High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/436/2019dismissed

Pr. Commissioner Of Income Tax-1, Ludhiana v. M/S Rico Auto Industries Ltd

2020-01-15Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan5 pages

!"#$ %%&& ' ()*## " *% !

"# $ !

"#%# &'(')* &+,'(-.+*/-0#')1&#*+)21)34)('5+)2 (&12-1+(61)2'&#+)2-404)1&#*+)21)34)('5

&*-'+77'55+)* +,,-./.0!/ -'&'8')4'1(1)+77'+54)2'&#'/*1)

*-')/9'+:

/*0 ;

&(-&*0!*-'/*!<+3+1)(**-'&2'&2+*'2 =

7+(('2>?

*-')/9'+:77'55+*'&1>4)+50-+)213+&-; &(-&*0!*-'&1>4)+5!< 5561)3(4>(*+)*1+5@4'(*1)( 5+6-+8'>'')/5+19'2 A;1<$-'*-'&)*-' +/*(+)2/1&/49(*+)/'( *-'/+('+)21) 5+60*-')!>5'6+(,4(*1 1'21)3181)321&'/*1)(* *-' * /974*' *-' 21(+556+)/' )5? ) *-(' 1)8'(*9')*(6-1/--+8'?1'52'2':'97*1)/9'013)&1)3 *-'/5'+&9+)2+*' 45'B ;111<6-1/-4)+9>1344(5?

/974*'(21(+556+)/'4C('@4+5*)'-+5 7'&/')* *-'+8'&+3'8+54' 1)8'(*9')*01)/9' &96-1/- 2'()*&(-+55)* &97+&* **+51)/9' ;11<$-'*-'&)*-' +/*(+)2/1&/49(*+)/'( *-'/+('+)21)

5+60*-')!>5'6+(,4(*1 1'21)3181)321&'/*1)(* *-' * /974*' *-' 21(+556+)/' )5? ) *-(' 1)8'(*9')*(6-1/--+8'?1'52'2':'97*1)/9'013)&1)3 *-'/5'+&9+)2+*' 45'B ;11<6-1/-4)+9>1344(5?

/974*'(21(+556+)/'4C(>?*+D1)3*-'+8'&+3'

8+54' 1)8'(*9')*01)/9' &96-1/-2'()*&(-+55 )* &97+&* **+51)/9'+(+77'+&1)31)*-'>+5+)/'

(-''* *-'+(('((''0)*-' 1&(*2+?+)2*-'5+(*2+? *-'

7&'814(?'+&EF -' +/*(&'5'8+)* &*-'7&'(')*+77'+5+&'*-+**-'+(('((9')* ?'+&1)858'21(

G-'+(('((''9+2'1)8'(*9')*(1)*-''@41*?

29'(*1/3&47/97+)1'(0(9' 6-1/-?1'52'2':'97*21812')2(-'

+(('((''-+2(13)1 1/+)*>&&6'2 4)2(6-1/-6'&'+59(*'@4+5*))G 1)*'&'(* >'+&1)3 4)2( -' +(('(('' 1*('5 /974*'2 21(+556+)/'

0 =0

0B CG4)2'&#'/*1) *-'/*&'+261*-45'B *-'

)/9'+:45'(0

;

&(-&*0!*-'45'(!< 4&1)3*-'+(('((9')* 7&/''21)3(0 *-' +(('(('' /)*')2'2 *-+* 21(+556+)/' 6+( 1)+28'&*')* 91(*+D'0+(*-'1)8'(*9')*(6'&'9+2'4* ))G1)*'&'(*>'+&1)3 4)2(+)2 &'345+& /+(- 7& 1* *-' /97+)? -' (('((1)3

1/'& &'

4('2 61*-2&+6+5 854)*+&?21(+556+)/'-'+(('((9')*6+( &+9'2812'

&2'&2+*'2 =

-'991((1)'& )/9'+:;77'+5(< & (-&*0!;<!812'&2'&2+*'2

B+556'2*-'+77'+5 *-'

+(('((''61*-&'3+&2*61*-2&+6+5 854)*+&?21(+556+)/'4&*-'&01* 6+(21&'/*'2*-+*21(+556+)/'4)2'&#'/*1) *-'/*&'+261*-45'

*-'45'(>'9+2'+(7'&*-'+9')29')*9+2'6'

&'8')4'7&'

'&&'2+)+77'+50*-'&1>4)+5812'&2'&2+*'2 =

7+&*5?

+556'2*-'+77'+5+)2-'52*-+**-'+9')2'2#'/*1) *-'/*+)2 45'B *-'45'(6452)*>'+7751/+>5' &*-'&'5'8+)*+(('((9')* ?'+&+(*-'+9')29')*6+(7&(7'/*18'6'8'&0*-'(('((1)3

1/'& 6+(21&'/*'2*/974*'21(+556+)/')*-'1)8'(*9')*(6-1/-?1'52'2 ':'97* 1)/9' -' &'5'8+)* 7&*1) *-' &2'& *-' &1>4)+5 1( &'7&24/'2>'56 A'3+&21)3 *-' &451)3 *-+* *-' (('((1)3

1/'& (-+55 +//4)*)*-('1)8'(*9')*(6-1/--+8'?1'52'2':'97* 1)/9'06' 1)2(*&')3*->?*-'&2'&( *-'(7'/1+5 ')/- 1)*-'/+(' %&''*)8'(*9')*8*"*2BB

;

'5G&1>< +)2 +5( *-'&2'& 1) *-'/+(' &19'

