #  %  .  .#%" 

% . "  'B% #   #  % $    

 #  %        6  01%,. .$ $  
  % "    "$  # %   =
 "$ 

   

  #

  $  "/# %, $# ""   

% #    !5      



#  .     6 

"   %.75 8
 "# %%C  

( ,

3  ) + #%%"    " # %$=
 "$   %  ""

    ,     .

 (

%

 .%%  " ""

  %$$ =
 "$ %
,.%%, %%"8 



 


""

 =
 "$ % ""

 (.  % ",  $ %%

%$%=
 "$ % ""

 ("



%,   ,.%%  #   %$% 

  

      # %$       %   

)  + 9     %  #    %   

% %(   "

 % "

$,5. "

# ! % $,   "#%"  

   $, .%%     "    !

'

.  ...$ $      " # %$
7 $ B>   =
 "$ %D

""



 

>   =
 "$ % ""

 .%%" ""

  .

$ %.7 2 $,537


$,.%% %#"  ""

 .  $#" "$ 
%$% 

$,

""

 #%"#%%% , %%.$   7   #""     "    0  ,     = 
 ,   "$  %"   .  ""=
 ,  "$   " %

0,   ,  

%

"

"  #

 

%

 

# #   

%"$ *   %"       .     %";%"   %

  ,=
 , "$   "  ,   ,    %

"

  #

 

%


   , #%"    

  ""

  %; %?

  " % " # %     " 

       " %%%$ "$    "# " %    

   




%, " %%%$  , "$  ".   %%

 

# .  01  ""#

"

"#%"

 (  $.#%"%%"#    #

. 

"  6    , 3

 #  #% $ 1

 #  %  
 .#%"



  %%,    %%  #

  #$  $.#%""

""   

 % $ 
 % 



"

 %  

.#%"$  

 

 "

"  $5%  ""  #% $ %%$ % ,

   1

 #  %   '. (  

#"

%" . $ 

 #



. .



  0 (#

 "$   # %$ #". ,( " #" 



"#%(..#%"         

 

# %$. #  $ ,/# %$   # >  "

"  %     ,  "  %   

"

 "  ?

(


 
 


@

  



<

  



<
 
!"

 

<
   

* 
B 
@ <
 

 

11





* 

   @

 * :

 
@

@<



<
 
<
"'
 '1D
 
*
@



%
:
E


@  
< 

@





  

 
@0

 
< 6288(6

'1D
*


9(


)"

<
* 
'D 

<

   


 
@ *
 




<
  



 




 
@ 0
<
9(
    :  0



  






 @ 0
<
    :



 
*



 

 
  

<
@ 
<



 
 


E 



* 
*
 





 

 1+1'"1-
;
 











  
*





0
E

@
  

< 
( 
* 
 
@<
6@
 





E 


 
<





'1'"1-
E 0
@0 

 
&1'"1-
*
 
 




<
)1'"1-


'1'"1-

 
 



<<  
  %




 
@
< 
@0

   
*






 
<0
;
 
*






 
 

 
 
 

< 9(
   


 

 
 
 *

 
  



 
<

 *
*
<

 
  




  0

 



 

 0
 
@
<<

   (
 0
 *
*




E






* 
*
 0



@*
5>

 ; 


* $
<




 


 
 
*



< 
<

  







 
@ 0
<
9(
   
<
  


 
*
 
11D




< 
<

@ 
  
  




<


  





 
!"
   

 

 ; 

   
*
 


 
   


 



0
<
   
*

 @
 
<

0

  :

< 










   





<


 
  

 
@ 


@0

  
 
<
6@
 


 


<

*  


@  
<
 
 

  





*
 


= 
@ :

 
<


 0
 
<

 

 


< 
 
@0
*
 
<


<





  

 
   0.

$ 

 

  

 
 "#.

 %"


 

  

  



!
 %#.



!

  "    

   " 

"

.
#  :

+"
<
!

#

 
=   

 
@ @


5  
 

<  

  
<

  *

<





   


< 


  
, 
 

@


 

<


 
3 
=::
 
#


@0
* 0
<



 
<
<

@
< 
 '1D
<

 
 



@ 
 F :

*
@
  
<


+&
<

0 .


5> C%::





<
B
:



 
@0

<


;

<
<




%:::


  

<

  
 




 
 0
@.
<



#



 
<

B 
<
'1D
<
  





:

 
 
 
<

 
%::
 6
9 
 
    F

<



)+

* 
@

<*
5> C
 #  ,    %%.$7 )+


# =    )+3  

" % ,  $" %"#

  

#"

 

 )+
 .$  "



! "# #    % /#"      " 

 "

  E 

      

    %6  ( # (.#%" %  /# % , % #  ) +
   

 #  %   .  

,3

 ."#



%,

 

  %

 #

." " ) +-   

 . "" "    # :  " F B

) #  + " %G" "

 #  %

  ) + #    % #$  ""  $   .%%5

% " "

    ) +3 $ ," ,

%"#  

 #  %  

"   % ""  % %



3  , 

.%.$#    $ 

  %,  % %

#"

.%%    $$ "  



" %; " .

