Bony Polymers P Ltd v. M/S Bestways Transport India P Ltd And ORS

 
  
  
  
   
   
   
   
 



!" "#$%$&'(

!" "#$%$&'(

!" "#$%$&'(

!" "#$%$&'(

&)*)+",%-!. "!$!$&", /% 01% "%!2 )%, &%3,!&.$ -!. &.!4",% "%3&."&!%
0'5 -0
660 0'5 -0
660 0'5 -0
660 0'5 -0
660 ,"%"&!' 0,*7 $&8.9# !"8

,!4"3"!$!$&", 6608:-;

6608:-;

6608:-;

6608:-; 4"3"!$!$&",4 %#4 **"&<".!4"3,#"".$&<% !4" ,) &  0$#, &. + ** &!",3,$%"%  #$*$! !$&
=&#$* ,"#,.". $& $!%  &. +""!$&<4"*.&> (?)24$#4!4"
=&#$*4 .=& &$+=%*)."#$.". !,"

",!4"+ !!",!!4""+3 &"**".,?$!, !,&!$ $".?)!4"9",&+"&! $&!",+% =*"@ !4" ,) & 0$#, &.+ **&!",3,$%"% #$*$! !$&
=&#$*8 =*"%8 ( A , %4,! B!4" =*"%5C ," . 2$!4 "#!$&  :D; 
4 3!",/ 0$#,+ ** &.0".$=+&!",3,$%"% "9"*3+"&!#!8 @ ,%4,!B!4"#!5C &..$,"#!".!4",?$!, !,!."#$."!4"+ !!",2$!4$& 2""7% &?,$"

8 #* $+,"

","&#"2 %+ ."?),"%3&."&!!!4"  ,) & 0$#, &.+ **&!",3,$%"% #$*$! !$&
=&#$*8$&!",+% !4" 3,9$%$&% !4"#!8 < $&%!!4"3"!$!$&",$&,"< ,.! & +=&! ##,=$&< & ##=&! %",9$#"%,"&.",".?),"%3&."&! % !, &%3,!",!!4"

  3"!$!$&",8 24 $%  + &= #!=,", & D (8 !4"
=&#$* 3 %%". !4"

**2$&<,.",' E,"%"&!'  4 & &. 0 *$78 *""! 0 & <",8 & ?"4 * #* $+ &!

 &" 33" ,". & ?"4 *  ,"%3&."&! &" 33" ,". & ?"4 *  ,"%3&."&!  4"
=&#$* ?%",9". !4 ! !4" # %" 2 % *$%!". , !4" $,%! !$+"  4"
=&#$* ."#$.". ! <$9" &" +," 33,!=&$!) ! !4" ,"%3&."&! , 33" ,$&< ?"

,"!4"#=&#$* &. ,+ 7$&<"

,!% , %"!!*"+"&! !4"3 )+"&!.$%3=!" .F=,&".G  $&#" !4"," 2 % & . !" <$9"& ! !4" !$+"   .F=,&$&< !4" 4" ,$&<8!4","

,"8 &!$#"2 %$%%=".?)!4"
=&#$* ,!4"&"H!4" ,$&< +""!$&<& D ( , ( !D 0$&!4"

$#" $,"#!, !"  &.=%!,$"%I
++",#"8 ,) & 8%!*,8D  )% =$*.$&<8"#!,(8
4 &.$< ,4 3,3%8!4"+""!$&<2 %4"*.& (824$#42 %# **".  !4+""!$&< !4"
=&#$*$&24$#4!4" **2$&<,.",2 %3 %%".' E,"%"&!'   &"&?"4 * #* $+ &!

