Sukhwinder Kaur v. State Of Punjab



IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH 120-2
 



42  # 5* *

  

***  

122 2
 

  !

***26  
"# 

$ %&'() * +,-.
)  "%.$"

'"-"
/
1

/
-) 
#
 
( /
20)'
3 
3-4


, "%.$"

"

'"-"/ +*




)
( 

#
'
 
( 

 
 
, *
#
) 
 


6  *
#
 

 


  "
(
'
 
 
#

.

 
/ 

 
% 

  

     






 

 



 
#
$8
9

 
  






!
 


"
#
$ 

  
%
& '
 
( 



 '

) 






# #
$

& "
#
$

&
 





*(*
#

( 
#
*+* *

'

&
# 

 
#
#


 , *
 
  !
(
'
 
-

.


/

   

    
& '
 
((
# #
'
 
( 

 
 




*  7

#
 
( 

 
)'
 
 *



 


(
 
(


 

0

 
) 





(
 
 

 *

 +
 
#
#
( 
 
(
$
)&
 # #
 


#


 

&  
 
('
*
'

'
 
(
#
+
 #
#
( 




(

:

-
*
)
 
( 



 '
'

'
 
  
#
**
#
## 
(  





#
$
 
& "
#
$
1 
((


*
'

'
 ((


*
)
5 
(

# 
 
#

# #*
 

*
 
"
' 
/

&

#&
 
 
( 

'

 
*(*

(
#
!
 '


 )
(
 


 ))

'
 
*





 
(('

( # 
#
&


#*'

1 



#
 
( 


 
 
( 



 
# 
#
( ;
 
 






 
,


 
* 
('
*
'
 
( !

%#

 
(' 
*
'
 
(

 



( 

)

0




&

 
( 
*
, 
#




- 
*





'
1<
-(+
 



       
     

 
! "
1 >

(*
 
& 

 
 ( (
#
 

- 

 



=5 

#
;## 
- 
&
 

"!
& 

)&

()
#
 

#
##
#




(

 #
 
*

#
* 

 
 &

5 , 
#
 
- 


()

7




)
#
' # 
## #

 
*
 
#
 
 
& 
*
#
*  



 
' # 
 ##

 

 
*(*

, 
 )
, 


6 
& & 
(


 
# 
#
('




&

##
 

*


 
 #*
#
 
) 
##



 

 )
, 
/ *
, (  
  A






* 

 


*'
* 


(


#
    *
*

- 

*




#

* *



 



 
# *
#
' 
##

  '
#
)'
 
## 

 #
()
 
 
& &


* =

8 


( 

(  *
 +

+,


# $  "

(

 $ ) $ 

% 

   &

 
! ''

'
& 
1>

(*
 


0

*
)&
8)
( (
#
-)
/ 
 >


? (@
 


=5 

#
;## 
- 


#*)
* 

, 


 *
* * 
##
& 
#
( 
 '
#
   


# '
  

 '

-
,
*
 *'

 

&(
 
#
 
 
  
&

 
 '
( 


) 

 
 *'
**'
 
& & 
,
*

 
 
*
&





) ) 
#

 
*'
& &
 
 


 
'

'
( (
#
(  *


 

#
 
# 
$
  

(  *



 

 
 
*'
* 
*'
&
 *)
# #


A
#
0


 
#
*
% 
) 
& & 
'

 
(
#
* 
  

 

#
 '

'









 '

*


&'


*
 





*'


('

  
# 



'


&

()'


 
#
;##
- 
 

*( 
#
)* 
# 

 ** 
#
*

( 

* *'
& '
 
##
 

#*

  

 '

-
 
#
 
# 

 0
&

*


) 
& 
# #

,
*

(

 0




*



# 
*'



#
* , 
#
 

#
;

;##
- 


(
 
 

 

B#
-
0 0
 
(


' *
&

()

*
# #
 


& 
  '
#
0
(
 
## <
*
#

*)

*
#*
 
 
   
#
*
?2
.

) 

?