     "



# # $ .  % %

#"

01(

#"

. "

  " %%3" -   -6  .#%" % $

$

  
   $

#"

.. $    

,. ,

 #  %  .#%"

" # $". "    # : " F B

) #  +

# #%# %,%%." ) +! $ #      



 % ,.   %"

"%,   $ %   2  %   



 # 3"  )6+


#"

..#%"$  

 #  %   $    "  %  $#"(       "%,  , 

     #% ?

:


<

 <<  



 

<
*
@

  



@
*
 
@
$

@ 


 *


B  <
 


<

 
*
 
 



< 



@0


* 
 





 
<

"'D
=


<
0  

'1D
=


<

. @
;
 0

$



<
#



/=:

/%
<


  
  
8


#


"111
 @
@0
  
 
<
:
* 
 


5> C   1)(231(  1  +(4()'*,    )&,2*2&'(  1 +'51&23&'()31+(++6&447(& 448+
5> :

:::

































 :
(



<
 

   G 


<



  
 
@




 @
 *
 


G9 
(

  %

:




*


>* 




<
  @
   
 
@
 


@  
<
 $
@



2

 
8  @

0>>8  
(


   
 
@



 >  


% <

 


 
0

5

 

  



<    
*


 
<
 @  

0
*  


 $
 0
@
 
@0
 G 
% 

0






<
1D
<

 $
@


<
 
0 
<
 


 
G
 << 
 



 B 
<
!1D <

 $
@



2

 
8  @

0>> 8  
( 
 

 << 
 
 
@
 < 
@0


 G 
 

0
<



F  
99, 
3,+(44*,5>>
= 
(
 
@

 
<
  


   
=

GG GG


   8

 
:




@  
<



<

 
8  @

0>>8  
(  ="
(
  
 

0
<
 
<

'1D %
:
H
 
<

 @




 
@  
@0

   
 
<
  
  
 



B



 
@
0 <




G
 =!
(
 
<

   
 =

 GG GG


  
8

  :




G9 
(

0
 
   8

 
:


 @ 
@0

  

  



9 

0
 9 

0
( 
 0


 0G 

:

G 


 
@
 
@0

 


 
 
@

> 
  
 



 
<


 F %
 
<

@
*
 @ 

 
*
@

 @ 0

 @

B 
<



 
<


0
 

<








 
   
(
 
<
<*
<

 


!

#

 
*



)+
=B   
@

6
  @


 
@

 
<
 

 

 

<
0








  
<



0









  
 
:

 
<



E


<


 0
*   
@
   
0

 
<
 


<
%


&
<



<
: 
(<




 

@





 
 


  

 (

 
<
*


@ $>
<
 
)!

<
"'

 
@ 
'1D
*
@



%
:
H

  


 
<
)"
* 
<
 @



<
 


*
 


<
0
 


  
(
 
 
 

<
9(
    *
@
E $

 

<

 
>-

>-
  




 @

< 

<



$ *

   
*
 
  

   
<

 
< '
0 


 
<

*
 
 

9 
(

0 <
   
<

 
<

 
'
0 


 
<


*
 

 @
  0

9(
   
<

 
<
'
0 

0




 
 
<

@  
<




*
@
  ( 


<
*
 $

  <    

 0
E



*

  
*




@ 
11D



 
<

:
<  
  <


 
@ 
 
 @ 




<
<
@
@0
  


 




 


<


 
<
@0
$ 


 
 
(
 




'1D
<
 
@ <
 
 
@

<


 
<

<

  <
  



<
9(
   
C( 
@
<
 F

$
<

 



<


 
<
 

"'

* 
 


*
@

<

  
 


<
"'
 
 

9(

'1D

)!
 
*
@

 

<
@

<

9(
   


 0
 


%
:
H
  
0
)"
 
<




@
< 
 
(<
 
@
<
 
<


 

<



  


< 



< 
% :
H 

(

 


 
@0
   
%


*
  0
  
<
 <
 


 


  
*
 0
@ 
<

 
@ 
 


@
*
 
B

 (
 


@ 

  

0

*
@


<  <


'1D


 
<
@
  

)"
 <  

 
<



< 


 
'1D
  @



%
:
E  2@0
 
 
0
E



 
>-

> -
*

   
  
 $ 

   



 



 
<

 

  0

<


 


0

<

<< 


 0

 


<


 
<
*





 @

0
<
 @
<
 
* 

"'
 
 






$
< @

  



 


<
%


&
<



 <
: 
;
*



 
<

9(
    


 
; 
  




<



 
<
*
*
 

*
 

'1D
<


 
  @




< 
'1D
<
%
:
H
  @


 

 


*
 

 
  
 


  
:
 
@
 
@    
   



  @

0
@
*

<










@ < 



> 
<
 

B   :
 *
<

@

*
  

   




 
!"
   

  
<
@0
$



 *

@ 
 

 
 






< 
 
* 



  
@
 
*
 

   0
 $

 

*
*

<





 
@ @0  
  



B 
 
 
<



   

<
*
*



 

< 
<

   

 *
<
*
 
@



@
*
   
*
 
 
 
 
< 
%
:
  *
@
 
  

@


<
6@
    %


 
 
<  0
<


@
 

 

 


  
<
9(
   


  
<

  0









































































=%
#48#



,98 '1'"1-





















































=#%, :#
8 #%;%( 











,98




 

 $; "

H    % H