D

 466,$9 %! 9 80$& &#"& ?"4 * ,"%3&."&! &" 33" ,".&?"4 * #* $+ &!8 42"9", !"*"34&$#+ %% <","#"$9". ,+ !4" #* $+ &! !4 ! 4" $% &! ?*" ! !!"&. +""!$&< .=" ! ?=% %!,$7"  "%3&."&! %=?+$!!".!4 !* %!!, &% #!$&+ ."$&0 )8

  &. !4") 4 . &! ,"#"$9". &) #++=&$# !$& " ,*$", ,"< ,.$&< 3"&.$&< 3 )+"&!%!4"#* $+ &!2 %&!3,"%"&!8 !4"
=&#$* ."#$.". ! .F=,& + !!", , &"H! 4" ,$&< ! ! 7"  ."#$%$& ,"< ,.$&< F=,$%.$#!$& & !4" $%%="  $*$&<   #* $+ 33*$# !$&2$!4!4"#=&#$* .F=,&".G < $&&%3"#$ $#. !"2 %<$9"&24$*" .F=,&$&<!4"+""!$&<8 !4","

,"89$."&!$#". !". ( (8!4"+""!$&<2 %# **". ,> ( ! !4" % +" !$+" &. 3* #" & 24$#4 !4" " ,*$", +""!$&< 2 % 4"*. 4$% +""!$&<2 %# **". &.+""!$&<$&24$#4!4" **2$&<,.",2 %3 %%".' E,"%"&!'  4& &.0 *$78*""!0 & <",8& ?"4 * #* $+ &!

 4 6 6 ,$9 %! 9 8 0 $& &#" &?"4 * ,"%3&."&!

  "%3&."&!%=?+$!!".!4 !!4","2 % & ?=%$&"%%1#,,"%3&."&#" %$&#" "3!8

D %* %!#3)$%   D &. !4","#"&!#++=&$# !$&2 %,"#"$9".?) !4"+ & >  @  4=% !4" #* $+ $% ? ,,". ?) * 2   *$+$! !$&  4"
=&#$* ?%",9". !4 ! % 3", !4" *".<", ##=&! &! %=?+$!!". *&<2$!4#* $+ 33*$# !$&8* %! 3 )+"&!% 2"," ,"#"$9". & D@  ?) #4"J=" 4","

,"8 !4"
=&#$* 2 %   !4" 9$"2 !4 ! #* $+ $% &! ? ,,". ?) * 2  *$+$! !$&4"
=&#$*?%",9".!4 ! %3", !4"*".<", ##=&! &!%=?+$!!". *&<2$!4 #* $+ 33*$# !$&8 * %! 3 )+"&!% 2"," ,"#"$9". &

D @ ?) #4"J=" 4","

,"8!4"
=&#$*2 % !4"9$"2!4 ! #* $+$%&!? ,,".?)* 2 *$+$! !$& 4"
=&#$* =,!4", ?%",9". !4 ! !4" ,"%3&."&! 4 . $*". ! ,"#&#$*" !4" + !!", ."%3$!"   %=

$#$"&! 33,!=&$!$"% 3,9$.". .=,$&< !4" +""!$&<% 4"*. &

 D (8  ( &.  > (

=!!4","%3&."&!$%&!#+$&< ,2 ,.! %"!!*"!4".$%3=!"4"
=&#$*2 % !4" 9$"2 !4 ! !4"," ," & #4 &#"%   +=!= *

> %"!!*"+"&! &. !4" ,"#&#$*$ !$& 3,#"%% %! &.%!",+$& !".  !",4" ,$&<?!4!4"3 ,!$"%8!4"
=&#$* =& &$+=%*)."#$.".!,"

",!4"+ !!",! !4" "+3 &"**". ,?$!, !, &!$ $". ?) !4" 9",&+"&! 9$." ,.", . !".   D8

 &. D @ > =&.", =*" @   !4" 0
 =*"%8 ( ," . 2$!4 "#!$& :D; 
4 3!",/ 0$#,+ ** I 0".$=+ &!",3,$%"% "9"*3+"&! #!8

@4",?$!, !,%4 **."#$."!4"+ !!", 2$!4$& 2""7% ,+!4". !" ,"#"$3! !4"# %"

$%3%".

G  4"3"!$!$&",8242 %!4","%3&."&!?"

,"!4"
=&#$*82 % ,"3,"%"&!".?)66,$9 %! 9 80$& &#"&!4"% $.+""!$&<$" &. +""!$&<8 $! 2 % ?%",9". ?) !4"
=&#$* !4 ! !4" ,"%3&."&! !4","$& 4 .

