← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4047/2011dismissed

(O&M) Ravinder Singh & ANR. v. Jagjit Kaur & ORS.

2020-02-14Mr. Justice Arun Monga23 pages

  

   

  



 !"#"$%&%'())

*%'#"+%',- '+) ))).."// '!& *"+&0&  ,1%!2 0+ +&) ))) "&.'#"'!& '#

3

*%'#"+%',- '+) ))).."// '!& *"+&0&  ,1%!2 0+ +&) ))) "&.'#"'!&

(  45

)  



  

     



          

 

              

 

  

 

! "

#    !  

 

   

             

 

       

     

!  

       

 

 !

 !

  !      

     

       

    $  %    &'!   (     (  )           

*   

       +

!

    

    

    (   

  (  

 ( $)

  

      (  )

  ! !  



  

!     

   

,!  !   

     

  ! 

    

    $ * !

 

  

!     ) - 

.

  /!

   

0 ! ! & &     (  #'! 



  

1

    



      !

 ! ! !  !

 

 

 



!  

 2"%

3& 

 



  2#

3&   

 '!

     ! 2 "%

3&       &'!       &  

#

-  '!

  

   

 

 

 !04 0 5  !  

06

 

,/ 0

0   0

   ! 

     !

      

 ( !



6

!   2#

3&    

 !  

  !    ! 6

0 ,

0  - 

 

!

     

      !  !

 !

             ,     '  

   ( '!   & ) #

 

   (  $     ( ) 1 

 

3

 

   '!

   & ) #

 (  )  7   



   

#

   !!2

 !



          & ) #

'!  

0 ! (     (  )   !

 !          

 # 8    

  

 (  )

        

      !

       !  !

       

9'!

          

 

  8      !  !



  !    !  

 2#

3&

 (   

    5 (  ) !

          ! 

   

!      

   

5 (  )!



  !

 !      

        !

     

 

(  % 8 

!

        

 

  !      

   !     *     

      

 :&  

       

   

       

  !   "

       # "        $ $

% 

       

    &$           

       

   

' 

       

   $  

    

  ( $

  #      !          !%     

) 

       

     # "# $  $ $    

 

 *+,

- . 

         !      '    

$ $   "

  $      

 

 #    

- * / 0 !  

     

"       

        #          #    

    $



     

     # %& '% '$$'                #       

  

 "

'%

## ( '( )*   

+ 

  +

3 + #  # # 

+"

  ''

, 

  

  +"    

      #  +"        # +" + -..

 -  +"     ')

!  %* %/ )%') 

 #0 ( *%*& )%''  

     #   +   1         

 .

 

       



        

  

 

   



    

  

   

       !

             

                     

  

    

  

 

      

 !

'2 3       

 #      

  "#  

  #

#  #  "  # 4 #  %& '% '$$'+ +"

5

 !   #

+ "+  

 # 

#+ +



#  1  +"

+" #  +  !   #

     # " 

  1

"

7



#

"    4 # %& '% '$$'    #+ 

 64   #       #+   #+  #+"



#  

5  

5     

 '*

3  

 #    #

#  #

 

 

 

     #               "    7  

#  8 9:.2;

#9:.*;

!

  #"  #3 +< 

#+ 4

+"       

#"4    

   ( =   # ,

   



5   )% %/ '$$)   +"3 +< 

# 

#4 .  

    ( = '/

3  

 #  

  #   #

5  + +" +" #

+

+0# # +       #     , #    +

   

5



"       " +   + #  #9

 ";

 ""  #      ++   +     #   "  " "

0 ) =%%5.   +      +           #   "

   +  0 '/%%%%5. "  

"+ 

%& '% '$$'  ,  #    '! %',-8&)%'#"+%',-

+&) 

%*%/79'%,/ &"- '' '8&) :/ !-  +&) 3

 6369 ;0%+ - '# '+)8&)0#"&-20: +% 

%*%/79 +&- '%',-8&) :%',-9< 

%*%/==9 >- +0/! ' 8&)) 1 : '% +&)= 

 +? '

%',-8&)2 '@ +%',- 

%*%/369  

#"4 .'$ %/ '$$) 

   ( = + " 

5 

+

+0# #  +  #  )% %/ '$$) ,"

      5  4 "# +    1     #      >   #+" 5     "  #  

"   + #+"   +#"  +"

 , # 

 '!%',-8&): +1%!%',-93 =

%*%/

< <3) 7) 3  

 #  

+

  # " +  #  

  +"

#  .4

 

5  "  #       +"  #              +      #"

 .4

   

# 



  >+ " +

"#  

    '$ %/ '$$)964 .);     

964 :5);              964 5);     ##   '&

3  

 #  +    "   # 

    "        #     



 # "  # #  964 ';  +"

  

  4       )%9);

  0        #  1    +#  

5  :  #    #      

      "        

#         

 

#

5  "  #     

"#       

#  ++

   #  "   

 "  

5  , 

5   +  0 '/%%%%5. 

