High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/143/2015dismissed

Pr. Commissioner Of Income Tax-I v. M/S Bbf Industries Limited

2016-04-26Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik,Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta8 pages

!"#"$%&%'())

*++%&&%'"*'$+" ,-./#0% '

1122"33 '!

5& '#/&!*%"&.%+%!"# 1 "&2'#"'!

( 6.

7 7 .

!"# $$%% & '( )*'!)"# +'

' %!"# !

$" 9 :8/+ * %!! 3- '"

%%"'$ ! ,! -!.

% " *% $ ' /"

'0'% 1*' '#%#"' %2+#!

3'/4 " 0

3$ "35 #**" '

, 0 4 !.,' !6 7 / ' ""

4* 8 $ " 35 0 4 $$%% '3* %!

"'/ ' !6 '3* %7', :92;:

0 5

,& - $$%%

" '%" 9 -&9

('/ $0'' 0" *3 '

%1*' % + '" $$%'

%%+" #'" " "

" .

" %%+'/ 0"" *3 '

% 1*' % ++ ( "& 6' <

" ' *0 2=3% 0 4$$%% '3* %+ '/ '% +'1* '/ $'/ 0*" ' -: > 0 4 !.,! %"'/ 03 0

/ $'' "

% /*"

'0 '/' 0 $ "'/

""' %" $'0 5

3 '/

' !+ $ "'/*" ' - 0 !.,+'''

"+' ' $'" *5 0 "

%# 05 '$#' ' - 0 4 !.,+ $$%'

3%'

''< 2=3% 0 4$$%% '3* %' '" %"

$ "'/*" ' - 0 4 !., "*$

/ $''+

" % '0"

""* '*" '> 0 4 !.,# '* *3'"'+ 0+ "0''3%'#'+ % +% '"

"+35 2=3%$49*'

'''<

"' ' *0 ! 2=3% 0 4$$%% '3* %+ '"' %%+'/%'

35 %"'/

# '**3'"''*3'"5! '/ *3'"5 "'* *3'"5 '#"35 $' % '$' *?

'#<

"' ' *0 ! 2=3% 0 4$$%% '3* %+ '"' %%+'/%'

35 % $'/' % '#$%

"* '/ *3'"' 0 4$"'*' *"! * ' 0+ % *" " *3'"5!+ * %%535"* '/ *3'"5

0 4$! ' % '0'/""* '*" ' > @ *3'"'''"' 0 35

'/ $ '

%'/'3%3*'

#< 2=3% 0 4$$%% '3* %' '"'% + ' %%+'/""* '*" '> 0 4 !

.,# '**3'"' '#"35 !+ 0 ' %%+ 3%'#'+ % +% '""+35 2=3%$4 9*'

?7 A*'' "''

#3 % '0"'

%5+ A*''''#

#3 % '0"' " % + '

'"'

%# " '' #5'#%#" "'

0 53' "*" % '/ ' 0 !>!,.! :&+ '%" .

, 0+ 0$%"*" ' ,

> ' 0 !!> !

:&B !

0+ $"*" ' - .

0 + 0$%"

' 0 !

,.:&

"' %%+'/ ""* '*" '> 0*'/!

:& * # '**3'"'35 '/ *3'"' $ $ '%'/'3% ""* '*" '> //'#"35 "!

'%" %3 900'' 0 4$$ %C9D / ' $'/ 0 +%% "' %%+ ""* '*" '> @ 0*'/ !" !"

":& 9*$ %" '

' / "'/$'/ 0*" ' -

+%% "' %%+'/""* '*" '> )'%% ' '"!

'%" % 3 '3* % 8'" " "

4*8! '3* %1* " $'/ 0*" ' - 35%5'/*$# '* *"/0 %%+" %2+#!

'*% '/""* '*") '> # '**3'"' + *"'

" '

#* 2 ' % 35 #* <

# "% " *% $ ' "#'/A*'' "'' ' " 3#!/ "'/ '*1* $'/ 0% '/ 05

,& -*" ' - /*" 0

/ $''!'

%%5 ""35 '3* %

""' %" 0$%

3 '/

' / '/' 0+ '

+ "*%5#'

'" " *!0

/ $''!$'/ 0 *%"3 %"3# %'" '" %# '"'/ ""35 '3* % ''* " *"& 6- !

'%"3 '3 '/

' 4$% ''/

+ + %'/'3% ""* ' *" '> @'$ E' "E' ) ! +#! '/

' " 3 ' #'"% "

@&- '%!'/

' $"

0' (

3" "+ '

/ $'''!

! %

+(+ #*"$ 0

'0 '/' 0$ "'/'$ % '0 *" '> ) *' " '/

' #'

" +

'%* $

"' % 0$%

3 '/

0 / + 0 '

0 ' 4' "

$' '/

' $'/ 0

/'3% 0 '

% + *" / ' "

% 0 " $'/ 0 " ''+ '

"' $'/

0'" '' 2=3%)*$09*' )%'/F" "B'35"'

B'0'"*$ + % "5 '"" 35 '/

' + '% $ '/ '/' %

0" !'' % %5

$'' $ '/

' " !0

/ $''!$'/ 0 *%"3 %" 3# %'" '" > 9'"'/ 3# $$'' % + " '"" ' # '*

*"/01*" 3#!'' %

' '

'"'$'/ 00

/ $'' % " *% ! 3 ' $%' '%"

3 '/

' '/' 0$ "'/

3 3%$#

"' %" %%$'0 5

3 '/

' '0 0 ('/'/' 0" " ,

> '/

' !

4 0''/ $%' "" '% "! $" *3 '

% % '0

""* '*" '> @'$ *' ) *! '/

' 0" $'' 3 '

" 0 '

% " 35 $'/ % '0

0'*+ '

0+ $" " '' '"35% ";+*%"*$$ #*3 * '"'/ "" 3# .9'"'/ 3#"' *'!+" '" 5 '

* ''3%+ 5 $'/ 0 $'/ 0' * % %53 "'% + "' %'

3%31* "< "'/%5 '" "

* '' 3%+ ' 0 5

,& - " 1* $'/ 0 *" ' -: > $$ % ' %%+"' 05

,& - ' /*" 4444444444444444444444444444444447 , "#'/A*''''#! 5% "'

*3'"'!

, ''+('/9 $' %*3'"5!* *3'"5 "F'/ *3'"5 '#"35 " '* ''+ ""* '*" ' > + %%+ 3%'$ *3'"' - 4 0''/ 0 " % + $' "' %'

%5'/*$ *"/0 G *

'2'/ 9*' !

! "

+ # '* *"/0' %*"'/ *"/0 )*$09*'

*$ + '""! '3* %"

F'/ *3'"5!'* *3'"5 "'*3'"5 "'#" 0'"*'

%*" ('/ "%'/'3% ""* '*" '>

> #*

%%/"

'"" '' G *

'2'/

9*35+ 5 )$ '

%B #'' $49*' #""# #$

%#" & !

9'#'%$$ %-,

" '""

'0" " '' G *

'2'/ 9* ""'0'"

% #* %# 3# '0 "35 $49*' &

!" ' *$ ! " *& #$

(

) ( *

(

& &

& %

(

, % ) &

- %%

)

$!.*/ $!.*'

)

- % &

)

$!.*/ $!.*'%

- % 0 2 1%

3!4$'',!53-,'4

3!!4 6*

"!3,74

3!4

!* 63,74

% % 8 % %

) '

! " #

$ 3 4

% % !

.% %