Indian Oil Corporation v. State Of Haryana And ORS
!"!#$
%
&'() # !
#!*+,+
!#- ,, ** #
." /
+0 # # +"
",# # "
22 2
&'() "14!+/!#51 ,, ** #
." /
+0 # # +"
",# # "
($ 6-(/(/7/(-3
!" # $$%$ &'%() * +, -. % / 0.
203 4567#
& 3 4567#
( /
20 23 4567# 88888 (/7/(-38
1.
0 12 !2 " # (%%9 :
$$%$ &'%( 12 00 1
0 ;
-
.
12 0 !" # (%%9 &'%(
< 6 -. ) "
.
6 -. 0 2 '= 2 6 + 1 > 1 0.?
0 2 *
!.
0 , - !
+) 2. %$ %& &''@
6 $
;
%A9$ B B )
0 '$ '@ &''C
6 @
;
&C '& &''9 ! %@'''''7F + 1
6 %A ;
0 0 2 %$ '% &'%( 2 ! &A@==''7F
*
22 2 0 2
1
*.
0
B
B ) D2 0 0
D2 0 0
-2
1 2 22
D2
0
.
0 0 1 0 - .
1.
2 0 0
.
0
12
1 0 2
.
0.
%@ >0 %( 0 2
6
.
1 D 1 - .
2 1.
2 0 5> !% 5> !& 5> !( / 2 D 2 0.
> 1 0 5> ( 5> = 5> C 5> 9 5> %= 5> %@ < 5> ( 0 2 'A '( D
! %(%A (A ;
. %& %' &''@ 2
1 < 5> = 'C %% &''= 0 2 9@ D %C 0 2
1
! %'9= '$ ;
. 60. 5> C && %% &''= 0 2 &$ D %C 0
2
1 ! %'9$ ('
;
. 2 5> 9 (' %& &''= 0 2 @'
D %A 0
2
1 ! %%$% =& ;
. <
2 5> %= 'C %% &''= 0 2 A@ D '( 0
2
1 ! %'9= '$ ;
. < 5> %@ 'C %% &''= 0 2 %%$ D %A 0 2
1
! %'9= '$ ;
.
6
.
2 0 00
2 2 "
D2 2 >
0 ! %%&9 @% ;
.
2 &'
:
&%
-
.2 ('G 1 D2
H
.
0 0 .
2 1 # 1 1 .
.
2 F D 0 2
02 0 1 .
2 ;
.
.
1 0 600 0 0D
-B1 0 9"9# + #
# +."/
4!* 9 # +"8
&)/:
D 0
: + *
20 +;
#"/!#51 # +"."/
9#< ; 1+951 - # =9!"!
!#**
+8
!
* 8
%& ) &!>!*)%28
1
-B1 0
1 0 + *
%& %(
20 +;
#"/!#516 )
2 .
! !
"
"
# ! $ !
" %"" &
'
! # %"" &
" ( '
" )
!
"##$ %"& '''
$()* "##$
+",
* !
!
%
(
") !
!
!
"+!
,
")
!
"+ !
!
!
(
&"-./' "
&"0"1. " " )
,
"2 !
#
) 4 5 6 !
% - . & / '
!
"##0
+#, * )
#
"
?
!
!
" )
!
" # $ ! ,
!7.8
( "+
# $ ! !
( &"-971/'7.8"
'
, # $ !
"2 ! .
2
-B1 0
+ *
1 .2 0 12
0 0 0.
>
2
122
D
D 1.
0
2 0
.
.
0 - 2 0
2
1 5> /(7%& 1 2 %A( !B )
.
- > 2 0
.
0 0 1 2
@ >
D
0 - 2 0 22
2 .
.
.
- 2 0 2 2
2 .
.
.
1 1 .
5> /(7%&
0 /( <
0 1 2 (C%
!
/$ !0
0 1 2 (C(
! 0 1
0 <.
0.
1 0 2 00 1 0
.
0.
-
0.
6 0
1.
0 .
0 0 2 1
.
00
02 0 5> !% 5> !& 5> !( 0
2
2 2 * I * 1 2 0.
* I *
1 .
2 1 0 5> !% 5> !( 0 1 2
-B1 0 ( 1+ * 31 <! +9"
& 5 )8 +! B # +"."/
9#< ; # +"8
&:)/ 2
1 "
-B1 0 1 ""."/
+0 # 8
& )/:
.
2 0 0 0 .
.
.
0D
0
0 1
1 2
20
D 1 1
> 2 0 1
,2 .
0 0
.
;
2.
0 0
! %%&9 @% ;
.
! %%('7F ;
. 0
6 $ 6 0 0 0 2 1 0 ! ='''''7F
2 6 2 &$ 0 2
1 0 0
2.
.
1
.
2 0
2 0 1
0
1.
0
.
0 1 0
.
1
0
1.
0
.
0 > 1
0
! %%('7F ;
. 0
6 $ * .
1 1
0
! .
1 0 1
0
(/7/(-3D '% '( &'%@