Oriental Insurance Company Ltd v. Yash And ORS.

  



      

 !"# $%& '&()*)+,  

 -&.)&+%$/+*0.$+(& 12$+34%' 522&//$+% 6&.*0* $*-$+'%-&.*  5&*2+'&+%* & .&,

+78/&".0*%)(&9:$/)$ .&*&+%, ".9$+;)<$88)='<($%& .%-&$22&//$+% ".$<)+'&."$/)>='<($%& ..&*2+'&+%*! ".9 -$-$.='<($%& ..&*2+'&+%? ".@9)+A/$= = $.3$+$ ..&*2+'&+% BBB
  

 
 ".$<)+'&."$/)>='<($%&-$*20%)+$22&$.$+(&+8&-$/ .&*2+'&+%*$+'$+' )/&'2C&. $%%.+&3)+ 0.%%'$3 -& *$1&)*%$>&++.&(.'
 22&$/ -$* 8&&+ )/&' 83 %-& +*0.$+(& 12$+3 *&&>)+A 1') )($%)+   $C$.' '$%&' 



D 2$**&' 83 %-& /&$.+&' "%. (()'&+%* /$)1* .)80+$/=-$;;$. -&.&)+$ %&..& &..&'%$*E%-& .)80+$/7# + %-& A.0+' %-$% )+ <)&C   %-& '&(&$*&' 8&)+A $ 0&*% 4&(%0.&. + %&12.$.3 8$*)*= $C$.'  0%0.& 2.*2&(%* F  G C$* /&A$//3 )12&.1)**)8/& $+' %-& (/$)1$+%* C&.& &+%)%/&' % (120%$%)+  0%0.& 2.*2&(%*+/3F?

G)+<)&C %-&'&()*)+ +78/&%-&902.&1& 0.% )+                 !"#$ %&&  #""'9&(+'/3=$+$10+% 
=

HI$C$.'&' 83 %-& /&$.+&' .)80+$/ + $((0+%  0+&.$/ &J2&+*&* $+'
 

$C$.'&'+$((0+% /** /<&$+'$

&(%)+%%-&2$.&+%*I)+I/$C %-&

 '&(&$*&'$*$/*
=

HI+$((0+% /** /<&$+'$

&(%)+%%-& 1)+.(-)/'.&+C$*0+*0*%$)+$8/&
 4&$.+&'(0+*&/$22&$.)+A .%-&.&*2+'&+%*H(/$)1$+%*'&* +%')*20%&%-&2/&$ %-&/&$.+&'(0+*&/ .%-&$22&//$+% .%$>)+A)+% $((0+%?

G %-&&*%$8/)*-&')+(1& %-&'&(&$*&')+*%&$'  G . %-& 20.2*&   C.>)+A 0% %-& 0%0.& 2.*2&(%* $* $/* % %-& ++I &+%)%/&1&+%%$C$.' $+3$10+%+$((0+% /** /<&$+'$

&(%)+

C&<&.= /&$.+&' (0+*&/ . %-& .&*2+'&+%*H(/$)1$+%* *%$%&* %-$% %-& .&*2+'&+%*H(/$)1$+%* $.& &+%)%/&' %


HI + $((0+%  0+&.$/ &J2&+*&*$+'


HI+$((0+% /** &*%$%& 
? 4&$.+&'(0+*&/ .%-&.&*2+'&+%*H(/$)1$+%* 0.%-&.(+%&+'* %-$%%-&/&$.+&' .)80+$/C.+A/3'&'0(%&')+(1&%$JF

GC-&.&$*+ )+(1&%$JC$*2$3$8/&+$++0$/)+(1& 
=

HI$**&**&'83%-& /&$.+&' .)80+$/4&$.+&'(0+*&/ .%-&$22&//$+% .$+>/3(+(&'&*%-$% $++0$/ )+(1&  
 =

HI)*++I%$J$8/&= %-&.& .&=+)+(1&I%$J )* 2$3$8/&


$<)+A(+*)'&.&'%-&*081)**)+* /&$.+&'(0+*&/ .%-& 2$.%)&*=  $1   %-& <)&C %-$% %-& $22&$/ )* /)$8/& % 8& $//C&' $+' (12&+*$%)+2$3$8/&1') )&'
D '1)%%&'/3= %-& '&(&$*&' C$* +% $ 2&.1$+&+% &12/3&&= %-&.& .&=$/%-0A-*-&C$*/&**%-$+?

3&$.* $A&=(/$)1$+%*C0/'+%8& &+%)%/&'%%$>&)+%$((0+% G %-&&*%$8/)*-&')+(1& %-&'&(&$*&'

. %-& 20.2*&   C.>)+A 0% 0%0.& 2.*2&(%*= 80% +/3 ?

