Gurcharan Singh v. Harjinder Singh And Others

   
    
  


 



 !"#"$% & '

()!* ) $ "$+*

 ,, -- $ .#

 )/"$0 ) "$+*

$0 * )#


#,$0 $#
 

()!* ) $ "$+*

 ,, -- $ .#

 )/"$0 ) "$+*

$0 * )#


#,$0 $# 
1%

23 1
  13
 

 

      

    

!!!!

4-

$ "$+*5 





 

 


 


  
 


 







  







 

 

 


 




 

 













!"#$""$

 

  
%






 

&

#
  


 


 


 
'
(
) 
 

* 
+, 
'









- 

- 


 







 


  $"""-"












 
 .#"""""/-

0

 
 

!"#$""$
 



(  

-



' 


 
 
 

 

 
 

  


 
 
 





 


  .&!""""/-
 


 

 

 



  
#$""$
  



 

0


 

  




'
 
 
 
 




 

  
 !$""$

1$""$



 -



2 
 3


)

.  

4$""$
 


  


0 





 





  

$  

 


 

 

 
 
 




 


 


  




 

 



 

50  

 

 


 




7  


 
 

4$""$ 


 



 

 




 

 
 









 


  
 
 
 

 

 
 
 

 







 

 
$

&
 




 

 
 
 


 
$

&

 



   


 


 


 
'
(
) 
 
*  





 


 




 


 

8 9
 

 


 
 
 
81
 
8
 



 
$

&


 

  ""$""$
 


 
 
9
 


 
 



 






 




6 

 



  


 









 






 
 





 



 



 
 




8$$""$



  
 

 

  

 
$

&
0

 

 



 
2
3
& :










 

  
 


  

   
 
 


 



 
2






 


 3


 


9
 


 


 



- /- 





 

0  


 - 


 




 






 



-

 






 



   
 
  
 

 









 

29
 



 
 

 


 







 



3
;


   
 
 
 

   


 
  
 


 
$

&


 



 
 

 

 
 
!"#$""$  

 

  
 
+

   
 
 


 
 



 








 



 

 


# <


 
 
 


 




 
 






 


 






  
2



 3






 

 

 
 



 



= 






 
 

 
 

 




 
 
 


 



 


 


  




  






   



 







0
 
  




 

 
+

 

 

 
 
 
 












 


  
 

 
 


 




  






7
 




  

 



 
  
! 9
 
0




  
 

  



 



84


%
 

 
 
$

&

%"1$""

 
 
 

.8#""""/- 
 

 

 


0



$"%$""$
  



0

""$""$
 


 
 

>

 


 
 





  
  


 



 
 
 
 
$

&
  








1 * 
$

&


 

 

   



   
 



-   

9
 


 





 81


$
 


 







 
 

 
""$""$
0

 


   
%"1$"" 








 
  
 -  

 


 
 


 




 



 

   

 


 
0

 







 








0






 
+

 

 
 
$

&

 

 









 





'

 









 



  


 
 



&


 
 ? 
'
44$ 9
 


 
 
$

&


 
 

 



 





  
   
%"1$""




 >
 
 
!"#$""$
  




 






 


 


 


 
 

 
 
!"#$""$


 

    
 

 

 
$

&


    4 


 



 


 
   





 






 







 


'
(

) @-
2 A




 







 

 
 

 

 
  !"#$""$
0

 


 


B
<??

$ 9




 





  

  
 

 

.#"""""/-B
<??

8 A

 



 
!"#$""$


 

B
<?* & A

 

 

 

 

 



 
!"#$""$B
<?* # A










 



B
<?*

& ! A



 


 

 

 B
<?* 1 . 3 % 


0 
  

C 
=   (  


 


 



  

 



 
!"#$""$

 

  ""$""$


 



 

 
$"""-"

 
   
  
 
 
0 
 


*A
 






 
50*A/'

 



 




 
 





  
" ?A$
C 
= 




 
50?A$/'  
 






 
 



  






!"#$""$

 

%





 
 


- 

 
0



   


 
 

 
 
0

   D 
 
?A$
(  



 

 

   

?A$
 
 

 





   




  

 

 

 
0

.&!""""/-

 





 








 




 

 

 
  0

  

0


 

#$""$
'
 ?A$

 

 









 

' 
 
 

(  


 
   


 





?A8

 
 

 



 


 

E&1$

!"#$""$


 

50?&
 9

 
 

 


 







  

 
 


 






 


 
$

&
 
  

 
 

 




  
  


  

 



 ,

  

 

 




 
 



  
  

  
2
 3
 

 
 

   









 
 







 
 
0



 






   



 
 





 

 
 









 

 

  

 
;


 


  


 
 50?$ $ 

 

 
 




   

  

 
'
(
) 
 

  
 
 

 

 


  

  
 
 
 



  


  
0



 




+
 



  

 
 
 
   

  







  











( 
'



  



 


  


 

  
 
;



-0  

 

 

   
 







(

0
 

0

  








8 9



 

 
 

 
(
 
  
 


 

 

 

   





 
 

 





   
 
9
 


 

 




50?
   

  

 



2



 






  





3 <

 
 

 
'
(
) 
 
 



 
 
 


 

 



 

  





 
 

  
 


  





 
 
 > 
  
  & <


 


 


 
(
 


7



-0 

 



 



-0  
 
 
 


 
 


 



(> 

 
 
!"#$""$
 
 




  # 
 


 
 

 
 
   


 


-




 







 
 
 


 








  
 
 





  

 




 
 

   




 
50*$
 
 
 


-0  
 


 

-



(> 






 



0 

  
 





 


.&!""""/-

 

 






- 

F !G

 



 


0


 




 , 


 ! '



 
 




  '
(
) 
 
$!"#$""%


 















%!
(?(



'
*
) 
+,  



(



 


   


 


 
'
(
) 

 
  

 


 
 




  




 
 
!"#$""$
 

   



 
  
 

 
 

  
 

 


  

 

 

  


- 
 1 
  
 



 
'
(

) 














 
 





 




(




 
 
 
 
50*A/'
 

 
 
 

 
0
 


""$""$

 





>
 
 -0  



  



50*$ 9
 


 

 

 
 
 

 

 








  





 

 

 
 

 
 






 






 -.  
 