$*".!,"#&#$*"!4"+ !!",."%3$!"%=

$#$"&!33,!=&$!$"%3,9$."..=,$&< !4"+""!$&<%4","

,"8"H",#$%$&<$!%32",=&.","#!$& :D; !4"#!8 !4"
=&#$* 33$&!". "+3 &"**". ,?$!, !,8 &!$ $". ?) !4" 9",&+"&! =&.", =*" @   !4" =*"%8 ! ."#$." !4" *$% ?"!2""& !4" 3 ,!$"%  4" + !!",8 !4","

!",8 2 % 3=! =3 ?"

," !4" "+3 &"**". ,?$!, !,8 24 $%  ,"!$,". $%!,$#! &. "%%$&% =.<"  "

," !4" ,?$!, !,8 !4"," 2 % & ,"3,"%"&! !$& & ?"4 *    !4" 3"!$!$&", &. $! 2 % 3,#"".". < $&%! "H3 ,!"4",?$!, !,3 %%".!4" 2 ,.&@ ( %3",24$#4!4"

@ 3"!$!$&", 4 % ?""& + ." *$ ?*" ! + 7" !4" 3 )+"&!   #",! $& +=&! <<,$"9". < $&%! !4" 2 ,.   !4" ,?$!, !,8 !4" 3"!$!$&", 9 $*". !4" ,"+".)  $*$&< ?F"#!$&% =&.", "#!$& D    !4" ,?$!, !$& &.
&#$*$ !$& #!8 @ ?"

," !4" $%!,$#! =.<"8  ,$. ? .  4" % $. ?F"#!$&% ,"3"&.$&< &. ,"&2 $H". ,(>  4"3"!$!$&",4 % 33, #4".!4$%
=,!?)2 )  2,$!$&!4" & !=," #",!$, ,$ ,J= %4$&<!4",.",. !".> (?"# =%"?)!4 ! ,.",!4"
=&#$*4 % 33$&!".!4""+3 &"**".,?$!, !,!$%%=?+$!!". !4 ! !4"
=&#$* 4 % 2,&<*) ,"#,.". $& $!% ,.", !4 ! %=

$#$"&! 33,!=&$!$"%2","3,9$.".!!4"3"!$!$&",$&!4"3 %! ,!4"3=,3%" ,"#&#$*$ !$& ##,.$&< ! !4" 3"!$!$&",8 !4"
=&#$* 4 % ," ",,". ! D . !"%$&!4"$+3=<&".,.",$"  D (8 ( &. > ( 4 9" *," .) ,"3,.=#". !4" ,.",% 3 %%". & !4" ,"% $. . !"% ##,.$&< ! !4" 3"!$!$&",8 !4" 33" , &#" $& !4"  !4 +""!$&< 4"*. &

D (2 %&! ,!4"3=,3%" ,"#&#$*$ !$&?=!$&,"< ,.!."#$."!4" J="%!$& F=,$%.$#!$& !4"
=&#$*!$% =,!4",%=?+$!!".!4 !!4"#3)   !4" ,.", . !". > ( 2 % &! + ." 9 $* ?*" ! !4" 3"!$!$&", $++".$ !"*) !4","

!", &. 2 % ?! $&". &

D  &. !4","

,"8 !4" 3"!$!$&",#=*.&!#4 **"&<"!4"$+3=<&".,.",. !".> ($&!$+" &. *% #=*. &! 33" , ?"

," !4" ,?$!, !, !4",2$%" !4" 3"!$!$&", 2=*. 4 9" ."

$&$!"*) #4 **"&<". !4" $+3=<&". 2 ,. $& !$+" , 4 . 33" ,".?"

,"!4",?$!, !,24","!4")4 9"?""&3,#"".". < $&%!"H 3 ,!" -" ,&". #=&%"* , !4" 3"!$!$&", 4 % =,!4", %=?+$!!". !4 ! "9"&!4=<4!4",?$!, !,4 % &&=&#".!4" 2 ,. &.!4"3"!$!$&",4 %