=   0 '& =%%5.

#

  "   

  ""  %& '% '$$'

'

3  

 #  

5      #4 #  %& '% '$$'   

 " 

5  +  ( =  



 +    " +  # 964 ';

?  

 &?%'#"+%',-8&)%+: /2 0+< 

%*%/=69 1:"+%',-8&) 0+#% /%',-3 7

%*%/33=   ',  + '

#"$" &"#+".)A5 &8&)2 &-%+ & #9 37

%*%/ =9 )2) - ::"# B %#0// -8&) 1"" )B#0/C - B A 5+&9 6

%*%/3=3  %+: /%',-8&) "1 '# '!-"+ ==7 6

%*%/) '$   

 #+  # 

 #"

+"

 #

 ##  %& '% '$$' #+ 

 ? "

#    ""  #

          '=9;

  0 '$=2 .       

  

  #  

  "+"  #

    +  +"

 

    +   +"  +""        

"  

 +

+0# 

4 .

)% %/ '$$) ! #   "  # 

+0#  #     + 

+"( '  ( )* + 

 #" +   

#   < 

##   

 "  ( )*+ 4

+"  (4  +#  "  4

+"  

! 4  "  

+

+ 0#  #"+ +"

+ ! 

+ #" 

 #  +"

?@+ 4  0 9

; 

+ #"  #    # 

  +  +1  

  !     

" #1

     " 

 '=9;

  0 

   #"

 "

#

 9

;

)%

3    964 :)5';

# 

+     # +" 

  # >  #   '$ %/ '$$)   #   )% %/ '$$) !



 + #"     "

'$ %/ '$$)     ( A #

  #"+4

 >#



 # + ! 

+ #" + 

+" 

  '$ %/ '$$)5)% %/ '$$) "'$ %/ '$$)+"

  )'

 #    

  "   

 

+"  

  #"   #  ( )*9  ( =  ;" 

     # 

+"  3      #  

  ( )*##  %& '% '$$'+4 .+"( '

  ,

 #

     +"?@+ 4   0::  &1%#8&) 2#%: '% '#+ "*% - =7 <95-% +."+!%"& 5!#) %'&0@% %B+0, +-9&& :8&)!: + :20: +==6 

79 :

? #- " #BA5 & +&)8&)$-- %B +0B"A '+)  

<9 #: @0: +% +&)8&) & AA ' +&)3 <

7=39 >- +0/! ' 8&)) 1 : '% +&)= 

92- ,"'#+ 5 //0!!  '+)8&) $B/" $B==3 3

79 +A&! / "*"/."+&8&)&- 5 !  -&- :!) " #!-+0,-5 & +&) 3 =  

 639  ! '# +#  - +!"+"#   '@  8&)  '#-+   '@ %' '$% /  "+*%$"&  5!#)  +&)  7   

   )

 8%1 A - + !-%8&)) *%!+% +&)< 

7) ))

3    #  

        #"  +   :2    7

 8   9# +# ;#  #  

#  :2  

 8  

     

.

"       

# $%&     % ' 

 $ " $ 

  

     

"

 

   # $&

      

  

" $      



&     "

   $     "        

        "  

     ('")

* $   

+    "   

  ('" $      

  

 

       "     

 

+

     "   $   ,  )2

3      0 

#:) C!  #    +"  8D 

8    "   :) 0 

# 

C " "    ##  , " ##  , "

   #  : 

 # " +"   .4

  "  +"  +"

?    :*

#

6

# #  # C  8 

+  D  89:2;    C,   +  #3!,< 

#  6   )*

 #                        " +"

  #  ##   +# +  7

8 " +    "  + "

 ,     #      #     +"       (  A :)5'; + "  "# + "



8 !    7

8+

  #  "

3)  #   .4

  :2  7

8  + # +  7

8 

#4 #   )= #  #  #    # ..   +"    #  

    

+

+

 +

 !     #

   !  +  #

  4 # +   )&

 # + 1  

+"

       # +"

 

 



"4

#        %& '% '$$'964 .';          



  

   

+ # # !+ 3

 .

- .

