High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/369/2015dismissed

Sunil Kumar Gupta v. Asst Commissioner Of Income Tax

2016-09-27Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan7 pages

$! %$! &% ! ! ' (

)! *! #+,+- % (# %!+

*!+".

% (# %!+! ( ////

- +!(!+

!0 !- + !(! + $!

2 ! + +

! (! +

! + . !& +

((+

3-0 4 33++!

.! .

$ $ %

0& ! ( !- 4 ! 0 (-+ !( 0&0&

-! ( ( 3+ *5 ' * 6 $ . $ &+0&0& -!! ( (!

& 7 & $' # $ $' ( )

* %

+ ,&-

". /& & 0

* %

1 * '

1 1 ,% ($ 333

% 0% # &4&333 % $$' # 5 6 6

% $$' 6

2 $$ '

%( ) # & 0

( )

2 ( ) 8 0

% *

$$' #

# $'

9$ : ( )

&-36$0: +# # /& &0 # :

& -"<36$ 0: +

# #

( )

/ #

& # % % % 0= #>? 333& 102 (( + + . !% + . (

! . ! . ! + +%

+ !- +8 (!%*58+ ! 9 :(% !+!!!0

! + ( )! )! . + + !- (0.+8 (! !';1'

! (

3. 3 .2 ! 4 ! +

! 0 (!+ % .%3

0 + 0& 0&: . 0! ! 3

0 + 0&: 93#!% . ! + !- ( ! !. ! 0. *$ 3 ( 0 0& 0& : <

; +43++!+ + !- (! 0& 102 $ & + 0& 0&: -! 0 (( !+! *! ,+- % !(

!- 0+ +

! .((+ + + !- ! 0.+ 0&0& (! .+0 (! (+0& + +! !.+

- -$ & !0& 12 ! + 3!( 7

! " ! " #

# " $ # #$% +

3(0.0& 1 23++ (+! (0& 1023++ (+ + !- 0& 1 2 (102%+3#!% 0! (3++3!( ! ( !+ +0&0&

.+0& + + !- 0& 102 0 ! ( +3!(+ ( . !(%0 1 2 ( 102 !0! ( ( 1 2%+!3 (+ #0( (. 0& 1 2 ( 102 0& 1 2 3 ( + # 0 !-( 3++3!( (0& 1023 (+ #0 ( ( + 3!( 0& 102 7

+ !- + 0 (!<(.+ + !- (+ .+!3!( 0& 102 !4! + 0&0& . +

+ + !- +0 (!(!4!+0&0&

.+ +0 (! *! ,+- 0( + ! % + 0&0&

+ 0 .-+ + !-+0 (!

+ % ! (! (- 03 + (+0&0& ( !+!+ -!

++! (+ + !- !%+!!% 0. + 0&0& + + + + # +

!.0-+ !!#(!!# 0 0.+ = .#+ + !--+0 ((

!+! (+ % +. ( +! # ! ( (!

# # %

% #

# #

# % $

@ #@& 0 +

## A 0 % #

# # # 8 0 % # # #

0 8 0 % # # #

% # # %

# %

0 9

# #

# # 0 # % # #

# %

### # # %

# # &

+ 0 0 $

#% B

# % %

& 0 # % A 0

% % 8 0

#% #

% #

* & 0 $ 0 # A 0

# % # # 8 0 # #% & 0- # $ 0

A 0 $ # # %

# # 8 0 %

$ 0

&C + (! # !+ !

+ 0 + ! 7!< + 3( ( . 3++ ((! + !.0- + + !-! !+!+ !#0& 12 -- + 3+! + - ! (( ((- . (!-+ # + !.((

. *! ! % ( + ! ( #

#( 0. +! + ! +3#! 0 ((( (!-+ # + !.+ !#. !3++ + !

. (0.+ ++ ! ( +. 0(((+ #+.! ((+ # + !.+ !#( (+ + !-

(0.+ + + !- ! ((+!%3 ( 0 #( .- + ! # +

!.>(!12!+ !

+ # + !.+

0((0+!3+++ !.-+

! 0 .0

( !. !. !+ !3 (

0( ( + 0 (-+0!+ %4 # . (!4 # .%++-+!+! + !( . 0 --( + + # !. 3++ !#( #!

+ 3- % -. % !. !%

!?- ( # !3 (0+ + # !. + ! 03++ + !!#(3 (0 + +-+! 3+! + ! 0! !#( + + # + !.+

0((0+!3+++

!.-+! 0 .0

( !. !. !!3+!+

!. %+ !!#(!!# 0 0.+3!3++#! +-+!+! +!+ !#(! + ! 0 (-3+!+ !0!0(0+-+!+ +!+

(0!#(!!#( 0 (-3+!+ ! -( @+! + -! !#( + + 3! +

. + !+ % + !-%-- 0# (! 0 !+ + !(+!% ! 0.+ !+ + #+ 0 (((+! -!(0 (93#!%+ + !- !

(0 0.+ !+ ! ! !+!!+ !

-+ # +

#3+! !.3 ( 0 !.(!# + # + !. ! + !

0. +

( !#(-!+ .+ + !- ( +! ! .

; + + !-0 (( !+! !+ !

-+ # + !.+ !A((+!0. .#@ !!(+ + !#( (! + 0&0& + ( 0 0!-+ (! + + ( 7 ! + !.< ; !#( + + + !- 0 (!++ (7!+ !.<+

0 ( ! ?-+(( (+!>(! 1 2 ;% 4 +!. !+ # 0 0((( + + %+!!% +0(((! ; 3

(!+ !#+ + ! % + 4 3 ! 3!( #!+!# ( - + +

!(- .(( ,B CD '2 $9ED,> $E 1EE) 8 :2 ,>"E F! #(!G Whether speaking/reasoned √Yes/No Whether reportable √Yes/No