High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1309/2014dismissed

Phull Kumar Gaur v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-10-06Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik,Mr. Justice S.S. Saron7 pages

#$%%&$'($( ) **%% +($ ,(- #( ) *. ( (#**%% /%0/12 2(-2((*. /(*0 %-2 .32((*.! /(/#2 .32((*.4 &(#&$'( ) **%% +($ ,(- #( ) *. ( /(,5-+('2 .32(#**%% /%0/12 2(-2((*. /(*0 %-2 .32((*.! /(/#2 .32((*.4 ,##-%,# ) **%% +($ ,(- #( ) *. ( /(&(2 .32(#**%% /%0/12 2(-2((*. /(*0 %-2 .32((*.! /(/#2 .32((*.4

! #(.(#%%.*(.#(%(***% .(. 1 '' (.( *.6- # %(. ,1% $.1# $(!7 "!

829#(6-9(*%.6-#*(:**%%2 #%%11#'*$1.(.(..

!29#(6-#-9(('3. ('#*3('%1(29(.'. #6((#(-$6%,(3''; (*. 4 <( #( =# ''>? $. .3('

831**%($(*3('%1( (*#(A$6-#(-,%%$(% (.; (*.!<(#(=# (.>?#..3('*.# 1%'(**'6!

8 -( 8 !

8#%1 .!

82''$< B$(:4?96-# (. #,((-2(-$6%,(3''##,(3

1$%# (.#36*$6%#. "

8# 1$% *$6%#.'*%.#1(.((($'#$%.6%# 7-(('(#8 -(1(6(#(.-#'# B*(.1#%.$6'**%#'' 93(2..*1#(A$A$%29#( %(.-#(33('C (.C(*(2#$**(1%' #%%6$#*((6.6-#3('('''#. ''$(.$.( D&.%-((1(-E.@23.9###.3(' # 63 . * (%1 # (.2 # 6 *$6%#. # 9**(..

8 #2#36.(.##%$'

12#6'.#1#$%.6! :8 -( 8 !

82 9#(*(,(3 1$%# (.*$6%#.3.

"8C

C @78C, !C!

8.. "#6(2!

8<*-%.?2# 1#$%.6$.( : "# " *(#%%6**.-*#(3 6-.((($'29#%# 7-(('(# -(1(6(#(.-#'#B *(.1 # % . $6' **% # ''C#(' (3..# <? *( 6%11 ,#.$%. 2 ,#.$%. (62

09(. %2 B:,(3'2 #-%%-.**.2#$**(1%'#%%6$# *((6.6-#3('('''F. <6? .. *1 # (A$ A$%2 9# ( %(.- # (3 3('C (.C(*(2 # $**( 1 %' #%% 6 $#*((6.6-#3('(''' 3963.,(3 1$%#(-, %%$ (% (.2 #3 6 .(. (A$ -$ $ ( ((1.$'3.-%1%'*%G 93(2 ((1.$' < B$( :8? 9 $. !

8*(3.1"-((%B('*%-3('C (.C (*(#$1##(9$#.#%(('# (. .9#$-((-($%(#3('#(A$ $((1.$'939##9##(A$92 # ,(3 1$% 9( *$6%#. # ' 9( *$6%#.

8 ( # .3(' 9 $.

8 # ((1.$'922..6##**'6'. $.(#,(3 1$%# (.. "

8 # **%% **%. ( # * 3('% 1( #$1##- 9( '(# 8 -( 126$ %#8" -( 1 $($ #(%2 **'%( 9( $. 6 **%% ,$6A$%-2#**%%9((3.9##(1:#$.( $%7 # (- 3% ,(3 <$#' . **%? $%2 @E7 %3%%1

%%1 %%1% 1( 01#( **'. % # ##-9(%16%(**'613(1#((2 #6#A$(-(*(.. 8 7!

@2#(.(..

! #6*.6-# (.('31#**%%('(3# .(.(29###6#%%1.6-#**%%#9(* #.#9('%.6#%(*. ! # # (- $6% ,(3 '' $. # ((1.$' #( 9 %3% 9#$ # **(3% # (. ( # 3(' .3 .. 4

4 %. 6#% # ,*% ,((- 3(' (-2 3(' *('2 (-2 #6*.$#%%91 D # # >6% $( 9 *%. * (.( .. # $%-2 !

4 .(1 # (*. (' 9##( # '( (1(.1 (%B $**( 1 %' 9 3( 0 $* 6- # 3(' ( '1 ( # (- , %%$ (% (.,(3 1$%2!