      

   

      "

              */ * & .        "   %  */ *&                 

             '  

             %0 .  * %      .

*      */* & 

 */*&      1            

           . '               



     */*&  . + */*&       

             '              */*&   



  

  # $%&                 ' 

             

                    $       

       

       2                         

              

          

                      

.

*      $             

  

.

*'            

        

3                        */* &     

   ('"

)

*,          

   )

* 1  

       

       .

 *  3$ ,         

    .

 * "                       $        $   

                    '  .

*3$ ,   

        

,      '            

,

.

*"

  

                                  

,

 .

*        

  

           



     

   



+

     

 .

*   

           .

       "    

 "

      

 



   

.

*   '            $  

         



     



5 6             

 

"               ' ( 

 

  

      

 '      

* )  $*   



5  

         

    .

 *                      



7     

       

  

        

         7 

    

    $           '    

            "

  

!"!#$!

 %&'() 

18 1

     

   

  

 



      

   

  

        "    

      .  *   

        

1                 '    $                  

1                ('"  )

   *,         .     */*& .             .

  $

    "

                           

      .

*'  

     

     (  )

  *9        1              

   9 .

*      

     



* $*  & %                         $      * : 

          

         (   )

   *   

   

    9 .

*

* $*  '    

                    * : 

      

 '                    '                9 .

*      '      -    

 "

     .

                ;< ;;- 

               -=< ;;-"     

 -7-       

  "

             

;< ;;-    -=< ;;-  :           

                , !++ +" 

   + +" " + + + #  + 

64 '

+ # # 

# #

 +     ,   #  + #    +    ##  +  #  

#             

"     #  4    # 

+"  6 

5   :<    + #4    # %& '% '$$'964 ';+ # 

#                

       #  

       + +    #

    



  #  4 +"

# )

!  1   +"  

<  

 #

#  # 

 )$

# + 1   +"

    ( '2 # +"  

  + ( '/'= # 



 #      +.

< .                  

   $   * : 

      

 -=< ;;-   

   '   $         (  )

  *                     $ '     (  )

 *          (   



 

                 



 

              

>       

 .

*  

     :

*                        



                

2   

             

  

* + ""$ $#,(

- !#$ +.$ /%!  

    

9 .

*                                   

     "

     

                                             

 $   

     

 

            

= $              $                    

          

  "   

  

  

              9 .

*       

   $  &   9 .

*     

       

           

    9- 0   '         : * 

                     $                    

 

           4          #           

            * : 

            2           

        .

*  

9    

' ?!@    

 

   

 , 2%

!    

#    #  +  

#       #   #      5  ##    .4    !  "

 "  #    #  #" +" , ( )   " 1   >   " "   # ? #  #  " # .+"

#  ( )*+   + #  B   

   #

 )% %/ '$$)"  

#"   ( )    *  ,    +         #" 

++  

+ +  #     

+0# + 4 . + "

    +   #  2'

  #         +"    

      #  +"    #

"

  ( '/9

; #            

   +"  ""  #      !+ #  #   

   

     "# #

"  "  " 4      "   "   +  "     #  

   #  ,-

9

;    +"  ?@+     4                

       

     1

      # 1    ".

?@                A ?@                

  

  , 

  +   2)

, 

#@       4 .+ 

      # , 

 



"+"  #      ,   +"?@+ 4 

 - 

@  9

;    

+ 

  

5

 "+"  #      !   #     

#@9

; 

 " 

!  

   

( )*+ +

 # 64 ' +"1   

  +"                        

  6                        +    #+" 

    

    ( )* 

      ## 

+"

   

#  !           

              #  +

  #

      

  "

0 "+ :? #-

" #BA5 & +&)8&)$-- %B +0B"A '+) 

<) !   

 " #  +  +1 

     "  #       >- + 0/! ' 8&)) 1 : '% +&)= 

 ! #  

+"   

   " 



 2*

,0   

E+  9

; 

           "

       1

" +   4  # +

 + 

 ,  

   "

 #" 

   

     

 !   #    # ! #  

+"

  

 

 +  "    2/

0   #  ( 

#9

; 

 !    +1 



## +" 

 !+ #    #  

 + 

   "  #+" +1 

5   2=

, + #     #       #  

         #

@ 

  #

  "

! +  +"?@+

   0 9; 2&

,  

" #  +  +1 

      "  #   

0+ -

9

;

!#



6   

"  +  + "

!

   

 .

.      

  #  +"B 

  + 

"   +"   !       #+ 

      !        "    # "        #  (

  A







     "B+0 +A9  : 

#5 F5( : + F5(