" @
(

@
2 2&
8






 
#

) 
## 
? (
#
*' 
 2
?

"@
(
 @ =
 $
)&
#
 

#
&
 

&

# 
, * *

6  
 

#
 
 
 
 


&  
 
( 




#
#
(


:
$
 
(
#
#  
 &

 
6 
* 


 
##*)


, 
'
 
( )
#




# #
 
#
;##
- 
"!



       




C

#
 

 
 
# #
##




, 
#
** *
#

 
##  




#
)
0

 
 
 
#

&

 '

0'


+(


 
#
 
  
& 

 
*
*
#
 
, 
'

, 





* 
* 
&
 *
&

# #
#

*
 
#
#*
 * 
&

'

*
*
 


 

+
#*
 *

#
 


& 
( (




+ (,   

 


#
 
 '


& 
 (
 &

 
 
 
*'
,  

*(
#



#
*(* *


*


#
 

-
5 *
 
(
'
 


0(

' 
6 D#
## 
&'
#* *
 
('
#
  


 
&  

*
 
 
)
# # 
 
# 
()

)


 '
  "




#
 
  

(
(
& &


)
( 
#

(


'(
#




#
#*
&

'
& 

#
 

( 
'(
#
( 
& 


 *( 
#

  

 
(
&
 
 
& 


 



*
 
& 
) )
**
## 

 *
**'

'
&0
#

 

* 
*(
 
%'
(  
 ##
 
(
 
 
)

*
#*
 
*
#
,
#

#*
*
# 
#


(
*
 

) 
 
( (
&


6


# 
 
#
  '
*(
$
(

*
)

&

,
'
0(
* *'
##
&'
#*
 
(

 
  

&
 


 




(
#






#
*
& 

  
()   

 

  



 



 



 



 

 

$%&

     

  

  

 





 

   !" 

  





!



#



# 

 #
 ,

* *# 

#
 
# ()
#
 

- 
&  
)
 
 
 




  
(

   
 
 
()
#
# 


& )
)
## 
  
()
#
 
  

 
# #
/
 '
 
 

 
*(
(& 


 
#
##
#
*
## 

(
0(

#


 
C
*
#
 *

#
#  
##
 
 




* 
#
 
## 
 
#
**
*

,

70&


#
 
 
- 
( 
 
& & 
'
( 

# 
 '
#
)
* **

## 

( 


&



*(*
#
#


 
'
&

 
( 

# 
  '

#
 
(
 
) 


 

* 
# #



  
 
 
#
 
## 
 


 
#
 
##


+(


*

(
#
 



 
&  
' 



'
 
&
#

*


# 
 
 
*'
 
#
 
*

 
 
'
(  *
 


 




&


& 
 

((
 )
  
& 

(
  


(

+ 



'




 
*'
 


 **

0(
 
( 
 

#

 )  





 0&
 
#


*+
#
 


(

 $
)&
#
 




* *
)


 
 
# # 



* 
#





 
'



*
&

(


  
( 

((
) 


 
 
#
## 
 '
#
 
# 
C


* 



# 
* 
#*
 
 
$
*
#



(
 

 ( (
& & 

)
'



,

)
 
* 
(
#
 


#
 
 



(  -

 '


 
 
( 



(



#  
(

?& 

*  @

 
 *
#
8
!D
& & 
 '

'
#
 
0
* 

 
# # 
#
 

 
 ,



 
 
 
& 
0(
 
( 


#

 ) 
# #

(
#
 
'
#*
 

#
( 
#
 


 
  
(
 

( 
 *
# 
 

 

 
#*
 #

##)
 
*
#
#  

9 9

*
 

 
 
# 
 

 

'

 ) 
 
 
&


'

(( 
 
 

))

-



 

) 
(

'
* 

*
 
 
*( 
, *
#
 ) 
C

#
 
#
#

* 
1&)
 

#
  



'
*#
 
 +


 
*
( 

 )

9

*
 
  
6 
C
*(  &
#& &


'

5* *  (MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE


Whet Whet ther speaking/reasoned Yes/No ther reportable Yes/No