Commissioner Of Income Tax Gurgaon v. M/S Punjab Plywood Industries Ltd




   

 



 ! "#$% && !! "

'
"& () "

'*+,-'."

//00 **"

12! -"34 *56 
"

-!

'

!7 &

/

!0"

"

1# 871  9
:

1 1
7  871  9
 1 

 



      

   

  

 

    !"  # $##      "%& $%'





('   35:-&'1

*,


 

) %*

+
 + $ +$,-$,.$ ,/,0

+
.      



( '$

 '

'  

  1 '$

 2 ) %*  +

+
.  ) %*3 +

+
.  ' #

/+%

) 2%$
4/
5 $6%78 

,,+
-$%2%

) 2%



$  9   &  :%:    ) %  * 

0
;91;+

  

++0(+,$

    <

!(

8     

 $1 :) %



 


 $/ $- ;(

2 2   6 7  

   





       '

      

 

  =

    

 =

 = 

 

";

% 

)  

8     

 $1 :) %



 



$ .$-+.;(

#">$ 



";

 

  9   



  '

 %3

 '

   $#">



 

 

   )

8     

 $1 :) %



 


0+$

$.-;(



 '

  





'

  

   

   



  2 2    



'8     

 $1 :) %



 



+$4,$

;(

 

 =





  

   

    



= '8  5%2% 8

0+
- 5        ,,+
-8 

    ) %

  

  

       

 

' 7

 %     ' 

    

 

     ' 

'

'  ) %*  +

+
.  



 

  

'  

     

  %

 ?



#


5
8

% 

  

>

 + ++0   

?



$



++0(+,

  '



  


- 8

% +
++,$%2%
 9 

;

      



9 



)   2  5%

8  @9) 5%8A     <  

     9 

9) 5%8  '





     '



 !(

8

" 
,;,<2="-"

-"

(0* "

(0 "

-'

"

*4-'#

    + ++0$ '  



44++-           

  =         



   '





2    

 

 2


 $/ $- ;(





 

=

 

    

  '

 

 

   

   = 
 $/ $- ;(  2   





 



 

 =  '



 

";

  

)  

 ";

%

)   

  

 '

  

   





 =  = ";

%

 )    $


 $/ $- ;(  2  2    =  

 '



  +
++,$%2%
 







9) 5%8598B  -
++
$%2 %$9) 5%8598



 





    

     

    

               





++
(+ 

  







+

" 
  ,,<2="-"

4 "& "

'"4 ".'-" "

> "& 9& 1

"'.#   $  



  ";

 

  9 

#">

#

* >



 

 



#

'

= 



 '

   ) 

      

2'





%  $


 $ .$-+.;( 

     '2 

 



 '

 

  )   

 

#"> 



 '  

 

   %

3

   



 



2





  

   



    

2'

 

  


 $ .$-+.;(  

   

#">=  

  9) 5%8598 


 $ .$-+.;( 

   









  

= 

 

++(+  +

" 
?$,,;2="-"

-"

(0* "

 "@ !

& "

 "

"!

'- " '54- * ".#  



$



       '

#


-%

% '

 

 



$, $/0-;( ' ; 

    '

'



 

$+,$$+++;( 

 =   






4-$ ,$ /;(  



 2  '  

  

 '  '

''  ' 
0$+0$+++;( 

  B

3

 %

3

 

   
.C

 ' 'B

3



'



 


0,$
.$+/;(

 '  



 3

    

$    9) 5%8598       

 


+C 


0,$
.$+/;(    '

 

      

  2       

 

 ++
(+++ (+- %

  

 

%

* 

0
;91;+
      

 

   9) 5%8598

 


0+$

$.-;( 

 '



* 

4+;91;+
  

9) 5%8598     

 

 



  



  


0+$

$.-;(       9) 5%8598    

  

     

% 29  
 

$5+
+8 ,)

.
 @+

" 
  ,%$,2="-"

  '

"

 "!