&7'&*? '8'579')* &7 8* "*2 1) H

C49C

2+*'2

H$'21&'/**-'(('((1)3

1/'&*/974*'*-'21(+556+)/'+//&21)35?F -' 7&'(')* +77'+5 1( 15'2 &+1(1)3 + 3&1'8+)/' +3+1)(* *-' 21&'/*1) *-'&1>4)+5 "'+&)'2/4)('5 &*-'&'8')4'+&34'2*-+**-'&1>4)+5'&&'2

1) 21&'/*1)3 * /974*' 21(+556+)/' )5? /)(12'&1)3 *-' 1)8'(*9')*( 6-1/-?1'52'2':'97*1)/9'6'8'&0-'6+()*1)+7(1*1)*21(74*' *-+**-1(4&*1))49>'& /+('(-'52*-+**-'+94)* 21(+556+)/'

4)2'&#'/*1) *-'/*1(*>'&'(*&1/*'2**-'+94)* ':'97* 1)/9')5?+)2)*+*+-13-'& 134&' 4&*-'&0*-'#47&'9'4&*1) (%%' "'

!1&$!

4* -'52+( 4)2'& A $')*' &9*-' +/*(1)*-'#*+*' +)D +*1+5+/+('(

*-+**-'06-15'7+((1)3*-'+(('((9')*&2'&0-+2+5&'+2? &'(*&1/*'2*-'21(+556+)/'**-'+94)*6-1/-6+(/5+19'2 +(':'97*1)/9'>?+775?1)3*-' &945+/)*+1)'21)45'

*-'45'(+)2-521)3*-+*('/*1) *-'/* 6452 >' +7751/+>5' ) (71*' *-1( ':'&/1('

+77&*1)9')* ':7')21*4&'/+&&1'24*>?*-'0;< 21(+556'2*-'')*1&'2'24/*1) ':7')21*4&'-+*81'6

*-';<6+(/5'+&5?4)*')+>5'+)2&13-*5?('*+(12'>?*-' -'&'

&'0) +/*(0*-'4),+> +)2 +&?+)+13- 4&*-+(+&&18'2+*+/&&'/*/)/54(1)>?+

1&91)3*-'

81'6 *-'0*-43-6'+&')*(4>(/&1>1)3**-'*-'&? 291)+)*1)*')*1)+7751'2>?*-'13-4&**1(*>' D'7*1)91)2*-+*1)*-('/+('(6-'&'(-+&'(+&'-'52+( I(*/DG1)G*&+2'J01*>'/9'(+>4(1)'((+/*181*? *-'+(('((''

*2'+51)*-('(-+&'(+(+>4(1)'((7&7(1*1)$-'*-'& 21812')21('+&)'2 &)*>'/9'( 199+*'&1+5) +/*01* 6452>'+@41&D +*'*-+*6-')*-'1)8'(*''/97+)?

2'/5+&'2 21812')20 *-(' (-+&'( +&' -'52 >?*-' +(('((''0 *-43-*-'+(('((''-+(*45*19+*'5?*&+2'*-('(-+&'(>? ('551)3*-'9*'+&)7& 1*(-'(1*4+*1)-'&'1(0*-'&'

&'0

'&')* &9*-'/+('51D'+:77)8'(*9')*"*26-'&' *-'+(('((''6452/)*1)4'*-52*-('(-+&'(+(1*6+)*( *&'*+1)/)*&58'&*-'1)8'(*''/97+)?)*-+*/+('0 6-')'8'&21812')21(2'/5+&'2>?*-'1)8'(*''/97+)?*-+* 6452)'/'((+&15?>''+&)'2>?*-'+(('((''+)2*-'+(('(('' +5)'-'&'

&'0'8')+**-'*19' 1)8'(*1)31)**-('

= (-+&'(0 *-' +(('((''D)6( *-+* 1* 9+? 3')'&+*' 21812')2 1)/9'+(6'55+)2+(+)26-')(4/-21812')21)/9'1( 3')'&+*'2*-+*6452>''+&)'2>?*-'+(('(('')/)*&+(*0 6-'&'*-'(-+&'(+&'-'52+((*/DG1)G*&+2'0*-1(9+?)*>' )'/'((+&15?+(1*4+*1)-'9+1)74&7('1(*51@412+*'*-(' (-+&'(6-')'8'&*-'(-+&'7&1/'3'(471)&2'&*'+&) 7& 1*( ) *-' &'(45*0 *-' +77'+5( 15'2 >? *-' '8')4'

/-+55')31)3*-',4239')* *-'4),+>+)2+&?+)+13- 4&*1)#*+*' +)D +*1+5++5( +150*-43-5+61)*-1( &'(7'/*-+(>'')/5+&1 1'2-'&'1)+>8'F

-'&'1()21(74*'&+1('2*-+*/974*+*1) 21(+556+)/'

4)2'&#'/*1) *-'/*+)245'B *-'45'(6452>')5?61*- &'3+&2**-'+94)* ':'97*1)/9')(4/-/1&/49(*+)/'(0*-'21&'/*1) *-'&1>4)+5/+55( &)1)*'& '&')/'+(1*)5?*+)*+94)*(*&'9+)2*-'

9+**'&**-'(('((1)3

1/'&*/974*'21(+556+)/'+(7'&*-'5+6+)2 1)81'6 *-'&45'(+7751/+>5'1)*-'&'5'8+)*?'+& -'+77'+51(21(91(('2 3+,,-./.043/5,6*4 /70,/70, =

9D $-'*-'&(7'+D1)3C&'+()'2

'(C $-'*-'&&'7&*+>5'

'(C