Harvinder Singh And Another v. The New India Assurance Company Ltd. And Others
!"
# !$
! !% "
&&'' () % "
!"* ! ##+ !,"
,-!.
/%
! % "
#
&0
-(
( 12# 34)''(5 06 &&'' ( /' $(75 06 (
04 #489 #4(95 06 (&0 !!:
0 )(
( ( &&' 0 0'8 ; 08 '7 &&'5 9 '':0
'8 '7 &&'
00
##
!!$ ( ( &&' <7 )'
0 4(7 9 5 9 '':0
>(0 (7)9 4(0 %&' %() &&'
&(((0 77(60 (0( 00 ?5 &0 ( 0 ,'9 %(>)'5 ## !7( 4'
4(( (((0 @%(>)'A :4(>8 '>'8 0 )&
B(&0
>( %(>)' 0(6( :( >(7 !
?
?
4(( (((0 @07 64'A
:6(5 (&0 !?B)( 0(0 ( 4 7 (6(0 B(&0 :( 0(6( ( >80 ( 0&) '9 ''70 00 34)&0( 1)9( 1)4'
4(( (((0 @00A :4' 0(67 ( >(7 !, ? C 4 4'
>) >(7 !
?
? 0(6 &&''B(&0 (4 7'7 9( 474 &0 >) 9 #: 0 1)(' () 6( 00 : 4( >8 07 4( >) 40 &&05 ''
D)(0 1)('
&'
:6(5 00 ))9>0 D)( )(0 0 ?
&&'' B(&0 &(((0 D :( 9 =7 )9>( &('9(8 >D 9>'8 00 '8 (0 6 &' '
(7(0 :(7 9'
'9 & &(80 ( C '':7 ) (90 &'07 &( *44( 00 34)&0( 1)9( 1)4'
00 0) D)( (60 49 (0 0 )0 0) (4 7'7 0(67 (&0 :4' 0(67 >) !
?
? E --
? *44( '9 ( '0 (6 9&5 5 :4 < :49E -
? *44( 0(6( 4'07 6'0 6 0(67 ' 9 05 5 -
C *44( 4 '9 & 9>'E -
' ) (07'8 000 6)( '9B(&0 /(0 ( 0(7 (&6 60 '0 &( ')00 ()' (4 7'7 0(67 (07'85 7(0
?5 5? B '7 ( 0 '7 '9 & ''
('F
/(0 )'
B(&0 4''70 07 ) /(0 0)'8 &&(0 3':0( #745 ((-* (0 9( 8: 05 ((00
"<- '9 4( '9 & ! () 4''7 ( (>)'
'0 (&0 9( '0 49 0)'8 )0 &&''B(&0 !0(6( 7 ('
>D ( &( &&''B(&0 !0(6( &&0 : >< 08 9( -* "60 -*5 04(70 ) &(6 ()' (4 7'7 0(67 &&''B(&0 !0(6( /(0 (
C &&(7 ((0 45 (74'8 )0 9( > -*
6:
07 ) 9 00
5 ?B &( 945 000 G :(0 ))( &(&5 BC4 00) ) &('
<& 905 =&7 6:
00 )(660 )( 0&0 # 00 70 ?;
8( 9 9)'&'( @A (74'8 &&'0 0(9 ' 0&08
?5 5? B :(0
5 B 7(0 )0( 40 ' ()95 ' 5 )('
<& (&( <& ; 07 %(>)'5 > 4'0 > (() ( &(6(5 (4( >0 )& &(&' ':
'0 0:
A>' #)&(9 ,)( H) > 4'0 > <6 9 ) '>'8 9& H) >( 4 ,)( :44( 0(6(B:( ( D'8 6('8 '>' :44( '>' 098 &&''B(&0 !:( 6:
( ( '>' 098 6:
>(4 &'8 )0 ( &(9 0&)0 (7''8 :0
D -)>' #4'
:44 ((80 (&0 ! >( %(>)' 9
64' &)(40 &&'' !B(&0 !C6( #74 )(0
(&0!:
0 )( ,9&8 /0 ( &)(4 &&'' !B(&0 !C6( #74 (05 4 :4' &&(7
*C 0)'8 090 &)(4 ; ; (6(5 (&0B
D -)>' #4'
' <90
* -(=4 ,405 %(&( 4(7 ' '0 :8 6( #74 :8 06 00 ' 0&) 0(67 ' "<-
"< 0)'8 &'0 ((0 '7 &(9 "< 090'85 &(9 )0 -4=)' &' )0 #
(85 # -)D>5 )0( D)(0 14(( # &(9 )0 -4=)' )4(85 :)'0 46 # -)D> ! 9('
&'0 ((0 4:
"< &8 &(9 6( # -)D> &'87 4'
>) %4((5 ')00 >) 14(( 6'0 &(9 '>' 098 B(&0 C
:6(5 )( 0(0 76 (74 (6( ( &87 '9 /(0 )'
(7)0 0)8 &(6 0(6 4( (H)(0 &(9 &'87 14(( -()'
'0 7 4:
&&'' !B(&0 !C6( #74 &&(0
*C5 4:6(5 4 06 :44 0(0 "< *CB 4 :4( 90 4( ( &)(& (H)(7
9&'8 >)
&)(40 49 ; ;
4 <)0 06 4 &( 4 : 5 4(
*C (9
*C '(
*C 4( &= >) &)(& :44 9 ( &= >) )0( 6'0 090'85 4'
>) 99('
(&( :44 (H)(0 &(9 &'8 9 '
*?5 4( : &&(0 >4' &(6 (&0 '('8 '0 60 06 "< *?B 0)'8 00 7)( 6( #74
' 090 &(9 -)D> 6( )0 (((0 ? ''
4 0( ')0 9 05 0(6 6' &'8 >6 0 ') 0 )&&( D)079 '0 +%,)'-.%/()0'-&%((1.%'2) 34-5 .(5 #,, ' #,
(((0 )'
:4( '('8 4'0 4( 6' &(95 '>' 098 :( C 6:
()9 5
0 0 )' ') 0(: %(>)' 6'0 &(9 6'0 0 &'8 (07'85 (74'8 4'0 '>' 098 :(
64'
74 (6( 76 (0 ': &&'
9(5 4 090 -07 &&' 5 85 B( 0&0 (07'8
4(D6 *44( #&=7B 0 .B! *44(
&(>' .B!