High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9000/2018dismissed

Bhupender Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-04-16Mr. Justice Gurmit Ram6 pages

!"# $

%#%# "

&"'

%(% )("*( (( !% "'

! %'

"' %, -" ( (.*(( !#%/!01(%

%#%# " "(*"# % %#%# #' "#''

( 1 (3"#%# %

(% " 1"%#"("# " 4 ('

# $ #5

$ ! "!"' !(%!

6 ", (''!7*# ( 1#(855#''# "/)("*( (/"!"!(%!

6 " , (''! 7* 55#''# "/ + %(. #0#'# / + %(.( !"!"!(%!

6 ", (''!7*881%"/ ( # (%/3 "7*/"'

! % ('7 (

# %!(':(57("!("

&#88($#;(3(/ '#8'"( (/#'%"#1%( # (%3 #8";1%# $% 18(#5

%#%# " "# 8*/% (1%' 1('('5(! %# % %#%# / ("% (% (1.3("!8('':(57("!(" &#88($#;(3(/#'%"#1% ( # (% 88 0(1( % % !(% ("8#":(57("!("/ (58*/("*(0 # $ %" #'!(% /(

8#1(%# '3"# 0#%! "(

# %# $( 3 :(57("!(" '#8!("/ '"( ( ( ! #0#8/ ( # (% ( %"

1 '#!"# $"'

1( !#!(%'/"155 !!% (5 ! %+#'

#(8/3 3('(

# %!(':(57("!("7*%

881%"0#!"!"!(%!

$$"#0!7*"!"!(%!

(''! 7*881%"/ ( # (%/ % %#%# " #8! ( (

(8 7 " %

55#''# "/+ %(.#0#'# /+ %(./3 3('(8'!#'5#''!0#!

"!" !(%!

3(' 1 (88 $! 7* %

%#%# " 7* 3(* #8# $ "0#'# %#%# 7 " % # ( 1#(8 55#''# "/ )("*( (/ 3 3(' (8' !#'5#''! 0#! "!" !(%!

"!"' 881%"/55#''# "( !# ( 1#(8 55#''# "("'

7;1%5(%%" (88 $# % %#%# :(" !1 '8 %#%# "'

75#%'% (%"'

! % 3('$#0 " 17# $' !1('!,:(57("!("/3 "('/#%#'( '%%8! 8(3 % (% "!#%("* " 1 # (

# %5 % % % '%

:(57("!("#' 1 '%#% %# (8:(" !1 '8

"% "'

75#%'% (%8(" !

881%" (' "155 !! % (5 "'

! % 71( ' %

%#%# "#' 8* (''( !"'

! %#'$"(!

(%/3 "('/% #' 7("# (

# %# $ % 8'' !

1(%! "' (':(57("!("

&#88($ 1( !#!(%' (0 %7 %(. # % 1 '#!"(%# ('% %#%# "#'* $"# ($( !#' (0# $(!4 (%8( !

# 15 ("#' %"'

! % %#%# " ('(8'1 %"#7 %!

%3("!''1#(8'"0#1/3 "('/"'

! %#'"

# $(57#8'

( ! ("!8*$%'%#5 "'1#(8'"0#1' %% !/8(" !1 '8 '

75#%'% (%(88% "#%#' (0 %%(. # %1 '#!"(%# % 5"#%'

%#%# "( ! 8* % 7('#' "!#%("*18(#5/"'

! %

('7 (

# %!(':(57("!(" )("! % ("$ 5 %' (!0( 1! 7* 8(" ! 1 '8 " %

%#%# " ( ! (0 (8' $ % " $ #5

$ ! "!"' ( ! %

< !1 5 %'(0(#8(78 % #8 (1%' 1('(" %!#'

%! !5#%%!8*/ (5

! %3('"155 !!7* '#8!("/'"( (( !#0#8/ ( # (%( ! 3('(

# %!7*% 881%"/( # (%0#!"!"!(%!

$$"#0!7*'(#!"!"!(%!