(

$*".?F"#!$&%=&.","#!$&D !4",?$!, !$&#!)"!!4"3"!$!$&",# & #4 **"&<"!4"$+3=<&".,.", !4"
=&#$*3 %%".&> (?)2 ) !4" 2,$! 3"!$!$& & !4" <,=&. !4 ! !4" ,.", 3 %%". ?) !4"
=&#$* $% 2$!4=! F=,$%.$#!$&  & !4$% ,"< ,.8 4" 4 % ," ",,". !  ."#$%$&   "* &< &  &. &.4,  , ."%4 $<4
=,! ,"&.",". $& !4" # %"   E4" E4" E4" E4" &.=, $ &.=, $ &.=, $ &.=, $%!,$#!
3", !$9" 0 ,7"!$&< #$"!) -!. %!,$#!
3", !$9" 0 ,7"!$&< #$"!) -!. %!,$#!
3", !$9" 0 ,7"!$&< #$"!) -!. %!,$#!
3", !$9" 0 ,7"!$&< #$"!) -!. /% 0$#,3*"H :&.$ ;8 0$#,3*"H :&.$ ;8 0$#,3*"H :&.$ ;8 0$#,3*"H :&.$ ;8 ).", ? . &. &!4",G ).", ? . &. &!4",G ).", ? . &. &!4",G ).", ? . &. &!4",G @:D;&.4- >

8."#$%$& 0 ., %$<4
=,! ,"&.",". $& !4" # %"   E01%  +"%4
&.=#!,%  -$+ E01%  +"%4
&.=#!,%  -$+ E01%  +"%4
&.=#!,%  -$+ E01%  +"%4
&.=#!,%  -$+$!". !". !". !". ,"3,"%"&!".?)$!% $,"#!, +7=+ , *"+ ,"3,"%"&!".?)$!% $,"#!, +7=+ , *"+ ,"3,"%"&!".?)$!% $,"#!, +7=+ , *"+ ,"3,"%"&!".?)$!% $,"#!, +7=+ , *"+K@D@

@D@

@D@

@D@

 &.!4",% &.!4",% &.!4",% &.!4",%/% 0I #$*$! !$&
=&#$*:0$#,I+ **&!",3,$%"%;,"3,"%"&!".?)$!% I #$*$! !$&
=&#$*:0$#,I+ **&!",3,$%"%;,"3,"%"&!".?)$!% I #$*$! !$&
=&#$*:0$#,I+ **&!",3,$%"%;,"3,"%"&!".?)$!% I #$*$! !$&
=&#$*:0$#,I+ **&!",3,$%"%;,"3,"%"&!".?)$!%
4 $,+ &8
4"&& $
4 $,+ &8
4"&& $
4 $,+ &8
4"&& $
4 $,+ &8
4"&& $

 &.!4",%G

 &.!4",%G

 &.!4",%G

 &.!4",%G >:( ;
:
$9$*; @8."#$%$& !4" ** 4 ? . $<4
=,! ,"&.",". $& !4" # %"   E01%  &<$&"",% E01%  &<$&"",% E01%  &<$&"",% E01%  &<$&"",% 9!-!. 9!-!. 9!-!. 9!-!. /% $,"#!,8

$,"#!,8

$,"#!,8

$,"#!,8 &.=%!,$"%8: #$*$! !$&
=&#$*;8 6 &3=, &. &.=%!,$"%8: #$*$! !$&
=&#$*;8 6 &3=, &. &.=%!,$"%8: #$*$! !$&
=&#$*;8 6 &3=, &. &.=%!,$"%8: #$*$! !$&
=&#$*;8 6 &3=, &. !4",%G !4",%G !4",%G !4",%G :(; 
 :
$9$*; @>( &.  ."#$%$&    =4 !$ $<4
=,! ,"&.",".$&!4"# %" E$* &. !=, * %
,3, !$&-!. &. &!4", E$* &. !=, * %
,3, !$&-!. &. &!4", E$* &. !=, * %
,3, !$&-!. &. &!4", E$* &. !=, * %
,3, !$&-!. &. &!4", /%9",&+"&! %% + &.!4",%G 9",&+"&! %% + &.!4",%G 9",&+"&! %% + &.!4",%G 9",&+"&! %% + &.!4",%G  :

;
:
$9$*; >  4 9"4" ,.*" ,&".#=&%"* ,!4"3"!$!$&", &.3",=%".!4" ,"#,.2$!44$% ?*" %%$%! &#" &% , %!4" ,<=+"&! !4"3"!$!$&",!4 ! !4+""!$&< !4"
=&#$*8 4"*. & D (8 2 % ,"< ,.$&< !4" $%%="   F=,$%.$#!$&   !4"
=&#$* $% !! **) 2,&< ?"# =%" !4" ," .$&<   !4" ,.", . !". D ( 2=*.%42!4 !!4"?=%$&"%%24$#42 %!, &% #!".$&!4"% $.+""!$&<4"*. & D (2 %,"< ,.$&<<, &!$&<&"+,"33,!=&$!)!!4"3"!$!$&", 4","$& , 33" ,$&<?"

