Ramesh Chand v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Patiala And ANR




    
   


  !"#"$%&%'( 





 !!" 
#$%& !  "

       '()*+,-./
,-01.
+ ()*+,-./
,,2-
 &" '"*% 3#   ! !" "4"/!51"% 3#  " "    ) *+,- . %!! /0 123

3

26

6! !!5   

!#  
 !

7 "" 76 

 8 "/# !   
#$# %

!" %9 # :5!  "

 ;

<%  $8"  ;    76   
#  $  

  "!78% !5"*#=)% !5"!


;> >

;  6"

?

%#!!5 @!587  !A8 !

@'?

9!B "!  #  #!"#8 # " #%  " 8 "! !3"" !#!

"!5   "! #  

" 8! 6 "!5@5!3  

  # 3! ! "!#!

  8"C8 !#D !!B "!  #  #!"#8 #  #% "

8 "! !7@"" !# !56 7! 8 !  "8 !   "  !5"!5    @  "

 "!>3!

#  @!#  @  7"85    "#"

 76  

 >D !!!B "!  #  #!"#8 #  #% # !

8 "! !7@? ! 85 "

""568 !7 ! 6 @D:

; @ # "3  #!!  # "3"6!33

  ""   !    

  6 7   !#     

 ?  @ "8!5 78!  5"! 7( 8

" 36! 78!8  5!3 3#8   5"!#8 8"! 

 " 7 !5"!#8 8"  "  "#!!

! " !#  " @ 3#@" 5!3 " 8  " 68#% 

   #" !7!! 6 76"!!5 !5""  ! " ! 8 !@" ! "!?

6

E@ #" ! " "#  

  F  6  /    "  !@!  !"#A8# 8 @!#   "8 "7763!57!    78! " 

 @87  6  #" ! "% !   ! !!  !3!8"  78 " &"3!!
36# % @!  

"6"  7 #" !3   ##8 7  7 @ #" ! " 7 "G"  6"

?

% 

  !

" 8" !#

 #"!5  !# 
 %H;%

E>?

5"!#8 8"!# 


%

>?@!#@ "# 8 "/# ! <;

;

   #  

 ##8   " 76 #" ! "% 

   37 8% !# "!5" "#8 7"3 8 !A8 6%  "

"@

    < 

E  !5  $7  !#          

% ;%EE >?7!

5"!#8 8"!# 


%

>?5@! ! " 

 6 55"!3  76   "

"%   

  !

  7 "   !!"   
#  $  

  I
J  K!

  "

" 



;%$8"% 

@ 

  !

7 " "!78@!#@ 3!

"

"

;

<%$8";(# !  @"!   ! ! < 67 ! 7 "   76
# $

!#"%7@"!! 7! "!        "  "!  "3  !#  5!3

"  

 78  

 @ 3!7  !



"G!6   !#   7"3  "85

!$ !   F@

"!  "#

@  @!         #! 6  8%  " "  "# 8"  "5"

!5 "3!#  !#@ @   "!% "6" " !!



7  B3"

" #8 " ! 
7# 5"!#6"#"  76 "!78!! "

;

<   !#8 "# ! <;  # @"3  ;

E

  

"( "! @! 8 5!3!5 8" "

"    "  " "% " 8" "

!5  7 "    !5  

!#"%   !#  @"  "3  "85

!$ 8"   F@

"!  "#  @@!    #! 6/ ! 

   

",$ "  "

<    !#@"

!$   F@

"



"" 7 " 
 @    7 !7"" "3

! !5"#"

 76 "!78"  8'?

9; B  3  "

   " " "  !3   7   

" ! "8 ! !5  8 "! !7@
!   ! 8     !#8 "# ! <; <E

@"3  ;

E

" " "@ # !#  "     

  "! @! 8 5!3!5  8" "

"    "38

 "  " " !#@"3  "85

!$ 8"

8" " !57 " !5

!#" ##"

!5  " "    !#"3"! @  F@

"  !5@"   76 @6@!  !5

!#"" "    $ "  "

   !#@"

!$    F@

"   ! # @8 #"6"3   

 ! "3!#  "!" !#  

"7 "  !5

!#" " "!!5 !# @" "3  "85

!$8" "@  "

"@ "3 8   "85

!$ 8"!  "#   @@! ()7&8C7 ("6(!58"

! # K !&+!!  3.! 
 !   "%; 
< /     !#@!#@ "3 76

!$ 8"     !!  !@3!

!

# "#"

#"6 "3   !#@""3 8      "

"@"3 8     "85  

!$ 8"  " "%    

  ""

7 " " 


@#"6 !7""   "7  #8    7  $ ! "  !!5    

 7  67 " " 


" 
 

@ " "%C8 !

! ! !5 

 7 !7""   " #8  8" "87!    3!

 !#@"3 76

!$ 8"%8

!#!  !75!3   

 "  #7 " !5

!#"7#86 @  6  !  @   "  

!$ 8"       !#   <

E " !57 " !5

!#"  

E(@3"  $ !  @6     F6 

"  7 "   !5 

!#" " "  # " !!5 

 !7 " " 


 "!! " 8# 7 "8  87  ! 6#  !"! 7 "8B " "%    ! 6"! ! !

   "

5"8    "!    7  "!  7#8    

  @

76 " 


 !5 

 ! 7"" :

E


   
      

           

            

  7 7 @6!5! 6" "3"! 6! ! 85 "

"8% 87  !  A8 !    @  "!  A8 6%    

    

   ) *+,- . %!! /  ,#4" 5"-6".0

-"'#.  %'

=4&7,#4"