(''!7*881%"/ ( # (%/% %#%# " #8!( (

(87 "% 55#''# "/+ %(.

#0#'# /+ %(./3 3('(8'!#'5#''!

(#!"!"!(%!

3('1 (88 $!7*% %#%# "7*3(* #8# $"0#'# %#%# "% # ( 1#(855#''# "/)("*( (/3 3('(8'!#'5#''!

0#!"!"!(%!

'(8 "!" 881%"18("8*'

3'% (% # #%#(88*80 "' '(

8#! '%/3 "('/ 8%#5(%8* 8*%3 1( !#!(%'# %#%# "( !"'

! %3"# % "(1+'

! % 3('*("' ($( !3('' !1('!,:(57("!("/ (58*/ ("*(0# $ ) (!! #'$"(!

(%# "55#8#%("*( ! !%

$0" 5 % '1 5' 7* !

'#%# $ <= 8(1' # '5(88 (5#8* 8( # $ '1 5'('388(' ("%#1# (%!# % "1('' (5#8* 8( # $'1 5 )3(' (0# $1( (8'( !<5("8(' 8( !( !990#88($"' 0#88($ $(0'%(%5 %'# #' (0 " % % " ( !/% %#%# "3('< *("'

($( ! (! (''! 18('' 8*) (!!

'#%! =8(1'# '5(88 '(0# $'1 5'( ! (!(8' ("%#1# (%!# %31('' (5#8* 8( # $ *1 '#!"# $% %#%# " ('388('"'

! % ( ! # !# $ "'

! % 5" '

#%(78 ( ! 5"#%"# '/ %

881%" (' (

# %! "'

! % (' :(57("!(" 0#88($ "!" 881%"3('(

#"5!7*% 55#''# "('(

#8! 7* % %#%# " 3(' !#'5#''! #5#8("8*/ % # ( 1#(8

55#''# "(8'!#'5#''!% "0#'# #8!7*% %#%# "7* 8!# $ (%"'

! %#'5"4 (8# #!( !6 "# 1!% ( % %#%# " -"0"/#%#'('%%8! " '#%# 8(3% (%# 1('/%

"!" 881%"#'7('! " "(

"1#(%# 0#! 1

1!7*% ("%#'( !7*15 ("# $%

1( !#!(%'% # %"

" 1#'"4 #"!%1( 7# %"

"!/# 1('/%

"!"#'7('! 5#'"

"' %(%# (1%'0 #% ('7 8!# 0("# ';

!$5 %'% (%# 1('/%30#3'(" ''#78/% "'

8! % 7( *# %"

" 13#% #15(!7*% 881%"(' ('7 8!

# % ;

!$5 % #0#'# 1 "%# 1('

! 7%/ "(

# %5 %%% /% ($

1( !#!(%#' ("80( % (1%" " (

# %5 % /%

(1%"'3 (" 1''("*%71 '#!"!("% "!#%("*18(#5'>%

" "%*# % '%(% ''''!7*% 1( !#!(%%'1 "% "10"*

8( !,"0 >'"0#1" !"!%% %(%7* #5'8 "7* #' (5#8*( !

(8' #' "' (8 # 1/ 1 ("(1%"/ (7#8#%* ( ! "!5 "5 # !7%! ''(' ('7 8!7*) ?78% 6 "%# 1('

! "!

! 7%/( # !# $"1"!!7*% '%(% %"*( "#%*/# !

%7 "0"'/#'8#(78%7# %"

"!3#% # 6"1#' #%';

"#'!#1%#

!#( 3"!@:(57("!("?#'!

# !# !0( 1!:(3:6#1 /<"!

!#%# =/ ($ ('(@ (!5( (0#88($" ( (%%#"'1%#

(0#88($?% ('

"% "7 '%(%!% 8%#0(%"3 #% " #'3 (11 %/"('% "

"' %(%#0 % "557"' 0#88($/ (*'%

= A0" 5 %!