 
 




0 
 

 

 




 

 

  4 (> 

 





(
  


0










  



 
 


 


  



 


 


 



  







- 
  


0

 


 





 
 




 






0  

H
( 






(



 

0



 
% (> 



 

 
 
 











(








 -





 


 


 $" D

(


         

 "  " "

" 
#  
#$"

  "" %"  & "

 '

"  "%"%  

     

 "'"  "

  %" ""  "" "( " $)) $))* +   """   

,))))- .))))-   ""  "

" "

 /"  %"     "               

%"% 0"'" 10 2$   "' "% 

'

"%" "  "10 2* /%" 

 " "

"  '


  " 

""  3    "  %  

 "' """  '"    ""%  "  0 '""" /%"  "%"  

 "' ""   "   """"

 4  "56   "7

/"  %"     "         
 


 

 








 
$""$
 

 



 
6  
'

D

#"&$""$ 
""$""$
 




 

 
0 
 
    '

" "   "  0 "

   

"   "     """

  "  ""

 "   "8

""   -  '"

 

"  " "  

  ""

"" '     """  %"   % "  " %  "   "  $

/  "          "           

"  " '"    " " 8

"" 

    ' "  "

   """ "

  '"

9 " 

  " 4  

" :"8 "





 

$)) 6$7 68""7*);

%""%  '"

" "

 ""'% "  " "8

""

"     "( "

6   '8 '%6"  7 + "

 ' " """  
" "" 

  % " "'"8  + '

"  

      ""%"    " 

'  4   "  8 '

    "" 8""< ' "  "  """ ""  $$

 ""     

                 "" '

"     .

), $))$ "'  ''8 '%"

%"  "" "  "

"%

 """" "" 0 "  % '" %"  "" 0

" """  "0 "  "   " /       

   .

), $))$ '"    *;   " " " "  "  "

 """""""  " ""

  "" 8""<  "

 ""    %""    "% 4"%"  %'""

    "  " 

       

   8   "                $)) 6=7 68""7>$= %""%   % "4"    ' "  '      %"           "" "  "  

    "  % '  0   " '(

""  "" ' "" ""

/

     " 4   " :"8 " 







  !

 $))?6*7 68""7,,*

$*

9'

    

"""


#$

  "10 2  " ""'  ""%"    $=%"  "   * 

   "'' "'     "" '  "  $=

+ "                "     " "4  8 '%""%" ' ""% 

' "" 8""<  "   ."4  10 2$  %"2#$ /" %  ""  0"'"" 8 6%"  '

'"8 7"' 2#$ %"'"2#    ""

      "



'

"

" 

  " " " %"610 2# -70"'"' % 10 2   %"" 670 '2 '

 "  "

 ""  & "

6%"" 
#$7 / "  $= ), $))$"   "2 '

 "      )))))- & "

 %" %  $ ,@" 

/%  "

10 2 "'

" " '2 '

 "

 6$= ), $))$7"  "" )))))- & "



+ ( % ""  '      "   10 2$ 2#$"4   "" 8""< 

:    ""'"   "   " 

10 2   

  2#$%  

' 
#$%  " " 

)))))-  "2 '

 "$= ), $))$   "" 0 " "

" $,

A      '

"  

  " "%0"'"'  

  "               ""    "

  6
#$& "

7%  " 

  ""( "%"  %   

&   " ' '%    " 

      ""   '

" "

'

 "  ''% "' % "%   ""%   "%  "

 

 """0 "'
#$   ""( " %     " $.

+ ""  " 

 ""  '      
#$  "

 & " 

           ""   """0

" " ""  "

"  "2 '

 "" )))))- +    " "%  " 

 "

 =.))))-  ""  0  " %" ""% " 

  " "%% """    """""

  "

$;

/  " '"

'

"10 2   "


#$" "

    '%            ""  %          "   "       % ""  " ""'%% "   

"  """  

"" 9

"   %"                 "  

7 "   % "

    " % ( " '"

 %"

 %    " B '"'  %  0

"    " "'0  ' '     "" 

"'

    ' " "6%"%"% '

" "

7 "" "

 ""'%% "

"""%""

 " ' "%" "         %     

        "  "    

 -  '    "" 9 """8  "%  

'%     " %"    '

"'       """"8 ""

 %"" '0"  "

 ""    ""'"" ""'""   0   ""5   +%  

 =.))))-'  ""'  "

 "'  "'   '%"  " %"  ' " " 10 2 """" 8  ' "" 8""< ' " 

8 $>

8( 

B ,*)$) $"'     

"" " '%  8 8""  B =$))?"'"

"" " +%

B $), $) $"'"



"4    ' 8  "   ""' %"8"" B >, $))?"' """  % /4     "" 2""< CD  $$ $ $)  " 8"" B >," "  "'  "" 8""< CD ""4   $.

), $))?    ""   =.))))- %"" E.@ 

 "  .

), $))$" " "

" "  /  '%  8 "8""  B =$))?" ""    6   7  "    %         "  8""      >,   $))?- > ), $) " "

B  2' %  "

913
 

: 4; ) &5

'

 

A
 / 
;/E A
. 

;/E