A#   

$ 

 =  

=  
$0/$00$,./;(  

'





$ = 

  

$4-$+$/ +;( 

  =    >  



=


,$.0/$/;(  

 >    



=

  

 



'



'

 =

 2

 

 =   

=


00++0  %

3

    

  



+$4,$

 > 


 C  



=


,$.0$/;( 





=  =  



3

$9) 5%8598  



+$4,$

;( 

  



   





1 

' - '  



(' .

  %

  3

    

     





 '3



$9) 5%8598 

2

* 5

8     '

 

%

3

  9) 5%8598



  

  !( "
!!-  ) + B  

 

   ++0(+, 

 

 



++
(+



     '

!( 6

  '      '   

        )

 

 $ '





%

% 



    44++-         ?



  




%  



  

  

'$ 

 =

   

  

 =  

.4   
/





 



=2  


-$/0$--;( 

++.(+/   

' 1 '$ 

++(+

 2  

=

 

$,$04,;(

%

3

 



 <   



+ ++0



2 

  

 = 


!
4/ 2  



++
(+ 
-$.+$-
;(        

 


$/0$-- ;(  # 

  

 ++(+  ++/( +0
 



  

 



 $

$ 

 =   ' 

44++-       ? 

      2   2      

            

  




- 8  


.

%

%  

           

   

  + ++0   

% 





  

 =   '

 =

 

 



  

  

'$ 





  



  D  

 $    

             


- 8  


.

%

%'

  +
++, 



          



         



+ ++0  



 

 

      

  =   '

 

    '



2  3 

2   

2 2      

   

 

= 2    

=

  

 =

  

' 

 = '   

=

 D

  '   

44++- 





  

  '  

   

      

 




%# $   

  

 2 



 =

   

 

 =  '



    

.4  =   44++- 

   .4 = 

' 



  <



 =    

  

  "    



  



  

 =  

  

 



 ) 

 '



$

   

   

 







 ' 

2   

 

 =     

 ) $





 



'

 

 '



2

 = 

  

)'



$



 


$/0$-- ;( %

    





  7 "
!!- ) +

  * 




 $ .$-+.;(

#">$



";

 

  9  $   



'

 * 

 

     *   

    

    ++(+  

     





  



 %

3

 


 $ .$-+.;(  

* 

 

  7



 



++(+

 

!( 6
,   '       '   

          ) %*



. 

0+;9;+
 

#"> 

 ++(+

++0(+,$ '

    /+
-  '    



";

 

  9 





 

#">$ <

  

    



#"> % 



   



:

 /+
-)'





 ";

 

  9  

  '



#">$   









   

";

 

  9 $

 = 





 %  $        %

  3

      



$--$
+;(  

* 

 

   " !!- ) + 0

  * -



 





 '

  





B

3



,% 



  

  

=



      <  

      

 

  '

B

3

  '





  1 :# 9  # '

9) 5 ,) .
5#98A

4  

'   

=

   -+

'



  1 : % 29  #9 5 8

<



 

=

   %

3

3 $ %

3

 '

  

  B

  3

      

    ' 

     
0,$
.+/;(  

 




0+$

$.-;()'





 1 :# 9 $ 



  

 

=

            %  $    

%

3

 '  

9) 5%

8  

   

* -



   "
!!- ) @+ 6.0)  

   >         

            %

3

$

  

   

             

         



$

   >  2 

       '             >  $       %

3

 )'



  

  

' 


-$-
$ -.;( 



  ?   

 

=

 

2 

 '    

      

       

>  

 

 

2 

$

  

 %   

      =       

   



) 2  

  

 2

   '

 







       =  )       

       $   

           

 



+$4,$

;(

 

 =

 

  

* .

 

  7 / E  



' 







 



   

 



'

     

  

9   $

  <



%



 )35:-&'1

*+ - .

&4 '$,  ) & "

' "+  - .