'( !#'"$#'%"!# % 881%"?'"88(11"!# $% #'

57"('% "

"' %(%#0 "'% 5(* 8!%

#17*!'1 % "7*81%# #'$0" !7*% "0#'# '

;(7:( !+0 1%( !% + 8' "(5!% !")#' %( A0" 5 %'"0( %( ! !' % 8!(1#0#8 '%3#% # % 5( # $

"%#18< !#()#' (#!( #6!(5 %("8#"

#'!

%*3('%1881%% (5 % "0 ( ! '!%$%'5 (5 % "0 1881%! ("% "51881%# "0 / !'

% "

1%# '# 18 !# $" !#%# (''#'%( 1%( # 0'%#$(%# $

#1"/ # 1('/% 1"#5#'155#%%!# % 0#88($ #'%"#1%881%"#'%

# %# $( "#%*)1 '#!"'

1( !#!(%'# !%(#8 "%3 #86"1#'# $#%';

"#'!#1%#

!#(#'7('#1(88*1 1" !3#% 1""1% ''

!1#'# 5(.# $ "1''( ! %% 5"#% !1#'# % (' %7

!7*% "%% 881%"# 6 "''# $ #' # # ('"$("!'

15 ("(%#05"#% %#%# "0#B,(,0#B"'

! %155#%%!( """# #'!1#'# 5(.# $ "1'' C !#'

%!8*/ % "# 1# 8' (% "(8 ;

'%#1 (0 7 15 8#!3#% ( ! "1!

"(' 8(#! !3 # % + 8 ('(8' 7 15 8#!3#% %#'(8' %1""1%%'(*/(' ('7 1 % !!7*%

1 '8% 1( !#!(%' (! %7 %(. # % 1 '#!"(%#

' ;

!#1#(8"0#3#'% '

"% # !#0#!

(8 "1#0' (#"%"(%5 %( ! %% '

"% "#%*( %"(11"!# $

(#"%"(%5 %"(1 '/ (5(%%"3 #%#'( "#B!7*8(3%!1#!"

%!"(3(1 18 '# 3 #'1""1%# % *' "%D !#1#(8 "0#3#' %( (

(8 "5(!1#'# 7 %("0#3 5( "# 3

!1#'# ('7 %(. %#' %'( %'(*% "%'#%'# ;

!$5 % % 8* % 1""1% '' !1#'# 5(.# $ "1''7 (8' % 1""1% '' !1#'# #%'8 %#'(388'%%8!8(3% "%6"1#'# $% 3"

!#(#' %8#.( (

88(% ( "#%*%1 '#!"% !#'

%%#'%7' ('%3 "% #5

$ !

"!"#'7('! "1"!'"3 "% "#%#' (0(

8#!% #"3 5# !" %%% "80( % (1%' "1( %7( *! 7%"!#'

(%'0"% (%(3"#%1 "%1 8!# %"

"3#% ( # !# $ (1%/# 1('/ '(5#' !%7 "0"' #1 881%"1( %78#$ %8* #$ "!( ! %# %"

"!3#% 8''0"*$!"(' '6#'% 0#3 "$("!# $% 3#$ %($#'%7$#0 %% "155 !(%# ' 83"

#1"' 8% $ 881%" #' % 7 ! % (11 % %

"155 !(%# ' 83""0

#1"'7 % ('%5(.

3 5# !(7 %% '

#%(7#8#%* 1( !#!(%' 0#3 (1%'( !8(3 '#%# ('!#'1 ''!(70/% #' 5"#%# % 1 % %# '"(#'!7*8(" !1 '8 %#%# "('

"#' "0"'#%*# % "!"'('% 881%" ('1 '#!"!% ($/ 8( ! 8!# $( !1 %"#7 %# '%3("!'0#88($155 #%*3 #8(

# %# $ "'

! %) 1/% %#%# /7# $!0#! ( *5"#%/#'

"7*!#'5#''! "#8 /

;( "'

(.# $E"(' !

"%(78 F'