,"!4"
=&#$* &.+ 7""

,!% ,%"!!*"+"&! .$%3=!". 3 )+"&!  4=%8 !4" % $. +""!$&< . !". D ( 2 % &! 2$!4

  ,"< ,. ! !4" ."#$%$& ! ?" ! 7"& ?) !4"
=&#$* & $!% F=,$%.$#!$& 2"9",8$&!4" !4+""!$&<4"*.& (8!4"3"!$!$&",4 %, $%". !4"$%%=" ?=!!4"#+3"!"&#" ,"%3&."&!4","$&! $*"!4"#* $+ ?"

,"!4"
=&#$* &.!4"F=,$%.$#!$& !4"
=&#$*!."#$."!4"% +" *!$+ !"*) & > (8 !4" ,"3,"%"&! !$9"   !4" 3"!$!$&", $" 66 ,$9 %! 9 80$& &#"2 %3,"%"&!?"

,"!4"
=&#$*24"&$!3 %%".!4" ,.",!4 !!4"3 ,!$"%4 9" $*".!,"#&#$*"!4"+ !!",$&.$%3=!"."%3$!" %=

$#$"&! 33,!=&$!$"% 2"," <, &!" ! !4"+ &. 33$&!" "+3 &"**". ,?$!, !,4"% $.,.",2 %3 %%".&> ( &.!4"3,"%"&!3"!$!$& 4 %?""& $*". *+%! !",&")" ,&!4"$&!",,"<&=+8!4",?$!, !,4 . 3 %%". !4" 2 ,. < $&%! !4" 3"!$!$&", 4" 3"!$!$&", 4 % *% $*". ?F"#!$& < $&%!!4"% $. 2 ,.  + &!8 ,  ++"&!8 $+3,"%%". 2$!4 !4" ,<=+"&!   !4" 3"!$!$&",!4 !$!2 %&! 2 ," !4",.",. ".> ("%3"#$ **)24"& !4"3,"%"&#" !4"$,0$& &#"4 %?""&+ ,7".$&!4"$+3=<&".,.", & !4" 3,"%"&! # %"8 $  66 ,$9 %! 9 8 0 $& &#"   !4"
+3 &) 2 % 3,"%"&! !4"& 4" %4=*. 4 9" 3=,%=". !4" 3,#"".$&<% &. %4=*.&!4 9"%$! !4+"! 2 $!!4"%=33*) #3) ,.",!4$+ , !4"3=,3%" ! 7$&< =,!4", #!$&! 33" ,%!4 !!

4"3"!$!$&",$%&2 #,)$&<9",!4"%3$**".+$*7?)!,)$&<!#4 **"&<"!4",.",3 %%".?)!4" ,?$!, !, < $&%!$!4=%8 + !4"#&%$.",".3$&$&!4 !!4"3"!$!$&", 4 % #!= **)+$%%".!4"?=%$&#4 **"&<$&<!4"$+3=<&".,.", ,24$#4$!$% !?"?* +". &.&!!4","%3&."&!% $!4 !4"%" ?%",9 !$&%8  . &! <,"" 2$!4 !4" ,<=+"&! , $%". ?) #=&%"* , !4" 3"!$!$&", $& ,"< ,. ! + $&! $& ?$*$!)   !

 3"!$!$& !!4$%%! <" &.!4=%!4"% +"$%4","?).$%+$%%".!4=<42$!4=! &),.", %!#%!%   :660;

:660;

:660;

:660; (

(

(

(             
 4"!4",%3" 7$&<1," %&". '

"%1 4"!4","3,! ?*"  '

"%1