G  &*%$8/)*-&' )+(1& )+ %&.1*   2$.$A.$2-  D  )))#   %-& '&()*)+ )+ .$+$39&%-)*($*& *02.$#9&(+'/3=+$10+%)*2$3$8/&+$((0+% /** /<&$+'$

&(%)+&)%-&.%%-&2$.&+%*)+/$C$+'%%-&1)+.(-)/' %-&'&(&$*&')+%&.1* 2$.$A.$2-? %-&'&()*)+ +78/&%-&

 902.&1&

0.% )+ .$+$3 9&%-)7* ($*& 902.$#

C&<&.= %-& .&*2+'&+%*H(/$)1$+%*C0/'8&&+%)%/&'%


HI+$((0+% 0+&.$/ &J2&+*&*$*$A$)+*%
 =

HI$C$.'&'83%-&/&$.+&' .)80+$/8&*)'&*


 + $((0+%   /**   &*%$%& $* 2&. 2$.$A.$2-  D  <)))#  '&()*)+ +78/&%-&902.&1& 0.%)+.$+$39&%-)7*($*& 902.$#
 ((.')+A/3=$*$A$)+*%(12&+*$%)+ 
?

== HI$C$.'&' 83%-& .)80+$/=%-&.&*2+'&+%*H(/$)1$+%*$.&-&/'&+%)%/&'%%-& //C)+A (12&+*$%)+,I   (  ) *  )   *  + *   

 +(1&
 HI )+$(%0$/)&
 HI $*2&./$*%2$3(&.%) )($%&

J %-&'&(&$*&'# 80%
 ?HI 2.&*01&'$% %-&%)1& A)<)+A (12&+*$%)+#  0%0.&.*2&(%*  G 
 ?HIK
 ?

G 
 HI


HI

=DHI
 ?HIL
 =DHK
 HIL
  %$/ +(1&
=

HIK
= DHI **&**&' ? "0/%)2/)&.$22/)&'





H.' 
=

HIK


H.' 
= DHIK
  &'0(%)+ %C$.'* 2&.*+$/

=DHI

=DHI .0+'&'




=HI# &J2&+*&* '&(&$*&'#
=

HII
 =DHI#
= DHII
 D &2&+'&+(3 K
= ?HI 2&.1+%-#

=HI#K
=?HI ++0$/# $+'
= ?HIJ K
 2&.1+%-#$+'
=?HIJ #K
 =

HI $++0$//3# = =??HI $++0$//3#

? 

12&+*$%)+
=

HIJ K

= =??HIJ K
?==D $C$.'&' 83 ?=?=  $22/3)+A 10/%)2/)&.
?=?=  HII F

G  +(1& %$J +(1&+%%$J$8/&$* '&'0(%)+ 2&.*%$%&1&+% +%-&$++0$/)+(1&#
?==?

HIK (0+*&/ .$22&//$+%
?

HI


.2$.&+%*)+  4**   4<& $+' 4 

&(%)+ /$C %-&'&(&$*&'# +'
=

.1)+. (-)/' %-&'&(&$*&'#

 0+&.$/ J2&+*&*
=



HI

 4** *%$%& 4


 $%& )+%&.&*% G2&.$++01 G2&.$++01 %$/
?

= HI )+$(%0$/#
?==D 80%C.+A/3($/(0/$%&'$*
?

== HI
 ((.')+A/3=$*$A$)+*%(12&+*$%)+ 
?

==  C.+A/3 $**&**&' $* $A$)+*% $(%0$/ $10+% C-)(- C.>&' 0% %
 ? = HI# $C$.'&'83%-&/&$.+&' .)80+$/=%-&.&*2+'&+%*H(/$)1$+%*$.&-&/'&+%)%/&' % (12&+*$%)+  
 ?==D HI $/+A C)%- )+%&.&*% F G 2&. $++01 C)%-&

&(% .1%-&'$%& (/$)12&%)%)+%)//'$%& 2$31&+%=/&**2$31&+%= ) $+3=1$'&&$./)&.22.%)+1&+% %-&(12&+*$%)+*-$//8&1$'&)+ $((.'$+(&C)%-%-&.$%)*%)20/$%&')+%-&$C$.'83%-&/&$.+&' .)80+$/ 
 +%-&/)A-% %-&2*)%)+$*+%&'$8<&=$/%-0A-%-& 0%0.& 2.*2&(%* $.& % 8& ($/(0/$%&' F ?

G   %-& &*%$8/)*-&' )+(1& 

 '&(&$*&'=3&%)+%-&+&%.&*0/%=%-&(12&+*$%)+2$3$8/&*%$+'*&+-$+(&'$* %-&/&$.+&' .)80+$/C.+A/3'&'0(%&')+(1&%$JF

G)+<)&C %-& *%$%&1&+%* /&$.+&'(0+*&/ .%-&2$.%)&*

  ((.')+A/3=$22&$/)*')*2*&' 831') 3)+AC$.''$%&' 



D2$**&'83%-&/&$.+&' .)80+$/%%-&&J%&+%$*+%&'$8<& 9:$/)$# 0'A&

 

 $1)%


:-&%-&.*2&$>)+AH.&$*+&' , &*H 
:-&%-&..&2.%$8/& , &*H