8 ! #*$($63.(.(#>6%$( %( 9 $1# (' # # ,((- 3(' (-2 # # ,((- 3. 4C C!

4:8,:..!"

4#('.##(( ($ (1(.1 (%B # $**( 1 %' ( # .. (3 3('C (.C(*( 6%11 (%1((**'('.*('#( .*('< B$(;

? 4 # (%B # 6 1(. 6- # (- , %%$ (% (. ( # (- , %%$ (%

(.,(3 1$%2!

8'(G ##(A$(B'29##(#(-$6% ,(3''$%.$((1.$'1((%B1" -( 9#$ - ''$ # (* 6- # (- ,

%%$ (% (. ( - #( 1(% $% ( .( # 3('(- #$.*$.(#.3('9$.31 **% (' # ..2 9# ( '( # 8 -( ((1.$' 9 $. ( # ,$(- $% 9( *$6%#. '*%11%'(**'3('%1(69 78 -(#1(%B9*('6%*(3..*((6.6- #3('(''' *(#9('9%% .3..4

42#,3('#$.-(%B 1 #**%%9(.'.%-'(#8 -(129# #- $6'. #( **% ( **' .2 #$2 %16% ( **'('#,$(- $%#,3('# ('.,$(- $%B(#*9(((.$.(*(3

(% 4 @ # $2 $# $% 61 %1%3 6 #%%1. B* $ 3% - #( ,$ ( # $#>6%,$*('$( 1,9'-33(' .#( (.# < @@ ? , !EE2 #%. # ( # $( .(#(%3A$%*((6.(3($*#$( ..(.(9##$%.6#A$%6*((6.( #*A$+&,.3,((-23% 32.#(2 @@4,$**<4?,@2#>6%,$*('$(#%.# (% . *(#6#*((*(6%($%(%-'*%-'( **'-(* -*(3#A$%(# '*%-' ( **' ( * (6%- B. . **%6%%%H9$%.(%-69##.(#

A$%-**($-#3(''*%-:$A$% (#*A$9##.6#%6$%61(% A$%(%1#$6%-#..((3$#

3 ##$(5$.1'(*(.,#3 $*.#(3,(-.#(2I <!

8? 74E2#%. ## $%('.$.(#*(3 (%4 @#$( A$3%$# #(((15$.1'>6%,$*(' $( ,+.(3.2 @ @, E. ,.3. #(3,(-.#(2 @E ,"

2#%.$.( D4 ))%(('#63##($%('.$.(*(3

(%4 @(%-#31$(-#((2$#($%(13# #((%1%%#*J @ ! !

" J @@ @ !

" 7 *.2 # *% # # (.$ # (. '% .2 6 (.2 $ 6 A$.#1($.'%.G , # ,$(- $% *((6. *($%( . %16%-2**'$%.6'.3%$# $%#( (%B *((6. 6- # 3('2 9## *6%- $#(H # (- $6% ,(3 '' (%B # 1 6- 9- ((1.$' 39#6329.##**%%9(%16% (**'(*#.3('..

8(' #,$(- $% I(.$%(#**%%(%.$*3 # 5$.1' # $( ,(65 &$( #%9% + $56 1($%$(% 3(-2I$.#!

4<8?, 4!29#(9#%.#..2 9## 6 **.6- .%1'*% 2#((3 6 ('.#.2*(#.%16%-2#..

9 (A$(. #3 A$%

9# !. % # *( '*(3.#(A$%#316.1(.1(.$%3%('# 3(- %(2 3(. , '' 9 $. B'#%16%-#*(29#*.#

.1(# *(#(%32##.'*(3.$*#.1(9#( .3 .2 #$2 (''.. # # *( '- 6 %%. ( (39#($'29#%.##(3#*( 6('.#1($.##..*A$%

9#!.% J..#$#5$.1'*(3.-# (1$'(.#**%%.$%%%#%16%-.*( #,$(- $%#%16%-.($%%%.2'( ##**%%9(**.9%%(-(1##'$ #**.*#%16%-.$%.693.# '*%-( $%. 1 # ,$(- $% ('. #((2 #

(.6**.01#**%%#**%% 9(%16%#'**' 39#6329..-%%1%-(((1$%(- # (.( *. 6- # %(. ,1% $.12 9## '- 9(( - ((6-#$(A$%-2%%#**%(.'. $ % &

' $ % +'% &