Liyakat Ali And Others v. Devki Nandan Gupta And Others
!"#$#%&! %'()* ++(&&#,%*
(-$!#,.#, /+%# %'()* (*+,.(,%*
0 1
2'(%'())(+)%()*&3#&,(4*+#+()*5#"6(#&&4(.% *((7/.85(,%9 6()(())(.%)(+)%()*),%9 : 2'(%'()%'(7/.85(,%*'/&.6()(+)%(.!,%'(!8(*%9
! ""
# " #
$ %&
;
)#&
:<=> '( ! " ) * ) + " # , ""
- # ,*.-
! + / !
$
" + "
"
""
! + +
1 ! 11 + ""
""
""
$ !
2 + ! 2
&
$
""
""
2 $ +1 !
" 2 ""
3
4 2
15 $+ "" " "" 2+
$ 6
1""
'( 2"
, + 2!+ ""
"" 1
! 2
&
+ 7-
3+ & &
-- 1
""
+ + " +
1"
',( &!
1
-
8
++ $$
8
"
!+ 5 + ""
"" +$ 2!
1""" 2"
+ 7-
3+ & & -- 1
"
- 6
""
+
')(
""
+
'(
""
+
15
"
2 $ + "
"" "2
3
5
1 1
2
1
" "
! "
"
'(
1
"
+
1 9.:
'(
! ;<"
5
$
"
! 2 , "
4 1
!
1
"
2 = 2 $
"
"
2
"
',( + +
!
" "
""
+
1 ! ,
2 %! 2 2
:
+
1
., 2 + %! 2 &
+
1
>
$
1
2
$ 2"
., 4 2 ! $
+6 + 5
1 "
$
1
$ 2+ -!
6 9
'( ?
"2
3 "@4 '( ?
! A " 4 ',( ?
2+@4 ')( ?
2
+
" 2@4 '6( ?
+ +
+ 2 2 2 -@ 4 '( ?
+ +
+ !
1 1
+
+
"
@ '9( = ')( 0 -
>
! "" +
1 9. :
'(> "
$ '6(
1 11 ! 1
312 9 ) "
+ - "" +
1 #
1# !
312 .
) " "" 1 "
"
"
! $ < + +
"
!
$ 1 ! "
"
= 2 $ + < "
! 1 2
$ +
! ""$
'( / 1 "" "" ! 2 $
1 $"
!
" #$
%
&
'
& $
#$ %
' %
& &
%
$ &
%
$ (
!
" #$ %
&
%
% $ %
$
% &
%
)*% +, ' &
$ &
$
% %
- ( '9( / !
+2
2 + " +$ 1 ""
'*( 2+ B>
"
= 2 ! 9.:
2+ .*6.*'B> ( "
= 2 ! 1
9.:
&$! 2 :
% $
'B> ,(
$ "
B!
2 !
<B> B> , $ "
?C 5 "
! $ 2
'.( ! 5 "
! >
$
$
., 2
'( ?7 1$
!
" $ 2 B>? B> ?7
" ?7
?
! "" !
B> $
$
? !
2
>
!
:2'?( " $ "
1"
B> ? B> ?& B! " "
1"
$
"
1"
!
!
9.:
'( ! " " 1
1 >
! 0 32+ " +
!" 2"
++ 1 !
/$ !
+ + " 2" 32+
))
3+C =! **9 ! + " 2" +"!
>
! ""
'( " 32+ .*6.* ! :
+ :
=2$
$
2 $
" = 2 #$+:
"
"
$
$ D$
* ! :
5 $ 9. 5
99*= 9.:
'(
$
! ;<"
5 $
32+ 'B> ( ',( B
2
. 32+
! .
/ $
.
0"
# $
#
$ "
"
! $
< ! +
"
! "
"
= 2 $
1
1! 2 +
$ "
$ ')( 2 $
"
$ 2 :
2
.
.
/ $
.
0"
# $
#
2 $ ! 2$
3
! < " 1
$ + "" $ :
$
2$
" ! " 2
!
$
+ ! $""
$
$ 3
'6( $"" $
$ "" " "" +
1
3
! "" !
1
" $ + + $ "" '( /
"
" $ "
+
"
+3
$ &$! "
$
+$ $ 2
2
3 1
$ ! !
+ $ !
+ !
< ??$ B> ? B> ?7B> ? B> ?& " + +3 2
2"
1 .
/ +
!
+ "2
+
1
>
1
8 2
+
1
$
1+ 8 2 +
"" >
" 2 $ ""
"
- 1 + 3
3
2
"2
3 !
1 2
< "
312 $ ""
"" + 2
1 2 !
"!
7 8
" 2
$+ ""
'9( -
8
""
"
2"1 312 .
) "
+
1#
+
312 9 ) "
+ - !
1 ' !
( ;<"
5
+
#,/#)";>
3